Dr. Zakir Naik Replying to a Christen of Nigeria that Allah is alone Allah don't have any son
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00Answer I gave now are you convinced that the first two was it doesn't say that Allah can have a son
00:04Do you agree or not?
00:06If doesn't mean if I say if you're right, I will give you a million dollar. Does it mean you're right?
00:19Don't talk when I'm talking don't talk when I'm talking you understand English
00:26You understand English
00:31I think
00:34Then why are you breaking the rules
00:37In question and session, you cannot interrupt you cannot talk in between. Do you know that because you cannot
00:45Is this a debate or is it a question answer session questions, so once you ask the question you have to keep quiet
00:53You Christian missionaries
00:56You're a Christian missionary, I mean what are you a Christian missionary
01:02Can you ask a question, okay, my name is Benson Sunday
01:09My name is Benson Sunday
01:15Okay
01:18My name is
01:23So my question
01:26The first question will come out from your lecture and I want us to just clarify that
01:31Before we're going to really can you speak a bit slowly because there's echo
01:36So can I have your name?
01:39Mention your name but speak a bit slowly because of the problem in the system too much echo is there. Yes, brother
01:45Okay, so I said my first question is from your lecture
01:52Which I want us to clarify that
01:55Other question
01:57Okay. So my question goes by like this you were saying there in your lecture. That's
02:04But doesn't have a song
02:06And it is the most derogatory
02:10Thing to it for him to have a song you actually make some other examples like I can't hear you brother
02:17Okay, you say the monitor speakers are very bad
02:21The monitor speakers are very bad. I can hear the echo, but I cannot hear from the monitor speakers
02:26The monitor speakers are atrocious
02:29It's not working. I think only for show
02:33Only for show
02:36Okay, brother, can you come in the front and this us? Can you come in the front here?
02:49Yes
02:51Sorry
03:22And I discovered
03:24from checking the Quran
03:27Quran does not
03:28Quran, maybe we'll pick it one after the other to see some of the things that Quran says and be able to see
03:38Like
03:46I can't hear the last part. What did you say Quran says Quran chapter 39?
03:51Quran chapter 39 verse 4 verse 4. What does it say? Okay
04:10I can't hear you. Okay, maybe you could read it out for me. Okay Quran chapter 39 verse 4
04:17Was for yes, so will you read it?
04:22Yes, I
04:24Wanted to read it. You'll read you say you can hear me. So maybe you should read it. Yes
04:29Okay
04:31Quran chapter 39 verse 4
04:35If Allah had wanted to take himself a son or other son, he could have choose
04:43He anyone he wanted out of those who he created
04:48Glory be to him
04:51That he have he should have a son now, that's my beginning
04:57From this Quranic verse. It is clear. That's
05:02Choose to have a son. Ah
05:06That's the question
05:08What's the question tell me
05:11You are misinterpreting the Quran. What's the question? Tell me I will tell you. Okay, so this was doesn't mean Allah can choose
05:19You ask a question I will listen what's the question
05:26What's your question
05:49101
05:51Chapter 6 verse 101. He said easy is the originator of heavens and earth
05:58How could he have a charge when he had no needs?
06:02He created all things and at perfect knowledge of everything
06:06now
06:08Quran I don't know if I should continue
06:10Should I continue?
06:15What's the question?
06:17Yes. Quran chapter 6 verse 101 is saying that if Allah choose to have a wife, who is going to be the partner?
06:27Because he doesn't have a partner.
06:29But Quran chapter 19, Surah Al-Imran, Ayah 20, 21
06:37The same thing is a question that Mary, Maryam, asks the angel who actually came from verse 17
06:47Allah shows that he came in the appearance of a man in all respects and fell in love with him and tell him that you have a son
06:57And he said, how can I have a son without knowing anybody?
07:01I got your question.
07:03So, she was able to have a son without an husband.
07:09So, in Quran chapter 6 verse 101, that is also possible by Allah.
07:14Because Allah said, whatever he likes to say.
07:16I got your question.
07:18So, to continue with that.
07:20So, your first verse was which?
07:22The first Quranic verse was which?
07:24Sir?
07:25The first Quranic verse.
07:26Yes, I'm not finished with the first one.
07:27No, no. What was the reference?
07:29Reference? Quran chapter, the first one.
07:32Quran chapter 39, verse 4.
07:35Okay, fine. I got it.
07:36The brother has quoted two verses.
07:38Surah, he has quoted Surah Az-Zumar, chapter 39, verse number 4.
