👉 La Corte Suprema de Justicia ha rechazado la solicitud de licencia extraordinaria del juez federal Ariel Lijo, quien buscaba asumir un cargo en el máximo tribunal sin renunciar a su puesto actual. La decisión fue tomada por mayoría, con los votos de Rosatti, Rosencrantz y García Mansilla. Este fallo genera incertidumbre sobre el futuro de Lijo en la Corte y plantea un desafío político y judicial significativo. Mientras tanto, Lijo continúa desempeñando sus funciones como juez federal en Comodoro Py.
👉 Seguí en #BuenDíaA24
📺 a24.com/vivo
👉 Seguí en #BuenDíaA24
📺 a24.com/vivo
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Reverse for Ariel Lijo, Professor.
00:03Yes, the Supreme Court rejected the license, the request for a license,
00:08remember that the Chamber had already dealt with it,
00:10the request for a license as a federal judge
00:12to assume office in the Court.
00:14Most of the Court rejected that request
00:17and now a horizon opens up that we never saw, Luis,
00:23because the judge had already said that he was not going to resign as a federal judge.
00:27Let's remember what this license is about,
00:30that Ariel Lijo asks for a license as a federal judge
00:34to maintain the position in the license
00:36and assume as a judge of the Court.
00:38Why is this?
00:39Among other things, basically,
00:41because the appointment of Lijo in the Court,
00:43in commission, by decree,
00:44will be pending that, at most, within a year,
00:48the Senate expresses itself and approves or rejects the application
00:52for the appointment as requested by the government.
00:54In those terms, Lijo is the one who has to decide now.
00:57Let's remember that Lijo said that he was not going to resign.
01:00I repeat.
01:01Let's remember this, Lijo is a first instance judge in Comodoro Pi.
01:04He is appointed to be Minister of the Supreme Court by decree.
01:08He asks for a license that the Chamber grants him
01:11in an extraordinary way,
01:13it can be a license for a long time,
01:15for at least a year, it can happen before,
01:17and now the Court says,
01:19we do not accept him as a member of the Supreme Court
01:22because the extraordinary license, as such,
01:25does not validate him to enter the Supreme Court.
01:28It's a big mess.
01:29But then what should he do?
01:30Sorry, to make it clear in some way,
01:33he should resign directly from his position.
01:36But why doesn't he resign?
01:38Because he is afraid that he will not be approved by the Senate
01:42and he will be left without the judge to whom he resigned
01:44and without the Court to which he goes.
01:46Yes, it is a personal decision, definitely.
01:48He will remain as a judge of the Court for a year
01:50At most.
01:51At most.
01:52If tomorrow, if next week,
01:54there are two movements of Kirchnerism
01:56to put together a quorum for next week.
01:58There was a discussion,
01:59it is not said, well, no,
02:00he was appointed to the Commission for a year or for a year.
02:02Let's see, the Senate,
02:03if you want me to put it in other terms,
02:05because they are all the parties,
02:06not just Kirchnerism,
02:07says, no, not for a year,
02:08it is this one that we care about.
02:09Obviously.
02:10If the Senate,
02:11it would be a very difficult irregularity
02:14to find the way out,
02:16that the son is found with a license by decree,
02:18with a decree appointment for a year
02:20and the Senate rejecting the plea.
02:23It is logical that the son says,
02:26I want, I ask for a license,
02:27and the truth is that it is logical,
02:29because at some point he is going to stay,
02:30sorry to say it like that,
02:31without bread and without cake,
02:32or not,
02:33but it is a high risk.
02:34He, at this time,
02:35while waiting for approval or not,
02:38joins the Supreme Court.
02:40He is working in the federal court.
02:42He is not only a federal judge of his court,
02:44but he subrogates,
02:45if my memory serves me right,
02:46two more courts.
02:47Two more courts.
02:48Because the same as Rafecas.
02:49He has his court,
02:50plus two more courts.
02:52Because half of the federal forum
02:55of first instance is vacant.
02:57For death, for resignation,
02:59for promotion, etc., etc.
03:00So, of course,
03:01the other judges have to subrogate him.
03:03And because of political problems,
03:04it never ends up naming the judges
03:05that have to be named.
03:06Of course.
03:07Because this is a matter.
03:08Well, the information indicates
03:10that the court does not accept
03:12the extraordinary license for Ariel Lijo,
03:14for which, technically,
03:15he will not be able to assume.
03:17And we will have to wait for the possibility
03:20that the Senate will pronounce or not,
03:25not only for Lijo,
03:27but also for García Mancilla.
03:28If he rejects García Mancilla,
03:31who is already a member
03:32of the Supreme Court of the Senate,
03:33stop doing it.
03:34Briefly,
03:35why García Mancilla, yes,
03:36since you mentioned it,
03:37why García Mancilla, yes,
03:38and Lijo, no,
03:39technically speaking.
03:40Then...
03:41Yes, then we turn it around.
03:43We serve a mate
03:44and talk about the whole political issue
03:46that is behind it.
03:47But, why?
03:49Well, basically,
03:50because García Mancilla assumes
03:51within a...
03:52First, he is not a judge.
03:53And there are not all the incompatibilities
03:55that are being talked about
03:57by a federal judge
03:58who is going to review,
03:59even to be able to review
04:00his own sentence.
04:01Obviously.
04:02As a judge of the court.
04:03But the second point,
04:04because García Mancilla
04:05is going to occupy a place
04:06that, in fact,
04:07the Constitution allows
04:08the simultaneous replacement
04:09because it entered within the period.
04:12His vacancy is generated,
04:13which is that of Juan Carlos Maqueda,
04:15within the extraordinary period
04:17where he could appoint a president.
04:19So, there is a difference.
