KHABAR Meher Bokhari Kay Saath | ARY News | 21st May 2024
#WheatScandal #ciphercase #islamabadhighcourt #imrankhan #pmshehbazsharif #anwarulhaqkakar
۔Khabar - PM gives ‘clean chit’ to Caretaker Govt in wheat scandal - Meher Bukhari's Report
۔Wheat Import Scandal - Opposition Leader Punjab Assembly Raises Important Questions
۔PTI Chief Gets Big Relief in Tyrian White Case - Important Developments in Cipher Case - Report
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
Official Facebook: https://www.fb.com/arynewsasia
Official Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/arynewsofficial
Official Instagram: https://instagram.com/arynewstv
Website: https://arynews.tv
Watch ARY NEWS LIVE: http://live.arynews.tv
Listen Live: http://live.arynews.tv/audio
Listen Top of the hour Headlines, Bulletins & Programs: https://soundcloud.com/arynewsofficial
#ARYNews
ARY News Official YouTube Channel.
For more videos, subscribe to our channel and for suggestions please use the comment section.
۔Khabar - PM gives ‘clean chit’ to Caretaker Govt in wheat scandal - Meher Bukhari's Report
۔Wheat Import Scandal - Opposition Leader Punjab Assembly Raises Important Questions
۔PTI Chief Gets Big Relief in Tyrian White Case - Important Developments in Cipher Case - Report
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
Official Facebook: https://www.fb.com/arynewsasia
Official Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/arynewsofficial
Official Instagram: https://instagram.com/arynewstv
Website: https://arynews.tv
Watch ARY NEWS LIVE: http://live.arynews.tv
Listen Live: http://live.arynews.tv/audio
Listen Top of the hour Headlines, Bulletins & Programs: https://soundcloud.com/arynewsofficial
#ARYNews
ARY News Official YouTube Channel.
For more videos, subscribe to our channel and for suggestions please use the comment section.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Assalam-o-Alaikum and good evening, I am Meher Bukhari.
00:03In the mega scandal of 300 billion rupees to provide wheat to the Nigraan government,
00:07the Nigraan government has got a clean chit.
00:09The inquiry committee has put all the responsibility on the officers
00:12and the Prime Minister has also appointed four officers and approved the inquiries of the inquiry committee.
00:18In the big scandal of 300 billion rupees, the former Secretary of National Food Security,
00:25Mohamad Asif has been given the approval to carry out the inquiry.
00:30Former DG Plant Production AD Abid, Food Security Commissioner 1 Dr. Wasim,
00:35Dr. Food Security Sohail and Director Food Security Punjab Imtiaz Gopang have also been given the approval to carry out the inquiry.
00:42After the wheat scandal, the Prime Minister has appointed four committees
00:46under the leadership of Secretary Kabina Division Kamran Afzal for the inquiry.
00:50This committee was given only four days to determine the responsibilities.
00:54This committee had to find out who gave the permission to import the wheat.
00:58How much quantity of wheat has to be imported?
01:00Whose responsibility was it?
01:01Who gave the permission to buy cheap wheat and sell it at high prices?
01:05The inquiry committee had to find out why the regulatory duty was not imposed on the imported wheat
01:10and who is responsible for it?
01:12And the committee had to determine that despite importing more wheat than required,
01:17why the Nigraan government did not inform the new government in search of these questions.
01:21The inquiry committee took 16 days instead of four.
01:24On May 5, the Prime Minister was called for a meeting on the issue of wheat in Model Town, Lahore.
01:28The Secretary of Kabina Division Kamran Afzal was instructed to submit a final report
01:34by arranging the inquiries while giving the complete clarification of the wheat scandal.
01:38And he had issued an order that the names of the responsible people should be brought forward without any fuss.
01:43But the inquiry committee did not allow the Nigraan government to ask for any responsible person.
01:49On May 4, it was revealed that the inquiry committee had asked for the former Nigraan Prime Minister, Inwar-ul-Haq Qaqar.
01:54But the head of the inquiry committee himself denied this news.
01:58On May 6, it was revealed that the committee had completed 90% of the work.
02:03And this report will be presented to the Prime Minister on May 7.
02:06But then this report was so long that it took 16 days to reach the Prime Minister.
02:10This scandal of wheat was revealed when the new crop of wheat was cut and ready.
02:15So the government was not ready to take wheat from the farmers.
02:19It was found that more than necessary wheat is already available in the government warehouses.
02:23When the poll of wheat revenue was opened on the initial investigation, the mega scandal was revealed.
02:27It was found that from August 2023 to March 2024, 330 billion rupees of wheat has been earned in the Nigraan government.
02:34And out of this, the quality of 13 lakh metric tons of wheat was extremely poor.
02:39In 13 lakh metric tons of wheat, insects were found.
02:41According to the initial investigations, the Nigraan government allowed the private sector to export wheat in September 2023.
02:48Despite the availability of wheat, the National Food Security asked for permission to export 35 lakh tons of wheat through the private sector.
02:55But in the first phase, permission was given to export 20 lakh tons of wheat.
02:59In the second phase, permission was given to export another 10 lakh tons of wheat.
03:03In the initial report, it was said that the economic contact committee gave permission to export wheat.
03:08In this regard, it was also revealed that in October 2023, the Nigraan government took permission to export wheat through a Circulation Summary.
03:16In this regard, the Minister of Commerce at that time, Dr. Gohar Ejal, the Minister of Treasury, Shamshad Akhtar and the Secretary of Food Security, Mohammad Mehmood, came forward.
03:25All of whom have not been made part of this investigation.
03:29And because of these people's decision, 34 lakh tons of wheat was exported from Ukraine.
03:33It was also revealed that the wheat was bought for Rs. 3,100 per month and sold for Rs. 3,500 per month.
03:41That is, Rs. 1,400 per month was made a profit and Rs. 85 billion was looted.
03:47It was also revealed that 71 cargos of wheat were exported from Ukraine and Bulgaria and insects were found in 26 cargos of wheat.
03:56By April 1, more than 40 lakh tons of wheat were available in the government warehouses.
