#TheReporters #PMShehbazSharif #AliAminGandapur #MaryamNawaz #MuradAliShah #SarfrazBugti #JusticeYahyaAfridi #JusticeMansoorAliShah #SupremeCourt
Analyst Haider Naqvi has requested the PM Shehbaz and Chief Ministers
CJP Yahya Afridi's first day in Courtroom Number One - Complete Details of full court meeting
Who Will Hear the Reserved Seats Case? - Justice (Rtd) Shaiq Usmani's
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
Analyst Haider Naqvi has requested the PM Shehbaz and Chief Ministers
CJP Yahya Afridi's first day in Courtroom Number One - Complete Details of full court meeting
Who Will Hear the Reserved Seats Case? - Justice (Rtd) Shaiq Usmani's
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00As-salamu alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu, welcome to the program, it's the first day
00:14of the week, Monday, and our program, today Hassan Ayub is not with us, he is away, Naqvi
00:22sahib is with me from Karachi, Haider Naqvi sahib and none other than Chaudhry Ghulam
00:25Hussain sahib from Lahore will be joining us in the discussion, viewers, the 26th amendment
00:34which the people of Pakistan could not digest, it is still somewhere in the middle, it is
00:40still in the process of being digested, on top of that, the government has started announcing
00:47that perhaps we will have to bring the 27th amendment, now what is the matter behind this,
00:52this is the first, this will be our top story, today in the newspapers, we met yesterday,
00:57in Lahore, Bilal Bhutto Zardari sahib and the Prime Minister, Respected Shahbaz Sharif
01:02sahib, the Chief Minister came because in Punjab, he gave a long and broad speech, so
01:08we met with the Respected Prime Minister, today all the newspapers have covered this
01:14meeting, the way they have covered it, they will put it in front of you, congratulations
01:19are being given, the way to send the Prime Minister home is closed, in Bilawal's Malton
01:25we will meet Respected Shahbaz Sharif sahib for the strength of the Republic and Parliament,
01:30this is the news of the war, after that you can see the news of the world, for the 27th
01:35amendment, the meeting of Bilawal's Respected Shahbaz Sharif in Lahore, the names of the
01:41members of the Judicial Commission are being considered, then the experts, viewers, are
01:46being put in front of you, to keep the way of non-democratic powers, the 26th amendment
01:50will be established, the Chairman of the PPP Credit Units, the Prime Minister, the decision
01:56to bring the 27th amendment of Respected Shahbaz Sharif, ruling allies, cheer up for another
02:01amendment, this is the view of the Don, and after that, PM Bilawal, hash out the 27th
02:07amendment, you can see this in the Tribune, the news has also covered this news, PM Bilawal
02:14holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
02:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
03:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
03:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
03:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
03:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
03:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
04:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
05:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
06:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
07:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
08:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
09:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
10:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
11:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
12:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
13:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
14:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
15:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
16:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
17:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
18:59PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:04PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:09PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:14PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:19PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:24PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:29PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:34PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:39PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:44PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:49PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:54PM Bilawal holds weekend meetings amid talk of 27th amendment,
19:59Welcome back.
20:29PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
20:34PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
20:39PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
20:44PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
20:49PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
20:54PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
20:59PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:04PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:09PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:14PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:19PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:24PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:29PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:34PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:39PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:44PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:49PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:54PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
21:59PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:04PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:09PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:14PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:19PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:24PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:29PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:34PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:39PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:44PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:49PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:54PM Bilawal is advising the Law Ministry that there are still some options left.
22:59As per the Constitution it is allowed for the Supreme Court to make its own rules.
23:04So, they will make rules for themselves and find a solution,
23:08so that some solution is found and we can go through every single case at the disciplinary system.
23:13So, that some solution is found and we can go through every single case at the disciplinary system.
23:19Otherwise there would be more confusion and delays.
23:22Absolutely right. Mr. Ghulam Sahin would like to ask you any questions.
23:27No, in Mr. Usmani's standing, I will find out from him only what he has done, that he has destroyed the court.
23:40It should have been better, the cases that are not being filed, the 60,000 cases that have been filed,
23:53there should have been work to reduce the number of cases, there should have been other things.
23:56Today, there is a speaker, I am seeing him now, he says, I am not going to implement those orders of the Supreme Court.
24:08So, if this is the situation, then Mr. Usmani, please close this Supreme Court and High Court, there is no need for the courts.
24:21This is a good thing that you have closed it.
24:24We always say this jokingly, because when our lawyers go to the courts and come back, the cases do not go on,
24:31so we say that you should close the courts.