07:43And Surah An-Nam, chapter 6, verse number 101.
07:46And Surah Az-Zumar, chapter 39, verse number 4 says,
07:49If Allah had intended to take a son, he could have chosen from what he creates, whatever he willed.
07:56Exhausted is he, he is Allah the one and prevailing.
08:00Now, the brother is asking a question.
08:02This means, if Allah wants, he can take a son.
08:06And similar, in Surah An-Nam, chapter 6, verse 101.
08:10So, brother is saying that Allah can take a son if he wishes.
08:13That's the question.
08:14Okay.
08:15But the verse is very clear.
08:16If!
08:17Yes.
08:18But he does not.
08:19It is not befitting for Allah to have a son.
08:22Complete the full verse.
08:23If you read this context, it says in the first verse,
08:28Unquestionably for Allah is the pure religion.
08:31And those who take protectors say,
08:33We only worship them who may bring us nearer to Allah.
08:37Allah will judge between concerning them.
08:39Indeed, Allah does not guide who is a liar and a disbeliever.
08:43Read in context.
08:44Don't read out of context.
08:46So, Allah is saying, these people are liars and disbelievers.
08:49Then Allah says, if Allah had intended, that means Allah does not intend to take a son.
08:55It's a telling.
08:58So, read the context.
09:00It says, unquestionably for Allah is the pure religion.
09:04Allah does not guide who is a liar and a disbeliever.
09:09Then the next verse starts.
09:11So, don't quote out of context.
09:13Correct?
09:14If you quote in context, you come to know,
09:16Allah is telling all those people who say Allah has a son, etc.
09:20They are liars.
09:22And then Allah says, if Allah had intended to take a son,
09:26He could have chosen from what He creates, whatever He wills.
09:30Exalted is He.
09:31That means He is far above having a son.
09:35So, this...
09:36Let me complete.
09:38You asked the question.
09:39Now listen to my answer.
09:40Don't interrupt.
09:42Understand?
09:44You don't understand the Quran.
09:46Here Allah is saying, they are liars.
09:49What you are doing, you are taking a verse from the Quran out of context.
09:54And trying to misguide.
09:56In context it says, that this is all nonsense.
10:00These people are liars.
10:01And even the next verse.
10:03So, from here we come to know,
10:05If Allah wanted, He could have done.
10:07Allah is far superior than this.
10:09Then coming to our next verse.
10:11Of Surah An-Nam.
10:12Chapter no. 6.
10:15Verse no. 101.
10:21Verse no. 101.
10:25It says,
10:26He is the originator of the heavens and the earth.
10:29How could He have a son when He does not have a companion?
10:33The Quran says,
10:34How can Allah have a son when He doesn't have a wife?
10:39Allah is giving the answer.
10:41How can Allah have a son when He doesn't have a companion?
10:45And He has created all things.
10:47When He has created all things,
10:49He doesn't require a companion.
10:51We were created.
10:53He is uncreated.
10:55So Allah is saying,
10:56How will Allah have a son when He does not have a companion?
11:00He created everything.
11:01So this verse is very explicit.
11:03Allah cannot have a son.
11:05There is another verse in the Quran which says,
11:07If Allah had a son, I would be the first person to bow.
11:11Quran says,
11:12If anyone says Allah has a son,
11:14Tell them I will be the first person to worship Him.
11:17That doesn't mean Allah has a son.
11:19There is a verse in the Quran that if Allah had a son,
11:21Tell them I would be the first person to worship Him.
11:25That means Allah cannot beget a son.
11:29The whole Quran should be read together.
11:31You can't take out of context.
11:33Quran is very clear cut in Surah Ikhlas.
11:35Chapter no. 112.
11:39Verse no. 1 to 4 which says,
11:44Say He is Allah one and only.
11:45Allah is the Eternal and Absolute.
11:50He begets not, nor is He begotten.
11:54There is nothing like Him.
11:55So this is the definition of Allah.
11:57First you have to know the definition of Allah.
11:59And then try and read the other verses of the Quran.
12:01You can't read out of context and try and misguide the people.
12:05Allah is telling in this verse,
12:07There are people who are liars who will say this.
12:10So, let me finish.
12:13You asked the question, you have to listen to my answer.
12:15This is not a debate session.
12:19I have not finished the answer.
12:21I have not finished the answer.
12:25I have not finished the answer.
12:28Do you understand English?
12:33You can hear me, I cannot hear you because the speakers are there.
