What do you know about the Chinese Air Force?
Go Fund Me for my first book! https://gofund.me/11d58d68
Join this channel to support it:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVDkfkGRzo0qcZ8AkB4TMuw/join
Support me on Patreon https://www.patreon.com/Millennium7
One off donation with PayPal https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/Millennium7star
Join the Discord server https://discord.gg/kvuFyrxDez
AFFILIATE LINK:
Buy an Aircraft Model at Air Models! https://airmodels.net/?aff=173
----------------------------
Ask me anything!
Take part to the community Q&A clicking the link below!
https://forms.office.com/r/LNPQtf3Tc0
--------------------
Visit the subreddit!
https://www.reddit.com/r/Millennium7Lounge/
Go Fund Me for my first book! https://gofund.me/11d58d68
Join this channel to support it:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVDkfkGRzo0qcZ8AkB4TMuw/join
Support me on Patreon https://www.patreon.com/Millennium7
One off donation with PayPal https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/Millennium7star
Join the Discord server https://discord.gg/kvuFyrxDez
AFFILIATE LINK:
Buy an Aircraft Model at Air Models! https://airmodels.net/?aff=173
----------------------------
Ask me anything!
Take part to the community Q&A clicking the link below!
https://forms.office.com/r/LNPQtf3Tc0
--------------------
Visit the subreddit!
https://www.reddit.com/r/Millennium7Lounge/
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00So
00:29there is a question that everybody is asking and that is how good is the
00:35Chinese Air Force? Obviously there is no easy answer and the questions that seem
00:42easy are often deceptively easy. So let's make a whole video about it and despite
00:49the fact that many have done this already we will try as usual to focus on
00:54something which is not easily found anywhere else on YouTube. But first the
00:59ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM!
01:04So Chinese aircraft and weapons are just copies of Russian designs. There's
01:10nothing original. They copied everything and everything is just a big pile of
01:15rubbish. I wish life was so clear-cut. It's true the Chinese didn't produce
01:20anything original for quite a long time and the technologies they used were
01:24either reverse engineering or acquired through licensed productions or plain
01:30technology transfers from abroad. And yes every major country does intelligence
01:37against everybody else, even among allies, all the time and basically China is no
01:42exception. So it is well possible that some of the Chinese technologies have
01:47been acquired or have been started by some know-how derived from intelligence.
01:54However in the last 20 years a lot has changed and there have been massive
02:00resources dedicated to technology improvement. Despite some visible
02:05similarities with foreign products, the technologies that are in use today are
02:10mostly indigenous. The similarities that you see derive mostly from commonality
02:15of design choices rather than plain coping. Just look at the stealth
02:20aircraft being designed and produced around the world. They all look the same
02:25because the problem that they're trying to solve is basically the same and they
02:30use the same solution. Or just consider the case of Delta Canard configuration.
02:36It is a very very efficient configuration for a modern jet fighter
02:41so it's no surprise that the Chinese had chosen that for the J-10. Also the
02:46Chinese have in service different versions and different variants of the
02:50Flanker, many of them actually indigenous, in which they're basically using the
02:58flexibility of the Flanker platform to add their own technology. But no wonder
03:03they still look like Flankers from the outside. Russian and Chinese technology
03:08have been undervalued for a long time, but in the 21st century this approach is
03:15no longer justified.
03:20The Chinese Air Force is numerically second only to the United States and it
03:26would probably require a number of videos in itself to be fully covered and
03:31maybe we will cross that bridge in the near future. What matters now is to get a
03:36relatively good picture of the general force structure. The core is formed by
03:41about 1,300 4th and 5th generation fighters. It is difficult to assess the
03:48actual capabilities of these aircraft, we don't have much information, but analysts
03:53somehow agree that they are capable platform not too far from the Western
04:00equivalents. In this core there are three families, the J-10, various versions of
04:06the Flankers, and the J-20. This composition is probably going to remain
04:10roughly the same in the near future, even though the percentage of J-20s is
04:14actually going to increase. China today is actually building about a hundred
04:19aircraft a year, so we may expect that this core is going to slowly increase in
04:24number, even though we may also expect that some of these hundred aircraft go
04:30and replace older models. Before moving on, please notice that this is a really
04:36good mix of different platforms with different capabilities and different
04:40technologies, which makes for a very resilient mix. About 500 aircraft of
04:46older generations are still in service, together with about 200 trainers that
04:52can carry weapons. Some of these aircraft are still useful as reconnaissance or
04:57electronic warfare platforms, but most of them are pretty much obsolete and
05:02should be used for second line tasks or just in an emergency. However, we may argue
05:07that they keep quite a large body of pilots trained and ready to move on to
05:13newer platforms when they will be available. China is also one of the few
05:17countries that still have a proper bomber in service. The H-6 is similar to
05:23the old Soviet 216 Badger, only from an aerodynamic configuration and structural
05:29point of view. Otherwise, they are completely new aircraft. There are not
05:33that many, but they are essential for the new role of power projection in the
05:39first two island chains, because their role is to be the missile track that is
05:45required to attack large naval formations. Actually, a stealth bomber has
05:50been announced, but we really know nothing so far. Something which is little
05:55known is the attention that the Chinese are placing on airborne radars. There are
06:02about 25 to 30 aircraft in service of different models, but some of them are
06:07very modern, the production is still ongoing. They're generally smaller than
06:12the Western counterparts, they are also turboprops, but they are all equipped
06:16with modern AESA radars, and they seem to be used exactly in the way that
06:21Western air forces use AWACS. On the flip side, there is a real lack of
06:25capability of aerial refueling. Today, the role is covered by a specialized
06:30version of the H-6, and there are very few units between 10 and 20, which are
06:35not proportionate to the number of frontline combat aircraft. However, like
06:41everything in China, the situation is quickly evolving. There is a tanker
06:46version of the Y-20 transport planned, and it is expected to enter service soon.
