#MianAslamIqbal #PunjabAssembly #HabibAkram #MuzamalSuharwardy #IMF #banipti #government #PTI #MuzammilAslam #ShahbazRana
(Current Affairs)
Host:
- Maria Memon
Guests:
- Habib Akram (Analyst)
- Muzamal Suharwardy (Analyst)
- Muzzammil Aslam (Economist Analyst)
- Shahbaz Rana (Economist Analyst)
"Mian Aslam Iqbal Sahab ko waha ana chahiye tha," Muzamal Suharwardy's analysis
Bani PTi Ki Janib Se IMF Ko Likhay Jane Walay Khat Ke Manderjaat Kya Hon Ge??
Kya Mojooda Sorat e Haal Mein Bani PTI Ki Janib Se Khat Likhnay Ka Faisla Durust Hoga? ?
For the latest General Elections 2024 Updates ,Results, Party Position, Candidates and Much more Please visit our Election Portal: https://elections.arynews.tv
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
(Current Affairs)
Host:
- Maria Memon
Guests:
- Habib Akram (Analyst)
- Muzamal Suharwardy (Analyst)
- Muzzammil Aslam (Economist Analyst)
- Shahbaz Rana (Economist Analyst)
"Mian Aslam Iqbal Sahab ko waha ana chahiye tha," Muzamal Suharwardy's analysis
Bani PTi Ki Janib Se IMF Ko Likhay Jane Walay Khat Ke Manderjaat Kya Hon Ge??
Kya Mojooda Sorat e Haal Mein Bani PTI Ki Janib Se Khat Likhnay Ka Faisla Durust Hoga? ?
For the latest General Elections 2024 Updates ,Results, Party Position, Candidates and Much more Please visit our Election Portal: https://elections.arynews.tv
Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP
ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 Assalam-o-Alaikum, I am Maria Mehman from Top Stories.
00:16 The government has started its work.
00:18 The Punjab Assembly has taken up the task.
00:20 In a few days, the Prime Minister of Punjab will also take up the task.
00:22 Mareeb Nawaz Sharif Sahiba is here.
00:24 Most probably, she will talk about the number game in the first semester of the program.
00:28 The green signal of the IMF.
00:30 She is ready to work with the new government.
00:32 But the Justice Department says that they will also write a letter to the IMF.
00:36 And they will raise questions about the transparency of the current election process.
00:40 We will talk about this in the second semester of the program.
00:42 In the end, the situation is extremely bad.
00:44 The PTA has made the Sindh High Court completely deaf.
00:48 They have refused to obey the orders of the High Court.
00:50 I think this is the new normal in this country.
00:52 We will talk about this in the last semester of the program.
00:54 But let's start.
00:56 The first morning of the assembly, the PTA has started the process of the implementation of the constitution.
01:02 But today, there was no good omen for the democracy in Punjab.
01:06 If we look at the indicators and the proceedings of the day,
01:10 we see that the whole day was pushed into political turmoil.
01:16 First of all, Mian Aslam Iqbal, who is possibly the opposition leader,
01:22 was not seen anywhere today. He could not reach the IWAN.
01:26 Everyone was waiting for him.
01:28 But what kind of IWAN will this be?
01:30 Where the opposition leader of the IWAN, who is possibly Marim Nawaz,
01:34 could not reach there.
01:36 Then the police were standing there.
01:38 All the people who came there, the MPAs,
01:40 tried to create an atmosphere of some arrests.
01:42 This is also not a good omen for the democracy.
01:44 We also saw that the posters and slogans in the IWAN,
01:50 the politics of agitation, is usually done by the opposition.
01:52 But today we saw it from the government's side.
01:54 Will this be the new trend in Punjab for the next 4-5 years,
01:58 as long as the assembly is possible?
02:00 If we look at the possible government of Marim Nawaz in Punjab,
02:06 it is possible that the formalities will be removed.
02:08 There is no good start for that.
02:12 Who are these people who want to taint the government of Marim Nawaz from the beginning?
02:18 But there are still many issues that are a cause of confusion.
02:22 Because the special sessions of minorities and women,
02:24 have not been allotted to the movement.
02:26 If we look at Punjab, there are 36 sessions of women, 5 sessions of minorities.
02:32 The PMLN, People's Party, and Muslim League have sessions of women.
02:36 The same is the case with the Pakistan Party.
02:38 The Sunni Ijtihad, the free movement of PTI,
02:42 whose expected number is 24 sessions of women and 3 sessions of minorities,
02:48 has not been allotted yet.