12:37Correct?
12:38So let me finish the answer.
12:39So the definition of Allah is in Surah Ikhlas,
12:43Chapter no. 112, verse no. 1 to 4 which says,
12:47Say He is Allah one and only.
12:48You cannot get me off the hook.
12:49Okay, this verse of the Quran says that Allah is two.
12:53Then there will be a contradiction.
12:55And there is no contradiction in the Quran.
12:57Allah says in Surah Nisa chapter 4 verse 82,
13:01Do they not consider the Quran with care?
13:08Had it been from anyone besides Allah, there would have been contradictions.
13:11So number one, there is no contradiction in the Quran.
13:14So you assuming that Allah can is nonsense.
13:18It says, if Allah wanted.
13:21If Allah doesn't have a companion, how can he have a son?
13:27That does not mean that he has a son.
13:28Now coming to a question of Surah Maryam.
13:31In Surah Maryam chapter no. 19,
13:33When Archangel Gabriel comes and asks Mother Mary,
13:37Mary, Mary, Salam, you shall have a son.
13:39She replies, how shall I have a son when no man has touched me?
13:44How shall I have a son when no man has touched me?
13:47The reply given by Archangel Gabriel is,
13:54If Allah decrees a matter, He just says be and it is.
13:58So when she says, normally yes.
14:01For having a son, you have to procreate.
14:07For having a son, you have to procreate.
14:10But the reply given by the Archangel Gabriel is,
14:13If Allah decrees.
14:16If Allah wills.
14:18But Allah does not will.
14:21Allah can create Adam A.S. without father and mother.
14:24He created Eve with a man without a female.
14:28He created Isa A.S. with a mother without a father.
14:35If Allah decrees a matter, He wills.
14:37But Allah will not decree ungodly things like becoming a human being.
14:41Like having a son.
14:42That's for human beings.
14:45Allah cannot go against His definition.
14:47You understand?
14:48If Allah decrees a matter, yes.
14:51But did Allah say that? No.
14:52Allah says,
14:55He begets not, nor is He begotten.
14:57So this is the definition of Allah.
14:59The moment He begets, He ceases to be God.
15:02The moment Allah has a son, He will cease to be God.
15:06Do you understand?
15:09If the definition of God in the Quran is,
15:12Allah does not beget.
15:14He begets not, nor is He begotten.
15:17The moment you say Allah begot a son, He ceases to be God.
15:22Do you understand?
15:24Do you understand this, bud?
15:26If Allah begets a son, He ceases to be God.
15:29Do you understand this?
15:37If He intended.
15:39It's a question.
15:40For example, it is a sarcastic question.
15:43For example, it's a rhetoric.
15:46If Allah had a son, I would be the first to bow.
15:49That doesn't mean Allah has.
15:50That's a rhetoric.
15:53If you are correct, I will give you a million dollars.
15:55But you are not correct.
15:57So if doesn't mean it is correct.
15:59Do you understand?
16:00So these are rhetoric questions.
16:02If Allah had a son, I would be the first to worship Him.
16:05Allah doesn't have a son.
16:06So you don't understand English correctly.
16:09Because you don't understand English correctly,
16:11you are trying to say something and quoting out of context.
16:14First of all, you quote a verse out of context.
16:17If you quote a verse out of context,
16:19it will misguide the people.
16:20It will misguide the people.
16:21I got the correct context.
16:22Do you understand?
16:24Do you understand that you quoted out of context?
16:25Yes or no?
16:27If you want me to quote it from the beginning,
16:29I can quote it.
16:30It doesn't matter.
16:32If you want me to quote it from the beginning,
16:36like from earlier,
16:37You have to.
16:38You have to.
16:39We can.
16:40We did not.
16:41Okay, that's not a problem.
16:42You did a mistake.
16:43Okay.
16:44You did a mistake.
16:45Yes.
16:46You have to apologize.
16:48Okay.
16:49You know Quran says,
16:50Jesus is God.
16:52Do you know that?
16:53Quran says,
16:54Jesus is God.
16:55Okay.
16:56Do you know that?
16:58Out of context.
17:01Okay.
17:03Wait, wait, wait.
17:04Quran says in Surah Maida,
17:06Chapter 5, Verse 17.
17:07Full context.
17:14They are doing kufr.
17:15Those who say,
17:17Jesus is God.
17:19Yes, I agree.
17:20Jesus is God is there in the Quran,
17:22but out of context.
17:24The context is,
17:25they are blaspheming.