06:52One important aspect where I didn't manage to find information is readiness.
06:56That is, how many of all these aircraft are ready for use at any given moment.
07:02This is very important to assess the capability of the Chinese Air Force, but
07:06as I said, I didn't find any information. If you have any, please add in the
07:11And while you are there, why not subscribe, or just become a channel supporter through
07:17Patreon or Subscribestar, or just becoming a member, just say.
07:21Ok, now, what all this hardware is good for?
07:30The Chinese doctrine, for a very long time, has been even more rigid than the Soviet
07:37doctrine. Pilots were expected to follow a flight plan, fire against the targets
07:43they were ordered to, when they were ordered to, with the weapons they were
07:47ordered to, by the ground controllers. The experience of the last 50 years has
07:52proven this doctrine to be ineffective, and actually, it was a waste of resources.
07:58In the late 90s and early 2000s, the whole of the Chinese military doctrine
08:04has been subject to a revision. The focus shifted from a popular war,
08:09based on guerrilla, limited operations, limited regional conflicts, and limited
08:17power projections beyond the borders. The Chinese are well aware that they still
08:22don't have the power projection capabilities of the United States, but for example,
08:26the bases in Djibouti and in Pakistan show where they are headed.
08:31So the Air Force has begun restructuring along these lines, for example,
08:35integrating expeditionary capabilities, or developing the know-how for maritime
08:41operations. Very important is the fact that the pilot's
08:45training syllabus has become more similar to the Western Air Force training.
08:49The Chinese now focus on the capability and the proficiency of the individual
08:53pilot within a command and control environment, which is relatively similar
08:58to the American one, even though I suppose they keep speaking Chinese.
09:01In the same way the Russians have evolved away from the Soviet model,
09:06the Chinese did the same, but they went even further.
09:10The interesting element, from my point of view, is that while the Russians have
09:14embraced asymmetry to confront a Western opponent, the Chinese are going full
09:19Monty. They are trying to match the West with a similar doctrine, but indigenous
09:25hardware.
09:29Those who follow this channel already know that I think that the
09:33quality of the combat force is largely determined by
09:36the logistics and the human element behind the hardware.
09:41The Chinese government has been willing to invest a large amount of money and
09:45resources in aerospace development. The Chinese had a sharp focus on improving
09:50the industry, and today they have at least two or three large
09:54complexes that are adequate to design and build modern combat aircraft.
09:59They also tend to use a very pragmatic approach, they introduce a new type
10:03without all the capabilities in place, but then they very quickly iterate
10:07where the technology was not available, the Chinese have established cooperation
10:11with foreign manufacturers, and sometimes they
10:14push the boundaries through reverse engineering.
10:17At the same time the Air Force is continuously developing new tactics
10:21around these new technologies. This capability of quickly iterating and
10:25moving forward with a large and unrelenting support from
10:31the government and the public is probably the single most important
10:36strong point of the Chinese Air Force. It is so not only because it is promoting
10:41development and catching up with the West, but is
10:44also providing a moving target to the potential
10:49opponents. And in fact the result of this policy is
10:52literally a deluge of radar, electronics, ECM,
10:58weapons of any kind, long range, short range,
11:02air-to-air, air-to-ground, drones, and anything else you can think of. It is
11:07really difficult to keep up with all these developments.
11:10Then, not everything is perfect, not even in China.
11:14Propulsion has greatly improved in the last years, but still the
11:17Chinese engines are not at the same level as the western ones.
11:22There is a gap in thrust-to-weight ratio, but
11:25mainly the gap is in reliability. They require more maintenance,
11:30and this means either using more resources
11:33to keep the sortie generation capability high,
11:38or reducing the sortie generation capability. Another weak point
11:42is in the air-to-ground domain, where a limited number of guided weapons
11:47is available, and even those weapons are
11:50mostly designed to attack static targets. For example, a missing element is a
11:56weapon in the class of the Maverick or the Brimstone,
11:59or even anything similar to the French AASM family. But, like everything in
12:06China, this situation is expected to change
12:09soon. Actually, this video in two years will
12:12probably be very outdated. Third and crucial element is
12:16training. As we said before, it has greatly, greatly improved, but is still
12:22not at the same level as the west. The Chinese still don't have a red flag,
12:26and they lack combat experience. But even in this case, the situation is
12:31quickly evolving. They have started something that they call competitions,
12:34where the pilots are pitted against different types of
12:38aircraft. They invited the Russians, they are trying to be creative in the
12:43tactics, and by the way, they don't have combat
12:47experience, because they didn't fight any war,
12:50and I believe we should all be happy for that. Nobody really knows what's going to
12:54happen in case the Chinese system should
12:57interact with western systems, because, well, it's complicated.
13:03However, if you want to learn more about what may happen, and the kind of
13:07consideration that we can do around this, please click on the videos that are
13:12going to appear beside me. And by the way, this helps the channel
13:16a lot. Thank you very much for watching, and see you there!