02:50 If the number is given after the special sessions,
02:54 the PMLN has 201, and is currently in the lead.
02:58 If the Sunni Ijtihad Council and PTI's Ijtihad do not get 24,
03:02 then it is close to 106, but if they get it, they will cross the 130 number.
03:06 People's Party, Muslim League Kaaf, IPP, Muslim League Zia, and TLP,
03:10 are currently the number game in Punjab's assembly.
03:14 But why are the special sessions not being allotted to the movement?
03:18 There are many opinions on this by various experts.
03:22 In the legal matters, the first thing that Kabir Dilshahat said,
03:28 is that the Election Commission will look into this matter.
03:30 There are some legal obstacles in this.
03:32 Can this be done under the Election Act or not?
03:36 What is his opinion?
03:38 After the Sunni Ijtihad Council's request,
03:42 the Election Commission of Pakistan has the right to decide
03:48 whether their request is correct under the Election Act 104, subsection 4,
03:56 or what are the rights of the Election Commission of Pakistan.
04:00 The Election Commission of Pakistan has the right to use its own rights.
04:06 And it will decide under the Election Act.
04:10 So, obviously, the Election Commission of Pakistan has to decide
04:14 whether it is Article 924 or Section 104 of the Election Act.
04:22 So, this decision will be made, according to Kabir Dilshahat.
04:26 Ahmed Bilal Mehboob has drawn our attention to the Baap Party's free sessions in 2019.
04:32 He said that the precedence is there.
04:34 The elections were held in 2018, but the sessions were held in 2019.
04:38 What is Ahmed Bilal Mehboob's opinion on this?
04:40 In 2019, after the merger of FATA, the elections of the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly,
04:46 the three free candidates there had set the foundation of a parliamentary party,
04:52 the Balochistan Awaami Party, of Baap.
04:56 And Baap, although they did not give a list of their own special sessions,
05:02 they were still allowed to form a party,
05:06 and they were also allocated a session from among the women's sessions.
05:12 So, since this has started from Punjab,
05:16 all these questions should be asked in the context of the Punjab Assembly itself.
05:20 Shouldn't the Sunni Tariq-e-Insaf Council get these sessions?
05:24 Should it move forward in this direction?
05:26 Shouldn't this event be completed in numbers?
05:30 And if everyone wants to move this system forward,
05:32 then the vibrancy that is required in a democracy of the opposition,
05:36 shouldn't it be made possible that it not only reaches the event,
05:40 but that their parliamentary role is facilitated there?
05:44 Or will we see that, as has been the case in the last two and a half years,
05:48 the same pattern will continue,
05:50 and as a result, the dream of everyone, the desire of everyone,
05:54 is not fulfilled?
05:56 This is a very important question mark from all of us.
05:59 In the first part of the program, Habib Akram Sahib is with us,
06:01 Muzamil Saurwardy Sahib is also with us.
06:03 Let's take advantage of their presence,
06:05 because what has happened in Iwan today,
06:07 let's hope that all the political prisoners are released.
06:13 The people who are raising questions about the mandate,
06:17 let's hope that the tribunals decide on it soon.
06:19 Because if the foundation is crooked,
06:21 then the building can never be straight.
06:23 Muzamil Sahib, let's start with you.
06:25 The way the whole matter has started today,
06:27 do you think that the system is moving towards a revolution?
06:31 Yes, the transition of power has never been silent on the side of justice.
06:37 I remember during the time of Admitmat,
06:39 and after that, when in Punjab,
06:41 during the time of Hamza Shahbaz's defeat,
06:43 Umar Safraz Sahib refused to accept defeat,
06:46 and then Speaker Raja Pravez Ashraf Sahib was ordered by the Lahore High Court,
06:51 that you come and accept defeat,
06:53 because the Governor was refusing to accept defeat.
06:55 So this has been a pattern in Punjab, in the Central Government,
06:59 from the ruling to the transition of power.
07:03 Even today, the work that the Speaker should have done in half an hour,
07:07 when he had given the time of 10 o'clock,
07:09 he could have easily come at 10.30 or 11 o'clock,
07:12 he could have accepted defeat,
07:14 all the people in Irqan,
07:16 because he is an outgoing Speaker now,
07:18 he does not have any role,
07:20 he has to accept defeat and elect a new Speaker.
07:23 But he kept on prolonging it,
07:25 and kept on trying to create turmoil,
07:28 in the end, sense prevailed,
07:30 and he accepted defeat.