04:01In the month of March, wheat was exported from Sindh, and in April and May, a new crop was exported from Punjab in large quantities.
04:07In one acre of land, 10 to 20 mans were increased.
04:11The 3 crore tons of bumper crop was made even more serious.
04:16The warehouses were already full of wheat.
04:19And the farmers had hoped that the government would buy this wheat from them at the best prices.
04:24On April 3, the government of Punjab and on April 8, the government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa set aside Rs. 4,900 for the export of wheat.
04:31However, before this, the amount of wheat was set aside for Rs. 5,000 to Rs. 5,500.
04:36The government also buys flour mills from the government-declared warehouses.
04:40After the 18th amendment, the government sets the government rate for wheat.
04:44And the Subahi Mahakam of Khuraq and Piasco buy wheat at government prices and warehouses.
04:49Even though the government rate was low, the farmers were still happy.
04:52They had hoped that the bumper crop from the wheat production in Wafir Middar would meet their expectations.
04:58But the government started buying wheat with great difficulty.
05:01The government agreed to give the farmers only 6 sacks of wheat per acre.
05:06And even in these 6 sacks, only 15 mans of wheat could be put in.
05:10Whereas in one acre, 55 mans of wheat were produced.
05:13In this way, the farmers had to sell 40 mans of wheat on the streets.
05:18Due to the government's refusal to buy wheat, the farmers started selling wheat in the private sector.
05:24So the price of wheat also fell from Rs. 49,000 to Rs. 3,000.
05:28The hopes were fulfilled, but the farmers protested.
05:32And especially the farmers of Punjab came out.
05:35They set fire to wheat on the streets and also announced the Mulgir movement.
05:39And this movement was named Zaraat Bachao Pakistan Bachao.
05:43The farmers are protesting on the streets.
05:48They are protesting that the government has given one billion dollars to the country.
05:53And has given it to the farmers.
05:55The farmers have been given their share.
05:58But the farmers are not being given their share.
06:00If they had to eat commission after buying, they should have done this earlier.
06:03When their crop was about to come.
06:05They have destroyed the farmers.
06:08No one is going to ask them.
06:09The government has decided to raid the wheat.
06:12But the district administration is not able to buy it.
06:15In fact, the wheat that has been distributed has been bought by the mafia.
06:21The Prime Minister of Punjab, Maryam, was also left speechless on the farmers' protest.
06:27From April 22, the government and the farmers had a negotiation.
06:31But the result of this negotiation was that the Punjab government claimed the farmers' rights.
06:38As a result of the crackdown, 150 farmers were arrested.
06:42The Minister of Food and Rural Affairs of the state of Punjab admitted to this protest.
06:45But now, the Prime Minister of Punjab, Maryam Nawaz, is saying that there is no wheat protest or crisis.
06:52I have blocked the road that used to be full of corruption in buying wheat.
06:58And they say that there is a wheat protest.
07:01This is not happening. That is not happening.
07:03There is no wheat protest.
07:04There is no wheat protest.
07:08But the Punjab government also approved the farmer's card to convince the farmers.
07:12And instead of buying wheat from the farmers, it announced a loan of 150 billion rupees.
07:16And this wheat protest has been going on since April 20.
07:19The Punjab government is still not ready to buy wheat from the farmers.
07:23They are just refusing to believe it's even a crisis.
07:25However, the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government has decided to buy 300,000 metric tons of wheat from the farmers of Punjab.
07:31The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government is buying wheat from the farmers at a government rate of 39 rupees per ton.
07:36But there is also information that the Punjab government has set up check posts in important cities to prevent the smuggling of wheat.
07:46The farmers have been protesting on the streets since April 20.
07:50And despite the investigation of the mega scandal of the refunded wheat,
07:54now the Prime Minister has realized that he has to ask for a meeting on buying wheat.
07:59And in this meeting, the farmers of Punjab should not buy wheat.
08:02And they have to focus on all the issues.
08:05The sources say that the pressure of Mian Nawaz Sharif is increasing on Prime Minister Shabaz Sharif
08:09that the amount of wheat that can be bought from the farmers of Punjab through PASCO should be officially announced and bought.
08:15Viewers, questions were being asked from the government until yesterday about what they were doing.
08:19When is the report coming? But it was being reassured again and again.
08:22Take a look.
08:24Wheat has come from Ukraine to Pakistan.
08:262.4 million tons of wheat has come in the Nigran Stratum.
08:2810 lakh tons of wheat has come in the Noon League government from March 1 to April 30.
08:32Who is going to investigate it? Who made the summary?
08:35The Punjab government had set a rate of Rs. 4600 in Punjab.
08:38That wheat will not be issued at a price lower than this.
08:41Who set that?
08:42Why did the federal government allow the unlimited supply of imported wheat from Ukraine?
08:47At least tell us the name.
08:50Please expose those people who have done so much damage to the Punjabi commissioner.
09:01The government and Prime Minister Shabaz Sharif are very much concerned about this issue and are focused on it.
09:08You will see that the result will come.
09:11When we came, this whole process was going on and we stopped them.
09:17You can see that the meeting was of the Wheat Board.
09:20The minister at that time was K.Tekar.
09:23He gave the extension on March.
09:26We came and stopped them.
09:28If you look at the statement of the ex-federal minister, K.Tekar,
09:33that I had recommended that wheat should not be imported from Ukraine.
09:37That patience was approved against my recommendation.
09:41At that time, the Nigran Stratum,
09:43You can call them in the committee and ask them who approved it.
09:46It's all about K.Tekar.
09:48K.Tekar Stratum, what has happened.
09:50I am telling you to expose them.
09:53Please expose the Punjabi farmer in Pakistan.
09:56Do a little good.
09:58Food Minister Rana Tanvir was saying that the result will come and the result has come.
10:02That is, the poor farmers have been crushed.
10:06But on the other hand, the big crocodiles have been left open.
10:09No minister has been called.
10:11No minister has been called.
10:12No senior official has been made a part of this inquiry report.
