👉 Batata, una bulldog francés rescatada de un criadero ilegal en Buenos Aires, podría ser obligada por la justicia a volver con sus antiguos dueños. A pesar de las evidencias de maltrato y explotación, la causa prescribió y los tribunales aprobaron la restitución del animal. La familia que cuidó y sanó a Batata durante dos años lucha para apelar esta decisión.
👉 Seguí en #AndinoYLasNoticias
👉 Seguí en #AndinoYLasNoticias
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Look how divine she is.
00:02And the incredible thing is that the justice now would be forcing her to return her with her exploiters.
00:07I mean, a bitch who was exploited in an illegal nursery, who is rescued to have a better life as she deserves.
00:13It seems that the justice is taking a wrong decision.
00:15Look, she has issues to work with the justice, right?
00:17No, sure. And on top of that, they miss her, right?
00:19What a desire they have, right?
00:21There is Leo Godoy with this issue.
00:25Leo, how are you? Good morning.
00:28How are you, Guille? Good morning.
00:31Well, we are here, look, in the courts, in what is the headquarters of the courts of the city of Buenos Aires.
00:38An incomprehensible decision.
00:40Batata is a French bulldog rescued from a place where they subdued her.
00:46Because they had her there to have offspring, sell their offspring, do business, let's say.
00:51From that place they were able to rescue her along with other dogs.
00:54Florencia took care of Batata, took care of her, kept her during this time, paid the veterinarian.
01:02She gave her the love that Batata needed, which they never had because it was an object used to have offspring.
01:10Well, and finally, the owner is a presentation of justice.
01:14And the justice, in what I tell you, an incomprehensible decision, gave her the reason.
01:19And therefore, Florencia, now you are in a situation where you have to return the person who loved her, the dog that you took care of so much.
01:26Yes, now we are waiting to see if we can get a lawyer at the last moment to make a last resort.
01:33But the truth is that today, at 3 in the afternoon, before the trial closes, Batata must be handed over.
01:38Tell me a little about the story, how was this situation.
01:42You rescue her, you take her, tell us a little about that.
01:45We rescued Batata on October 6, 2022.
01:48A search was carried out in Chas Park.
01:51And they found the NGO where I work, Techo de Amor.
01:5522 animals that were separated, the cases were divided, with another NGO that breathed life.
02:02And well, that's how Batata came with us.
02:04She was already a super adult puppy when she arrived.
02:06She had two tumors on the sides.
02:08She was super dirty, she was skinny.
02:11Well, from day one we started with her treatments.
02:14She has the entire vertebral column destroyed.
02:17She has all the semi-vertebrae.
02:19Today she can't walk, she crawls.
02:23She lost the proprioception of everything that is the lower limb.
02:26And for the same reasons, she also has incontinence.
02:29She is a dog that requires a lot of care.
02:31She goes to physiotherapy, acupuncture, she takes medication every night.
02:35Yesterday they diagnosed her with vestibular syndrome.
02:42So she also has something neurological.
02:44And she is not ready to be delivered.
02:46We try to talk to the judge for good, but he doesn't want to answer us.
02:49We are very sad, we don't know what to do.
02:52Because it is very easy to say, don't give the dog.
02:55We don't want to give her, that's why we are doing all this.
02:58But they are threatening us with a lot of legal and criminal consequences that we can't face alone.
03:04Florencia.
03:05Yes.
03:06I'm listening to you, Guillermo.
03:07How are you? This is Guillermo.
03:10You talked about threats, now I want to go to that.
03:12But what would be the apparently wrong criterion that justice has to want to return a dog,
03:18which is now well treated, to the place, to the shelter where they mistreated her?
03:25I ask myself the same thing.
03:26I only know that the cause prescribed and that it asked for restitution again and it was approved.
03:32And during all this legal process that went on, we as a family were never informed.
03:38But, sorry, there was a legal process where mistreatment was in sight,
03:44where it was determined that indeed Batata was mistreated.
03:47I mean, this has a cause, a cause was established and indeed there was a dog that was being mistreated.
03:54The cause prescribed, she was clean.
03:56No, but prescribed means by time, because time passed.
04:00There a cause was prescribed.
04:02What was the case like?
04:04She goes to the police and that goes to the court.
04:08And what does the court say?
04:10What does the court argue for today to ask you to return the dog?
04:18They say it's their dog, legally.
04:20We do not understand why they are making this decision.
04:23I would love to be able to give you a better answer and understand,
04:26but it is not explained why they want to take a dog from a home that is fine with its family
04:30to return it to an animal abuser.
04:32Guille, Germán, I don't know if you remember the case of the dog in Villaluro,
04:35that we interviewed Nora Portela.
04:36Yes, of course.
04:37And she said that this situation is very common,
04:39that they had to rescue many dogs of clandestine breeders
04:43and that unfortunately after the justice, those people were returned to them,
04:46who had them in the worst conditions.
04:48It is not understood.
04:49They are incredible decisions.
04:50Here it is, look, it's just Nora.
04:52Look, there's Nora.
04:53Hi Nora, how are you?
04:54Again with a similar case, returning it to those who mistreated a dog,
04:59condemning it to death, right?
05:04Look, it is a disproliferation, because I explain that here the government of the city makes raids,
05:10they give you the dogs, they introduce themselves, they throw doors down,
05:15they take out the animals and then they don't ask you, you see,
05:18if you can bank the dog, if you can pay for a veterinarian,
05:21in what conditions they are.
