"Relief Hamein us Waqt Diya Jata Hai Jab yaqeen Hojata Hai..." Intazar Hussain Panjutha's Analysis
#imrankhan #pti #supremecourt #islamabadhighcourt #Intazarpanjutha
"Relief Hamein us Waqt Diya Jata Hai Jab yaqeen Hojata Hai..." Intazar Hussain Panjutha's Analysis
"Relief Hamein us Waqt Diya Jata Hai Jab yaqeen Hojata Hai..." Intazar Hussain Panjutha's Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00First of all, you have expressed distrust on two judges.
00:06On one hand, you have expressed distrust on Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa sahib and on the other hand, you have expressed distrust on the Chief Justice of Islamabad High Court.
00:11But today, he has rejected your argument.
00:13He said that a trend will start in this way, everyone will come and he will say that he has sent a reference, you should not sit on this bench.
00:18Look, today the court has mentioned two cases.
00:21We think that our case is completely different from those two cases.
00:25He mentioned the decision of Babar Sattar sahib, in which he was requested by the FIA and the government bodies.
00:32But our case is very different from that.
00:35It is different in the way that we have been struggling for the past two years and our grounds,
00:41if you look at the complaint that we have filed to the Supreme Judicial Council,
00:48it is a 24-page complaint in which we have given each and every detail,
00:54we have told each and every thing, on which occasions.
00:57And we are not saying those things alone.
00:59Those things, now a judgment has come in the Therian-White case,
01:03in which the judges have mentioned the conduct.
01:06They have also given a note on it.
01:07They have not given a finding.
01:08But they have mentioned the conduct.
01:10Apart from that, the letter of six judges, in which our case has also been mentioned.
01:14And of course, in our cases, they have been pressurized like this.
01:19And then on 9th May, the biggest thing is that on 9th May, the case was declared legal.
01:25After that, an inquiry was ordered by them.
01:28That we will order that whatever happened was illegal.
01:33They themselves accepted it as illegal.
01:35But despite that, no inquiry has been done so far.
01:38Nor was there any injustice committed on the attack of the High Court.
01:41Sir, please tell me one thing.
01:42If you look at the track record,
01:44because I understand that you also have a ground for Shikhs.
01:47But in Tosha Khana NAB reference also,
01:49Chief Justice Amir Farooq has suspended the punishment of Imran Khan and his wife, Bushra Bibi.
01:54Along with that, on 28th August, 2023, the punishment was suspended.
01:58On 3rd June, the Chief Justice of Islamabad High Court,
02:00against whom you have now taken reference,
02:02once again, when the Do-Rukni Division Bench has given a verdict on these appeals,
02:06in the Cypher case, Imran Khan and Shah Mehmood Qureshi were also acquitted.
02:09Along with that, in 15th May, in the Kolkata Trust case also,
02:12a release order was given on bail, in which Amir Farooq Sahib was present.
02:15The Chief Justice of Islamabad High Court,
02:17once again, Do-Rukni Bench,
02:19then on the day of Budh, on Imran Khan's request for bail,
02:21a day before, the verdict was given.
02:24Sir, on 13th July, in the Iddat case, the punishment was suspended.
02:27Qazi, so before I get to Qazi Sahib,
02:29please tell me that, sir, this, and now,
02:31the Jalsa that you want to do tomorrow,
02:34on that also, the NOC was suspended and sent back to the administration.
02:37So, you cannot say that this is a one-sided matter.
02:41Absolutely. You have asked a very good question.
02:43I will answer it in detail.
02:45As you have asked in detail,
02:47I will keep it in front of you, I will keep the figures.
02:51More than 135 cases,
02:53around 200 cases,
02:55in this duration, we have filed.
02:57I am telling you roughly.
02:59We did the calculation 10-15 days ago.
03:01According to that, 135 cases,
03:05which is around 70-80%,
03:08Aamir Farooq Sahib has kept it with him.
03:10Here, we think that,
03:12for us, only to the extent of Khan Sahib,
03:15and to the extent of TTI cases,
03:17only one man has been hired.
03:19If there is a divisional bench,
03:21then the Chief Sahib is also a part of that.
