#islamabadhighcourt #imrankhan #pti #shahmehmoodqureshi #ciphercase #HassanAyub #khawarghumman #HaiderNaqvi #pti #batsymbol #supremecourt #sunniittehadcouncil
"Qanoon Ko Kabhi Maqbooliyat kay Tabay Nahi Hona Chahiye" Haider Naqvi's Analysis
Shah Mehmood Qureshi ki Rehai Main Rukawat Kiya? | Hassan Ayub's Analysis
"PTI Azad Umeedwaron Nay Apne Form Par Likha Tha Kay ...", Abid Zuberi
PTI Bat Symbol Case | SC resumes hearing on SIC’s plea | Abid Zuberi's Analysis
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
"Qanoon Ko Kabhi Maqbooliyat kay Tabay Nahi Hona Chahiye" Haider Naqvi's Analysis
Shah Mehmood Qureshi ki Rehai Main Rukawat Kiya? | Hassan Ayub's Analysis
"PTI Azad Umeedwaron Nay Apne Form Par Likha Tha Kay ...", Abid Zuberi
PTI Bat Symbol Case | SC resumes hearing on SIC’s plea | Abid Zuberi's Analysis
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:30Karachi crime rate is increasing, so we will ask Mr. Naqvi why the situation in Karachi is so bad.
00:45Mr. Faisal Wada said that he will not ask for an unconditional apology.
00:49Mr. Mustafa Kamal has asked for an apology from the Supreme Court.
00:52What will be the outcome of the case?
00:54I would like to hear the views of the panel.
00:56But today, the first story we have included in the program,
01:00viewers, it is a long story.
01:03Yesterday, a big decision was made.
01:05A big case was going to be closed.
01:09Because Pakistan's former Prime Minister, Abani PTI,
01:12and his Vice-Chairman, Shah Maud Qureshi.
01:16And the case was a chart sheet.
01:19And if you read the chart sheet,
01:21if you prove the chart sheet,
01:23the way it was circulated in the media,
01:26then some people had the opinion that death penalty should be imposed.
01:30If not death penalty, then at least age cap should be imposed.
01:33But since yesterday, we have seen that
01:35Mr. Hassan Ayyub's case was the most upset.
01:38He did not fight the case.
01:39It is his opinion that the lawyers who were present there,
01:42they did not know how to proceed with the case.
01:45Some of our senior media people are also saying that
01:51the prosecution should be hanged.
01:53Such a big case.
01:55Everything is in front of us.
01:57And despite this, Abani PTI and his Vice-Chairman,
02:01Mr. Shah Maud Qureshi, have left.
02:04You can see how our coverage has spread all over the world.
02:07Let's start with BBC.
02:09Abani PTI acquitted in state secret case.
02:14Al Jazeera.
02:15Islamabad court nullifies Imran Khan convictions in state secret leak.
02:20The international media has put more emphasis on the secret leak.
02:25Ex-Pakistan Prime Minister acquitted in state secret case but to stay in jail.
02:31TRT.
02:33Pakistan court acquits ex-Prime Minister Imran Khan in state secret leakage case.
02:40Associated Press of America.
02:45Pakistan's Imran Khan is acquitted of leaking state secrets but remains in prison on other charges.
02:53Arab News.
02:55Bloomberg.
02:56You name any international media,
02:59you name any website,
03:01you name any television channel,
03:03tomorrow this news will be a big headline.
03:07Prime Minister of any country,
03:09President of any country,
03:10an important official,
03:11if he is accused of treason against his country,
03:16if he has leaked state secrets,
03:19then the case will be a big one.
03:21But this case is in front of us.
03:24The news was also made.
03:26Yesterday, when the State Department had a press briefing in America,
03:32they were also asked,
03:34when it was said that all the other cases have been closed,
03:39some have been bailed out,
03:41some have been suspended,
03:44but the reason why he is in jail is because he is married.
03:49And of course, he is married in iddah.
03:52And that too, in the whole world,
03:55we are making a lot of fun of our honor.
03:58What was the question?
03:59What was the comment?
04:01Look at the big picture.
04:02What did the people around him say?
04:30And you just saw to this question,
04:35charges against him thrown out by the courts.
05:00The court was told that there are 17 cases against Shah Mukherjee in Islamabad.
05:11In the report, it was said that there are 38 cases against Shah Mukherjee in Punjab.
05:17There are 17 cases in Islamabad.
05:19Are there so many police stations here?
05:21This is what the Chief Justice of Islamabad asked there.
05:25There are so many cases, so many police stations in Islamabad.
05:28Similarly, on 9th May, he was in Karachi.
05:31He is a lawyer in the court of Taimur Malik.
05:35There are 38 cases in Punjab.
05:37Assistant Attorney General Azmat Basheer Dar said,
05:40there are 2-3 cases, we understand,
05:43but there are 38 cases.
05:45Then the Chief Justice questioned him.
05:48So, this is about Shah Mukherjee.
05:51Hassan said that Bani PTI has been in jail for 1-2 years,
05:56they don't come out.
05:58How soon will Shah Mukherjee come out?
06:01His daughter confirmed it.
06:02There is hope.
06:03I will start with you.
06:05Yesterday, you said that cases are being filed against politicians,
06:09and should be filed.
06:11No, they are being filed, and they will come out.
06:14There is no problem with them.
06:16What do you think?
06:18Yesterday, I was listening to a loyal advisor.
06:21He said, it is possible that the government of Pakistan
06:24should think about reviewing this case, or prosecution.
06:27Maybe they should hire a good lawyer like Hassan,
06:30so that the case can be fought well.
06:32In your opinion, should this case be left,
06:36should the government put more energy somewhere else,
06:39or should this case be held and moved forward completely?
06:43Look, one thing is that when there are such cases,
06:46there are two parties involved,
06:48and both parties want the decision of the case to be in their favor.
06:51And when the decision is not in their favor,
06:53they use all the provisions of the case.
06:55Obviously, the Supreme Court is also a provision of the case.