10:15It was not specified in the inquiry report.
10:17Who gave the permission to import 64 lakh tons of wheat?
10:20Who was the one who brought the summary and who approved the summary?
10:23And whose pocket is filled by selling expensive wheat brought by the state to hell?
10:28In this regard, we have with us the leader of the opposition of Punjab, Malik Ahmed Khan Bachar Sahib.
10:33And Deputy Bureau Chief, ARY News, Azhar Farooq Sahib.
10:36Thank you both very much.
10:38Tell me, Malik Ahmed Sahib,
10:40that in the 300 crore rupee scandal of importing wheat during the Nigrahan government,
10:44the Nigrahan government has got a clean chit.
10:47The inquiry committee has put all the responsibilities on the officers
10:50and the Prime Minister has also appointed four officers and approved all the recommendations of the inquiry committee.
10:55It seems that the matter has been put to dust.
11:00Look, first of all, let me tell you that this is a big propaganda that they have done
11:07that this did not start in the Nigrahan government.
11:11This first summary of 10 lakh tons of wheat was made in the meeting of ECC on 13th July.
11:20And after that, their last meeting of ECC was on 8th August.
11:26In which they usually wind up things when the government is going.
11:34But they adjourned it and put it on hold.
11:38And after their meetings on 8th August,
11:41because I think that there was no difference between the Nigrahan government and them.
11:46The rest were in agreement on everything.
11:49Especially in matters of our Pakistan's justice system,
11:53they were completely one-sided.
11:55So in that, they called a meeting on 4th September.
12:01Which they called on 4th September.
12:04In that, there was a series of meetings on 13th July.
12:08And then on 20th September, they ordered 10 lakh tons of wheat.
12:13Whose notification is being made on 23rd September by the finance division.
12:21Actually, this is not the matter.
12:23Actually, this is the matter of their bad policy.
12:25See, their government was from 9th April,
12:28as I would say in the so-called Nigrahan government with Pakistan's justice system.
12:34And whatever this government did together.
12:37So why was their opinion different in the matter of wheat?
12:40That they differ from each other.
12:42And the next thing I will tell you,
12:44that this 300 Arabian Tika,
12:46these are 65 companies.
12:48And on 4th March, when this government came again,
12:53when this gap came in between.
12:55So till 31st March, they ordered 8 lakh tons of wheat.
12:59So how can you say that this is injustice?
13:02These are the same criminals.
13:04That is the old way of the noble families.
13:07That the officers of 20th grade, 19th grade, 21st grade,
13:12the secretaries, etc. were arrested.
13:14For some time, they will be missing from the scene.
13:17Again, they will come to some site.
13:19See, this is the loss of Pakistan.
13:22The loss of 1.5 billion dollars.
13:24Allow me to tell you, Azhar.
13:26Now, against the former Secretary of National Food Security,
13:30Mohammad Asif,
13:31some proceedings have been approved.
13:33Along with that,
13:34against the former DG of Plant Production,
13:36A.D. Abid,
13:37Food Security Commissioner 1,
13:39Dr. Wasim,
13:40and against him as well.
13:41And against the Director of Food Security, Sohail,
13:43and the Director of Food Security, Punjab, Imtiaz Gopal,
13:45has also been approved to be arrested.
13:47But the important characters,
13:49whose signatures were there,
13:50who led the meetings,
13:52including the Prime Minister,
13:53the caretaker, Anwarullah Kakar,
13:54who himself said in the interviews
13:56that I am ready to be presented.
13:58Why didn't you call him?
13:59Why didn't you make him a part of the investigation?
14:06First of all, let me tell you
14:08that the Secretary of National Food Security,
14:11Mohammad Asif,
14:12was charged on 25th January.
14:16Before that, he was not the Secretary.
14:17Mohammad Mehmood was the Secretary.
14:19There is no mention of him anywhere.
14:21And first, Mohammad Asif was suspended.
14:24And today, it has been approved
14:26to start an inquiry against him.
14:28Along with this,
14:29the other officials have also been held responsible.
14:32But as you have said,
14:34where are the real responsibilities?
14:37The Secretary of National Food Security,
14:40Mohammad Mehmood,
14:41who departs from here on 25th January,
14:45his real role was
14:47that he was the Secretary.
14:48He has also been given a safe path.
14:50He has been saved.
14:51Whereas, the ministers of that time,
14:53the Cabinet of Ministers,
14:54or the Prime Minister,
14:56have also been given a clean sheet.
14:58Actually, all the blame
15:00has been placed on these other small officials.
15:02And they have been made the scapegoat for the sacrifice.
15:05Anyway, these matters will continue.
15:08But did the committee call Gohar Ejaz,
15:10Shamshad Sahiba,
15:11Kakar Sahib,
15:12Mehmood Sahib,
15:13Mohammad Mehmood
15:15for an inquiry or not?
15:18No.
15:19No one was called.
15:21His name was mentioned.
15:22Maybe the committee called him.
15:23But all of them have insisted
15:25that no one has been summoned by the committee.
15:28No one has been forced by them.
15:30Nothing has been done.
15:31A committee was established on its own.
15:35A cabinet committee.
15:36And a committee was established before this as well.
15:38In light of this committee's efforts,
15:40only Mohammad Asif,
15:42the former Secretary of National Food Security,
15:44has been appointed.
15:45As I said earlier,
15:46he was appointed on January 25.
15:48And all of this happened before that.
15:50And after that,
15:51when this government came,
15:52the current government,
15:53after the 8th February election,
15:55even after that,
15:56this wheat was imported.
15:58And a large amount of wheat was imported.
16:01But there is no mention of it anywhere.
16:03Who is responsible for this ongoing process?
16:06If these officials were responsible in the Nigrahan government,
16:08then after that,
16:09when this government came,
16:10who is responsible for it?
16:13So, it seems that the real culprits have been saved.
16:17And the goat of sacrifice has been given to the other officials.
16:19Malik Ahmed Khan sahib,
16:20only 4 days were given.
16:21But this committee took more than 16 days to investigate.
