Body of Evidence 1993 With Eng Sub (Unrated)
A lawyer defends a woman accused of killing her older lover by having sex with him.
Transcript
00:00:04(loud roar)
00:00:11(thunder rumbling)
00:00:17(rain pattering)
00:00:23(gentle music)
00:01:24(heavy breathing)
00:01:29(woman moans)
00:01:35- [Woman] Yeah!
00:01:41(woman moaning)
00:01:47(man panting)
00:02:08(woman panting)
00:02:22(man groans)
00:02:49- [Officer] All right, easy.
00:02:50(police radio chattering)
00:02:54- Lousy morning for it.
00:02:56- Mr. Andrew Marsh, bagged and tagged.
00:02:59Better him than us, huh?
00:03:00- So what did him in?
00:03:01- Looks like cardiac arrest,
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
21
22
23
(people chattering)
(woman moaning)
- [Bob] Nice quality.
- [Investigator] Nice ass.
- [Reese] That was the tape in the VCR
and the power was still on.
- So the sucker had a heart
attack watching his home movies.
00:03:41What do you need me for?
00:03:42- He was tied up.
00:03:43I've heard remote, but.
00:03:45- What the hell is this?
00:03:48- That is a nipple clamp.
00:03:51- How would you know?
00:03:52- He's from LA.
00:03:53- I just happen to be a
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
45
46
she had him handcuffed.
Who found the body?
- His secretary came by to pick
up some papers this morning.
00:04:14Hell of a shock.
00:04:16You want to talk to her?
00:04:17- She wouldn't leave.
00:04:18Thought we were gonna steal the silver.
00:04:19- Well, can you blame her?
00:04:24- Do you want me to identify her?
00:04:26It's Rebecca Carlson.
00:04:28- His girlfriend.
00:04:29And they had a date last night
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
will raise him up in glory.
Thenof your presence, Lord Jesus.
00:05:10In the name of the Father
00:05:12and of the Son and of
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
70
71
- Excuse me.
- [Priest] We ask this
through Christ our Lord.
00:05:29Amen.
00:05:31Go in peace with Christ.
00:05:32Thanks be to God.
00:05:35(people chattering)
00:05:51- [Frank] Miss Carlson?
00:05:53I'm sorry I'm late.
00:05:55I'm Frank Dulaney.
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
83
84
charges filed against you.
- But there will be
Do you think I killed him?
- That's a question 1
never ask my clients.
00:06:20What matters is whether the
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
91
92
93
with a wealthy older man.
- He wasn't old to me.
- I'm sorry I said that.
- A big part of my life
has been taken away from me
00:06:45and people are saying it was my fault.
00:06:49They've taken something good
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
109
110
111
112
113
narrow view of love.
- Well
Did he have any family?
- Lots of wives
- Sharon.
- The register broke down again.
- It's the register.
You gonna be here for a while?
- NoT
00:07:33- I have to lock up tonight.
00:07:35- Why don't you hire a manager?
00:07:37- Because at least I won't
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
129
- Over here!
- [Sharon] Jamie
(chuckles)
- [Jamie] Saw some friends.
- Those are your friends?
These are my friends.
- Can you really screw someone to death?
- No.
Besidesworry about that stuff yet.
00:08:18Do you?
00:08:20- No.
00:08:22- Because you are a good-looking guy.
00:08:25Let's go.
00:08:38- [Officer] Okay, let's go.
00:08:41- [Reese] A neighbor saw you
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
150
151
honesty and cooperation.
- Bullshit.
- When did you leave his house?
- Around midnight
If I had known it was going to matter
I would've paid more attention.
(whispers)
Well
There's nothing wrong with saying that.
- Miss Carlson
- Cocaine use is illegal
in the state of Oregon.
00:09:19- I've never used it in Oregon.
00:09:20(chuckles)
00:09:25- Okay, can we move on, please?
00:09:27- Did Mr. Marsh use cocaine?
00:09:29- Never.
00:09:32- The toxicology tests came
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
169
170
171
172
173
Marsh's heart condition?
