• 3 months ago
#electionact #reservedseatscase #electioncommission #supremecourt #pti #sunniittehadcouncil #nationalassembly #pmlngovt #khawarghumman #hassanayub #chaudhryghulamhussain #haidernaqvi

"Election Act Main Jo Govt Amendment Kar Chuki Hai Wohi Prevail Rahegi" Hassan Ayub's Analysis
Transcript
00:00Ladies and gentlemen, there are thousands of such wishes that every wish comes true.
00:05Yesterday, you saw that a wish was expressed by some leaders of Pakistan Muslim League Moon.
00:12They went to the Election Commission and said, these seats are ours, give us the seats.
00:16Immediately after that, we saw that a letter was written to the Election Commission by the Speaker of the National Assembly
00:23that the Supreme Court's decision is no longer feasible because we have already made a law on it.
00:31Parliament, National Assembly, Senate, President of Pakistan.
00:34Yesterday, Hassan Ayub made a correction, so we repeat it again.
00:37Now it is that today, one more step has gone further, the Speaker of the National Assembly.
00:43He has issued a new list, the law that has been passed by the Parliament.
00:49Keeping in mind the amendment to the Election Act 2017, he said that the allocation of those 23 controversial seats is now directly attached with the Election Commission notification.
01:06The Election Commission should notify that these are the controversial seats that were given to the PTI after the Supreme Court's decision.
01:13Since the Supreme Court's decision is no longer feasible, the letter was very clearly explained in it by the Speaker of the National Assembly.
01:21Therefore, the new list that the viewers are putting in front of you today, the art of Pakistani justice has been completely eliminated.
01:29There is no mention of Pakistani justice.
01:31The Sunni Tahaat Council has been brought back into this list.
01:3780 seats have been given to them.
01:44The remaining seats are in front of you, 110 PML and 69.
01:4869 seats have been given to the Pakistan People's Party.
01:53MQM has 22 seats, PML has 5 seats, Kaaf League has 4 seats, IPP has 4 seats.
02:02These 23 controversial seats are those seats that the Supreme Court said in its decision.
02:10We have checked the affidavits of 39 PMLs of Pakistan Justice.
02:16They already have a relationship with the PTI at the time of election.
02:19We have checked the affidavits of 41 PMLs of Pakistan Justice.
02:25We have checked the affidavits of 41 PMLs of Pakistan Justice.
02:30We have checked the affidavits of 41 PMLs of Pakistan Justice.
02:35We have checked the affidavits of 41 PMLs of Pakistan Justice.
02:40We have checked the affidavits of 41 PMLs of Pakistan Justice.
02:44Our Chief Election Commissioner, Sikandar Sultan Raja has held a meeting.
02:50I think it is the fourth or fifth day. He holds a meeting every day.
02:54He decides every day that we need more legal and legal advice on this.
03:02We will decide after that.
03:04Kamal Dilshad has given a very good advice to the Speaker of the National Assembly.
03:08What should he have done?
03:11I think he has sent the letter to a wrong address.
03:14He should have sent the letter to some other address.
03:17The Speaker of the National Assembly should have sent a reference to the Supreme Court of Pakistan
03:21instead of writing a letter to the Election Commission.
03:24Your decision has come under the scope of the Election Act.
03:28You have reached the conclusion that you are not eligible.
03:31The Supreme Court's decision on 12th July is very important.
03:35The Election Commission of Pakistan will not decide on its own.
03:38It will be decided by the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
03:41Hassan, let me come to you first.
03:44On one hand, the Supreme Court's decision.
03:47On the other hand, the Speaker of the National Assembly has made his own determination.
03:52He has passed his own law in the Parliament.
03:57Thirdly, the Election Commission of Pakistan is obviously a direct stakeholder.
04:04The Election Commission of Pakistan is silent right now.
04:06The decision of the Supreme Court, the Election Commission and the Speaker of the National Assembly
04:12has become a tricker.
04:15What do you think is the solution to this story?
04:18The Election Commission of Pakistan is not even notifying the Supreme Court.
04:22They can either say that they do not accept the Supreme Court's decision
04:26and that they accept the decision of the National Assembly and are notifying it.
04:31Now, they are silent.
04:33What do you think, where will this matter go?
04:37Will all the parties have to take their arguments in front of the Supreme Court?
04:42Or is it expected from the Election Commission
04:45that the letter written by the Speaker of the National Assembly
04:50should be accepted and notified?
04:53There are 23 seats in which 15 are PMLN, 5 are PPP and 3 are JOIF.
04:58Hassan.
05:00The problem is that the Election Commission has to act in accordance with the law.
05:05The Supreme Court of Pakistan has to act in accordance with the law.
05:09The Speaker of the National Assembly has to act in accordance with the law.
05:17So, all three institutions have to act in accordance with the law.
05:23The position of the Speaker, the position of the Chief Election Commissioner
05:27and the Supreme Court of Pakistan have to act in accordance with the law.
05:31So, the Supreme Court's judgment has become ineffective.
05:37The law has to prevail.
05:40And when it has been implemented in the past,
05:45there is no doubt that the Election Commission has to act in accordance with the law.
05:51So, I can see that in the end of the day,
05:56the government's amendment to the Election Act will prevail.
06:03Hassan is consistent with his view that the amendment to the Election Act will prevail.

Recommended