"Supreme Court Nay Constitution ko "re-write" Kardiya" Hassan Ayub's & Haider Naqvi's Analysis
#reservedseatscase #supremecourt #cjp #imrankhan #pti #chaudhryghulamhussain #khawarghumman #breakingnews
"Supreme Court Nay Constitution ko "re-write" Kardiya" Hassan Ayub's & Haider Naqvi's Analysis
"Supreme Court Nay Constitution ko "re-write" Kardiya" Hassan Ayub's & Haider Naqvi's Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00When the decision was announced, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah read it first and gave the first two points.
00:30The decision of the Leonard Fullbench of the High Court is set aside to the extent it is or may be inconsistent with this order or the detailed reasons.
00:38Number two, the order of the Election Commission of Pakistan dated 1st of March 2024 is declared to be ultra-wise the Constitution without lawful authority and of no legal effect.
00:52Mr. Nagvi, the decision of the Peshawar High Court, the decision of the Election Commission, both of them said that it is ultra-wise, against the law and the constitution.
01:04They are set aside. We will talk about the seats in detail later. All of this will be settled in a Pakistani manner.
01:11You have been saying from the beginning that these seats are made by the PTI.
01:21Did you have any difficulty in understanding the decision?
01:24Because the government is in a lot of trouble. They are saying that they are not able to understand where this decision came from.
01:32I understood it very easily and very quickly.
01:37Earlier, these seats were with the coalition of the Election Commission and the ruling party.
01:44Now, these seats are with the opposition party, with the coalition of the Supreme Court.
01:50Neither the Election Commission could give any clarification on this as per the law.
01:54They said that Aiwan cannot remain empty. Therefore, it is necessary to complete it.
01:58I did not see any clarification in the decision of the Supreme Court that it should be given to a party which was not contesting this case and which was not present in the assembly.
02:08Anyway, the decision has come. This happens. We have seen many such decisions in Pakistan.
02:14I am not saying that the decision is wrong. I am not saying that the decision is right.
02:18I want to say something else.
02:19I want to say that the nation has to move forward, institutions have to move forward, political parties have to move forward.
02:25How long will we remain stuck in these decisions?
02:28We have suffered a lot. We have gone very far.
02:31I will request the Supreme Court, I will request all the institutions, I will request the political parties, I will request all the activists to move back a little for God's sake and try to make this country.
02:44This country has come to such an extent that nothing is being achieved.
02:51A new Ramlila comes to light on a daily basis and the whole nation is behind it.
02:56Yes, yes, you are right. But obviously, this is a very big decision of the politicians of Pakistan.
03:03I said that I will make a decision.
03:05The current parliamentary system, the way the state will run, will be discussed.
03:13Viewers, when the decision was made today, the chairman of Pakistan Justice, the election commission has not yet accepted him.
03:20Ambassador Gohar was present there.
03:22So, when he heard the decision, he thanked him, he was surprised.
03:27Let me show you his reaction.
03:29Majority order. For detailed reasons to be recorded later and subject to what is set out therein by way of amplification or explanation or otherwise, these appeals are decided in the following terms.
03:42Number one, the immune judgment dated 25th of March 24 of the learned full bench of the High Court is set aside to the extent it is or may be inconsistent with this order or the detailed reasons.
03:56Hassan Ayoub, I have a special question for you.
04:00I have a big request from the whole of Pakistan.
04:02From the whole of Pakistan?
04:03From the whole of Pakistan.
04:04You are a celebrity. You know that social media is a celebrity.
04:11Because of you, there is peace and tranquility in Pakistan.
04:14Alhamdulillah.
04:15Alhamdulillah.
04:17But the question is, is Noreen Fatima happy today?
04:21Is she satisfied?
04:22Did you ask her on the phone?
04:25She is crying.
04:27Listen to the question.
04:28She is crying, she is happy.
04:30Or she is surprised, she is shocked.
04:33With regards to Pakistan, with regards to her party.
04:36She is a big success.
04:37What does she think is a failure?
04:40I feel that every time you mention Noreen Fatima, her name is Noreen Farooq.
04:47That is why I say Noreen Fatima, so that you can record it.
04:56Every time I tell you that Noreen Farooq.
05:01Okay, Noreen Farooq.
05:03What is Noreen Farooq?
05:05I did not get in touch with Noreen Farooq.
05:08But apparently she is happy.
05:10Why?
05:11Look, her party, Pakistan Party for Justice, got those seats that they did not demand.
05:18You see, there should be a reason for her happiness.
05:21There should be no reason.
05:23And the interesting thing is that the election commission misinterpreted the Supreme Court decision.
05:28This matter was also not in front of the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
05:31This decision was also not impugned.
05:33They were also given relief on that.
05:35Okay, let me tell you one more thing.
05:37The law says that when an independent candidate becomes a return candidate, that is, wins,
05:46then he gets three days to participate with any party.
05:52But the Supreme Court made it 3 to 15.
05:55This was also a very surprising thing for me.
05:57I did not understand this either.
05:58Okay, the interesting thing is that the Supreme Court of Pakistan is a legal court.
06:02The judges also have the right to decide according to the law.
06:06But the Supreme Court of Pakistan also gave a decision of 63A+.
06:10That is, by rewriting the law.
06:12Now, if you want to rewrite the law, then there is only one legitimate institution in this country.
06:19That is the Parliament, which is supreme.
06:21Now, the supremacy of the Parliament, on the one hand, if you say that it is interfering in the affairs of the court,
06:27and those six judges write their own letter,
06:30then you have to tell the Election Commission that we are going to Fana Jamaat.
06:39You made it 15 in three days.
06:41So this was the work of the Election Commission.
06:44You came into it.
06:45The other Election Commission did not declare it a parliamentary party.
06:48We have to do the whole program.
06:50We have to talk for an hour.
06:52No, no, not at all.