How do grocery stores offer such low prices while still earning huge profits? Many rely on strategies they hope customers overlook. Here's a look at some questionable tactics used to keep prices down.
Category
🛠️
LifestyleTranscript
00:00How do grocery stores offer such low prices while still earning huge profits?
00:05Many rely on strategies they hope customers overlook.
00:07Here's a look at some questionable tactics used to keep prices down.
00:11Bringing your own bags when grocery shopping not only benefits the environment but also
00:15helps stores cut costs.
00:17Many grocers now charge for plastic or paper bags to reduce expenses.
00:21While it may seem insignificant, the cost of providing single-use bags quickly adds
00:25up.
00:26Grocers can spend anywhere from $1,000 to $6,000 monthly on bags, costs that are often
00:31passed on to customers.
00:33This strategy of charging for bags or offering none at all is common among discount retailers
00:38like Aldi and Lidl.
00:39Other stores, including natural grocers and some Trader Joe's locations, also charge for
00:44bags, offering either reusable options or more expensive single-use ones.
00:48Warehouse clubs like Costco and Sam's Club take it a step further by providing no bags
00:53at all.
00:54Stop encouraging shoppers to use leftover shipping boxes.
00:57This growing trend helps stores save money while promoting eco-friendly practices.
01:02Automation in stock rooms can reduce waste and make training more efficient, ultimately
01:06helping stores cut costs and offer lower prices.
01:09However, this comes at a cost to the customer experience.
01:12Fewer staff members are available to assist shoppers, leaving them without help when questions
01:17arise.
01:18A prime example is self-checkout, which can lead to several issues.
01:21Shoppers scan and bag their own groceries, but if the price doesn't match or the bar
01:25code isn't working, the process is interrupted.
01:28Produce often requires manual lookup, and age verification can stop the process, leaving
01:33shoppers waiting for help.
01:34With only a few employees on the floor, assistance can be slow as one worker tries to manage
01:39multiple customers at once.
01:41Research from CBC's Marketplace found that cashiers are faster and make fewer mistakes
01:45than self-checkout kiosks.
01:47These delays and frustrations result in slower transactions and greater confusion, highlighting
01:52the tradeoff between lower prices and personalized service.
01:56While automation may save money, it often sacrifices the quality of customer interaction.
02:00Because I do believe that these entry-level jobs that are applied in retail will ultimately
02:06be automated out of existence.
02:09Retailers often attract customers by offering popular items at discounted prices, a strategy
02:14known as loss leaders.
02:16These items, like milk, eggs, and razors, are sold at a loss to draw shoppers in.
02:21Once inside, customers are likely to purchase more of the discounted products or add extra
02:25items due to impulse buying.
02:27Studies have shown that grocery stores may even place loss leaders like milk and bread
02:31in opposite corners, encouraging shoppers to pass by other products, thus increasing
02:35the likelihood of additional purchases.
02:38While U.S. law restricts widespread loss leader tactics, large chains with deep pockets often
02:43find ways to exploit them, pushing smaller grocers out of business who can't sustain
02:47such aggressive pricing.
02:49Major retailers like Amazon and Walmart have been known for using this strategy on a large
02:53scale.
02:54Walmart, in particular, faced a lawsuit in the early 1990s over predatory pricing, accused
02:59of unfairly undercutting local competitors.
03:02However, the Arkansas Supreme Court ruled in favor of Walmart, allowing its low-price
03:06strategy to continue, highlighting the challenges smaller stores face in competing against these
03:11retail giants.
03:13Several large grocery chains have come under fire for treating employees poorly, despite
03:17seeing record profits.
03:19Workers claim they are overburdened with part-time hours, lack essential benefits, and struggle
03:24to access paid leave when they're ill.
03:26Many minimum-wage earners in grocery stores report living below the poverty line.
03:30In 2019, Stop & Shop employees in the Northeast staged protests over reduced benefits, such
03:36as the elimination of holiday pay and increased healthcare costs.
03:40The store argued these changes were necessary to stay competitive, allowing them to offer
03:44lower prices to customers.
03:46However, Stop & Shop's parent company still reported $2 billion in profits the year before.
03:51When Amazon acquired Whole Foods in 2016, the company shifted its focus to lowering
03:56grocery prices, cutting back on the generous benefits Whole Foods once offered.
04:00This resulted in layoffs and reductions to healthcare benefits for 1,900 workers within
04:05a few years.
