KHABAR Muhammad Malick Kay Saath | Sher Afzal Marwat | Bilal Azhar Kiyani | ARY News | 8th Jan 2025
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Assalam-o-Alaikum, I am Mahmood Malik and you are watching Khabar Lahariya's
00:28Welcome to Khabar Lahariya's YouTube Channel.
00:58Today, we are going to talk about how the Speaker's Office is not responding to our calls.
01:03Today, we are going to talk about how the Speaker's Office is not responding to our calls.
01:08Earlier, Mr. Irfan Siddiqui said that this is the work of Mr. Mohsin Naqvi of the Interior Ministry.
01:13Today, Mr. Irfan Siddiqui said that this is the work of Mr. Mohsin Naqvi of the Interior Ministry.
01:18Why is this not happening? Who is not letting this happen?
01:23Today, we are going to talk about how the Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
01:28Today, we are going to talk about how the Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
01:33They come to our votes, they spend money on our taxes, but they do not respond.
01:38The PMLN Government passed a Right of Information Act in 2017.
01:43The PMLN Government passed a Right of Information Act in 2017.
01:48Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
01:53Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
01:58Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:03Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:08Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:13Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:18Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:23Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:28Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:33Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:38Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:43Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:48Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:53Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
02:58Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:03Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:08Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:13Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:18Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:23Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:28Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:33Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:38Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:43Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:48Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:53Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
03:58Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:03Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:08Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:13Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:18Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:23Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:28Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:33Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:38Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:43Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:48Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:53Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
04:58Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:03Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:08Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:13Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:18Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:23Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:28Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:33Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:38Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:43Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:48Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:53Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
05:58Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:03Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:08Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:13Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:18Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:23Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:28Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:33Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:38Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:43Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:48Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:53Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
06:58Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:03Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:08Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:13Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:18Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:23Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:28Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:33Today, we are going to talk about how the PMLN Government has become a Civilian Dictatorship.
07:38Did Mr. Khan say anything?
07:41If you think that the appointment is wrong, have you ever tried Mr. Khan?
07:44I will meet Mr. Khan tomorrow and will tell him.
07:49I am sure that Mr. Khan will not tolerate his party's violations.
07:56I don't know why no one gave Mr. Khan's notice.
07:59I don't know why no one gave Mr. Khan's notice.
08:02I don't know why no one gave Mr. Khan's notice.
08:05I don't know why no one gave Mr. Khan's notice.
08:08He used to interfere in my case.
08:13He used to interfere in my case.
08:18Stop it, man.
08:20Stop it, man.
08:22He used to interfere in my case.
08:25When he became a Secretary General, he told me that he should be disciplined.
08:30When he became a Secretary General, he told me that he should be disciplined.
08:33He didn't say anything against me. I didn't say anything.
08:35He said it 4-5 times again.
08:37So if he says it again, I'll answer him.
08:40You guys should sort it out amongst yourselves.
08:42It's better if you don't fight.
08:43There's already a big fight going on.
08:45No, you fought.
08:46I fought? I was worried.
08:48I told him I wanted to talk to you.
08:50He gave me such a hard look.
08:52He says it all the time.
08:54Stop it.
08:56I turn on the TV every day.
08:58I don't understand.
08:59How do you understand?
09:00You live in Lahore for 20 days.
09:02How do you understand?
09:04Tell me, why aren't the meetings taking place?
09:06Forget it.
09:07Send some water to Mr. Marwad.
09:12Let him cool down.
09:13We'll talk about it later.
09:15What are you guys doing?
09:16Why aren't you letting me meet him?
09:18In the name of God.
09:20First someone says it's his responsibility.
09:22Then the speaker says it's not his responsibility.
09:25Now you guys put it on the speaker again.
09:28Everyone said they'd meet.
09:30If he's right,
09:32if you don't have the power to get them to meet,
09:37then stop this drama.
09:40You guys are doing drama with him.
09:43In the name of God.
09:45Thank you for inviting me to your show.
09:47First of all, I think this show should have been
09:49hosted by Mr. Salman Raja instead of me.
09:52It's only been 5 minutes.
09:54But frankly...