05:23Nobody appears, until later one day you have breakfast,
05:26they send you a letter, a document that you have to deliver to the dog.
05:30A dog that was two and a half years old, with terminal care.
05:35Now the owner remembers that she wants her to be returned.
05:39How do you understand that a dog that was with tumors,
05:42with bleeding, with otitis, in some nefarious conditions,
05:46all the dogs accumulated in cages,
05:48that you have to return it to a person who profits.
05:52Nora.
05:53I mean, this can't go on.
05:55It is a letter, a document that she sent.
05:57There is no longer a judgment of the judge, of a judge.
06:00She sent a letter, a document to be returned to the dog.
06:03That is the legal status at the moment.
06:08The only thing that has already been resolved by a judge
06:11is that at nine in the morning the dog had to be delivered.
06:14Ah, so the process advanced.
06:15The dog is not in condition.
06:17No, yes, it's done, it's over.
06:20What we were asking for, if they gave us more days,
06:23because this case came to me yesterday,
06:25Florencia called me yesterday, if I could help.
06:27So what we are asking for, if they give us a few days,
06:30as to present in the government of the city,
06:33in pets of the city, wherever,
06:35that the dog, there are veterinary studies of everything,
06:39that are not in condition to be delivered
06:41to a nefarious, dirty place and a person who is abusive.
06:45Of course.
06:46In fact, if this person was removed,
06:48it is because the dog is abused.
06:50So it can't be returned.
06:52It's crazy to return it to an abuser.
06:55Apart from the dog, how much more is it going to live?
06:58What is left of life, that lives with a family
07:00that gave it love, took care of it,
07:02took care of it, healed its soul.
07:05The dog does not walk, it gets on top, poor thing.
07:08You have to give it little by little so that it does not drown.
07:11Now it has vestibular syndrome.
07:13It is on medication.
07:14Who is going to pay for that?
07:15And who is going to pay the family everything?
07:17This is not what is being questioned.
07:19But who is going to pay for everything
07:21that this family put in for two years?
07:23No, no.
07:24Apart from the love and that they are involved.
07:26Of course.
07:27That dog lived two years thanks to this family.
07:29Now, we are on a regressive account.
07:31Is it inexorably necessary to return the potato?
07:35Or is there an instance that can save it?
07:37Yes, of course.
07:38Yes, appeal.
07:39No, no, you have to return it now.
07:41But if the judge had two grams of heart,
07:45because I don't understand how justice works.
07:48They put people to work with animals
07:50and they suck the eggs of the animals.
07:52What heart do they have?
07:53What part do they have?
07:54Nora.
07:55So, that I have a little humanity.
07:58And to Leo, after the contact is made to Dr. Marcelo Chumbita,
08:01who is in charge, is a lawyer who is in charge
08:03of the issue of protectionism.
08:06He is going to take care of the case in this time that remains.
08:10Or surely maybe he will delegate it to someone.
08:12I want Leo to give us the contact of the girl,
08:16well, of Nora herself,
08:18so that we can speed it up and avoid it quickly.
08:21Thank you very much.
08:22At the same time, I am working, trying to see
08:24in what legal instance this aberration is.
08:27Because it is an aberration.
08:29It has to be taken into account, I understand,
08:32for a failure of this instance.
08:34We have to detain the owners of the nursery,
08:36all of them, these judges.
08:38They cannot be accomplices of animal abuse.
08:40This is a shame.
08:41Of course.
08:42No, without a doubt.
08:43Germán, let's see, and Guille, what they told you,
08:45is that the second instance happened.
08:47That is, I suppose, I don't know if technically I'm right,
08:51what I'm going to say,
08:53it's like they did a restitution trial,
08:55they gave it to the tenant, let's say,
08:58to be restituted.
08:59Potato.
09:00Yes.
09:01And that, there was an appeal, it went to the Chamber,
09:04and the Chamber said again,
09:06we have to return the dog.
09:07I understand up to there, right?
09:08Yes.
09:10So nothing, we are desperately asking for help
09:12so that Tata can stay with us.
09:14Today we have to return her to the nursery where she was rescued.
09:17I can't even conceive it in my head.
09:20Well...
09:21I'm going to make legal actions against them.
09:23It's crazy that they make legal actions against them.
09:26Because, really, the dog shouldn't stay.
09:28The dog shouldn't stay.
09:29No.
09:30Under what conditions is this family going to have it
09:32if it had it for two years?
09:33The dog is 10 or 12 years old,
09:35if they had it badly.
09:36Well, let's hope that today...
09:38To make an appeal now,
09:40to give us a few days to put together this strategy,
09:44we have to write at least 30 pages.
09:47So all this takes time,
09:49and this closes here at 3 in the afternoon.
09:51We finish at 12,
09:52but probably in the continuity of the information today,
09:55when they have to return her,
09:56we can accompany her.
09:59The media, I think,
10:01is the best way to save Potato.
10:04Let's continue with this story, Leo.
10:06Yes.
10:07Thank you all.
10:08I want to scratch everyone.
10:10I mean, it's a shame.
10:12The names of these people have to come out.
10:14They can't go unpunished for life,
10:15doing what they want with the lives of animals.
10:17Well, let's hope that justice also contemplates this.
10:20Thank you very much.