17:27They are blaspheming,
17:28those who say Jesus is God.
17:30They are blaspheming.
17:32Blasphemy, not blasphemy.
17:34What is blasphemy?
17:40So if you say,
17:41if you quote out of context,
17:43it is devilish.
17:45If you did it purposely,
17:46it is devilish.
17:47Okay.
17:48So you have to always quote in context.
17:49You can't just quote out.
17:51Now your question is over.
17:54I already answered your question.
17:57Don't say no.
17:58You gave three references of the Quran.
18:01You gave three references of the Quran.
18:03Surah Zumur, Chapter 39, Verse 4.
18:06Surah Anam, Chapter 6, Verse 101.
18:10And Surah Maryam, Chapter 19.
18:12I answered all those three.
18:13I have not finished on that.
18:14I was still quoting when you decided to answer.
18:16You cannot.
18:17This is not a debating session.
18:18If you want to debate,
18:19you hire a hall.
18:20I will send my student to debate you.
18:21No debate.
18:22It is a question and answer session.
18:25This is a question and answer session.
18:28You have to go beyond the queue.
18:30That concludes the question.
18:31Quran, Chapter 21, Verse 91.
18:33Which one?
18:34Quran, Chapter 21, Verse 91.
18:3821, 91?
18:39Yes.
18:40And my question,
18:41to conclude that memorandum question.
18:43Okay, this is the last.
18:45This is the last reference you are giving.
18:4621, 91.
18:47Okay, what does it say?
18:53Do you agree that you made a mistake in the first two verses?
18:55Say yes.
18:58The answer I gave.
18:59Now, are you convinced that the first two verses
19:01doesn't say that Allah can have a son?
19:03Do you agree or not?
19:04He said, if he wants to have a son.
19:05If, does it mean?
19:06If I say, if you are right,
19:07I will give you a million dollars.
19:09Does it mean you are right?
19:10That means, it's not you to decide.
19:12It's not me to decide.
19:13It's Allah to decide.
19:14It's Allah.
19:16Wait, wait, wait.
19:17Not anybody.
19:18Don't talk when I'm talking.
19:20Don't talk when I'm talking.
19:22Do you understand English?
19:23Why not, sir?
19:24Do you understand English?
19:26Okay.
19:27Why not?
19:28I'm speaking English.
19:29I think you can't understand English.
19:31I understand.
19:33Then why are you breaking the rules?
19:35In question and answer session,
19:36you cannot interrupt.
19:38You cannot talk in between.
19:39Do you know that?
19:40You cannot.
19:41Again, you are talking.
19:44Is this a debate
19:45or is it a question and answer session?
19:46It's a question and answer.
19:47So, once you ask a question,
19:48you have to keep quiet.
19:49Okay.
19:51Thank you.
19:52You Christian missionaries,
19:55you are a Christian missionary?
19:56I'm a what?
19:57Are you a Christian missionary?
19:59I'm a Christian.
20:00I'm a Christian.
20:01Ah.
20:02I'm a Christian.
20:03Are you a Christian missionary?
20:04I'm a Christian.
20:05Are you a missionary?
20:06I'm a Christian.
20:07Are you a father or a pastor?
20:09Say that again.
20:10Are you a father or a pastor or a...
20:12I'm a Christian.
20:14Oh, you're afraid to tell your identity.
20:15Okay.
20:16You told 21,
20:1821, 91.
20:19Yes.
20:20I've only put the verse.
20:21I've not said my question in it.
20:23So, if you permit me to say my question
20:25so that you can explain it.
20:29Quran chapter 21, verse 91.
20:31So, my question there
20:32is it,
20:33and it's in that build up
20:34of that other question,
20:35is that
20:36from that verse,
20:37Allah said,
20:38he's the one who sent
20:39his angel Jibreel
20:41to go and
20:42breathe
20:43his spirit
20:44into the
20:46private part
20:47of Mary.
20:49Now,
20:50I,
20:51looking at it,
20:53even humanly speaking,
20:54that
20:55if I do anything
20:57to the private part
20:58of a woman,
21:00anything that comes out of it,
21:02I am responsible for it.
21:04Now, if it is Allah,
21:06the sent his angel
21:07to take his spirit
21:09and breathe it into
21:11the Mary,
21:12then Allah is responsible
21:14for that child.
21:16And that child
21:17is
21:19son of Allah.
21:20Likewise,
21:21if I did that to a woman,
21:22he's my son.
21:24Okay.