16:24And then,
16:25the mountain was dug,
16:26the mouse came out.
16:27This is in front of us.
16:28As Azhar just said,
16:30even after this government came,
16:33wheat was imported.
16:35In that regard,
16:36what role has the Justice Movement played?
16:38Has it highlighted it?
16:39What are you doing?
16:42Look,
16:43I have already told you that
16:44on 4th March,
16:46the new government that they have formed,
16:48even after that,
16:498 lakh tonnes of wheat have been imported.
16:51This is the first thing.
16:52The second thing is that
16:53there are 65 companies
16:55who have benefited from this.
16:56The third thing is that,
16:58I am saying this again and again,
17:00that the first meeting of the ECC
17:02took place on 13th July.
17:04Then,
17:05Nawaz Sharif was the Prime Minister.
17:07After that,
17:08the next thing I will tell you is that
17:10on 8th August,
17:12I am repeating this again,
17:14they have made an emergency meeting.
17:16In this,
17:17the people of the government of Nawaz Sharif,
17:20the caretakers of the ECC,
17:24first of all,
17:25they have to be called.
17:26What do they call these poor secretaries?
17:28The secretaries who were telling us
17:30that on 25th January,
17:32the last shock has reached them.
17:37The thing is that,
17:38their intentions are corrupt.
17:40And let me tell you one more thing,
17:42it has never happened that
17:44you decide in September or October
17:47that you have to import wheat.
17:49Look,
17:50we had to find out about wheat now.
17:52You have 40 lakh tonnes already.
17:54You have ordered 32 lakh tonnes more.
17:57Now, the farmers are crying over there.
17:59The farmers are buying 40 kilograms of middlemen
18:03for Rs. 2,500 to Rs. 2,700.
18:06They are buying middlemen.
18:07And let me tell you one more thing,
18:09the new wave that will come,
18:10in November,
18:11they have to smuggle all their wheat.
18:14And after that,
18:15the new wave that will come,
18:16their wheat wave will start in November-December.
18:18So,
18:19since they have come with a jelly mandate,
18:21they are not worried about the people.
18:22So,
18:23they have made a bad state of Punjab.
18:25This is a criminal offence.
18:28On this,
18:29as they used to say,
18:30that I will drag Zardari on the streets.
18:32The farmers will drag them on the streets in this matter.
18:35Now, remember this time of mine.
18:37When they have committed that crime,
18:3978% of Pakistan's wheat is produced in Punjab.
18:43And with Punjab,
18:44they have made such a state that
18:45right now,
18:46the purchasing is completely shut.
18:48And whatever is happening,
18:49according to them,
18:50it is the same patwari,
18:51and AC,
18:52and wheat,
18:53whatever is happening.
18:55But right now,
18:56the poor farmer,
18:57the next wave,
18:58the cotton crop is being affected.
19:00The rice crop is being affected.
19:02They themselves are taking it towards a crisis.
19:05The TikTokers,
19:06who are the Chief Minister,
19:08they are breaking them.
19:09They are running the government of the people.
19:11But this is not done.
19:12Azad, these were the most important questions.
19:14Who gave the permission to import wheat?
19:16How much quantity do we have to import?
19:18Whose responsibility was this?
19:19Who gave the permission to buy cheap wheat and sell it at high prices?
19:22And then,
19:23the research committee had to find out about all these things.
19:26Why was the regulatory duty not given to the imported wheat?
19:29Did the answers to all these questions come forward?
19:32Yes,
19:33so far,
19:34no answer has come forward.
19:35And only that has been told,
19:36that the leaflets that have been sold to the Prime Minister,
19:39in those leaflets,
19:40it has been said,
19:41that these people should be killed.
19:43They are responsible.
19:44They are responsible.
19:45So, they have been suspended.
19:46The National Food Security Secretary,
19:49who took charge later,
19:50they have also been suspended.
19:51Now, it seems that
19:52the inquiry will start against them.
19:54Although,
19:55this is a very clear and determined matter,
19:58that this wheat,
19:59at that time,
20:00was the decision of the government,
20:02due to which it was imported.
20:04And,
20:05the statement of this,
20:06has been made by the Secretary-General himself,
20:09that we have imported this wheat.
20:11But, now,
20:12if Malwa has done something wrong,
20:14then,
20:15when the Secretary-General himself is saying,
20:17that we have imported this,
20:18then,
20:19why has this Malwa been put on these small officers?
20:21Why was the upper level not questioned in this regard?
20:24It seems,
20:25that
20:26they have been released.
20:29And,
20:30the whole sacrifice,
20:32has been made by these small officers,
20:33and now,
20:34they are trying to cover it up.
20:35Malik Ahmed Khan Sahib,
20:36on one hand,
20:37this is a storm,
20:38which the Prime Minister of Punjab,
20:40does not call a storm.
20:41Mariam Sahiba says,
20:42that this is not a storm.
20:43This is being done out of proportion.
20:45You have seen,
20:46that during disruptions and protests,
20:48the farmers were arrested.
20:50And, the government was also denying this.
20:52But,
20:53along with this,
20:54Tehreek-e-Insaaf,
20:55even after a walkout,
20:56you are going to challenge the Hath-e-Izzat Bill,
20:58in the courts,
20:59which was passed yesterday evening,
21:01by the Punjab Assembly.
21:02This Bill,
21:03and its passing,
21:04now you are going to challenge it.
21:06But,
21:07is there still any room in this,
21:09from the government,
21:10or is there any door open,
21:11so that you can once again,
21:12sit down and have a discussion?
21:16Look,
21:17this Reformation Bill,
21:18this,
21:19they,
21:20four days,
21:21five days ago,
21:22they sent the Select Committee,
21:23in Ujlaz.
21:24In that,
21:25twelve clauses,
21:26are there,
21:27which,
21:28contradict the eyes of Pakistan.
21:31If they,
21:32the first thing is,
21:336A,
21:348,
21:359,
21:3612,
21:3717,
21:3820,
21:3921,
21:4023.