06:58If the government wants to go to the Supreme Court,
07:00then it has the right to go.
07:02And even if it doesn't want to go,
07:04it can make a better decision for itself.
07:06But one very important thing,
07:08which is important for the people of Pakistan,
07:10is that the law should never be subject to acceptance.
07:13I said this earlier as well.
07:15The law should always decide according to its law.
07:19It should not decide on the basis of acceptance.
07:22For example, Kasur has come to this decision
07:25because Mr. Imran Khan is a very accepted leader,
07:28and the law decided on the basis of acceptance.
07:31So the law should never be subject to acceptance.
07:34The reference you gave yesterday,
07:36that the cases of politicians are made.
07:38This is our history.
07:39The cases of politicians have been made,
07:41and we have also seen this.
07:43When there was a case against Mr. Imran Khan,
07:45neither did he fulfill his duty,
07:47nor did his sentence end.
07:49Or until he was in jail,
07:51the dates of those cases kept increasing,
07:54and those cases kept going on.
07:56His decisions did not end.
07:58So this is what is happening with politicians in Pakistan,
08:01and it will continue to happen in the future as well.
08:04Right.
08:05We have Mr. Hassan Ayub in front of us.
08:07Which lawyer are you referring to?
08:09Did you talk to any government official
08:11about the case you were referring to?
08:14No, I did not talk to the government,
08:16nor did I talk to the FIA.
08:18But in the beginning,
08:20the lawyer was Mr. Rizwan Abbasi.
08:22Who is he?
08:23You like him a lot.
08:25You were telling me about him yesterday.
08:27Show me the picture.
08:28We like him.
08:29We don't know.
08:30You were telling me that
08:32in every case,
08:33he takes a big share,
08:35and then he loses the case as well.
08:37No, you told me.
08:38I said,
08:39do you remember the Supreme Court case,
08:41when the bail matter was filed
08:43against Sardar Tariq Masood?
08:45I said,
08:46if the lawyer had any work to do,
08:48he should have talked about it.
08:50He should have given an argument.
08:52That day,
08:53he did not talk much.
08:55In this case as well,
08:56when the trial happened,
08:57there were some flaws in the trial,
08:59which happened in haste.
09:01And second,
09:02let me say this again,
09:04the lawyer's job was to
09:06get more punishments,
09:08to fix his case.
09:10How many punishments did he need?
09:11I think,
09:12if he had been punished for 2 years,
09:14then the cipher would not have disappeared.
09:17And in our ARY program,
09:19Mr. Maria Memon,
09:20the Chief Justice,
09:21said,
09:22I have lost that copy.
09:23Now,
09:24the content of the cipher
09:25was on an international website.
09:27You said,
09:28it was his job to keep the cipher.
09:29It was on an international website.
09:31The problem was that,
09:33the other copies of the cipher,
09:35had to be brought on record.
09:37Who did this?
09:39Our lawyer,
09:40Mr. Moses,
09:41who was in the trial.
09:42He forgot this as well?
09:43He forgot this as well.
09:44He did not do this as well.
09:45It was a conspiracy.
09:46When you did not bring it on record,
09:49you could have declassified it.
09:52After declassifying it,
09:53Mr. Bali Chairman had already published it.
09:55Where?
09:56The entire content.
09:57It was published.
09:58He lost the copy.
09:59He said,
10:00I will play.
10:01I have heard the audio leak myself.
10:04I think,
10:05it was Mr. Bali Chairman's voice.
10:07I am very convinced.
10:09But,
10:10you should check it.
10:11Why should I?
10:12You are doubting me.
10:13You are doubting me.
10:14You are doubting me.
10:15You are doubting me.
10:16You are doubting me.
10:17You are doubting me.
10:18You are doubting me.
10:19You are doubting me.
10:20You are doubting me.
10:21You are doubting me.
10:22You are doubting me.
10:23You are doubting me.
10:24You are doubting me.
10:25You are doubting me.
10:26You are doubting me.
10:27You are doubting me.
10:28You are doubting me.
10:29You are doubting me.
10:30You are doubting me.
10:31You are doubting me.
10:32You are doubting me.
10:33You are doubting me.
10:34You are doubting me.
10:35You are doubting me.
10:36You are doubting me.
10:37You are doubting me.
10:38You are doubting me.
10:39You are doubting me.
10:40You are doubting me.
10:41You are doubting me.
10:42You are doubting me.
10:43You are doubting me.
10:44You are doubting me.
10:45You are doubting me.
10:46You are doubting me.
10:47You are doubting me.
10:48You are doubting me.
10:49You are doubting me.
10:50You are doubting me.
10:51You are doubting me.
10:52You are doubting me.
10:53You are doubting me.
10:54You are doubting me.
10:55You are doubting me.
10:56You are doubting me.
10:57You are doubting me.
10:58You are doubting me.
10:59You are doubting me.
11:00You are doubting me.
11:01You are doubting me.
11:02You are doubting me.
11:03You are doubting me.
11:04You are doubting me.
11:05You are doubting me.
11:06You are doubting me.
11:07You are doubting me.
11:08You are doubting me.
11:09You are doubting me.
11:10You are doubting me.
11:11You are doubting me.
11:12You are doubting me.
11:13You are doubting me.
11:14You are doubting me.
11:15You are doubting me.
11:16You are doubting me.
11:17You are doubting me.
11:18You are doubting me.
11:19You are doubting me.
11:20You are doubting me.
11:21You are doubting me.
11:22You are doubting me.
11:23You are doubting me.
11:24You are doubting me.
11:25You are doubting me.
11:26You are doubting me.
11:27You are doubting me.
11:28You are doubting me.
11:29You are doubting me.
11:30You are doubting me.
11:31You are doubting me.
11:32You are doubting me.
11:33You are doubting me.
11:34You are doubting me.
11:35You are doubting me.
11:36You are doubting me.
11:37You are doubting me.
11:38You are doubting me.
11:39You are doubting me.
11:40You are doubting me.
11:41You are doubting me.
11:42You are doubting me.
11:43You are doubting me.