04:20The issue of Lijo
04:21has been discussed for months
04:22when the Congress was talking.
04:23Of course.
04:24Lijo, Liko Hayton,
04:26and García Mancilla Maqueda.
04:28No, I wanted to ask the Professor a question
04:30because it says that the majority
04:31of the Supreme Court
04:32rejected the request.
04:33One assumes that Rosenkrantz
04:35must have voted against...
04:37Lorenzetti voted against.
04:39Lorenzetti must have voted
04:40in favor of Liko.
04:41Lorenzetti...
04:42Well, then...
04:43I don't have the vote.
04:44No, but taken to that,
04:45one wonders,
04:46well, if the majority,
04:47the majority composes it
04:48with García Mancilla,
04:50one assumes
04:51that he must have voted against.
04:52Because if not,
04:53it's a 2-2 draw.
04:55Again?
04:56Of course.
04:57If Lorenzetti,
04:58we assume,
04:59and I suppose...
05:00No, no, here are three that...
05:01No...
05:02No, it's just that it's great.
05:04Of course.
05:05García Mancilla,
05:06who has just been appointed
05:07by the government,
05:08should have rejected
05:09Lijo's license
05:10so that a majority
05:11of 3 against 1 is formed.
05:12Without a doubt.
05:13And of course,
05:14because I assume
05:15that Lorenzetti
05:16is not rejecting
05:17Lijo's license.
05:18No, we all assume.
05:19I don't have the fault.
05:20Now, we have to see
05:21the fault.
05:22If that were the case,
05:23the fellow
05:24of the decree,
05:25let's say,
05:26said no.
05:27The truth is that,
05:28if that were the case,
05:29I would speak
05:30of an independence
05:31of García Mancilla.
05:32García Mancilla
05:33has a problem
05:34of origin.
05:35He said,
05:36I do not assume by decree,
05:37and he assumed.
05:38And that seems to me
05:39to be the reason
05:40for the delay
05:41in the appointment.
05:42Lucia Salinas,
05:43Buendía 24.
05:44How are you, girl?
05:45How are you?
05:46Good morning to you.
05:47Indeed,
05:48the license request
05:49of Judge Ariel Lijo
05:50was rejected.
05:51Some were surprised
05:52because,
05:53precisely,
05:54to reach
05:55the majority vote,
05:56it was a case
05:57in which there could not
05:58be a draw
05:59in the Supreme Court
06:00of Justice.
06:01That majority
06:02was completed
06:03with the vote
06:04of the judge,
06:05of the Flemish
06:06Minister of the Court,
06:07Manuel García Mancilla.
06:08Sorry, Lucia,
06:09it is confirmed,
06:10Rosati,
06:11Rosencrantz
06:12and García Mancilla
06:13voted
06:14not to accept
06:15the license.
06:16Yes,
06:17exactly,
06:18that is the confirmation
06:19of the majority vote.
06:20Soon,
06:21you will know
06:22the letter
06:23of this agreement
06:24that,
06:25I will tell you,
06:26Luis,
06:27that it was quite
06:28brief
06:29in relation
06:30to the extensive
06:31individual
06:32matters
06:33of the Supreme Court
06:34of Justice.
06:35In addition
06:36to the extensive
06:37discussions
06:38that usually
06:39take place
06:40in agreements,
06:41it is also necessary
06:42to understand
06:43that
06:44the central
06:45issue
06:46of the agreement
06:47of this Thursday
06:48for the Court
06:49was the request
06:50for the license
06:51of Ariel Lijo
06:52and that the case
06:53had already begun
06:54to be analyzed
06:55with the corresponding
06:56lettered advisers
06:57during
06:58last week.
06:59So,
07:00the decision
07:01taken
07:02was to
07:03reject
07:04the request
07:05of the licensee,
07:06an extraordinary
07:07license
07:08that is always
07:09treated
07:10by the Supreme
07:11Court
07:12without salary
07:13because in the note
07:14that Ariel Lijo
07:15submitted
07:16to ask for this,
07:17he spoke of
07:18the lack of
07:19stability
07:20generated by
07:21that designation
07:22to commission
07:23by the national
07:24government
07:25to assume
07:26the Supreme Court.
07:27Yes,
07:28I would say
07:29that,
07:30first,
07:31the title,
07:32more than Ariel Lijo
07:33for now,
07:34this is the news
07:35that we have,
07:36I think that
07:37in this way
07:38we should title it.
07:39The other thing,
07:40I know that
07:41people are without
07:42light,
07:43anguished
07:44by the price,
07:45I mean,
07:46who,
07:47except Salina,
07:48the teacher,
07:49Gustavo and me,
07:50the vast majority
07:51are not interested
07:52in this internal.
07:53Now,
07:54how interesting,
07:55because some
07:56said,
07:57if Lijo and García Mancilla
07:58enter,
07:59there will be
08:00a new majority,
08:01Lorenzetti,
08:02and the first vote,
08:03García Mancilla
08:04voted with the
08:05old majority,
08:06Lucía.
08:07Well,
08:08there,
08:09also,
08:10what we have to
08:11understand is that
08:12we always raise it
08:13and it is that
08:14nothing is so
08:15linear.
08:16Nothing is so
08:17linear within
08:18the judicial power
08:19and the truth
08:20is that
08:21even if
08:22it was intended
08:23to break
08:24the current
08:25majority
08:26or that it
08:27was trimmed
08:28until last Thursday
08:29that the
08:30court
08:31decided
08:32to
08:33have
08:34Manuel García Mancilla
08:35who was on
08:36one side
08:37the president
08:38and the vice-president
08:39and on the other
08:40side
08:41Ricardo Lorenzetti,
08:42finally,
08:43this shows
08:44that nothing
08:45is so linear.