07:32 I thought that like Umar Safraz,
07:34 he would also say that he would not accept defeat,
07:36 and then the courts would have to intervene,
07:39 that if the outgoing Speaker does not accept defeat,
07:41 then what will be done in the Constitution?
07:43 Because the Constitution has not perceived such things,
07:45 that sometimes a group will come,
07:47 which will create such hurdles in the transition of power.
07:50 Like it was never thought that the Governor would refuse to accept defeat,
07:54 it was never thought that the President would refuse to accept defeat,
07:59 so the Constitution had not thought of such things,
08:01 that such a group would come,
08:03 which would create such hurdles in the path of transition of power.
08:07 But the Constitution had not thought that the opposition,
08:11 who is possibly Mian Aslam Iqbal,
08:13 would not be able to reach the IWAN,
08:15 the Constitution had not thought that when people would come out,
08:17 or opposition people would come to take the vote,
08:19 there would be such a big crowd outside the police station,
08:21 and it would not be facilitated,
08:23 but there would still be a fear.
08:25 We are seeing a lot of first timers this time, right?
08:29 No, you are not seeing first timers.
08:32 During the assembly proceedings,
08:34 security in Punjab has been very high,
08:37 and you are not seeing first timers.
08:39 And the second thing is that today there was a protest call
08:42 from the Tehreek-e-Insaf outside,
08:44 and possibly to stop that protest,
08:47 the presence of the police was necessary,
08:49 because when you had given the protest call,
08:52 if the police had been sitting at home,
08:54 then you would have asked,
08:56 where were the police on 9th May, why did the police not stop?
08:59 And if the police had come to stop,
09:01 then you would have asked, why did they come?
09:03 They had the audacity to come and stand there.
09:06 So there are arguments on both sides.
09:08 If they are present, then it is a question,
09:10 and if they are not present, then it is a question.
09:13 But it is also true that
09:15 Mian Aslam Iqbal should have come there,
09:18 when he had the bail from the Peshawar High Court,
09:21 then he should have come there, why did he not come?
09:24 If he had come and they had been stopped,
09:26 then we could have asked a question,
09:28 and if they would not have come from home,
09:30 then what question is there in relation to their coming?
09:32 There is no such thing in the constitution,
09:34 that a special car will be sent to pick them up.
09:37 Hmm, okay.
09:38 Habib Akram Sahab, today's whole day,
09:40 because today is the beginning of Mariam Sahiba's parliamentary politics.
09:43 So these small indicators, these small matters,
09:46 because they have to set a tone for the next 3-4 years,
09:50 or 5 years, we hope that the assemblies should be completed in this country,
09:54 but what to do, our past examples,
09:57 are a trauma for us, that this does not happen.
10:01 But anyway, the tone that had to be set today,
10:04 how did you interpret that?
10:07 Look Maria, this tone is actually the climax of what has been happening in the last 2 years.
10:13 Especially when in April 2022, the central government went,
10:17 and after that the Punjab government went,
10:19 came, then went, and after that the assembly broke.
10:22 So, from that onwards, the discriminatory treatment that is being done,
10:26 from a special party, and in this case, Pakistan Tariq-e-Insaf,
10:30 so this is the climax of what we have seen today.
10:34 And especially in an environment where questions are being raised about the election,
10:38 the entire Pakistan, the media from Pakistan, the media outside Pakistan,
10:42 the people inside Pakistan, are not satisfied with the outcome of this election.
10:46 They are not satisfied with the outcome because of the results that the Election Commission has issued.
10:51 A lot of people think that this is not a translation of the public's desires,
10:55 but rather there are some issues that are present in this, which are problematic.
10:59 So, in such an environment, when a very big party in Pakistan,
11:04 and it is now the single largest party,
11:06 so when there are questions raised about the mandate of that party,
11:10 that the mandate that should have been there is not there,
11:15 and its mandate has been put in someone else's pocket,
11:18 then obviously, you cannot expect in Pakistan's politics that all the good kids will be here,
11:24 and that good thoughts will be expressed for each other,
11:29 or that the assembly proceedings will go smoothly.
11:32 The second thing is that the tested Hikmat-e-Amli that Pakistan Muslim League had invented,
11:39 you must remember that when the first National Assembly was being held in 2018,
11:44 in that first meeting, the opposition, which later became the government,
11:49 the workers of the Pakistan Muslim League, what did they do?
11:54 They created an environment where it was impossible to even give a speech for the then elected Prime Minister.
12:00 So, now the seeds that were sown, it is time to cut them.