21:25Did you understand
21:26my first two answers,
21:27yes or no?
21:28Yes, yes.
21:29I will give this answer.
21:30Thank you.
21:31So, first two answers,
21:32you understood?
21:33I understood.
21:35I understand.
21:36You understand, very good.
21:37So, first two answers
21:38is agree
21:39that Allah.
21:40Now, I'm coming to the last.
21:41Now, you don't reply back,
21:42please.
21:43This is a question and answer session.
21:45He did not tell the verse,
21:46the verse of the Quran
21:48of
21:49Surah Anbiya,
21:50chapter 21,
21:51verse number 91 says,
21:52and mentioned
21:53the one who guarded
21:54her chastity.
21:55So, we blew into
21:56a garment
21:57through our angel,
21:58Gabriel,
21:59and we made her
22:00and her son
22:01a sign for the world.
22:04He is saying that
22:05Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala
22:07has blown
22:08his spirit
22:09into Isa a.s.
22:10Correct?
22:11Yes, sir.
22:12I agree with it.
22:13Do you know
22:14Allah says in the Quran
22:15in Surah Hijar,
22:16chapter 15,
22:17verse 29,
22:18Allah blew the spirit
22:19into every human being.
22:21Quran says.
22:24Does it mean I'm God?
22:26Does it mean you're God?
22:27You don't understand
22:28the Quran.
22:29Allah says in
22:30Surah Hijar,
22:31chapter 15,
22:32verse 29,
22:33Allah has blown the spirit
22:34into every human being.
22:36Allah says in Surah Sajda,
22:37chapter 32,
22:38verse number 9,
22:39Here,
22:40blowing spirit means
22:42Allah has put
22:43his knowledge
22:44into every human being
22:45including Isa a.s.
22:47Now, the problem is
22:48you read one verse,
22:49you don't read
22:50the full Quran.
22:51Have you read
22:52the full Quran?
22:53Have you read
22:54the full Quran?
22:56Have you read
22:57the full Quran
22:58cover to cover?
22:59Have you read
23:00the full Quran?
23:03As much as I can.
23:04He could read
23:05only five verses.
23:06No.
23:07Or ten verses.
23:08No.
23:09As much as I can
23:10means what?
23:11You're afraid to tell
23:12that,
23:13sorry,
23:14I have not read
23:15the complete Quran.
23:16This is trying to
23:17beat around the bush.
23:18Now, please don't answer.
23:19Your question is over.
23:20I've already answered
23:21your question.
23:22I've already answered
23:23your question.
23:24Now, don't talk.
23:25I'm completing the answer.
23:26This brother came
23:27to deceive the people.
23:29As much as I can.
23:31He's afraid to say
23:32I read 100 verses
23:33or 200 verses
23:34or 1,000 verses.
23:35As much as I can.
23:36These are the ways
23:37the Christian mysteries,
23:39they try and attack.
23:41Good example of
23:42brothers given here.
23:43How I give in my talk,
23:44they come and
23:45knock at the doors.
23:46Now, normal Muslim
23:47would have got scared.
23:48Quoting what's out of
23:49the context.
23:50This is a very good
23:51example you have
23:52in Nigeria.
23:53This brother
23:54is coming here
23:55trying to deceive
23:56the Muslim audience.
23:58Trying to deceive
23:59the Muslim audience.
24:00The first two agreed.
24:01Do you agree that
24:02the Quran says
24:03Allah has born the spirit
24:04in every human being.
24:05So every human being
24:06is God.
24:07According to you.
24:08He breathed the spirit
24:09to Mary in a private bath.
24:11To all human beings
24:12he just breathed.
24:13That is what the Quran says.
24:14Quran chapter 21
24:15verse 91.
24:16Everybody can read it.
24:18Quran chapter 21 verse 91.
24:19Go and sit down.
24:20Don't waste your time.
24:21Go and sit down.
24:22Go and waste your time.
24:23You don't want to
24:24give the answer.
24:25You're afraid.
24:26You're afraid to say
24:27that I did not read the Quran
24:28as much as I can.
24:30You are trying
24:31to go on the internet
24:32pick up verses of the Quran
24:34out of context
24:35and trying to deceive
24:36the people.
24:39When you want to read the Quran
24:40read the complete Quran.
24:43Read the complete Quran
24:44and then say
24:45that the reason
24:46they pick up verses
24:47they are being trained.
24:49They are being trained
24:50by missionaries
24:51how to ask questions
24:52out of context.