09:56That is an internal issue.
09:57It's an internal matter of his party.
09:59But I will say this.
10:01And with all due respect,
10:03Mr. Marwad is here with us.
10:05This is what happens.
10:07This is what happens in your party.
10:09No, no.
10:10No matter what they point out,
10:12everyone agrees.
10:13They don't say anything.
10:14No, no.
10:15There is a debate in our party.
10:17Yes, there is.
10:18No, no.
10:19There is no debate in their party
10:21that Rana Sanaullah should speak against him.
10:23Or that he should speak against Saad Rafiq.
10:26This is our opinion.
10:28He is right.
10:29Our opinion is different.
10:31Whoever comes to a position...
10:33You can go and talk about the establishment.
10:39You can also look at the social media.
10:42The people I mentioned,
10:44and their sympathizers,
10:46they are all after me.
10:48Therefore, I can't take it anymore
10:50that whoever comes on TV
10:53and gives a narrative about the party.
10:56After 9th May,
10:58where were Salman Akram Raja?
11:00If someone had come,
11:02we wouldn't have gotten the translation.
11:04I was the translator.
11:06I was the lawyer.
11:08I was holding all the conventions in Pakistan.
11:12I was meeting all the parties,
11:14election commissions, and institutions.
11:16Where were these people at that time?
11:18Now they have come.
11:20Come here.
11:22Mr. Malik, your question...
11:24There is a debate in our Jamaat.
11:26There are many politicians in our Jamaat
11:29who have their own individual right
11:31and political careers.
11:33They are senior by all definitions of the word.
11:35Leave it.
11:37You asked a question,
11:39but the debate is internal.
11:41I have not traveled to America.
11:43I have been here for 38 years.
11:45I know how much debate there is.
11:47There is, sir.
11:49Otherwise,
11:52No, no, no.
11:57You just talked about my position.
11:59There are glass ceilings.
12:01You won't go above the glass ceilings
12:03of the General Secretary.
12:05I can guarantee you.
12:07You will never become the Chief Minister
12:09or the Prime Minister.
12:11I predict the future.
12:13If your last name is not Sharif,
12:15you won't become the PM.
12:17You asked a question.
12:19There are debates.
12:21There is a consensus.
12:23Once a decision is made,
12:25there is a party opinion.
12:27That is why I keep telling you
12:29that whenever you make a statement
12:31about a person,
12:33we say,
12:35there is evidence of it.
12:37You talked about negotiations.
12:39Look...
12:41Simple question.
12:43Why are you not meeting Imran Khan?
12:45Once again,
12:47He can correct me if I am wrong.
12:49Mr. Marwad said that
12:51Mr. Gohar and Mr. Gandapur met yesterday.
12:53As a lawyer,
12:55you didn't meet the negotiating committee.
12:57No, no, no.
12:59Don't do this.
13:01There is a negotiating committee.
13:03You promised to meet the committee.
13:05You didn't meet the committee.
13:07When will you meet?
13:09Sir, we will meet.
13:11Why not?
13:13I don't know.
13:15The jail was open at 7 am.
13:17On 24th November.
13:19The jail was open.
13:21Ask the people
13:23whom you met.
13:25How did you meet?
13:27They might have made a request.
13:29We will meet.
13:31There is no issue of meeting.
13:33It is the biggest issue.
13:35The matter is halted.
13:37The matter is halted because
13:39in the last meeting,
13:41the PTI came and said
13:43that they need more time.
13:45No, no.
13:47They said that they will meet you
13:49in return.
13:51They will meet Mr. Imran Khan
13:53and give you a reply.
13:55Sir, what were you doing two weeks before?
13:57Whatever you were doing.
13:59You were supposed to meet.
14:01It has been 10 days.
14:03You are not meeting.
14:05Look, the negotiating team
14:07will meet again next week.
14:09The speaker is expected to return.
14:11You are not letting me talk.
14:13No, no.
14:15I get the impression that
14:17you are not letting me talk.