11:44You are doubting me.
11:45You are doubting me.
11:46You are doubting me.
11:47You are doubting me.
11:48You are doubting me.
11:49You are doubting me.
11:50You are doubting me.
11:51You are doubting me.
11:52You are doubting me.
11:53You are doubting me.
11:54You are doubting me.
11:55You are doubting me.
11:56You are doubting me.
11:57You are doubting me.
11:58You are doubting me.
11:59You are doubting me.
12:00You are doubting me.
12:01You are doubting me.
12:02You are doubting me.
12:03You are doubting me.
12:04You are doubting me.
12:05You are doubting me.
12:06You are doubting me.
12:07You are doubting me.
12:08You are doubting me.
12:09You are doubting me.
12:10You are doubting me.
12:11You are doubting me.
12:12You are doubting me.
12:13You are doubting me.
12:14You are doubting me.
12:15You are doubting me.
12:16You are doubting me.
12:17You are doubting me.
12:18You are doubting me.
12:19You are doubting me.
12:20You are doubting me.
12:21You are doubting me.
12:22You are doubting me.
12:23You are doubting me.
12:24You are doubting me.
12:25You are doubting me.
12:26You are doubting me.
12:27You are doubting me.
12:28You are doubting me.
12:29You are doubting me.
12:30You are doubting me.
12:31You are doubting me.
12:32You are doubting me.
12:33You are doubting me.
12:34You are doubting me.
12:35You are doubting me.
12:36You are doubting me.
12:37You are doubting me.
12:38You are doubting me.
12:39You are doubting me.
12:40You are doubting me.
12:41You are doubting me.
12:42You are doubting me.
12:43You are doubting me.
12:44You are doubting me.
12:45You are doubting me.
12:46You are doubting me.
12:47You are doubting me.
12:48You are doubting me.
12:49You are doubting me.
12:50You are doubting me.
12:51You are doubting me.
12:52You are doubting me.
12:53You are doubting me.
12:54You are doubting me.
12:55You are doubting me.
12:56You are doubting me.
12:57You are doubting me.
12:58You are doubting me.
12:59You are doubting me.
13:00You are doubting me.
13:01You are doubting me.
13:02You are doubting me.
13:03You are doubting me.
13:04You are doubting me.
13:05You are doubting me.
13:06You are doubting me.
13:07You are doubting me.
13:08You are doubting me.
13:09You are doubting me.
13:10You are doubting me.
13:11You are doubting me.
13:12You are doubting me.
13:13You are doubting me.
13:14You are doubting me.
13:15You are doubting me.
13:16You are doubting me.
13:17You are doubting me.
13:18You are doubting me.
13:19You are doubting me.
13:20You are doubting me.
13:21You are doubting me.
13:22You are doubting me.
13:23You are doubting me.
13:24You are doubting me.
13:25You are doubting me.
13:26You are doubting me.
13:27You are doubting me.
13:28You are doubting me.
13:29You are doubting me.
13:30You are doubting me.
13:31You are doubting me.
13:32You are doubting me.
13:33You are doubting me.
13:34You are doubting me.
13:35You are doubting me.
13:36You are doubting me.
13:37You are doubting me.
13:38You are doubting me.
13:39You are doubting me.
13:40You are doubting me.
13:41You are doubting me.
13:42You are doubting me.
13:43You are doubting me.
13:44You are doubting me.
13:45You are doubting me.
13:46You are doubting me.
13:47You are doubting me.
13:48You are doubting me.
13:49You are doubting me.
13:50You are doubting me.
13:51You are doubting me.
13:52You are doubting me.
13:53You are doubting me.
13:54You are doubting me.
13:55You are doubting me.
13:56You are doubting me.
13:57You are doubting me.
13:58You are doubting me.
13:59You are doubting me.
14:00You are doubting me.
14:01You are doubting me.
14:02You are doubting me.
14:03You are doubting me.
14:04You are doubting me.
14:05You are doubting me.
14:06You are doubting me.
14:07You are doubting me.
14:08You are doubting me.
14:09You are doubting me.
14:10You are doubting me.
14:11You are doubting me.
14:12You are doubting me.
14:13You are doubting me.
14:14You are doubting me.
14:15You are doubting me.
14:16You are doubting me.
14:17You are doubting me.
14:18You are doubting me.
14:19You are doubting me.
14:20You are doubting me.
14:21You are doubting me.
14:22You are doubting me.
14:23You are doubting me.
14:24You are doubting me.
14:25You are doubting me.
14:26You are doubting me.
14:27You are doubting me.
14:28You are doubting me.
14:29You are doubting me.
14:30You are doubting me.
14:31You are doubting me.
14:32You are doubting me.
14:33You are doubting me.
14:34You are doubting me.
14:35You are doubting me.
14:36You are doubting me.
14:37You are doubting me.
14:38You are doubting me.
14:39You are doubting me.
14:40You are doubting me.
14:41You are doubting me.
14:42You are doubting me.
14:43You are doubting me.
14:44You are doubting me.
14:45You are doubting me.
14:46You are doubting me.
14:47You are doubting me.
14:48You are doubting me.
14:49You are doubting me.
14:50You are doubting me.
14:51You are doubting me.
14:52You are doubting me.
14:53You are doubting me.
14:54You are doubting me.
14:55You are doubting me.
14:56You are doubting me.
14:57You are doubting me.
14:58You are doubting me.
14:59You are doubting me.
15:00You are doubting me.
15:01You are doubting me.
15:02You are doubting me.
15:03You are doubting me.
15:04You are doubting me.
15:05You are doubting me.
15:06You are doubting me.
15:07You are doubting me.
15:08You are doubting me.
15:09You are doubting me.
15:10You are doubting me.
15:11You are doubting me.
15:12You are doubting me.
15:13You are doubting me.
15:14You are doubting me.
15:15You are doubting me.
15:16You are doubting me.
15:17You are doubting me.
15:18You are doubting me.
15:19You are doubting me.
15:20You are doubting me.
15:21You are doubting me.
