" Aeen Aur Qanoon Ke Naam Par Har Woh Ghalat Kaam Kya Hai, Jo Hum Tawaqqa Nahi Karte Thay. ."
" Aeen Aur Qanoon Ke Naam Par Har Woh Ghalat Kaam Kya Hai, Jo Hum Tawaqqa Nahi Karte Thay. ."
Transcript
00:00You can see the tweet on the X.
00:02It says,
00:04Honourable Judge Syed Mansoor Ali Shah
00:06stated that
00:08following the judicial decisions
00:10is a must.
00:12The administration has no choice
00:14but to follow these decisions.
00:16If it goes in this direction,
00:18the balance sheet will be ruined.
00:20The Supreme Court,
00:22agreeing with the judge 100%,
00:24only requires so much guidance
00:26that following the judicial decisions
00:28is also a must.
00:30The question is,
00:32does the judiciary have the choice
00:34to ignore the clear and unambiguous
00:36articles of the judicial system
00:38and write their own judicial system
00:40and if the court moves
00:42in this direction,
00:44will the balance sheet be ruined
00:46or not?
00:48The Supreme Court,
00:50agreeing with the judge 100%,
00:52only requires so much guidance
00:54that following the judicial decisions
00:56is also a must.
01:26We are moving towards a meltdown.
01:28If this fight continues,
01:30the balance sheet will be ruined.
01:32Do you think we are moving
01:34towards a meltdown?
01:36On one hand, the Supreme Court's
01:38decision and on the other hand,
01:40the Parliament's judicial system
01:42which came after the Supreme Court's decision.
01:44Honourable Government,
01:46you have experienced
01:48so much on job.
01:50Judge Syed Mansoor Ali Shah
01:52spoke very clearly
01:54in a few sentences.
01:56Even a layman like me
01:58who has not read the law,
02:00has understood
02:02what he is saying.
02:04Whether you like it or not,
02:06when the Supreme Court gives a decision,
02:08you have to act on it. Period.
02:10What they are doing,
02:12it is a group of their interests.
02:14Someone has been defeated
02:16by 50,000, someone has been defeated
02:18by 100,000. They want
02:20the people of Pakistan
02:22to be defeated.
02:24They want us to be defeated
02:26by the judicial system,
02:28by the legal system,
02:30and by the Parliament.
02:32When has the Parliament
02:34become supreme?
02:36When have you accepted
02:38any of its work?
02:40You have a rubber stamp
02:42that you have been doing for 2.5 years.
02:44One amendment at night,
02:46another law in the morning,
02:48and another the next day.
02:50We did not expect
02:52that any government would do it.
02:54But it has not stopped yet.
02:56Why?
02:58Now you are inviting trouble
03:00and saying
03:02that the law will
03:04melt down.
03:06May the coming storm
03:08not stop it.
03:10God did not want me
03:12to drown on the shore.
03:14They said, you are already going to drown.
03:16I said,
03:18what are you saying?
03:20Neither will the country drown,
03:22nor will Pakistan move forward.
03:24And you will see that the country
03:26will move forward under the law and the constitution.
03:28Just a matter of time.
03:30Viewers, as
03:32a majority opinion is found in our panel,
03:34that this is an unconstitutional decision.
03:36The constitution has been misinterpreted.
03:38Rana Tanveer Hussain
03:40also says the same thing. He has said
03:42in a statement that if the support
03:44of the government is unconstitutional,
03:46then is it necessary
03:48for the government to act?
03:50There is no explanation.
03:52There is no article in the constitution
03:54according to which the judgment
03:56has been made.
03:58There is no such article anywhere in the constitution.
04:00It has been decided that it is an unconstitutional decision
04:02and there will be no action on it.
04:04There is an article that if there is
04:06any unconstitutional decision,
04:08then there is no need to act on it.
04:10Hassan,
04:12we know
04:14your opinion.
04:16I want to ask you a question.
04:18There was a fight.
04:208 members of the Supreme Court
04:22agreed to the decision.
04:24The government made a law.
04:26The solution
04:28was that
04:30the review petition should be accepted
04:32until the judges of the Supreme Court
04:34themselves accept it.
04:36Is it possible
04:38that the Supreme Court
04:40will be silent
04:42even after the decision
04:44has been made?
04:46What do you think
04:48is the solution?
04:50The solution
04:52is obvious.
04:54There are three constitutional institutions.
04:56There is also the role of the Election Commission
04:58which we are not discussing now.
05:00What will the Election Commission
05:02do?
05:04The Election Commission
05:06is having a meeting on this issue.
05:08The legal department
05:10is also having a meeting.
05:12What options do they have?
05:14On one hand, the Election Commission
05:16has filed its review.
05:18On the other hand, the Election Commission
05:20has asked for its approval.
05:22There are two applications
05:24pending in the Supreme Court.
05:26On the other hand,
05:28Justice Mansoor Ali Shah
05:30has taken a clear position
05:32that there is no option
05:34other than acting on the Supreme Court's decision.
05:36The Supreme Court has a role
05:38in the decision of powers.
05:40The Supreme Court
05:42does not have the authority
05:44to amend the constitution.
05:46If you amend the constitution
05:48in the name of justification
05:50then you have encroached
05:52on the independence of the Parliament.
05:54This is your opinion.
05:56This is the opinion of many law experts.
05:58This is the opinion of many law experts.
06:00I am saying
06:02that the solution
06:04to this conflict
06:06is your opinion.
06:08I am saying
06:10that the solution
06:12to this conflict
06:14is your opinion.
06:16I am saying
06:18that the solution
06:20to this conflict
06:22is your opinion.
06:24The solution
06:26to this conflict
06:28can be notified
06:30by the Election Commission.
06:32This can be notified
06:34by the Election Commission.
06:36This can be notified
06:38by the Election Commission.
06:40This can be notified
06:42by the Election Commission.
06:44This can be notified
06:46by the Election Commission.
06:48This can be notified
06:50by the Election Commission.
06:52This can be notified
06:54by the Election Commission.
06:56This can be notified
06:58by the Election Commission.
07:00This can be notified
07:02by the Election Commission.
07:04This can be notified
07:06by the Election Commission.
07:08This can be notified
07:10by the Election Commission.
07:12This can be notified
07:14by the Election Commission.
07:16This can be notified
07:18by the Election Commission.
07:20This can be notified
07:22by the Election Commission.
07:24This can be notified
07:26by the Election Commission.
07:28This can be notified
07:30by the Election Commission.
07:32This can be notified
07:34by the Election Commission.
07:36This can be notified
07:38by the Election Commission.
07:40This can be notified
07:42by the Election Commission.
07:44This can be notified
07:46by the Election Commission.
07:48This can be notified
07:50by the Election Commission.
07:52This can be notified
07:54by the Election Commission.
07:56This can be notified
07:58by the Election Commission.
08:00This can be notified
08:02by the Election Commission.
08:04This can be notified
08:06by the Election Commission.
08:08This can be notified
08:10by the Election Commission.
08:12This can be notified
08:14by the Election Commission.
08:16This can be notified
08:18by the Election Commission.
08:20This can be notified
08:22by the Election Commission.
08:24This can be notified
08:26by the Election Commission.