21:41If they read this carefully,
21:42then,
21:43whoever has read this Bill,
21:44then,
21:45they will know,
21:46where this Bill came from,
21:47and how it came,
21:48and how they did the overnight call.
21:50In this,
21:51we have given fourteen amendments.
21:52They,
21:53did not own any of our amendments.
21:55This is the first thing.
21:56The second thing,
21:57is that,
21:58your media persons,
21:59yesterday,
22:00were present in the Assembly.
22:01They did a great favour,
22:02they came to our Chamber as well.
22:05So,
22:06after a two hour meeting with them,
22:08they were called,
22:09to take your suggestions.
22:10Their suggestions were also not taken.
22:12Now,
22:13after that,
22:14they did this,
22:15that in this Bill,
22:16total dictatorship can be seen.
22:18In this Bill,
22:19you can imagine,
22:20that the application of the Law of Martial Law,
22:22which is the law of the world,
22:24in which there is no application of evidence,
22:26you do not even bother to present any evidence.
22:30This is like,
22:31a throat is being choked,
22:33which is the freedom of speech,
22:34of Article 19.
22:36After that,
22:37their class 12,
22:39that you cannot commit anything,
22:41which will be proceeding on going.
22:44And if you tell,
22:45how many big cases there are,
22:47how many big cases there have been,
22:49in this,
22:50in this,
22:51what is such a big issue,
22:52that you cannot even talk about it.
22:54And,
22:55if you go into their punishments,
22:57if you go into the formation of their Tribunal,
23:00then three lawyers,
23:01will be presented,
23:02will be presented,
23:03the Chief Executive of the Punjab Government,
23:06that you have seen yourself,
23:08the state of the ATC Courts,
23:10that in Punjab,
23:11the judge is not feeling,
23:12the High Court,
23:13the consultation,
23:14which is said,
23:15with the consultation of,
23:16Chief Justice High Court,
23:18so the consultation,
23:19is being done by the Chief Justice,
23:20who is not putting,
23:21the judges of ATC,
23:22on their request,
23:23because in that,
23:24there are cases of,
23:25Pakistan Tariq-e-Insaf,
23:26there are cases of,
23:27our leaders,
23:28which are bogus cases,
23:29there are cases of,
23:30our workers,
23:31that is why,
23:32they are saying,
23:33not to put the judges,
23:34today,
23:35five major courts,
23:36are vacant,
23:37of ATC,
23:38see,
23:39the bill of,
23:40respect to the limit,
23:41this whole civil society,
23:42they had to,
23:43take on board,
23:44the biggest stakeholders,
23:45social media,
23:46print media,
23:47electronic media,
23:48this is,
23:49after that,
23:50civil society,
23:51what did they get,
23:52that in four days,
23:53they,
23:54as it is,
23:55the bill,
23:56which they,
23:57have made,
23:58as it is,
23:59they have not put,
24:00any if,
24:01any but,
24:02they have not put any comma,
24:03they have passed the bill,
24:04as it is,
24:05from the committee,
24:06we have,
24:07yesterday,
24:08four,
24:09Thank you very much,
24:10Malik Ahmed Khan,
24:11was with us,
24:12you listened to the discussion,
24:13on one hand,
24:14the situation of the farmers,
24:15the wheat crisis,
24:16on the other hand,
24:17the bill of,
24:18respect to the limit,
24:19from the consultative action,
24:20in haste,
24:21in the dark,
24:22it is clear,
24:23from the statement,
24:24of objectives,
24:25that the public officials,
24:26are mentioned,
24:27and the private citizens,
24:28are mentioned,
24:29but in this,
24:30the public figures,
24:31image damage,
24:32has not been mentioned,
24:33to protect the image,
24:34this bill has been made,
24:35respect to the government,
24:36and image,
24:37protect,
24:38and to protect it,
24:39this is not less,
24:40than a joke,
24:41in a thriving democracy,
24:42defamation,
24:43is a different thing,
24:45defamation,
24:46is a different thing,
24:47disinformation,
24:48is a different thing,
24:49the message,
24:50is very clear,
24:51the government,
24:52and the institutions,
24:53and the institutional,
24:54office holders,
24:55to respect,
24:56is the objective,
24:57defamation,
24:58the laws,
24:59that are already there,
25:00civil law,
25:01versus criminal law,
25:02punishments,
25:03is a healthy debate,
25:04which is very much needed,
25:05in our society,
25:06a democracy,
25:07which has health,
25:08in it,
25:09criticism,
25:10and criticism,
25:11is the most important part,
25:12here,
25:13the government,
25:14and the institutions,
25:15to respect,
25:16is the objective,
25:17defamation,
25:18is a different thing,
25:19the message,
25:20is very much needed,
25:21civil law,
25:22versus criminal law,
25:23punishments,
25:24is a healthy debate,
25:25in our society,
25:26a democracy,
25:27which has health,
25:28in it,
25:29criticism,
25:30and criticism,
25:31is the most important part,
25:32here,
25:33a democracy,
25:34is a healthy debate,
25:35civil law,
25:36punishments,
25:37is a different thing,
25:38in our society,
25:39a democracy,
25:40is a healthy debate,
25:41in our society,
25:42a democracy,
25:43is a healthy debate,
25:44in our society,
25:45a democracy,
25:46is a healthy debate,
25:47in our society,
25:48a democracy,
25:49is a healthy debate,
25:50in our society,
25:51a democracy,
25:52is a healthy debate,
25:53in our society,
25:54a democracy,
25:55is a healthy debate,
25:56in our society,
25:57a democracy,
25:58is a healthy debate,
25:59in our society,
26:00a democracy,
26:01is a healthy debate,
26:02in our society,
26:03a democracy,
26:04is a healthy debate,
26:05in our society,
26:06a democracy,
26:07is a healthy debate,
26:08in our society,
26:09a democracy,
26:10is a healthy debate,
26:11in our society,
26:12a democracy,
26:13is a healthy debate,
