How will conflicts between SC's judges be resolved? - SC Reporter Hasnaat Malik Told Everything

3 months ago

#OffTheRecord #QaziFaezIsa #JusticeMansoorAliShah #KashifAbbasi #SupremeCourt #JusticeMuneebAkhtar #JusticeYahyaAfridi #HasnaatMalik

Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY

Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP

ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.

Official Facebook: https://www.fb.com/arynewsasia

Official Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/arynewsofficial

Official Instagram: https://instagram.com/arynewstv

Website: https://arynews.tv

Watch ARY NEWS LIVE: http://live.arynews.tv

Listen Live: http://live.arynews.tv/audio

Listen Top of the hour Headlines, Bulletins & Programs: https://soundcloud.com/arynewsofficial
#ARYNews

ARY News Official YouTube Channel.
For more videos, subscribe to our channel and for suggestions please use the comment section.

Transcript

00:00No, I will talk to Mr. Panjotha, because apparently the PTI has called for a protest, a convert protest, which is the Jalsa of Pindi.

00:09I don't understand what Mr. Tehrik-e-Ishaq is doing, what he wants to do.

00:12He is putting pressure, he wants to hold Jalsas, he wants to protest, or he wants to spend time.

00:17I will come back to this and ask you, but what is happening in the Supreme Court, Mr. Hasanan?

00:21Look, this has been happening for a long time, now things have opened up.

00:25How much has opened up?

00:27Now it is obvious that there is a judicial civil war going on.

00:30At the moment, any collateral damage, anything can happen.

00:33The situation is getting worse.

00:35The thought of becoming a constitutional court has made the situation worse.

00:39No, the real problem is…

00:41Because everyone must be thinking, the other judges, that Qazi sahib will become his beneficiary,

00:45and all these casualties will be made, he will remain a judge of a civil court,

00:48the real court will be a constitutional court.

00:50Because of this, the fight is increasing.

00:52The other judges are trying to get through these 25-30 days easily.

00:57But Chief Justice Qazi Faisal, he has an art of writing letters,

01:02and there is controversy in that.

01:04After that, the judges start trolling.

01:06So, if you look at how this matter, after July 12th,

01:10in July 12th, I think, the decision that came,

01:14a group is thinking that the constitutional package should become a hurdle in its path.

01:19And in the constitutional package, the main thing was to keep Chief Justice Qazi Faisal,

01:23who is the currency of the system.

01:26After that, it seems to him personally that Chief Justice Qazi Faisal has also taken it.

01:30His and Justice Mansoor Ali Shah's relations are worse than that.

01:33They were very good relations before.

01:35They were exemplary relations.

01:37Qazi Faisal is sitting now, so Justice Mansoor Ali Shah has a big role in that.

01:40So, after that, you see, such things happened that the researcher was transferred.

01:46Then, after that, ADR committee...

01:47Qazi sir will again say that I did not say anything sitting in the court.

01:50He said it that day.

01:51No, he was saying that for 10 years...

01:53I was sitting, so what could I have done?

01:54No, so on July 12th...

01:55I would have given you an answer by sitting on the bench and saying such things.

01:58Now, after that, Mansoor Ali Shah has to be removed from the ADR committee.

02:02Then, after that, you see, so,

02:04as soon as the review is put in place,

02:07on the Tristate A review,

02:09now the matter is that we are seeing that more things will be intensified than a week.

02:13And...

02:14What will happen?

02:15See...

02:16Are you looking at the resignations?

02:17See, the Supreme Court is running through an Ardiness.

02:20I think it is not happening in the world that an Ardiness comes and Ardiness...

02:24Whom Qazi sir is locking.

02:25Internal working.

02:26Yes.

02:27He has locked him.

02:28See, in the past, it is completely law, but in the past, what were the restrictions on their Ardiness?

02:32What were the restrictions?

02:33It was that...

02:34They belong to the Parliament.

02:35Why do they belong to the Parliament?

02:36What is the need?

02:37And these things happen in this regard.

02:38By the way, one more thing has passed through my eyes.

02:40Yesterday, in the newspaper, they have said that the vote is nothing more than form 45-47.

02:44Yes.

02:45It is a ballot.

02:46If you look at the boxes, if there is a ballot in them,

02:48it is more than form 45-47.

02:50The primary evidence is in those boxes.

02:52The ballot is in them.

02:53Now, if you look at that ballot,

02:55then in that, the PTI...

02:57But you know, when the PTI case was filed,

03:00at that time, Qazi sir had said,

03:02that how many votes did they get, how many...

03:04We can't sit and count.

03:06So, show us some paper.

03:08At that time, they were asking for a paper to show where the count is.

03:11They were not accepting votes.

03:13Today, they are saying that vote is everything.

03:15But that remass was not needed.