- He had a little arrhythmia.
That's not a heart condition.
- Mr. Marsh had an advanced
case of heart disease.
00:09:59- He said it wasn't serious.
00:10:02- Now, why would he lie to you about it?
00:10:05- I never know why men lie.
00:10:08They just do.
00:10:10
00:10:14- Would you describe
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
191
192
think that'll be necessary.
- Reese.
- Right.
Rebecca Carlson
you're under arrest for
the murder of Andrew Marsh.
00:10:41You have the right to remain silent.
00:10:42Anything you say can and
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
201
202
203
204
205
name on the front page?
You fucking sandbagged me!
- Jesus
Don't take it personal.
You're spending too much
time around criminals.
00:11:05It affects your judgment.
00:11:06- You don't have probable cause.
00:11:07- Sure, I do.
00:11:08Marsh's will leaves all
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
to have myself indicted.
- This case is ridiculous.
Drop the chargesthe state some money.
00:11:31You can't convict.
00:11:32- In conjunction with cocaine
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
230
231
years
- [Reporter] There they are.
- Frank--
(reporters chattering)
00:11:59- [Reporter] Were you with
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
241
242
243
244
245
you weren't in the will.
- Andrew put me in his will?
- Don't start jerking me around
You're the primary beneficiary.
- How much?
Well
Come on
- Eight million
- That's a hell of a motive.
- I know how Bobby works.
He's gonna build his
case on your sex life.
00:13:12He's gonna drag out every dirty
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
260
261
262
263
are gonna be sitting
in the jury box listening to Garrett say
how you led Andrew into perversion.
- I didn't have to lead him anywhere.
Andrew knew exactly what he wanted.
All we did was make love.
- In handcuffs.
- It was differentit was still making love.
00:13:54Have you ever seen
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
283
284
anyone who might want him dead.
- I'm hitting all the dealers with a list
of their nearest and dearest.
Maybe we'll get lucky
and come up with a user.
00:15:52- Joanne Braslow is here.
00:15:54- [Frank] Uh-huh.
00:15:55- Garrett brought donuts.
00:15:56- [Frank] The man's considerate.
00:15:57- Yeah, but he always eats them all.
00:16:02- It wasn't normal.
00:16:04They didn't have normal sex.
00:16:06- How do you know what
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
299
toys all over the place.
- Would you characterize your feelings
toward my client as negative?
- I don't have much
sympathy for drug users.
00:16:28- Do you have personal
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
305
306
307
308
309
and she was spooning coke
from one of those little vials.
- What did she say when she saw you?
- She was too busy to notice.
- And did you tell your
boss what you had seen?
00:17:00- No.
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
329
330
331
332
been in the house
while I was there?
- Do you know the expression smoking gun?
- Frank
Don't you see that?
- Andrew Marsh must've been
a pretty goddamn lovable guy.
00:17:54Everybody was in love with him!
00:17:55- Besides, I haven't
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
ready whenever you are.
- Thank you.
Supposed to be on my side
Could've at least given me
the benefit of the doubt.
00:19:34- You're right.
00:19:36I'm sorry.
00:19:37- [Rebecca] You mind waiting 15 minutes?
00:19:39- [Frank] Not at all.
00:19:41- Look around.
00:19:43(gentle music)
00:19:59Just a little pain in the lumbar.
00:20:24(thunder crackling)
00:20:31(cat mewing)
00:20:40- Here, pussy-puss.
00:20:43Hello, kitty.
00:20:45Oh, such a beautiful kitty.
00:20:51Yes, kitty.
00:20:53Yes, yes, yes.
00:21:18- [Rebecca] Is it still raining?
00:21:22- Uh, yeah.
00:21:27- Can you drive me home?
00:21:29- [Frank] Sure.
00:21:29I'll give you a ride home.
00:21:38I've never been in one of these.
00:21:40- Now's your chance.
00:21:57Come in.
00:21:58- [Frank] It's a bad idea.
00:22:00- Why?
00:22:01- I'm your lawyer.