26:14in our society,
26:15a democracy,
26:16is a healthy debate,
26:17in our society,
26:18a democracy,
26:19is a healthy debate,
26:20in our society,
26:21a democracy,
26:22is a healthy debate,
26:23in our society,
26:24a democracy,
26:25is a healthy debate,
26:26in our society,
26:27a democracy,
26:28is a healthy debate,
26:29in our society,
26:30a democracy,
26:31is a healthy debate,
26:32in our society,
26:33a democracy,
26:34is a healthy debate,
26:35in our society,
26:36a democracy,
26:37is a healthy debate,
26:38in our society,
26:39a democracy,
26:40is a healthy debate,
26:41in our society,
26:42a democracy,
26:43is a healthy debate,
26:44in our society,
26:45a democracy,
26:46is a healthy debate,
26:47in our society,
26:48a democracy,
26:49is a healthy debate,
26:50in our society,
26:51a democracy,
26:52is a healthy debate,
26:53in our society,
26:54a democracy,
26:55is a healthy debate,
26:56in our society,
26:57a democracy,
26:58is a healthy debate,
26:59in our society,
27:00a democracy,
27:01is a healthy debate,
27:02in our society,
27:03a democracy,
27:04is a healthy debate,
27:05in our society,
27:06a democracy,
27:07is a healthy debate,
27:08in our society,
27:09a democracy,
27:10is a healthy debate,
27:11in our society,
27:12a democracy,
27:13is a healthy debate,
27:14in our society,
27:15a democracy,
27:16is a healthy debate,
27:17in our society,
27:18a democracy,
27:19is a healthy debate,
27:20in our society,
27:21a democracy,
27:22is a healthy debate,
27:23in our society,
27:24a democracy,
27:25is a healthy debate,
27:26in our society,
27:27a democracy,
27:28is a healthy debate,
27:29in our society,
27:30a democracy,
27:31is a healthy debate,
27:32in our society,
27:33a democracy,
27:34is a healthy debate,
27:35in our society,
27:36a democracy,
27:37is a healthy debate,
27:38in our society,
27:39a democracy,
27:40is a healthy debate,
27:41in our society,
27:42a democracy,
27:43is a healthy debate,
27:44in our society,
27:45a democracy,
27:46is a healthy debate,
27:47in our society,
27:48a democracy,
27:49is a healthy debate,
27:50in our society,
27:51a democracy,
27:52is a healthy debate,
27:53in our society,
27:54a democracy,
27:55is a healthy debate,
27:56in our society,
27:57a democracy,
27:58is a healthy debate,
27:59in our society,
28:00a democracy,
28:01is a healthy debate,
28:02in our society,
28:03a democracy,
28:04is a healthy debate,
28:05in our society,
28:06a democracy,
28:07is a healthy debate,
28:08in our society,
28:09a democracy,
28:10is a healthy debate,
28:11in our society,
28:12a democracy,
28:13is a healthy debate,
28:14in our society,
28:15a democracy,
28:16is a healthy debate,
28:17in our society,
28:18a democracy,
28:19is a healthy debate,
28:20in our society,
28:21a democracy,
28:22is a healthy debate,
28:23in our society,
28:24a democracy,
28:25is a healthy debate,
28:26in our society,
28:27a democracy,
28:28is a healthy debate,
28:29in our society,
28:30a democracy,
28:31is a healthy debate,
28:32in our society,
28:33a democracy,
28:34is a healthy debate,
28:35in our society,
28:36a democracy,
28:37is a healthy debate,
28:38in our society,
28:39a democracy,
28:40is a healthy debate,
28:41in our society,
28:42a democracy,
28:43is a healthy debate,
28:44in our society,
28:45a democracy,
28:46is a healthy debate,
28:47in our society,
28:48a democracy,
28:49is a healthy debate,
28:50in our society,
28:51a democracy,
28:52is a healthy debate,
28:53in our society,
28:54a democracy,
28:55is a healthy debate,
28:56in our society,
28:57a democracy,
28:58is a healthy debate,
28:59in our society,
29:00a democracy,
29:01is a healthy debate,
29:02in our society,
29:03a democracy,
29:04is a healthy debate,
29:05in our society,
29:06a democracy,
29:07is a healthy debate,
29:08in our society,
29:09a democracy,
29:10is a healthy debate,
29:11in our society,
29:12a democracy,
29:13is a healthy debate,
29:14in our society,
29:15a democracy,
29:16is a healthy debate,
29:17in our society,
29:18a democracy,
29:19is a healthy debate,
29:20in our society,
29:21a democracy,
29:22is a healthy debate,
29:23in our society,
29:24a democracy,
29:25is a healthy debate,
29:26in our society,
29:27a democracy,
29:28is a healthy debate,
29:29in our society,
29:30a democracy,
29:31is a healthy debate,
29:32in our society,
29:33a democracy,
29:34is a healthy debate,
29:35in our society,
29:36a democracy,
29:37is a healthy debate,
29:38in our society,
29:39a democracy,
29:40is a healthy debate,
29:41in our society,
29:42a democracy,
29:43is a healthy debate,
29:44in our society,
29:45a democracy,
29:46is a healthy debate,
29:47in our society,
29:48a democracy,
29:49is a healthy debate,
29:50in our society,
29:51a democracy,
29:52is a healthy debate,
29:53in our society,
29:54a democracy,
29:55is a healthy debate,
29:56in our society,
29:57a democracy,
29:58is a healthy debate,
29:59in our society,
30:00a democracy,
30:01is a healthy debate,
30:02in our society,
30:03a democracy,
30:04is a healthy debate,
30:05in our society,
30:06a democracy,
30:07is a healthy debate,
30:08in our society,
30:09a democracy,
30:10is a healthy debate,
30:11in our society,
30:12a democracy,
30:13is a healthy debate,
30:14in our society,
30:15a democracy,
30:16is a healthy debate,
30:17in our society,
30:18a democracy,
30:19is a healthy debate,
30:20in our society,
30:21a democracy,
30:22is a healthy debate,
30:23in our society,
30:24a democracy,
30:25is a healthy debate,
30:26in our society,
30:27a democracy,
30:28is a healthy debate,
30:29in our society,
30:30a democracy,
30:31is a healthy debate,
30:32in our society,
30:33a democracy,
30:34is a healthy debate,
30:35in our society,
30:36a democracy,