14:19Either you take responsibility.
14:21Either you meet Mr. Imran Khan
14:23or any other person of the team.
14:25Then I can understand
14:27the severity of the matter.
14:29Didn't you meet Gohar Khan?
14:31Didn't you meet Ali Amin Ghandapur?
14:33You are meeting.
14:35If there is a group meeting,
14:37it will happen.
14:39If I am correct,
14:41Gohar Khan said that
14:43he will meet you if you
14:45meet him.
14:47Look,
14:49there is no point in discussing this.
14:51Mr. Khan said
14:53that he does not want to create
14:55a problem of ego.
14:57He was supposed to meet
14:59and meet now.
15:01He said that if the team
15:03meets me,
15:05he will not meet.
15:07So,
15:09you are delaying the meeting.
15:11No, we have conveyed
15:13that we want you to
15:15come to the meeting
15:17so that we can present
15:19the demands in writing.
15:21One thing that I understand
15:23is that after the
15:25negotiations have started,
15:27PM Lehn and his allies
15:29have developed
15:31the idea
15:33that as a result of
15:35the negotiations,
15:37PTI
15:39will not
15:41come out victorious.
15:43The loss will be
15:45on their cost.
15:47This is the benefit of a conflict.
15:49If there is a negotiation,
15:51the victim will be the same.
15:53I think that
15:55there are a lot of people
15:57in NUN and
15:59their allies' parties
16:01who want the end of
16:03the civil war.
16:05They do not want
16:07political instability.
16:09They want the republic
16:11to be re-established.
16:13However, the world benefits
16:15or gains or politics
16:17can be a little
16:19reserved in this regard.
16:21Ultimately,
16:23sanity will prevail.
16:25Negotiations will take place
16:27and I am sure that they will be
16:29successful.
16:31We have to redefine
16:33the relationship
16:35between politics
16:37and the establishment.
16:39Once the politicians
16:41reach some TORs,
16:43then they can
16:45talk to the establishment.
16:47If Imran Khan comes out,
16:49PTI does not want
16:51all the political prisoners to come out.
16:53They are calling themselves political prisoners.
16:55They are saying that all the cases have been closed.
16:57But all the decisions of the lower courts
16:59have been overturned by the higher courts.
17:01They are saying that
17:03Al-Qadir will be released
17:05because they know that
17:07they have to get a conviction.
17:09So, if you look at the past,
17:11the past is an indicator.
17:13The future of your case
17:15does not seem so optimistic.
17:17It is not an issue
17:19whether the case will be closed or not.
17:21Do you all
17:23afford Imran Khan to come out?
17:25You are standing for everything.
17:27If Imran Khan does not want to come out,
17:29then how can you
17:31keep him in jail?
17:33We have not kept him in jail.
17:35There are two serious crimes.
17:37One of them is a daylight robbery
17:39of 190 million pounds.
17:41You know the facts of the case.
17:43It is a daylight robbery.
17:45Imran Khan used a cabinet
17:47of 190 million pounds.
17:49This is the reality of the case.
17:51He is still in my pocket.
17:53Yes, yes.
17:55Imran Khan's money
17:57is in the Supreme Court's pocket.
17:59No, no.
18:01One person's fine
18:03which he had to pay in the Supreme Court,
18:05he used the money against that fine
18:07which he was not supposed to use.
18:09He had to pay a separate fine.
18:11The money that was given to Pakistan
18:13by the NCA for the people of Pakistan,
18:15Imran Khan put it back in that person's pocket
18:17that you pay your fine in the Supreme Court.
18:19This is the reality of the case.
18:21These convictions should come to me.
18:23Anyway, these cases are in the Supreme Court.
18:25As far as we don't want these discussions,
18:27we have sat down with an open mind.
18:29The first two meetings
18:31were held in a very good environment.
18:33In my opinion,
18:35it is a good omen for the Imam
18:37that two communities are sitting together
18:39and this process should continue.