15:22You are doubting me.
15:23You are doubting me.
15:24You are doubting me.
15:25You are doubting me.
15:26You are doubting me.
15:27You are doubting me.
15:28You are doubting me.
15:29You are doubting me.
15:30You are doubting me.
15:31You are doubting me.
15:32You are doubting me.
15:33You are doubting me.
15:34You are doubting me.
15:35You are doubting me.
15:36You are doubting me.
15:37You are doubting me.
15:38You are doubting me.
15:39You are doubting me.
15:40You are doubting me.
15:41You are doubting me.
15:42You are doubting me.
15:43You are doubting me.
15:44You are doubting me.
15:45You are doubting me.
15:46You are doubting me.
15:47You are doubting me.
15:48You are doubting me.
15:49You are doubting me.
15:50You are doubting me.
15:51You are doubting me.
15:52You are doubting me.
15:53You are doubting me.
15:54You are doubting me.
15:55You are doubting me.
15:56You are doubting me.
15:57You are doubting me.
15:58You are doubting me.
15:59You are doubting me.
16:00You are doubting me.
16:01You are doubting me.
16:02You are doubting me.
16:03You are doubting me.
16:04You are doubting me.
16:05You are doubting me.
16:06You are doubting me.
16:07You are doubting me.
16:08You are doubting me.
16:09You are doubting me.
16:10You are doubting me.
16:11You are doubting me.
16:12You are doubting me.
16:13You are doubting me.
16:14You are doubting me.
16:15You are doubting me.
16:16You are doubting me.
16:17You are doubting me.
16:18You are doubting me.
16:19You are doubting me.
16:20You are doubting me.
16:21You are doubting me.
16:22You are doubting me.
16:23You are doubting me.
16:24You are doubting me.
16:25You are doubting me.
16:26You are doubting me.
16:27You are doubting me.
16:28You are doubting me.
16:29You are doubting me.
16:30You are doubting me.
16:31You are doubting me.
16:32You are doubting me.
16:33You are doubting me.
16:34You are doubting me.
16:35You are doubting me.
16:36You are doubting me.
16:37You are doubting me.
16:38You are doubting me.
16:39You are doubting me.
16:40You are doubting me.
16:41You are doubting me.
16:42You are doubting me.
16:43You are doubting me.
16:44You are doubting me.
16:45You are doubting me.
16:46You are doubting me.
16:47You are doubting me.
16:48You are doubting me.
16:49You are doubting me.
16:50You are doubting me.
16:51You are doubting me.
16:52You are doubting me.
16:53You are doubting me.
16:54You are doubting me.
16:55You are doubting me.
16:56You are doubting me.
16:57You are doubting me.
16:58You are doubting me.
16:59You are doubting me.
17:00You are doubting me.
17:01You are doubting me.
17:02You are doubting me.
17:03You are doubting me.
17:04You are doubting me.
17:05You are doubting me.
17:06You are doubting me.
17:07You are doubting me.
17:08You are doubting me.
17:09You are doubting me.
17:10You are doubting me.
17:11You are doubting me.
17:12You are doubting me.
17:13You are doubting me.
17:14You are doubting me.
17:15You are doubting me.
17:16You are doubting me.
17:17You are doubting me.
17:18You are doubting me.
17:19You are doubting me.
17:20You are doubting me.
17:21You are doubting me.
17:22You are doubting me.
17:23You are doubting me.
17:24You are doubting me.
17:25You are doubting me.
17:26You are doubting me.
17:27You are doubting me.
17:28You are doubting me.
17:29You are doubting me.
17:30You are doubting me.
17:31You are doubting me.
17:32You are doubting me.
17:33You are doubting me.
17:34You are doubting me.
17:35You are doubting me.
17:36You are doubting me.
17:37You are doubting me.
17:38You are doubting me.
17:39You are doubting me.
17:40You are doubting me.
17:41You are doubting me.
17:42You are doubting me.
17:43You are doubting me.
17:44You are doubting me.
17:45You are doubting me.
17:46You are doubting me.
17:47You are doubting me.
17:48You are doubting me.
17:49You are doubting me.
17:50You are doubting me.
17:51You are doubting me.
17:52You are doubting me.
17:53You are doubting me.
17:54You are doubting me.
17:55You are doubting me.
17:56You are doubting me.
17:57You are doubting me.
17:58You are doubting me.
17:59You are doubting me.
18:00You are doubting me.
18:01You are doubting me.
18:02You are doubting me.
18:03You are doubting me.
18:04You are doubting me.
18:05You are doubting me.
18:06You are doubting me.
18:07You are doubting me.
18:08You are doubting me.
18:09You are doubting me.
18:10You are doubting me.
18:11You are doubting me.
18:12You are doubting me.
18:13You are doubting me.
18:14You are doubting me.
18:15You are doubting me.
18:16You are doubting me.
18:17You are doubting me.
18:18You are doubting me.
18:19You are doubting me.
18:20You are doubting me.
18:21You are doubting me.
18:22You are doubting me.
18:23You are doubting me.
18:24You are doubting me.
18:25You are doubting me.
18:26You are doubting me.
18:27You are doubting me.
18:28You are doubting me.
18:29You are doubting me.
18:30You are doubting me.
18:31You are doubting me.
18:32You are doubting me.
18:33You are doubting me.
18:34You are doubting me.
18:35You are doubting me.
18:36You are doubting me.
18:37You are doubting me.
18:38You are doubting me.
18:39You are doubting me.
18:40You are doubting me.
18:41You are doubting me.
18:42You are doubting me.
18:43You are doubting me.
18:44You are doubting me.
18:45You are doubting me.
18:46You are doubting me.
18:47You are doubting me.
18:48You are doubting me.
18:49You are doubting me.
18:50You are doubting me.
18:51You are doubting me.
18:52You are doubting me.
18:53You are doubting me.
18:54You are doubting me.
18:55You are doubting me.
18:56You are doubting me.
18:57You are doubting me.
18:58You are doubting me.
18:59You are doubting me.