24:35Because our courts are in such a bad condition that you cannot even imagine.
24:40No cases go on, no bench is made, the bench breaks or no one listens.
24:45This is a joke.
24:48Mr. Usmani, the case of special sessions, the speaker said, I am waiting for the Election Commission's notification.
24:57From there, of course, the direction of the Supreme Court is to the ECP.
25:00I will get the direction from there.
25:02Now the question is very critical, Mr. Usmani, that the full court became a bench, the decision of special sessions came,
25:1113 members heard the case, 13 members of the bench.
25:15Now that is a legal matter.
25:17Now that case is pending, it has a review petition.
25:20Now the question is being asked that the review petition, whether that 5-member or 7-member bench,
25:26which is to be determined now, the constitutional bench, will listen to it or will the full court bench listen to it again?
25:34What is your opinion on this?
25:37Look, there is no doubt in this that the appeal that the Supreme Court decides,
25:47if a review is filed on it later, then that review is heard by the same bench that heard it earlier.
25:54This is a standard rule of the Supreme Court.
25:57And there are many reasons for this, but this is a standard rule.
26:00And this will be the same in this too, because it relates to the old days, that is, the time before this amendment.
26:07So when it will go, it will certainly be the same bench that heard it earlier.
26:12Our friend Mr. Naqvi is also with us, he also wants to ask you a question. Yes, Haider.
26:17Sir, I wanted to ask you this, because you know better.
26:21The constitutional bench that is being talked about, the 27th amendment that is coming,
26:25in this, the role of this constitutional bench can be limited in such a way,
26:30that every case that is related to Parliament, that is related to Parliamentary Affairs,
26:35whether it is of the President's House, whether it is of the Prime Minister's House, or of the institutions working under it,
26:40a separate bench should be made for them, for their cases, and the rest of the cases should be heard by the judges of the Supreme Court.
26:46Is this possible?
26:48Everything is possible, do whatever you want, but what they should do,
26:53they should decide that when a case comes, to whom it will go,
27:00they should decide on this basis, when the role of the constitutional benches is that they only look at those things,
27:07in which the provision of the constitution has been challenged, or something has been said against it,
27:15for that, the constitutional bench should go.
27:18This is what the Parliamentary Affairs is about.
27:21Yes, the Parliamentary Affairs is also about the constitutional things,
27:25for example, if a Parliament has passed a law, and someone has challenged it,
27:31if someone has challenged it, then he will go to the constitutional bench,
27:34but in the rest of the cases, it is decided that this will be done by the constitutional bench,
27:40because if this is done, then the Supreme Court will be in a bad state.
27:44Okay, Mr. Nagvi, sorry, Mr. Usmani,
27:47the Constitutional Benches of the Supreme Court,
27:51the 26th Amendment says that
27:53there shall be constitutional benches of the Supreme Court comprising such judges of the Supreme Court,
27:59and for such term as may be nominated and determined by the Judicial Commission of Pakistan from time to time.
28:05This has come to our attention.
28:07Now, this amendment in Article 175A,
28:10the members of the Judicial Commission who have to make these benches,
28:14the Chief Justice of Pakistan will chair it,
28:17three senior judges will be a part of it,
28:20the Federal Minister of Law, the Attorney General of Pakistan will also be a part of it.
28:25Now, an important issue has come up,
28:27the senior judge of the Constitutional Benches,
28:32now, the first thing that will happen here is that the hen will lay the egg,
28:36now, this member will lay the egg here,
28:39because the one member who has to decide,
28:43who has to vote,
28:44he will be the senior most member of the Constitutional Benches.
28:51They have not been formed yet.
28:53So, how will this vote be followed?
28:55You must have seen it too.
28:57Yes, I have seen it, but I have not seen it in such detail yet
29:00that I can give you a view on it.
29:02But these things have to be decided.
29:05This happens all the time.
29:07Whenever you make an amendment in the Constitution or any law,
29:10when it is enacted,
29:13there are always problems.
29:15There is no perfection.
29:17There are always problems.
29:19Those problems can be resolved,
29:21because the Supreme Court has the power to make its rules and procedures.
29:26The Supreme Court can do that.
29:28Mr. Usmani, you know that the 26th amendment has been challenged in front of the Supreme Court.
29:34Now, the question is that this challenge will be seen by the Constitutional Benches,
29:39the full-court benches,
29:41the three-member committee under the Procedure Act,
29:45will decide which bench will listen.
29:48What do you think, what should ideally happen?