03:17It seems that the tribunals working in Pakistan,

03:20especially in Punjab,

03:21were given a guideline,

03:22that where there is a form 45-47 control,

03:25you open the boxes and look at the ballot.

03:27Now, in the ballot...

03:28If the ballots have been completed, then they have been completed.

03:30Already, in the recounting, the PTI people are saying that

03:33our four seats have gone.

03:35So, why did they go?

03:36When the recounting took place,

03:38in some places, the rejected votes increased.

03:41In some places, the situation was different.

03:43Anyway, that matter is different.

03:45But, now, this matter is that,

03:46on the ordinance,

03:47Justice Mansoor Ali Shah had requested

03:49to call a full court meeting on this.

03:50Justice Qazi Faisal, on four pages,

03:52Justice Muneeb Akhtar, on four pages,

03:54gave four hearings.

03:55Then, after that, he told his 25 achievements,

03:57that whatever I have done in this,

03:59I have brought democracy in the country.

04:00And...

04:01But...

04:02And you will also prove it.

04:03And...

04:04But...

04:05But, you will prove it.

04:06Justice Qazi Faisal,

04:07you will strengthen democracy.

04:08Absolutely.

04:09But, later,

04:10the request of Justice Mansoor Ali Shah,

04:12that you call a full court meeting,

04:14he is talking about that,

04:15that a full court meeting...

04:16Obviously, it seems that

04:17if a full court meeting is not being called,

04:18then...

04:19So, what will the full court meeting do?

04:20Look, they are considering this matter,

04:22administratively,

04:23that through this ordinance,

04:24our internal working.

04:25Now, in that,

04:26which so-and-so,

04:27at what time will it be taken,

04:28first, those so-and-so will be taken up,

04:30which were earlier,

04:31the cases of 1843.

04:32Later, the new ones,

04:33they cannot be taken up.

04:34This...

04:35Justice Qazi has just said,

04:36that the cases of great compulsion,

04:38which were there,

04:39they were not being taken up.

04:41They were being taken up.

04:42No, now,

04:43this ordinance that has come,

04:44if you see in this,

04:45it is only,

04:46for now,

04:47the focus is on the committee.

04:48Apart from that,

04:49whatever is written in this,

04:50that, in fact,

04:51outside,

04:52the pro-government lawyers,

04:53they are also unable to defend,

04:54that this is affecting

04:55the independent judiciary.

04:56Someone,

04:57tell me,

04:58a lawyer,

04:59who is outside,

05:00who is supporting the government,

05:01the constitutional court,

05:02but,

05:03no one is defending this ordinance.

05:04And,

05:05the interesting thing is,

05:06Justice Qazi,

05:07Pakistan Bar Council,

05:08is supporting everything,

05:09against this ordinance.

05:10No, no,

05:11no one has done it.

05:12So,

05:13this is a very serious matter.

05:14But,

05:15the good thing is,

05:16now,

05:17the courts,

05:18and the Supreme Court,

05:19should also work on the ordinance.

05:20Why do you waste so much time

05:21on the courts?

05:22And,

05:23at least,

05:24it should work for a month,

05:25so that,

05:26by the time the Constitution

05:27Amendment is done,

05:28Trace Act,

05:29now,

05:30in that,

05:31the court should also work on it.

05:32Now,

05:33the government has become,

05:34with regards to the Trace Act,

05:35its own like-minded,

05:36by making it like-minded,

05:37now,

05:38it is being discussed,

05:39that,

05:40if you talk to Yahya Afridi,

05:41then,

05:42that case,

05:43that will not be settled.

05:44But,

05:45Yahya Afridi,

05:46in everything,

05:47he just denies everything.

05:48No,

05:49the questions that he has asked,

05:50that Justice Mansoor Ali Shah has raised,

05:51first,

05:52if a full court meeting takes place,

05:53it is better.

05:54What do you think,

05:55why did Yahya Afridi,

05:56deny it?

05:57I think that,

05:58what is the position of

05:59Justice Mansoor Ali Shah,

06:00This should be seen.

06:02And instead of...

06:04First, if there is a full court meeting

06:06and Justice Qazi Faisal has explained these points here,

06:09all the judges should do it.

06:11Maybe they will be convinced.

06:13But it seems that

06:15Justice Qazi Faisal does not even have a simple majority.

06:19Why? This is not an election.

06:21We are not doing election campaign here.

06:23No, but full court...

06:25Look, I always say this.

06:27If you want to stand with your principles,

06:29stand alone.

06:30Now, if Justice Qazi Faisal stands alone with principles,

06:32then stand.

06:33Why take tension?

How will conflicts between SC's judges be resolved? - SC Reporter Hasnaat Malik Told Everything

Category

Transcript

Recommended