18:41It should not be limited to a few agenda items.
18:43People should know that
18:45every kind of issue will come to this table
18:47and will be discussed with the same seriousness
18:49between the opposition and the treasury.
18:51Secondly, as per tradition,
18:53Imran Khan himself
18:55seems to be in control
18:57of the situation.
18:59Everyone has expressed restraint
19:01and again Imran Khan has given
19:03such statements this week.
19:05He has always jeopardized.
19:07We have not adopted the same attitude
19:09that Imran Khan did after the Balakot attack.
19:11He must have jeopardized
19:13because he must have said
19:15that when all these things are happening
19:17and I have restrained for so long
19:19and I have not been able to meet him.
19:21He has given you a bluff call
19:23that he will not meet you
19:25and you should give him a return.
19:27We were ready for the last meeting
19:29and his community came after two weeks
19:31and said that they need more time.
19:33Now you have a problem that
19:35if you do not meet a group in five days
19:37then this is a mood point.
19:39This does not justify
19:41the kind of statement
19:43that Imran Khan has given.
19:45What do you have to give him?
19:47We say that
19:49number one
19:51which I have seen
19:53from Mr. Anas Naulat
19:55and he is a member of the committee
19:57that if you keep one thing
19:59then it is fine.
20:01Then there will be a discussion
20:03on what is possible and what is not.
20:05Whatever it is.
20:07First, if you keep one thing
20:09then you have asked for more time.
20:11Secondly, we want
20:13that the communities should always sit
20:15and discuss.
20:17This is my overall mindset.
20:19Secondly, if in any way
20:21for political reasons
20:23or to improve the environment
20:25this session can be the reason
20:27then it should be.
20:29We are still waiting
20:31to start a substantive discussion
20:33because PTI said in the last meeting
20:35that we need more time.
20:37In the next meeting
20:39we hope that things will move forward.
20:41Let me tell you
20:43that if we observe simple politics
20:45then there is no interest of the government.
20:47They wanted two things.
20:49They think that
20:51after 26th November we have
20:53brought them down
20:55and now there is no need to
20:57make them angry.
20:59If they cannot bring down
21:01our government by disturbing
21:03then it is fine.
21:05We will keep them hanging.
21:07Half of the leaders say
21:09that we are doing indirect negotiations
21:11and they can go and ask
21:13whoever they want.
21:17If you and the establishment
21:19are doing indirect negotiations
21:21through them
21:23and they are sitting in the front
21:25and you call them a proxy
21:27then the biggest issue there
21:29is mistrust.
21:31How will that mistrust
21:33end?
21:35They recorded a statement
21:37by Busha Bibi
21:39that if we come back
21:41then there will be no vengeance
21:43and no revenge.
21:45The real issue is mistrust.
21:47Whatever we are seeing
21:49how will that mistrust
21:51end?
21:53I think that
21:55the establishment
21:57is taking big steps.
22:03Now the establishment
22:05especially after 26th November
22:07and after these incidents
22:09their thinking
22:11is not the same
22:13as it was
22:151-1.5 years ago.
22:17I am saying this
22:19because in the next few days
22:21these things will be revealed.
22:23Negotiations are taking place
22:25between the political leadership
22:27because repeatedly
22:29their leaders
22:31expressed the desire
22:33that we want to do negotiations
22:35and they invited us.
22:37And
22:39the offer that was not
22:41accepted at that time
22:43but when the situation
22:45came to the point that
22:47on 26th November there was a shooting
22:49and after 26th November
22:51two things were in danger.
22:53One was Farm 47
22:55because if the future of Pakistan
22:57is the democracy of Farm 47
22:59then no party will go to the people.
23:01There will be elections of Farm 47
23:03and this democracy
23:05can neither flourish
23:07nor can it grow in Pakistan.
23:09The second thing
23:11is the right to protest
23:13which Article 16 guarantees.
23:15If the political forces
23:17like PTI
23:19want to protest
23:21then this example
23:23has been established.