19:00You are doubting me.
19:01You are doubting me.
19:02You are doubting me.
19:03You are doubting me.
19:04You are doubting me.
19:05You are doubting me.
19:06You are doubting me.
19:07You are doubting me.
19:08You are doubting me.
19:09You are doubting me.
19:10You are doubting me.
19:11You are doubting me.
19:12You are doubting me.
19:13You are doubting me.
19:14You are doubting me.
19:15You are doubting me.
19:16You are doubting me.
19:17You are doubting me.
19:18You are doubting me.
19:19You are doubting me.
19:20You are doubting me.
19:21You are doubting me.
19:22You are doubting me.
19:23You are doubting me.
19:24You are doubting me.
19:25You are doubting me.
19:26You are doubting me.
19:27You are doubting me.
19:28You are doubting me.
19:29You are doubting me.
19:30You are doubting me.
19:31You are doubting me.
19:32You are doubting me.
19:33You are doubting me.
19:34You are doubting me.
19:35You are doubting me.
19:36You are doubting me.
19:37You are doubting me.
19:38You are doubting me.
19:39You are doubting me.
19:40You are doubting me.
19:41You are doubting me.
19:42You are doubting me.
19:43You are doubting me.
19:44You are doubting me.
19:45You are doubting me.
19:46You are doubting me.
19:47You are doubting me.
19:48You are doubting me.
19:49You are doubting me.
19:50You are doubting me.
19:51You are doubting me.
19:52You are doubting me.
19:53You are doubting me.
19:54You are doubting me.
19:55You are doubting me.
19:56You are doubting me.
19:57You are doubting me.
19:58You are doubting me.
19:59You are doubting me.
20:00You are doubting me.
20:01You are doubting me.
20:02You are doubting me.
20:03You are doubting me.
20:04You are doubting me.
20:05You are doubting me.
20:06You are doubting me.
20:07You are doubting me.
20:08You are doubting me.
20:09You are doubting me.
20:10You are doubting me.
20:11You are doubting me.
20:12You are doubting me.
20:13You are doubting me.
20:14You are doubting me.
20:15You are doubting me.
20:16You are doubting me.
20:17You are doubting me.
20:18You are doubting me.
20:19You are doubting me.
20:20You are doubting me.
20:21You are doubting me.
20:22You are doubting me.
20:23You are doubting me.
20:24You are doubting me.
20:25You are doubting me.
20:26You are doubting me.
20:27You are doubting me.
20:28You are doubting me.
20:29You are doubting me.
20:30You are doubting me.
20:31You are doubting me.
20:32You are doubting me.
20:33You are doubting me.
20:34You are doubting me.
20:35You are doubting me.
20:36You are doubting me.
20:37You are doubting me.
20:38You are doubting me.
20:39You are doubting me.
20:40You are doubting me.
20:41You are doubting me.
20:42You are doubting me.
20:43You are doubting me.
20:44You are doubting me.
20:45You are doubting me.
20:46You are doubting me.
20:47You are doubting me.
20:48You are doubting me.
20:49You are doubting me.
20:50You are doubting me.
20:51You are doubting me.
20:52You are doubting me.
20:53You are doubting me.
20:54You are doubting me.
20:55You are doubting me.
20:56You are doubting me.
20:57You are doubting me.
20:58You are doubting me.
20:59You are doubting me.
21:00You are doubting me.
21:01You are doubting me.
21:02You are doubting me.
21:03You are doubting me.
21:04You are doubting me.
21:05You are doubting me.
21:06You are doubting me.
21:07You are doubting me.
21:08You are doubting me.
21:09You are doubting me.
21:10You are doubting me.
21:11You are doubting me.
21:12You are doubting me.
21:13You are doubting me.
21:14You are doubting me.
21:15You are doubting me.
21:16You are doubting me.
21:17You are doubting me.
21:18You are doubting me.
21:19You are doubting me.
21:20You are doubting me.
21:21You are doubting me.
21:22You are doubting me.
21:23You are doubting me.
21:24You are doubting me.
21:25You are doubting me.
21:26You are doubting me.
21:27You are doubting me.
21:28You are doubting me.
21:29You are doubting me.
21:30You are doubting me.
21:31You are doubting me.
21:32You are doubting me.
21:33You are doubting me.
21:34You are doubting me.
21:35You are doubting me.
21:36You are doubting me.
21:37You are doubting me.
21:38You are doubting me.
21:39You are doubting me.
21:40You are doubting me.
21:41You are doubting me.
21:42You are doubting me.
21:43You are doubting me.
21:44You are doubting me.
21:45You are doubting me.
21:46You are doubting me.
21:47You are doubting me.
21:48You are doubting me.
21:49You are doubting me.
21:50You are doubting me.
21:51You are doubting me.
21:52You are doubting me.
21:53You are doubting me.
21:54You are doubting me.
21:55You are doubting me.
21:56You are doubting me.
21:57You are doubting me.
21:58You are doubting me.
21:59You are doubting me.
22:00You are doubting me.
22:01You are doubting me.
22:02You are doubting me.
22:03You are doubting me.
22:04You are doubting me.
22:05You are doubting me.
22:06You are doubting me.
22:07You are doubting me.
22:08You are doubting me.
22:09You are doubting me.
22:10You are doubting me.
22:11You are doubting me.
22:12You are doubting me.
22:13You are doubting me.
22:14You are doubting me.
22:15You are doubting me.
22:16You are doubting me.
22:17You are doubting me.
22:18You are doubting me.
22:19You are doubting me.
22:20You are doubting me.
22:21You are doubting me.
22:22You are doubting me.
22:23You are doubting me.
22:24You are doubting me.
22:25You are doubting me.
22:26You are doubting me.
22:27You are doubting me.
22:28You are doubting me.
22:29You are doubting me.
22:30You are doubting me.
22:31You are doubting me.
22:32You are doubting me.
22:33You are doubting me.
22:34You are doubting me.
22:35You are doubting me.
22:36You are doubting me.
22:37You are doubting me.