30:37is a healthy debate,
30:38in our society,
30:39a democracy,
30:40is a healthy debate,
30:41in our society,
30:42a democracy,
30:43is a healthy debate,
30:44in our society,
30:45a democracy,
30:46is a healthy debate,
30:47in our society,
30:48a democracy,
30:49is a healthy debate,
30:50in our society,
30:51a democracy,
30:52is a healthy debate,
30:53in our society,
30:54a democracy,
30:55is a healthy debate,
30:56in our society,
30:57a democracy,
30:58is a healthy debate,
30:59in our society,
31:00a democracy,
31:01is a healthy debate,
31:02in our society,
31:03a democracy,
31:04is a healthy debate,
31:05in our society,
31:06a democracy,
31:07is a healthy debate,
31:08in our society,
31:09a democracy,
31:10is a healthy debate,
31:11in our society,
31:12a democracy,
31:13is a healthy debate,
31:14in our society,
31:15a democracy,
31:16is a healthy debate,
31:17in our society,
31:18a democracy,
31:19is a healthy debate,
31:20in our society,
31:21a democracy,
31:22is a healthy debate,
31:23in our society,
31:24a democracy,
31:25is a healthy debate,
31:26in our society,
31:27a democracy,
31:28is a healthy debate,
31:29in our society,
31:30a democracy,
31:31is a healthy debate,
31:32in our society,
31:33a democracy,
31:34is a healthy debate,
31:35in our society,
31:36a democracy,
31:37is a healthy debate,
31:38in our society,
31:39a democracy,
31:40is a healthy debate,
31:41in our society,
31:42a democracy,
31:43is a healthy debate,
31:44in our society,
31:45a democracy,
31:46is a healthy debate,
31:47in our society,
31:48a democracy,
31:49is a healthy debate,
31:50in our society,
31:51a democracy,
31:52is a healthy debate,
31:53in our society,
31:54a democracy,
31:55is a healthy debate,
31:56in our society,
31:57a democracy,
31:58is a healthy debate,
31:59in our society,
32:00a democracy,
32:01is a healthy debate,
32:02in our society,
32:03a democracy,
32:04is a healthy debate,
32:05in our society,
32:06a democracy,
32:07is a healthy debate,
32:08in our society,
32:09a democracy,
32:10is a healthy debate,
32:11in our society,
32:12a democracy,
32:13is a healthy debate,
32:14in our society,
32:15a democracy,
32:16is a healthy debate,
32:17in our society,
32:18a democracy,
32:19is a healthy debate,
32:20in our society,
32:21a democracy,
32:22is a healthy debate,
32:23in our society,
32:24a democracy,
32:25is a healthy debate,
32:26in our society,
32:27a democracy,
32:28is a healthy debate,
32:29in our society,
32:30a democracy,
32:31is a healthy debate,
32:32in our society,
32:33a democracy,
32:34is a healthy debate,
32:35in our society,
32:36a democracy,
32:37is a healthy debate,
32:38in our society,
32:39a democracy,
32:40is a healthy debate,
32:41in our society,
32:42a democracy,
32:43is a healthy debate,
32:44in our society,
32:45a democracy,
32:46is a healthy debate,
32:47in our society,
32:48a democracy,
32:49is a healthy debate,
32:50in our society,
32:51a democracy,
32:52is a healthy debate,
32:53in our society,
32:54a democracy,
32:55is a healthy debate,
32:56in our society,
32:57a democracy,
32:58is a healthy debate,
32:59in our society,
33:00a democracy,
33:01is a healthy debate,
33:02in our society,
33:03a democracy,
33:04is a healthy debate,
33:05in our society,
33:06a democracy,
33:07is a healthy debate,
33:08in our society,
33:09a democracy,
33:10is a healthy debate,
33:11in our society,
33:12a democracy,
33:13is a healthy debate,
33:14in our society,
33:15a democracy,
33:16is a healthy debate,
33:17in our society,
33:18a democracy,
33:19is a healthy debate,
33:20in our society,
33:21a democracy,
33:22is a healthy debate,
33:23in our society,
33:24a democracy,
33:25is a healthy debate,
33:26in our society,
33:27a democracy,
33:28is a healthy debate,
33:29in our society,
33:30a democracy,
33:31is a healthy debate,
33:32in our society,
33:33a democracy,
33:34is a healthy debate,
33:35in our society,
33:36a democracy,
33:37is a healthy debate,
33:38in our society,
33:39a democracy,
33:40is a healthy debate,
33:41in our society,
33:42a democracy,
33:43is a healthy debate,
33:44in our society,
33:45a democracy,
33:46is a healthy debate,
33:47in our society,
33:48a democracy,
33:49is a healthy debate,
33:50in our society,
33:51a democracy,
33:52is a healthy debate,
33:53in our society,
33:54a democracy,
33:55is a healthy debate,
33:56in our society,
33:57a democracy,
33:58is a healthy debate,
33:59in our society,
34:00a democracy,
34:01is a healthy debate,
34:02in our society,
34:03a democracy,
34:04is a healthy debate,
34:05in our society,
34:06a democracy,
34:07is a healthy debate,
34:08in our society,
34:09a democracy,
34:10is a healthy debate,
34:11in our society,
34:12a democracy,
34:13is a healthy debate,
34:14in our society,
34:15a democracy,
34:16is a healthy debate,
34:17in our society,
34:18a democracy,
34:19is a healthy debate,
34:20in our society,
34:21a democracy,
34:22is a healthy debate,
34:23in our society,
34:24Allahumma Salli wa Sallim Mubarak
34:26Qala Sayyidina Muhammad
34:27Walali Muhammad
34:29This week,
34:30this week,
34:31within three days,
34:32this is the second major incident
34:33within three days,
34:34within three days,
34:35within three days,
34:36within three days,
34:37within three days,
34:38within three days,
34:39within three days,
34:40within three days,
34:41within three days,
34:42within three days,
34:43within three days,
34:44within three days,
34:45within three days,
34:46within three days,
34:47within three days,
34:48within three days,
34:49within three days,
34:50within three days,
34:51within three days,
34:52within three days,
34:53in three days,
34:54in three days,
34:55in three days,
34:56in three days,
34:57in three days,