29:51No, but the way their views are in the 26th amendment,
29:54according to that, the Constitutional Benches will understand.
29:57Because it has been challenged.
29:59This amendment has been challenged in the court.
30:04Although it cannot be challenged.
30:06It is clearly written in the Constitution that
30:09any constitutional amendment cannot be challenged in any court.
30:14It is clearly written.
30:16It cannot be challenged.
30:18But in any case, when it will be passed, it will go to the Constitutional Benches.
30:21Mr. Usmani, thank you very much for your time.
30:24Thank you very much.
30:25Viewers, we will go to a break.
30:27After this matter, what kind of statements are being given by Mr. Rana Sanawala
30:33that who is senior, who is controversial, who is non-controversial.
30:37What is this whole matter?
30:39What will happen on this?
30:41What is the government thinking?
30:42We will talk in detail after the break.
30:47Viewers, there is a lot of debate these days
30:50about the decision-making of judges.
30:52How does it happen in India?
30:54How does it happen in America?
30:56How does it happen in Britain?
30:58First of all, let me take you to India.
31:00In India, over the period of time,
31:02there are different judges of the Supreme Court.
31:05The judgments of the judges.
31:07Based on them, there is a collegium system.
31:10Chief Justice is at the top.
31:13And there are four senior judges.
31:15They decide on all the decisions.
31:18Transfers, postings, judges, everything is in their hands.
31:21In 2014, their parliament, Prime Minister Modi's government challenged this.
31:28And they passed the National Judicial Appointment Commission Act 2014.
31:32In this, what has happened in our country today,
31:35exactly the same method was adopted.
31:37Government control, politicians' control, they kept it in it.
31:41In it, the law minister, attorney general, everything happened exactly the same.
31:44When this issue went to the Supreme Court,
31:47they blew it up.
31:49They said, this cannot happen.
31:51And all the control went back to the court.
31:54The principle of freedom of the court was implemented there.
31:58Talking about America,
32:00in America, their president is directly elected.
32:05He nominates.
32:08When the nomination is done,
32:10after that, the senate votes on it.
32:14There is a mixture of legislature and executive.
32:18There is a mix of both.
32:23If you look at Britain,
32:26they have an open competition.
32:28The position is vacant.
32:29It is advertised.
32:30The commission that recruits them,
32:33the majority, there are only two non-legal people.
32:37The majority of the members of the commission
32:39are determined by the judges.
32:42The president and deputy president of the UK Supreme Court.
32:46So, according to that,
32:47the legal minds are used more.
32:51What do you think, Mr. Nagbi?
32:54You have seen the situation so far.
32:56Don't you think that the government has done a little injustice?
33:00They have taken everything in their own hands.
33:02They have taken everything in their own hands.
33:04On the other hand,
33:06there is a free and fair dichotomy of power.
33:10The biggest responsibility of the powerful,
33:14now that you have become powerful,
33:16you have not talked about injustice.
33:18The hand of the government is up.
33:20The biggest responsibility of the powerful
33:22is to support the weak.
33:24After that,
33:25they should keep their conditions in front of them
33:27and take matters forward according to that.
33:30I think that the government is in a position
33:36to make the opposition do something
33:40to improve the situation in Pakistan.
33:44This is one thing.
33:45Secondly,
33:46I want to request the whole of Pakistan.
33:48We have to get out of this game of ifs and buts.
33:51If this happens, this will happen.
33:53If that happens, that will happen.
33:55We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
33:57We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
33:59We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:01We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:03We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:05We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:07We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:09We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:11We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:13We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:15We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:17We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:19We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:21We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:23We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:25We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:27We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:29We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:31We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:33We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:35We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:37We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:39We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:41We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:43We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:45We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:47We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:49We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:51We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:53We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:55We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:57We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
34:59We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:01We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:03We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:05We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:07We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:09We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:11We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:13We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:15We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:17We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:19We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:21We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:23We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:25We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:27We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:29We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:31We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:33We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:35We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:37We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:39We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:41We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:43We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:45We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:47We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:49We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:51We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:53We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:55We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:57We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
35:59We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:01We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:03We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:05We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:07We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:09We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:11We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:13We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:15We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:17We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:19We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:21We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:23We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:25We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:27We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:29We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:31We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:33We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:35We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:37We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:39We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:41We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:43We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:45We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:47We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:49We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:51We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:53We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:55We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:57We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
36:59We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:01We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:03We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:05We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:07We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:09We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:11We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:13We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:15We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:17We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:19We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:21We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:23We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:25We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:27We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:29We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:31We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:33We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:35We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:37We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
37:39We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.