22:38You are doubting me.
22:39You are doubting me.
22:40You are doubting me.
22:41You are doubting me.
22:42You are doubting me.
22:43You are doubting me.
22:44You are doubting me.
22:45You are doubting me.
22:46You are doubting me.
22:47You are doubting me.
22:48You are doubting me.
22:49You are doubting me.
22:50You are doubting me.
22:51You are doubting me.
22:52You are doubting me.
22:53You are doubting me.
22:54You are doubting me.
22:55You are doubting me.
22:56You are doubting me.
22:57You are doubting me.
22:58You are doubting me.
22:59You are doubting me.
23:00You are doubting me.
23:01You are doubting me.
23:02You are doubting me.
23:03You are doubting me.
23:04You are doubting me.
23:05You are doubting me.
23:06You are doubting me.
23:07You are doubting me.
23:09Welcome back.
23:11Now as in Zahira,
23:22Files a nomination paper saying I belong to party X.
23:27Yes.
23:28And attaches the certificate from that political party.
23:34Because we are, for this clause we are only concerned with political parties.
23:40Which says that yes, he is our candidate.
23:45That person is not an independent candidate.
23:50He is a candidate of a political party.
23:53Only that person who has made a declaration, I do not belong to any political party.
24:00Now the question is that you have told us yesterday that all of these candidates who are now with you
24:29in your camp, they filed their nomination papers.
24:33And in those nomination papers they made declarations that they belong to PTI.
24:39Those nomination papers as I understand it, but kindly correct me if I have got it wrong,
24:45were never repudiated by PTI nor were they rejected by definition by anyone
24:51because they went through the scrutiny process.
24:54And they, those people naturally stood for election and they got elected.
25:01Surely as a matter of law, I applying the principal parent act,
25:08all of those persons were PTI returned candidates.
25:15How can rule making power of the election commission,
25:19especially in the context of rule 94,
25:22go against the parent statute and impose this additional condition of election symbol.
25:29Where does that come from?
25:31Mr. Zubairi, please explain this argument to Justice Musa Muneeb.
25:38Yes, I totally agree with that argument.
25:42Do you remember, last year when this issue was going on,
25:45I had done a program with you on this point.
25:48I always had this that this is not independent.
25:52Because the form which they have filled, it is written on it that it is PTI,
25:55they have a certificate.
25:56So this is not independent.
25:58By taking the symbol, they do not become independent.
26:00Their symbol was taken as a punishment that your intraparty elections were not right.
26:05So your punishment, section 215 says that is also a debatable issue
26:09whether it was taken right or not,
26:10whether the judgment of the Supreme Court is right according to law or not.
26:13That is a different debate.
26:15The question that Hassan was asking,
26:17that the judgment is right, I think the judgment is also wrong.
26:21And because of that only we are in this situation,
26:24the condition we are going through.
26:26So in this, they were not independent at all.
26:30So when they were not independent,
26:31by taking their symbol, their political affiliation,
26:34their political party does not end.
26:36And that party which is registered with the Election Commission of Pakistan,
26:39so they were not independent.
26:41So if you take their symbol,
26:42so my issue has always been this.
26:44You see, by taking the programs,
26:46that they are not independent.
26:48And if they fight with them,
26:50that elections were fought on them,
26:52but they were people of PTI.
26:53So it was the existence of PTI.
26:55So brother, this should have been clarified to the Election Commissioner.
26:57Mr. Naqvi, ask a question.
26:59Look, it is not a question,
27:01I would just like to say that
27:03a part of the people understand this law and the constitution and these things.
27:08But the rest of the people see it in a completely different way.
27:11And if you want to correct the things of the past,
27:13if you say that that decision,
27:15one thing has been said,
27:16that if that decision had not come,
27:18then today this would not have happened.
27:19If you want to correct the things of the past,
27:21then the decision to hold elections on 14th May,
27:24in that too, these Moses judges were sitting.
27:26Start talking from there,
27:28why couldn't you hold elections on 14th May?
27:30Right, your point has come.
27:32Mr. Chaudhary, you also comment,
27:34ask a question to Mr. Zubair.
27:37What did he say to Mr. Zubair?
27:39Mr. Zubair is one of the finest lawyers that we have.
27:45He never keeps anything hidden.
27:47Whatever he thinks is right, he talks about it.
27:49And Mashallah, we are very fond of him.
27:53But the thing is,
27:55you give me an answer to three things.
27:59Did anyone consider this election to be free, fair or impartial?
28:04Remand.
28:06They formed for it.
28:08I don't care if they formed for it.
28:33The police and the officers were put in jail.
28:37The election commission,
28:39almost as a party,
28:41is still going on.
28:43And if these people are not brought to the judiciary,
28:48if they are not punished,
28:50and the people who have been remanded,
28:52if they are not returned,
28:54then in Pakistan,
28:56there will be no trust left on any institution,
28:58on any election.
29:00And forgive me,
29:02the lawyers did not play the role that you expected.
29:06Okay, Mr. Zubair,
29:08you can comment on this too,
29:10but an important point was raised.
29:12Can I answer this?
29:14Yes, yes, Mr. Zubair.
29:16First of all,
29:18you are right,
29:20the election was not free and fair from the start.
29:22Mr. Ghulam,
29:24remember where it started.
29:26When his wife's appointment was challenged in the Lahore High Court,
29:30the election commission came to the Supreme Court
29:32in a direct appeal
29:34against the order of Justice Bakar Najfi,
29:36if you remember.
29:38And on that,
29:40Umair Niazi,
29:42the lawyer who filed the petition,
29:44was issued a contempt notice.
29:46And the judge was also issued a contempt notice.
29:48And he said,
29:50how can you interfere?
29:52Then the women were challenged.
29:54That was also set aside by the Supreme Court.
29:56Two basic things that the Supreme Court
29:58itself has said in its previous decisions.
30:00That for a free and fair election,
30:02it is necessary for women to be independent.
30:04You finished that before this Supreme Court election.
30:08We also said at that time
30:10that this was not the right decision.