23:25It can happen with any other party
23:27because the precedent has been established.
23:29This means that the political forces
23:31should also refrain from protesting.
23:33The third thing is
23:35that there was a lot of violence
23:37in the international world of Pakistan.
23:39The state and the government
23:41rejected the bodies
23:43and the incidents.
23:45Now the gist of all this
23:47is that
23:49now the political forces
23:51inside the house
23:53who are their leaders
23:55are not happy with these things.
23:57They are not happy
23:59with the protests.
24:01They are happy
24:03if there are no protests.
24:05But the democratic people
24:07who are sitting in Farm 47
24:09cannot be happy.
24:11No matter
24:13which party
24:15they belong to
24:17they cannot be happy
24:19with the actions of the democratic forces.
24:21Remember one thing
24:23that
24:25these demonstrations
24:27just a few days ago
24:29two or three days ago
24:31we think that
24:33the government
24:35and the parliamentary team
24:37under certain instructions
24:39adopted this strategy
24:41that it is not showing
24:43the enthusiasm
24:45that it showed in the first few sessions.
24:47The reason for this could be
24:49that
24:51between us and the establishment
24:53if there is any interaction
24:55which is not visible
24:57and is not happening
24:59they are looking at it with suspicion.
25:01And they may not want to come out
25:03that if there is any re-approach
25:05then
25:07they will be
25:09in favour of the mechanism
25:11as Mr. Rana said.
25:13I am being asked to take a break
25:15but I am leaving the question.
25:17These negotiations did not start
25:19all of a sudden.
25:21Let's talk Imran Khan.
25:23Imran Khan also said
25:25that let's talk to them.
25:27These negotiations
25:29also started
25:31all of a sudden.
25:33Do you agree?
25:35100%.
25:37Let's take a break.
25:49Welcome back to the show.
25:51What will be the success
25:53of these negotiations?
25:55Half of you are sitting
25:57and Imran Khan is inside.
25:59The party is in a bad state.
26:01There are no protests on the roads.
26:03You just want to play the committee.
26:05Let me tell you
26:07that our interest
26:09as a government
26:11is that
26:13for example
26:15if we can fight
26:17against terrorism
26:19it is a good thing.
26:21If we can bring
26:23a better economy,
26:25it is a good thing.
26:27Can you make a big decision
26:29for example
26:31in the early elections?
26:33Can you make such a big decision?
26:35You can ask me
26:37but there is no chance.
26:39Our government
26:41will complete its time.
26:43These are good optics
26:45that the government
26:47can talk seriously
26:49and bring national issues
26:51to the forum
26:53and make joint decisions.
26:55CBM is also showing
26:57that
26:59Dr. Yasmeen Rashid
27:01is a cancer patient
27:03and there are other senior people
27:05and their bails are not going
27:07from their country.
27:09You can do this.
27:11Prosecution is under you.
27:13If you do not resist
27:15this is like
27:17putting the cart
27:19before the horse.
27:21What do they want?
27:23They talk about judicial commission
27:25and Mr. Rana Sinhaullah
27:27is right.
27:29But I don't think
27:31there are any political prisoners.
27:33What success
27:35can we expect?
27:37Mr. Rana Sinhaullah
27:39said that if the commission
27:41is not announced before 31st
27:43your anger will end.
27:45I have
27:47shared this clip.
27:49You are still angry.
27:51Salman Akhran Raja crossed the line.
27:53He became personal.
27:55How can he
27:57talk against me
27:59on national media?
28:01How can he
28:03taunt me
28:05that he was
28:07a lawyer in the case
28:09of Mian Nawaz Sharif
28:111.5 years ago
28:13he was a lawyer
28:15in the case of
28:17Mian Nawaz Sharif
28:19against
28:21Nawsheen Iftikhar.
28:231.5 years ago
28:25he was a lawyer
28:27in the case of Mian Nawaz Sharif.
28:29It is a lawyer's job
28:31to fight.