12:05 Now, if anyone here understands that we should see a smooth transition in Pakistan,
12:10 or we should see a smooth assembly, that we have done a very democratic exercise,
12:16 so now there are some outcomes, so one is that that democratic exercise is taking place.
12:21 There are about 200 seats on which questions are being asked,
12:24 and they are being forced to sit in Pakistan, including the National Assembly and the Parliament.
12:28 Now, the Election Tribunals, the Election Commission, are raising their fingers for its role.
12:34 When the Election Tribunals are being formed, there are a lot of concerns and threats from them.
12:39 So, the road ahead of Pakistan's politics, I see a lot of ups and downs in it.
12:45 What is the solution to this ups and downs, Mr. Soharwardy?
12:50 If you want stability in the elections, if you want to complete the numbers in your assembly,
12:57 then solve the problem of these special seats and move forward,
13:01 so that if you want to run the elections, you don't need the opposition,
13:04 and then there will be another cycle of seats.
13:07 [Hindi]
13:36 [Hindi]
13:39 [Hindi]
14:07 [Hindi]
14:16 [Hindi]
14:21 [Hindi]
14:25 [Hindi]
14:28 [Hindi]
14:34 [Hindi]
14:43 [Hindi]
14:56 [Hindi]
15:17 [Hindi]
15:38 [Hindi]
16:06 [Hindi]
16:09 [Hindi]
16:27 [Hindi]
16:51 [Hindi]
16:58 [Hindi]
17:01 [Hindi]
17:14 [Hindi]
17:42 [Hindi]
17:52 [Hindi]
18:02 [Hindi]
18:12 [Hindi]
18:22 [Hindi]
18:32 [Hindi]
18:42 [Hindi]
18:52 [Hindi]
19:02 [Hindi]
19:12 [Hindi]
19:22 [Hindi]
19:32 [Hindi]
19:42 [Hindi]
19:52 [Hindi]
20:02 [Hindi]
20:12 [Hindi]
20:22 [Hindi]
20:35 [Hindi]
21:04 [Hindi]
21:14 [Hindi]
21:24 [Hindi]
21:34 [Hindi]
22:00 [Hindi]
22:10 [Hindi]
22:20 [Hindi]
22:28 [Hindi]
22:38 [Hindi]
22:48 [Hindi]
22:58 [Hindi]
23:08 [Hindi]
23:18 [Hindi]
23:28 [Hindi]
23:48 [Hindi]
24:08 [Hindi]
24:28 [Hindi]
24:38 [Hindi]
24:48 [Hindi]
24:58 [Hindi]
25:08 [Hindi]
25:18 [Hindi]
25:28 [Hindi]
25:38 [Hindi]
25:48 [Hindi]
25:58 [Hindi]
26:08 [Hindi]
26:18 [Hindi]
26:28 [Hindi]
26:38 [Hindi]
26:48 [Hindi]
26:58 [Hindi]
27:08 [Hindi]
27:18 [Hindi]
27:28 [Hindi]
27:38 [Hindi]
27:48 [Hindi]
27:58 [Hindi]
28:08 [Hindi]
28:18 [Hindi]
28:28 [Hindi]
28:38 [Hindi]
28:48 [Hindi]
28:58 [Hindi]
29:08 [Hindi]
29:18 [Hindi]
29:28 [Hindi]
29:38 [Hindi]
29:48 [Hindi]
29:58 [Hindi]
30:08 [Hindi]
30:18 [Hindi]
30:28 [Hindi]
30:38 [Hindi]
30:48 [Hindi]
30:58 [Hindi]
31:08 [Hindi]
31:18 [Hindi]
31:28 [Hindi]
31:38 [Hindi]
31:48 [Hindi]
31:58 [Hindi]
32:08 [Hindi]
32:18 [Hindi]
32:28 [Hindi]
32:38 [Hindi]
32:48 [Hindi]
32:58 [Hindi]
33:08 [Hindi]
33:18 [Hindi]
33:28 [Hindi]
33:38 [Hindi]
33:48 [Hindi]
33:58 [Hindi]
34:08 [Hindi]
34:18 [Hindi]
34:28 [Hindi]
34:38 [Hindi]
34:48 [Hindi]
34:58 [Hindi]
35:08 [Hindi]
35:18 [Hindi]
35:28 [Hindi]
35:38 [Hindi]
35:48 [Hindi]
35:58 [Hindi]
36:08 [Hindi]
36:18 [Hindi]
36:28 [Hindi]
36:38 [Hindi]
36:48 [Hindi]
36:58 [Hindi]
37:08 [Hindi]
37:18 [Hindi]