04:06Despite the price drops on some items, it became clear that the lower costs were being
04:10paid for by the workers themselves.
04:13Credit cards have become the preferred method of payment for many shoppers, offering the
04:17convenience of not needing to carry cash or visit the bank.
04:20However, this ease of use comes at a significant cost to retailers.
04:23For each card transaction, stores are charged fees ranging from 1% to 5% by banks and credit
04:29card companies.
04:30In an effort to reduce these fees, Kroger even banned Visa cards at its Smith's food
04:35and drug stores in seven states.
04:37Smaller retailers often combat these fees by requiring a minimum purchase for credit
04:41card transactions, passing on the added costs to consumers through higher prices.
04:46Occasionally, grocery chains will respond to high swipe fees by banning specific credit
04:50cards, either temporarily or until a more favorable fee structure is negotiated.
04:55In some cases, grocery stores opt out of credit cards entirely to keep costs down.
05:00Salvage stores, which sell heavily discounted items like damaged goods, near-expiry food,
05:05and surplus stock, often accept only cash or debit cards, ensuring lower overhead and
05:10providing even deeper savings for their customers.
05:13In some discount stores, shoppers take on tasks typically done by employees to keep
05:18prices low.
05:19For instance, Aldi requires customers to bag their own groceries after checkout, a practice
05:24shared by stores like Costco, Sam's Club, and Lidl.
05:27This self-bagging policy helps speed up the checkout process by allowing cashiers to focus
05:32on handling transactions quickly, rather than spending time bagging items, ultimately improving
05:37efficiency and lowering costs for the store.
05:40"'Whoever has the fastest ring rate will win it all!'
05:46At Aldi, cashiers simply place items directly into the cart, bypassing traditional bagging.
05:51While this saves on labor costs, it shifts the responsibility to customers, who now sort
05:56through carts and hunt for leftover boxes.
05:58This approach cuts employee expenses by making shoppers do the extra work.
06:03Can customers really trust that what they're buying is Chilean sea bass?
06:06A study by the ocean conservation group Oceana found that mislabeling of fish is common across
06:12grocery stores and restaurants in various states.
06:14The research revealed that 33 percent of fish samples from small grocery stores and 30 percent
06:20from larger national chains were mislabeled.
06:22Misidentifications were found in seafood samples from cities like New York, Seattle,
06:27Miami, and San Francisco.
06:28However, grocery stores may not always be fully to blame.
06:32It's possible they unknowingly purchase one type of fish while believing it to be another.
06:36The confusion can also stem from varying labeling standards between states.
06:40The FDA recognizes around 1,700 fish species and offers a guide for retailers, but discrepancies
06:46between state and federal regulations can lead to inconsistent naming conventions.
06:50With these complexities, shoppers should be cautious when buying fish, especially if
06:54the price seems unusually low.
06:56In many cases, it may not be what it's labeled as, so being skeptical is wise.
07:01As grocery stores work to lower prices, many are turning to organic-adjacent products to
07:06keep up with the growing demand for organic options.
07:09The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that organic food sales continue to see strong,
07:14consistent growth, with three-quarters of traditional grocery stores now offering organic
07:18products.
07:19To qualify for the USDA organic label, products must meet strict guidelines, including ensuring
07:24that at least 95 percent of the ingredients are organic.
07:27These requirements contribute to the higher cost of organic foods, which can deter price-conscious
07:32shoppers.
07:33In response, many grocers are creating new certifications that allow products to be labeled
07:37as organic, with fewer organic ingredients, helping them keep prices low.
07:42This shift could create confusion among consumers and increase demand for cheaper products that
07:46only contain some organic ingredients.
07:49According to Will Fantel of the Cornucopia Institute, this trend risks undermining the
07:53growth of truly organic products.
07:55If customers are trained to expect lower-priced organic items, it could be difficult to reverse
08:00this expectation, just as with other pricing strategies like loss leaders.
08:04This could have long-term consequences for the organic food market.
08:08When large supermarkets and big-box retailers dominate the market, it creates an uneven
08:12power dynamic between suppliers and retailers.
08:15Companies like Walmart leverage their vast buying power to pressure suppliers into accepting
08:19rock-bottom prices, or risk being cut out entirely.
08:23While this strategy lowers prices for consumers, it often has negative effects on producers,
08:28leading to factory layoffs, changes in manufacturing practices, and the relocation of jobs overseas
08:33to take advantage of cheaper labor.