28:33It is their job
28:35to criticize
28:37Mian Nawaz Sharif.
28:39I can see
28:41that his
28:43anger will end
28:451.5 years later.
28:47Now I will hold him
28:49tirelessly.
28:51Tell me
28:53what is the minimum success
28:55of the dialogue?
28:57If the commission is announced
28:59it is not all that great.
29:01In the dialogue
29:03it is not
29:05a small thing
29:07It is not a small thing that PMLN, People's Party and PDI are sitting at the same table.
29:12Yes, it is a very big thing.
29:13Number one.
29:14It is a very good thing.
29:15Number two is that the statements that came out in the first round were also very positive.
29:22Now, let the third round come.
29:24Look, in the middle, they have left a bit of noise on small things.
29:29There was air firing.
29:31But I am sure that when the two parties sit at the negotiating table,
29:36that session will also be pleasant.
29:38And after that, the coming statements will also be pleasant.
29:41I am also seeing that, God willing, as a result of these negotiations,
29:46the political prisoners will not be imprisoned again.
29:50Their release is under the court.
29:52But this action will be stopped again.
29:56And I am also seeing that there will be a little bit of hypocrisy and politeness in the country.
30:03This talk of taunts, insults, arrows and arrows,
30:06this conversation and statements of gulabari,
30:11this will probably stop for a while.
30:14As Bilal said, sanity will prevail.
30:16Do you think it will prevail?
30:17Inshallah.
30:18Inshallah.
30:19Let's end this segment on this positive note.
30:22Today, after this break, I will share with you
30:25how this government looks at our questions with disgust.
30:29And what it thinks that we have no right to ask them.
30:32There is no answer.
30:33How can we do it?
30:34After this break.
30:44Welcome back to the show.
30:46At the beginning of the program, I told you that
30:48there seems to be a civilian dictatorship here.
30:50Why did I say that?
30:51Democracy's basic principle is that we elect people,
30:54they run governments, run systems,
30:57and give answers to us.
30:59We get a new law every day.
31:02You don't think, you don't say,
31:04you take whose name, you don't take whose name,
31:06we have restrictions to this extent.
31:08And where the taxpayer's money goes,
31:10where our money is,
31:11where these answers are,
31:13there is a total chill program.
31:15FAFN, Free and Fair Election Network,
31:17has done a very good report on this.
31:19A Right to Information Act,
31:21you heard it was made in 2017,
31:23and there were many speeches on it.
31:26Oh, see, now any citizen will write,
31:29he will be given an answer in 10 days,
31:31the ministry will not give,
31:32so this action will be done, so and so will be done.
31:34Come on, our expectations have also arisen.
31:36Then, as is the case in the government,
31:38it immediately becomes a system.
31:41Then these information commissioners
31:44will be appointed.
31:45Three in every province,
31:47the entire court,
31:49and in the MP-1 scheme,
31:51there are hundreds of thousands of salaries.
31:53If you look at the commission in the centre,
31:55if you look at the commission in every province,
31:57it is a small state.
31:59This is the expense of crores of rupees per month,
32:01which you and I are paying.
32:03And what is the work?
32:04Insolence.
32:05Absolutely nothing.
32:06FAFN has just reported,
32:07and that is why I am sharing it with you,
32:09very interesting data has emerged.
32:11They said, we did the average,
32:13you can see the state of the federal ministries,
32:15they said that we scrutinized 40 divisions
32:17of 33 federal ministries,
32:19and you know, it seems that
32:21on an average,
32:23they have posted 40% information,
32:25basic.
32:27And the information is completely
32:29incomplete,
32:31and benign information.
32:33They have done a lot of favour,
32:35they have told how many officers are there,
32:37what is it, under which law it was made,
32:39there is no serious information there either.
32:41And this is 40% average.
32:43There are important ministries,
32:45Information and Broadcasting,
32:47Human Resource Development,
32:49they have given 19% of their information.
32:51Defence,
32:53Power, Law and Justice, Railways,
32:55they have given 27% of their information.
