Azad Arakeen kisi jamat main Na gaye tou Seats kis kay Hissay main ayengi ?? Expert Analysis
#supremecourt #reservedseatscase #ECP #CJP #SIC #qazifaezisa #khawarghumman #haidernaqvi #chaudharyghulamHussain #hassanayub
Azad Arakeen kisi jamat main Na gaye tou Seats kis kay Hissay main ayengi ?? Expert Analysis
Azad Arakeen kisi jamat main Na gaye tou Seats kis kay Hissay main ayengi ?? Expert Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Ladies and gentlemen, the most important question is that if these people remain free,
00:06there is a legal argument in the Supreme Court,
00:09then where will the remaining seats go?
00:12In whose share will they come?
00:14Justice Mansoor Ali Shah, Senior Penal Judge,
00:16will also become our Chief Justice next year in October.
00:20When he asked this question, listen to the answer of Faisal Siddiqui.
00:24If you are not a political party, where will the reserve seats go,
00:29which are left outside the proportional representation?
00:32If they remain free, where will they go?
00:35They will go, then your Lordship will see who are these independents.
00:42Now the problem is, who are these independents?
00:46Obviously, they had gathered their affidavits, who had fought the election.
00:50Justice Muneeb Akhtar commented on this,
00:53how can this procedural issue be addressed?
00:57Then it seems to me that maybe we are focusing too much on issues of form and procedure.
01:05Maybe those seats can be, if I may now use the analogy,
01:10traced into wherever those PTI candidates, return candidates are going.
01:17And if they are ending up behind you for reasons of whatever,
01:23then maybe they can go to you.
01:26As a matter of form, as a matter of substance,
01:29once we have identified that here is a political party,
01:33entitled to those seats, where is that political party?
01:37Is it before us? Is it not before us?
01:39Well, of course, these are issues of procedure.
01:42But can procedure trump the constitution?
01:45Or are we allowed to trace those members?
01:49And it is not too difficult to trace,
01:51because everyone says that they are now standing behind Kurni Tehat Council.
01:57But there you have it.
01:59Fundamentally, Justice Muneeb Akhtar is saying that all these PTI supporters,
02:06initially they had gathered their affidavits,
02:09their nomination papers, that we are the people of justice in Pakistan.
02:13But of course, later they did not get the party symbol,
02:16then they declared independence on behalf of the Election Commission.
02:18So they are saying that if we go back to the original,
02:22then the solution will come.
02:24Justice Jamal Mando Khel has also commented on this occasion.
02:29Suppose, the petition of Salman Akhbar Raja is allowed,
02:32and it is declared that these were candidates of PTI,
02:36they were not free, and if they go back home,
02:39then where will you stand?
02:40Sir, I don't think the Sunni Tehat will have any problems.
02:43There you are conflicted. You are conflicted.
02:46You have washed all your arguments.
03:10Yes, yes.
03:12No, no.
03:31Justice Manohar Rao has also said that the interpretation of the Election Commission was completely wrong.
03:36Okay, let's come to the next question.
03:37Mr. Nagvi, the question here is that...
03:39Sir, the Election Commission is not responsible.
03:41Okay, the question here is that...
03:43No, the Election Commission is not responsible.
03:45Okay, the question here is that...
03:46PTI is responsible for this.
03:47Mr. Nagvi, your decision has come.
03:49Let me go ahead, Mr. Hassan Yuta.
03:51No, Mr. Chaudhary is in the middle.
03:52Mr. Chaudhary is talking, so you have no objection.
03:54If I talk in the middle, you will have an objection.
03:56What happened, Mr. Hassan Yuta?
03:57No, no, you can talk as much as you want.
03:59Okay, please go ahead.
04:01No, I am saying that when you make a mistake...
04:05Yes, I made a mistake.
04:06...you have to pay for it.
04:07Yes, I paid for it.
04:08Yes, so now it won't work.
04:10Okay, it's done.
04:11What about the country?
04:12You do it again.
04:13The country will work, God willing.
04:14Okay, Mr. Chaudhary, I will come to you.
04:16What's going on?
04:17I will come to you, Mr. Nagvi.
04:18What's going on in the country?
04:19Okay, Mr. Chaudhary, one minute.
04:21Mr. Nagvi, look, there is an issue.
04:23If you do this, you will say that you gave a good example that there is cancer.
04:27Now, its symptoms have also come in front of you.
04:30And cancer is a very serious...
04:31This is a joke between you and Mr. Nagvi.
04:33Okay, seriously.
04:34Mr. Chaudhary, there is a problem.
04:36Pakistan is in a political dilemma right now.
04:38There is a problem.
04:39The reason for that is very good.
04:40I was saying that we have...
04:41Okay, now Mr. Nagvi, there is a problem.
04:44There is a disease.
04:45Now, do you have to perform a surgery on that patient?
04:50Or do you have to do his chemotherapy?
04:54Or then, outside America or in the West, it is the same thing that the patient reaches such a place.
04:59He says, just relax, man.
05:01His law allows him to do the treatment.
05:03Then the next life...
05:05May Allah bless you.
05:07They are trying to solve it.
05:09Our judges are sitting to solve it.
05:11So, what do you think?
05:12What do you think is that a political party...
05:14Let's assume your argument for a while.
05:16Let's assume that there was a big mistake.
05:18They did not get their intraparty election done.
05:20If you have done any research on intraparty election, then definitely share it with us.
05:24Our party, intraparty election, let everyone know.
05:27Anyway, this matter is done.
05:28Now, what is the solution?
05:29Tell us the solution.
05:30We know about the disease.
05:31Everyone knows about the disease.
05:32Now, listen to my answer.
05:35Okay?
05:36Look, all this political, judicial...
05:39All this mess that is going on...
05:41And the mental debauchery that is happening on a daily basis...
05:45There is only a small solution to end it.
05:50Today, the decision of Islamabad High Court was made.
05:53PTI is very happy with it.
05:55The decision of appointing retired judges or making tribunals was approved.
06:02PTI is very happy with it.
06:04We are also happy.
06:05PTI will have to put a review.
06:07In fact, all political parties will have to put a review.
06:09That the decisions that come from the courts...
06:12They should accept it.
06:15They should accept it.
06:16Not that after the court's decision, you start a campaign against the judges.
06:21You start insulting them.
06:23You start giving them all kinds of nicknames.
06:26Today, when you can celebrate the decision of Islamabad High Court...
06:30After that, whatever decision these courts are giving...
06:33For God's sake, accept it too.
06:35Don't be so cruel to this nation.
06:37This is a small solution.
06:39The day you make a promise to yourself...
06:41That we will accept the decisions of the courts...
06:43No matter who has the final say...
06:45No matter who has the final say...
06:47Everything will be fine in this country.
06:49Everything will be fine.