34:58in three days,
34:59in three days,
35:00in three days,
35:01in three days,
35:02in three days,
35:03in three days,
35:04in three days,
35:05in three days,
35:06in three days,
35:07in three days,
35:08in three days,
35:09in three days,
35:10in three days,
35:11in three days,
35:12in three days,
35:13in three days,
35:14in three days,
35:15in three days,
35:16in three days,
35:17in three days,
35:18in three days,
35:19in three days,
35:20in three days,
35:21in three days,
35:22in three days,
35:23in three days,
35:24in three days,
35:25in three days,
35:26in three days,
35:27in three days,
35:28in three days,
35:29in three days,
35:30in three days,
35:31in three days,
35:32in three days,
35:33in three days,
35:34in three days,
35:35in three days,
35:36in three days,
35:37in three days,
35:38in three days,
35:39in three days,
35:40in three days,
35:41in three days,
35:42in three days,
35:43in three days,
35:44in three days,
35:45in three days,
35:46in three days,
35:47in three days,
35:48in three days,
35:49in three days,
35:50in three days,
35:51in three days,
35:52in three days,
35:53in three days,
35:54in three days,
35:55in three days,
35:56in three days,
35:57in three days,
35:58in three days,
35:59in three days,
36:00in three days,
36:01in three days,
36:02in three days,
36:03in three days,
36:04in three days,
36:05in three days,
36:06in three days,
36:07in three days,
36:08in three days,
36:09in three days,
36:10in three days,
36:11in three days,
36:12in three days,
36:13in three days,
36:14in three days,
36:15in three days,
36:16in three days,
36:17in three days,
36:18in three days,
36:19in three days,
36:20in three days,
36:21in three days,
36:22in three days,
36:23in three days,
36:24in three days,
36:25in three days,
36:26in three days,
36:27in three days,
36:28in three days,
36:29in three days,
36:30in three days,
36:31in three days,
36:32in three days,
36:33in three days,
36:34in three days,
36:35in three days,
36:36in three days,
36:37in three days,
36:38in three days,
36:39in three days,
36:40in three days,
36:41in three days,
36:42in three days,
36:43in three days,
36:44in three days,
36:45in three days,
36:46in three days,
36:47in three days,
36:48in three days,
36:49in three days,
36:50in three days,
36:51in three days,
36:52in three days,
36:53in three days,
36:54in three days,
36:55in three days,
36:56in three days,
36:57in three days,
36:58in three days,
36:59in three days,
37:00in three days,
37:01in three days,
37:02in three days,
37:03in three days,
37:04in three days,
37:05in three days,
37:06in three days,
37:07in three days,
37:08in three days,
37:09in three days,
37:10in three days,
37:11in three days,
37:12in three days,
37:13in three days,
37:14in three days,
37:15in three days,
37:16in three days,
37:17in three days,
37:18in three days,
37:19in three days,
37:20in three days,
37:21in three days,
37:22in three days,
37:23in three days,
37:24in three days,
37:25in three days,
37:26in three days,
37:27in three days,
37:28in three days,
37:29in three days,
37:30in three days,
37:31in three days,
37:32in three days,
37:33in three days,
37:34in three days,
37:35in three days,
37:36in three days,
37:37in three days,
37:38in three days,
37:39in three days,
37:40in three days,
37:41in three days,
37:42in three days,
37:43in three days,
37:44in three days,
37:45in three days,
37:46in three days,
37:47in three days,
37:48in three days,
37:49in three days,
37:50in three days,
37:51in three days,
37:52in three days,
37:53in three days,
37:54in three days,
37:55in three days,
37:56in three days,
37:57in three days,
37:58in three days,
37:59in three days,
38:00in three days,
38:01in three days,
38:02in three days,
38:03in three days,
38:04in three days,
38:05in three days,
38:06in three days,
38:07in three days,
38:08in three days,
38:09in three days,
38:10in three days,
38:11in three days,
38:12in three days,
38:13in three days,
38:14in three days,
38:15in three days,
38:16in three days,
38:17in three days,
38:18in three days,
38:19in three days,
38:20in three days,
38:21in three days,
38:22in three days,
38:23in three days,
38:24in three days,
38:25in three days,
38:26in three days,
38:27in three days,
38:28in three days,
38:29in three days,
38:30in three days,
38:31in three days,
38:32in three days,
38:33in three days,
38:34in three days,
38:35in three days,
38:36in three days,
38:37in three days,
38:38in three days,
38:39in three days,
38:40in three days,
38:41in three days,
38:42in three days,
38:43in three days,
38:44in three days,
38:45in three days,
38:46in three days,
38:47in three days,
38:48in three days,
38:49in three days,
38:50in three days,
38:51in three days,
38:52in three days,
38:53in three days,
38:54in three days,
38:55in three days,
38:56in three days,
38:57in three days,
38:58in three days,
38:59in three days,
39:00in three days,
39:01in three days,
39:02in three days,
39:03in three days,
39:04in three days,
39:05in three days,
39:06in three days,
39:07in three days,
39:08in three days,
39:09in three days,
39:10in three days,
39:11in three days,
39:12in three days,
39:13in three days,
39:14in three days,
39:15in three days,
39:16in three days,
39:17in three days,
39:18in three days,
39:19in three days,
39:20in three days,
39:21in three days,
39:22in three days,
39:23in three days,
39:24in three days,
39:25in three days,
39:26in three days,
39:27in three days,
39:28in three days,
39:29in three days,
39:30in three days,
39:31in three days,
39:32in three days,
39:33in three days,
39:34in three days,
39:35in three days,
39:36in three days,
39:37in three days,
39:38in three days,
39:39in three days,
39:40in three days,
39:41in three days,
39:42in three days,