32:57And this is also,
32:59what should I say,
33:01completely useless information.
33:03Then they wrote a letter,
33:05and when they wrote to all the ministries,
33:07only 19 of them thought it was appropriate to answer.
33:0914 did not even answer.
33:11And among those who did not answer,
33:13Interior Ministry,
33:15they said, who are you,
33:17black and yellow people,
33:19who are asking for answers from us.
33:21Human Rights, IT, which is the biggest problem
33:23in the country at the moment,
33:25they did not even answer.
33:27Law and Justice, Railways,
33:29and I read the list,
33:31these are all people,
33:33absolutely no responsibility,
33:35no answer,
33:37we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:39we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:41we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:43we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:45we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:47we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:49we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:51we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:53we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:55we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:57we are giving crores to the commissions,
33:59we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:01we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:03we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:05we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:07we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:09we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:11we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:13we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:15we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:17we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:19we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:21we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:23we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:25we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:27we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:29we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:31we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:33we are giving crores to the commissions,
34:3540% is a big average,
34:37the main departments have 19-20%
34:39the main departments have 19-20%
34:41what quality information is this?
34:43what quality information is this?
34:45what quality information is this?
34:47what quality information is this?
34:49what quality information is this?
34:51what quality information is this?
34:53what quality information is this?
34:55what quality information is this?
34:57what quality information is this?
34:59what quality information is this?
35:01what quality information is this?
35:03there is a lot of basic information
35:05there is a lot of basic information
35:07there is a lot of basic information
35:09there is a lot of basic information
35:11there is a lot of basic information
35:13there is a lot of basic information
35:15there is a lot of basic information
35:17there is a lot of basic information
35:19there is a lot of basic information
35:21there is a lot of basic information
35:23there is a lot of basic information
35:25there is a lot of basic information
35:27there is a lot of basic information
35:29there is a lot of basic information
35:31there is a lot of basic information
35:33there is a lot of basic information
35:35there is a lot of basic information
35:37there is a lot of basic information
35:39there is a lot of basic information
35:41there is a lot of basic information
35:43there is a lot of basic information
35:45there is a lot of basic information
35:47there is a lot of basic information
35:49there is a lot of basic information
35:51there is a lot of basic information
35:53there is a lot of basic information
35:55there is a lot of basic information
35:57there is a lot of basic information
35:59there is a lot of basic information
36:01there is a lot of basic information
36:03there is a lot of basic information
36:05there is a lot of basic information
36:07there is a lot of basic information
36:09there is a lot of basic information
36:11there is a lot of basic information
36:13there is a lot of basic information
36:15there is a lot of basic information
36:17there is a lot of basic information
36:19there is a lot of basic information
36:21there is a lot of basic information
36:23there is a lot of basic information
36:25there is a lot of basic information
36:27there is a lot of basic information
36:29there is a lot of basic information
36:31there is a lot of basic information
36:33there is a lot of basic information
36:35there is a lot of basic information
36:37there is a lot of basic information
36:39there is a lot of basic information
36:41there is a lot of basic information
36:43there is a lot of basic information
36:45there is a lot of basic information
36:47there is a lot of basic information
36:49there is a lot of basic information
36:51there is a lot of basic information
36:53there is a lot of basic information
36:55there is a lot of basic information
36:57there is a lot of basic information
36:59there is a lot of basic information
37:01there is a lot of basic information
37:03there is a lot of basic information
37:05there is a lot of basic information
37:07there is a lot of basic information