30:12You are relying so much on the election commission.
30:14From the beginning,
30:16you just talked about May 14th.
30:18Couldn't you get the election done on May 14th?
30:20I filed that case.
30:22I filed a case against the Supreme Court.
30:24I didn't have a notice in it.
30:26But the Supreme Court did not implement it.
30:28Government, establishment, no one did it.
30:30The Supreme Court itself did not take a contempt on it.
30:32That is my own question.
30:34Why did the Supreme Court not act at that time?
30:36But look at this.
30:38The Supreme Court ordered it.
30:40This is the first that the election was not fair.
30:42All this happened on the RO.
30:44When the government of Form 47
30:46is not accepting your mandate,
30:48the people of Form 45 are taking it.
30:50A presidential ordinance was issued
30:52that the retired judge will appoint him.
30:54The Chief Justice of Lahore
30:56gave a list of independent judges
30:58for the election tribunal.
31:00It is possible that the fraudulent decisions
31:02that have been made there,
31:04election fraud has been committed.
31:06Tell me this, Abhishek.
31:08Before this,
31:10the old law,
31:12from the 2002 election
31:14to the 2008 election,
31:16even at that time,
31:18the appointing authority of the election tribunal
31:20has always been the Election Commission of Pakistan.
31:22And earlier,
31:24the retired judges were also appointed.
31:26They included him later.
31:28But still,
31:30both had to
31:32consult each other.
31:34So,
31:36where there has been a dispute
31:38between the Election Commission
31:40and the Lahore High Court,
31:42there was a question raised
31:44by the respected Chief Justice,
31:46that he sent
31:48one person for Pindi and Bahawalpuri,
31:50the name of the judge,
31:52and was asked to notify him.
31:54He said, send us a panel.
31:56Send us 3-4 judges.
31:58Secondly,
32:00you were saying that
32:02the matter of ROs
32:04was taken up in the High Court.
32:06The Supreme Court has decided
32:08that you should not interfere in the work of the Election Commission.
32:10So, the question is,
32:12the responsibility of the election administration
32:14lies with the Election Commission of Pakistan
32:16or the Peshawar High Court?
32:18Yes.
32:20You are absolutely right.
32:22The role of the Election Commission of Pakistan
32:24in the last two years
32:26is that they have broken the law
32:28and have not held elections in the last 90 days.
32:30Look at the context of that.
32:32It was being said that the ROs
32:34who were appointed in the last elections,
32:36the elections you spoke about,
32:38were appointed by the judiciary.
32:40So, they were not accused so much.
32:42They were appointed by the bureaucrats.
32:44That is why it was being said that the bureaucrats
32:46should be taken up by the judiciary.
32:48Sir, Mr. Imran Khan had said
32:50that Iftikhar Chaudhary
32:52had held the ROs elections.
32:54Mr. Zardari had said that.
32:56Iftikhar Chaudhary had said
32:58that Iftikhar Chaudhary
33:00had held the ROs elections.
33:02Mr. Zardari had said that.
33:04Mr. Zardari had held the ROs elections.
33:06Let's move forward.
33:08Another important point was raised.
33:10It was said that
33:12to keep the people complete,
33:14you have to complete the
33:16reserved seats.
33:18It was also said that
33:20if only one person
33:22from each political party
33:24is elected,
33:26then what will happen?
33:28Listen to this.
33:30It is clear from the example
33:32that there are two political parties
33:34who have taken up
33:36each seat.
33:38The remaining 264 seats
33:40are with the independents.
33:42Will the parties who have
33:44taken up each seat
33:46get 70 votes?
33:48No, they cannot.
33:50In the world,
33:52there is disproportionate
33:54representation.
33:56I asked you the first question
33:58when you started.
34:00I said that this number
34:02could be reduced to
34:04336.
34:06It will not happen.
34:08Hypothetically,
34:10if no political party
34:12secures any seat,
34:14then
34:16will there be
34:18allocation of seats?
34:20Yes, it will happen.
34:24If there is no political party
34:26which has secured a seat,
34:28then it will not happen.
34:32This was a hypothetical
34:34question.
34:36All political parties
34:38win elections.
34:40But,
34:42in the world,
34:44the oldest and
34:46the newest democracy
34:48is run by political parties.
34:50No house is complete
34:52without a political party.
34:54Tell us the solution.
34:56It is not an act of parliament.
34:58This will require
35:00a creative reading
35:02of this provision.
35:04And your lordship can issue directions
35:06because this proportional representation
35:08It has left this option open
35:10that through
35:12a maturing interpretation
35:14of this
35:16court-faced
35:18interpretation
35:20of this
35:22court-faced
35:24interpretation
35:26of this
35:28court-faced
35:30interpretation
35:32of this
35:34court-faced
35:36of this
35:38contemporary problem.
35:40The court can solve this problem
35:42through interpretation
35:44because the section itself allows
35:46But, can we hear the election commission on this?
35:48Because you are not required to
35:50have a solution to it.
35:52This is their solution
35:54Let's just park it here.
35:56Let them explain how this works.
35:58Mr. Zubair, this question
36:00was very difficult for Mr. Siddiqui
36:02If no country wins elections
36:04So if he doesn't come, what is the House going to do?
36:06Obviously, any parliament, like I said, whether it's the UK's, or India's,
36:11elections are taking place right now, or it's the US's,
36:14without political parties, the system doesn't move forward.
36:17We have a parliamentary system of democracy.
36:19So in a parliamentary system of democracy, political parties are very important.
36:24So ifs and buts, you can say whatever you want.
36:26Mr. Khawar, I have something to say.
36:27Yes, Mr. Chaudhary, go ahead.
36:28I also have something to say, Mr. Khawar.
36:29Yes, yes, please, sir.
36:30Permission, sir.
36:31First, Mr. Chaudhary.
36:32Mr. Khawar, forgive me, and Mr. Zubairi,
36:36where you were sitting for five days, we were also there.
36:41Okay?
36:42We were told that Azad was winning with 203 seats,
36:46so-called Azad, PTI.