08:35These chain stores, in their race to offer the lowest prices, often pay farmers and producers
08:40far below the actual cost of production.
08:43As a result, many farmers struggle to make a profit, and workers, who endure long and
08:47exhausting hours, are paid meager wages, leaving them on the edge of poverty.
08:51This pressure from grocery chains to maintain unsustainable pricing reverberates through
08:55the entire supply chain.
08:57Consumers may benefit from lower prices, but they are often unaware that these savings
09:01come at the expense of suppliers, workers, and the true cost of food production.
09:07Retailers are increasingly using technology to manipulate discounts, with Amazon leading
09:11the charge in dynamic pricing.
09:13Other giants like Target and Walmart are adopting similar tactics, constantly adjusting prices
09:18based on factors such as time of day, demand, location, and customer behavior.
09:23Amazon alone changes prices millions of times daily.
09:26As a result, in-store prices can vary dramatically from what's offered online, depending on algorithms
09:31that track and respond to consumer patterns and market conditions.
09:35One pack of pens on Staples.com, the price on her computer?
09:39$15.19.
09:40And the price on his?
09:42$13.79.
09:44Some online stores have real-time savings that reduce prices as customers purchase more
09:47items, a strategy popularized by e-commerce but now used by physical retailers as well.
09:53For instance, Target offers a price match guarantee, but it's up to shoppers to notice
09:57the price differences.
09:58However, if not handled carefully, this approach can lead to issues.
10:02In 2017, Safeway lost a class-action lawsuit for misleading customers about maintaining
10:08consistent pricing between their online and in-store offerings.
10:12Some grocery stores are cutting costs in clever ways, including adjusting their hours.
10:17While some stores stay open 24-7, others like Aldi limit hours to reduce expenses.
10:22By closing earlier, often around 7, 8, or 9 p.m., Aldi saves on labor and operational
10:28costs.
10:29While these costs may seem like a small change, reducing hours significantly cuts staffing
10:33and utility expenses.
10:34This strategy, though inconvenient for late-night shoppers, is part of a broader trend in budget
10:39grocery stores.
10:40These cost-saving measures have allowed Aldi to operate with roughly half the overhead
10:45of larger retailers, making it a leader in budget-friendly grocery shopping.
10:50Wholesale pricing has become a popular retail trend in recent years, with many grocery stores
10:54offering better discounts to shoppers who pay for memberships.
10:57Essentially, customers pay for the privilege of saving money.
11:00Bulk retailers like Costco and Sam's Club have long used this membership model.
11:05Costco charges $65 or more annually for a membership, while Sam's Club offers two options
11:10— a basic membership for $50 and a premium membership for $110, which grants access to
11:16exclusive discounts.
11:18Newer online-only platforms, such as Thrive Market, are also adopting the wholesale model
11:22for healthier foods.
11:24To shop on Thrive Market and access their discounted organic products, shoppers must
11:28pay an annual fee of $60 or a monthly fee of $12.
11:32Whole Foods, now owned by Amazon, offers additional discounts to Prime members.
11:36While shoppers don't need a membership to shop at Whole Foods, they must be Prime members
11:40to enjoy the extra savings.
11:42But do customers truly save money by paying these membership fees?
11:45It depends on how much they buy and save each year.
11:48Ultimately, grocery chains charging these fees hope customers will become so accustomed
11:52to the discounts that the initial cost of membership fades from memory, and for many
11:56it does.
11:58Some budget grocery stores focus on stocking high-turnover items to minimize overhead costs.
12:03For example, Aldi offers around 1,400 products, while Lidl stocks roughly 4,000.
12:09Midsize chains like Trader Joe's also carry around 4,000 items, and Dollar General has
12:14between 10,000 and 12,000.
12:16In contrast, traditional supermarkets carry upwards of 40,000 products, and Walmart offers
12:22around 100,000.
12:23The limited selection helps grocery stores reduce costs, which can translate into lower
12:27prices for customers.
12:29However, this strategy comes with downsides, such as fewer choices for shoppers.
12:34If someone is loyal to a particular brand or needs a less common product, they may need
12:38to visit multiple stores.
12:40These extra trips can add up in terms of both time and fuel costs.
12:43Ultimately, while customers might save on low prices, it's often the grocery chains
12:48that benefit most from this streamlined approach.