37:09there is a lot of basic information
37:11there is a lot of basic information
37:13there is a lot of basic information
37:15there is a lot of basic information
37:17there is a lot of basic information
37:19there is a lot of basic information
37:21there is a lot of basic information
37:23there is a lot of basic information
37:25there is a lot of basic information
37:27there is a lot of basic information
37:29there is a lot of basic information
37:31there is a lot of basic information
37:33there is a lot of basic information
37:35there is a lot of basic information
37:37there is a lot of basic information
37:39there is a lot of basic information
37:41there is a lot of basic information
37:43there is a lot of basic information
37:45there is a lot of basic information
37:47there is a lot of basic information
37:49there is a lot of basic information
37:51there is a lot of basic information
37:53there is a lot of basic information
37:55there is a lot of basic information
37:57there is a lot of basic information
37:59there is a lot of basic information
38:01there is a lot of basic information
38:03there is a lot of basic information
38:05there is a lot of basic information
38:07there is a lot of basic information
38:09there is a lot of basic information
38:11there is a lot of basic information
38:13there is a lot of basic information
38:15there is a lot of basic information
38:17there is a lot of basic information
38:19there is a lot of basic information
38:21there is a lot of basic information
38:23there is a lot of basic information
38:25there is a lot of basic information
38:27there is a lot of basic information
38:29there is a lot of basic information
38:31there is a lot of basic information
38:33there is a lot of basic information
38:35there is a lot of basic information
38:37there is a lot of basic information
38:39there is a lot of basic information
38:41there is a lot of basic information
38:43there is a lot of basic information
38:45there is a lot of basic information
38:47there is a lot of basic information
38:49there is a lot of basic information
38:51there is a lot of basic information
38:53there is a lot of basic information
38:55there is a lot of basic information
38:57there is a lot of basic information
38:59there is a lot of basic information
39:01there is a lot of basic information
39:03there is a lot of basic information
39:05there is a lot of basic information
39:07there is a lot of basic information
39:09there is a lot of basic information
39:11there is a lot of basic information
39:13there is a lot of basic information
39:15there is a lot of basic information
39:17there is a lot of basic information
39:19there is a lot of basic information
39:21there is a lot of basic information
39:23there is a lot of basic information
39:25there is a lot of basic information
39:27there is a lot of basic information
39:29there is a lot of basic information
39:31there is a lot of basic information
39:33there is a lot of basic information
39:35there is a lot of basic information
39:37there is a lot of basic information
39:39there is a lot of basic information
39:41there is a lot of basic information
39:43there is a lot of basic information
39:45there is a lot of basic information
39:47there is a lot of basic information
39:49there is a lot of basic information
39:51there is a lot of basic information
39:53there is a lot of basic information
39:55there is a lot of basic information
39:57there is a lot of basic information
39:59there is a lot of basic information
40:01there is a lot of basic information
40:03there is a lot of basic information
40:05there is a lot of basic information
40:07there is a lot of basic information
40:09there is a lot of basic information
40:11there is a lot of basic information
40:13there is a lot of basic information
40:15there is a lot of basic information
40:17there is a lot of basic information
40:19there is a lot of basic information
40:21there is a lot of basic information
40:23there is a lot of basic information
40:25there is a lot of basic information
40:27there is a lot of basic information
40:29there is a lot of basic information
40:31there is a lot of basic information
40:33there is a lot of basic information
40:35there is a lot of basic information
40:37there is a lot of basic information
40:39there is a lot of basic information
40:41there is a lot of basic information
40:43there is a lot of basic information
40:45there is a lot of basic information
40:47there is a lot of basic information
40:49there is a lot of basic information
40:51there is a lot of basic information
40:53there is a lot of basic information
40:55there is a lot of basic information
40:57there is a lot of basic information
40:59there is a lot of basic information
41:01there is a lot of basic information
41:03there is a lot of basic information
41:05there is a lot of basic information
41:07there is a lot of basic information
41:09there is a lot of basic information
41:11there is a lot of basic information
41:13there is a lot of basic information
41:15there is a lot of basic information
41:17there is a lot of basic information
41:19there is a lot of basic information
41:21there is a lot of basic information
41:23there is a lot of basic information
41:25there is a lot of basic information
41:27there is a lot of basic information
41:29there is a lot of basic information
41:31there is a lot of basic information
41:33there is a lot of basic information
41:35Allah Hafiz