36:48PTI Azad.
36:50In fact, they were saying that there were cuts in the railways,
36:53one person said this, another said that.
36:55I mean, forget that.
36:56Yes, he said that.
36:57If Azad had won with 203 seats,
37:04and only with 63 seats,
37:06he would have won with 15-20 parties, 2-3.
37:09So with 203 seats,
37:12he would have won with 15-20 parties.
37:18What kind of election did you want to have?
37:21You made a list,
37:23then you found out that they had defied you.
37:27They all went and voted for Zubairi.
37:30What should we do now?
37:31Mr. Chaudhary, please comment,
37:32then we will go to the break,
37:33and then Mr. Zubairi will talk.
37:34I want to say a very small thing.
37:36One of our viewers said today
37:38that the matter got worse when PTI was not given a baton.
37:41Look, the matter got worse
37:44when your Majlis-e-Wahidat-e-Muslimeen was united,
37:47and you were going to the National Assembly in his name.
37:50So PTI should also answer the people
37:52that why did you destroy that unity?
37:54If you had come to the National Assembly
37:56in the name of Majlis-e-Wahidat-e-Muslimeen,
37:58you would have got all the seats,
37:59because there was already one seat there.
38:01This is a small answer.
38:02This is also a valid argument.
38:04Mr. Zubairi, after a short break,
38:06Mr. Zubairi, please comment.
38:12Welcome back.
38:13Mr. Zubairi, the points that have been put in front of you,
38:17please comment on them.
38:19Look, I think that PTI is present as a Jamaat in the Parliament.
38:25And only they should get these seats.
38:27I think this thing about the Sunni Ijtihad Council,
38:30when their lawyers were saying that they should join us or something,
38:34they have also done it.
38:35But I feel that its interpretation should be that
38:37no matter what symbol they take,
38:39the status of their party,
38:40all the people who have been elected,
38:42they belong to PTI.
38:43They have the right to these reserved seats.
38:46Number one.
38:47Number two,
38:48if you go,
38:49they will not get seats in any way.
38:51But the PR system,
38:52our proportional representation,
38:54the party that has the seats,
38:56should get them according to that.
38:58Now I am not talking about the supposed seats.
39:00Absolutely right.
39:01We are talking about the present position.
39:03We can do a lot to do.
39:05If all the people become independent,
39:06then what will happen?
39:07Now look,
39:08this is a practical situation.
39:09This is the decision of the case,
39:11the situation that is in front of us now.
39:13Is this PTI PTI?
39:15Then this debate ends.
39:17They should get seats.
39:18If they go with the Sunni Ijtihad Council,
39:20then should they get seats or not?
39:22But what I am saying is that
39:23others cannot get it.
39:24It is up to them.
39:25Now the fourth question that comes up is
39:27that will they remain empty?
39:28They should remain empty.
39:29Now this is a question of the constitution.
39:32This is not a question of an election act or rules.
39:35Article 51.5 and Article 51.6
39:41say that you will get representation
39:43according to the number of seats you get.
39:46It is not written anywhere that
39:48if you do not get anything,
39:49then it will be distributed among you.
39:51Thank you very much for your time.
39:53Viewers, there is a lot of debate
39:55on this argument that
39:56a creative solution should be found.
40:00The constitution of Pakistan is very clear
40:02that if the constitution is silent
40:04and there is no solution,
40:06then the final interpretation,
40:08the authority to find a solution,
40:11the constitution of Pakistan,
40:12the constitution of 1973,
40:14is with the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
40:16And the Supreme Court has to show the way
40:18if there is any silence.
40:21Viewers, today in Islamabad,
40:23as you know,
40:24there are groups of 46, 47, 48,
40:27Dr. Tariq Fazal Chaudhry,
40:29Akhil Sahib,
40:30and Raja Khurram Nawaz Sahib.
40:32Now they have taken Farm 45
40:35and have locked it in a box,
40:37have made a river,
40:40have drained it in a singly dam,
40:41they have found a place nearby,
40:43or maybe they have got sick,
40:46or they have eaten the chickpeas,
40:49so they are not giving the farm.
40:51If you ask them for Farm 45,
40:53today they have run away.
40:54The election commission of Pakistan,
40:56the election tribunal that is present,
40:59which is being headed by Justice Tariq Jahangiri,
41:03we do not trust him.
41:05So now they have petitioned the election commission,
41:09and the election commission has submitted their petition.
41:12Now in the morning,
41:13a case has to be heard in front of the election tribunal,
41:16and the election commission has to hear it as well.
41:18The election commission has given the authority
41:21to the election commission,
41:23as you know,
41:25to appoint a retired judge of their choice.
41:28So this is the situation.
41:30Hassan Ayub Sahib,
41:32the fight of the elders,
41:34the fight of the elephants,
41:35the fight of the grass,
41:36the grass will go bad,
41:38and who knows what will happen,
41:40the loss will be of the grass.
41:42All of them are experienced politicians,
41:45all three of them,
41:46have been in the MN for multiple times.
41:48Farm 45, there is no one in Gwanda.
41:50Let me tell you,
41:51they have done a very good job.
41:52The issue is that,
41:55the applicants who have come to the tribunal,
42:01have raised many such objections.
42:03First of all,
42:04they have made a separate registrar for the tribunal.
42:07A new registrar has been appointed.
42:09Now the existing registrar of Islamabad High Court,
42:11has raised some objections.
42:13Now the function of the tribunal is such that,
42:16when objections are raised by the registrar,
42:18now listen to the whole thing.
42:20After that,
42:21after that,
42:22after that,
42:23after that,
42:24after that,
42:25after that,
42:26after that,
42:27after that,
42:28after that,
42:29after that,
42:30after that,
42:31after that,
42:34after that,
42:35after that,
42:37after that,
42:39after that,
42:43theYou can't understand
42:45what I am saying
42:47properly.
42:48What I am saying is that,
42:49what I am saying is that,
42:51Farm 45 is organized in accordance with the deeds satisfied by the people of the land.