03:24And then, the release that you have talked about,
03:27this release was given when
03:29Imran Khan was, I mean,
03:32his release was not possible
03:34because of these reliefs.
03:36Now, I will explain it to you.
03:38I will take you back.
03:40On 5th August, when Khan Sahib...
03:42So, he was completely sure that he will not come out.
03:44So, give relief.
03:46Sir, you are checking the intentions.
03:48Sir, Madam, this is my case.
03:50I am telling you based on facts.
03:52This has not happened once.
03:54This is happening repeatedly.
03:56I will tell you the trend.
03:58The case in which we are present today,
04:00this case was filed a month and a half ago.
04:02In this case, what we were doing initially,
04:04or what challenge we were doing,
04:06we were challenging the case
04:08in which Khan Sahib has been arrested now.
04:10Bushra Bibi has been arrested now.
04:12So, this is that case.
04:14Fixing this case,
04:16without any reason,
04:18by putting it in the no scope list,
04:20it was cancelled.
04:22We have given the application again and again.
04:24We have requested again and again.
04:26Because you were foreseeing that this was going to happen.
04:28Our case was not heard.
04:30The day he was arrested,
04:32this case was filed twice in a week.
04:34Now, if we are given relief,
04:36it has happened in 9th May,
04:38we will be told that we have given relief.
04:40So, we have to say
04:42with heavy heart
04:44that this is a scheme
04:46which is continuously going on.
04:48This is not like that.
04:50I will take you to 5th August.
04:52On 3rd August, Amir Farooq Sahib gave a decision
04:54when Humayun Dilawar punished
04:56Tosha Khanna on election commission.
04:58On that day,
05:00on 3rd August,
05:02in that case,
05:04our criminal division against the order of Humayun Dilawar
05:06is still pending.
05:08Then, in our criminal division,
05:10he himself gave a notice for next week.
05:12And in the third one,
05:14he himself ordered to decide it in two days.
05:16And it happened that it was decided
05:18in two days.
05:20The meaning of the decision was the same.
05:22The question of maintainability,
05:24you can ask a common lawyer
05:26that the question of maintainability
05:28is such a question that
05:30the courts decide it first.
05:32Because maintainability is a question of law.
05:34If the question of law is not
05:36in accordance with the law,
05:38then perfectly,
05:40if you will run it,
05:42then ultimately,
05:44it has to be declared null and void.
05:46So, in all the proceedings,
05:48the legality is seen first.
05:50Two times,
05:52the application of maintainability
05:54will be sent back to the same judge.
05:56This never happens.
05:58The decision on the application of maintainability
06:00is given on 3rd August.
06:02Our criminal division
06:04is still pending.
06:06After that,
06:08there was a three-year sentence
06:10which is considered a short punishment.
06:12The President of Islamabad High Court
06:14himself suspended it straight away.
06:16Our petition
06:18went on and on.
06:20The decision was made
06:22on 27th or 28th August.
06:24But later,
06:26on 15th August,
06:28he was arrested in the Cypher case.
06:30So, the relief that is given to us,
06:32the relief is given to us
06:34when it is ensured
06:36that Mr. Khan will remain inside.
06:38That is, he has been arrested in some other case.
06:40Now, there is no danger,
06:42so we are relieved.
06:44You have put all this in the reference.
06:46You have shown the entire track record.
06:48There are many other things that we have shown.
06:52The recent cases that have been presented today,
06:54I have put an example in front of you.
06:56This is a part of the record.
06:58I am not talking from my side.
07:00The entire record of this case
07:02is available on the website of Islamabad High Court.
07:04You go and check
07:06why this case was
07:08no-scoped five times and its list was cancelled.
07:10And now, what is the urgency
07:12that it has been fixed twice in a week?
07:14So, on one hand, there is a delay.
07:16On the other hand,
07:18a balancing act is done.
07:20This is a clear thing.
07:22And then you see,
07:24if the judges of the other High Court are present,
07:26then why one judge for us?
07:28Only one judge is the entire High Court for us.
07:30So, this thing is...
07:32Sir, please give me a chance.
07:34A lot of things are going on at the same time.
07:36You have expressed distrust
07:38against two Chiefs.
07:40Qazi Faiz Isa Sahib is also there.
07:42We will come to him as well.