00:22:02Doesn't look good.
00:22:05- Nobody's looking.
00:22:09- Goodnight, Rebecca.
00:22:13- Frank.
00:22:14- Yeah?
00:22:22Are you scared?
00:22:24- Not if you tell me I shouldn't be.
00:22:28- We're gonna kick their ass!
00:22:36- [Bailiff] All rise.
00:22:39Superior Court for the county of Multnomah
00:22:41is now in session.
00:22:42The Honorable Judge
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
405
406
407
408
409
410
proceed
- Yes
Andrew Marsh made what turned
out to be a fatal mistake.
00:23:18He fell in love.
00:23:20He fell in love with a
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
416
417
defendant
but as this trial proceeds
you will see she's not only the defendant
she is the murder weapon itself.
If I hit you and you dieam the cause of your death,
00:23:47but can I be called a weapon?
00:23:50The answer is yes.
00:23:52And what a deadly weapon
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
426
until he rewrote his will
leaving her $8 million.
That she insisted on
increasingly strenuous sex,
00:24:10knowing he had a severe heart condition,
00:24:13and when that didn't
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
435
than a gun or a knife
or any other instrument used as a weapon.
She's a killer
and the worst kind
a killer who disguised
herself as a loving partner.
00:24:56- Mr. Dulaney.
00:24:58- Ladies and gentlemen, you
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
443
444
by what you hear.
But I want you to remember
that Rebecca Carlson is not on
trial for her sexual tastes.
00:25:18She is being tried for murder
00:25:21and to charge her with
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
451
built on fantasy
And the factsare entirely circumstantial.
00:25:40It's not a crime to be a beautiful woman.
00:25:43It's not a crime to fall
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
458
evidence objectively
you will acquit Rebecca Carlson
of the charges against her.
00:26:03- [Bob] Dr. McCurdy, did
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
462
membranes were way too smooth
for even occasional use.
- Were you able to determine
how he ingested this drug?
00:26:21- A bottle of nasal spray
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
467
at the time of his death.
I believe that he was drugged
without his knowledge.
00:26:31- Objection!
00:26:32Lack of foundation.
00:26:33The witness is speculating.
00:26:35Motion to strike the testimony.
00:26:37- [Mabel] So ordered, and
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
476
477
478
479
in Mr. Marsh's condition?
- It would accelerate his heartbeat.
- And if he were having sex
while under the influence
of such a stimulant?
00:27:04- It would be the same as
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
487
488
wrists and on the bedstead
I believe that the victim was handcuffed.
- At the time of his death?
- Oh
The bruising and the
friction was quite extensive.
00:27:28- Thank you, Dr. McCurdy.
00:27:30Your witness.
00:27:33- Dr. McCurdy, you testified
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
503
the throes of sexual ecstasy?
- I suppose.
- Did you find any older marks
that indicated the use of restraints?
- Just on his ankles.
- Where they wouldn't show in public.
- Objection!
Counsel's drawing his own conclusion.
- Sustained.
You know better
- Dr. McCurdy
that Mr. Marsh didn't decide to get high?
- Well
that a man in his set of circumstances--
- Dr. McCurdya licensed psychiatrist?
00:28:28- No, but--
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
525
Mr. Marsh had any common sense?
You just testified he
liked unpleasant things.
00:28:51- Your Honor.
00:28:56- No further questions.
00:28:59- It's going to be a long
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
531
532
physician at Memorial Hospital.
- Were you on duty the night
of February 5th this year?
00:29:15- I was the admitting physician.
00:29:17Yes, I was.
00:29:18- Did you admit Andrew Marsh?
00:29:20- Yes, I did.
00:29:21- What was the reason?
00:29:23- Cocaine poisoning.
00:29:25- Did Mr. Marsh discuss
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
543
544
it was the first time
he tried cocaine and it
was going to be the last.
00:29:43- Would you describe
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
555
556
557
558
559
ever tried cocaine again
he would be committing suicide.
- [Bob] Your witness.
- [Frank] No questions for
this witness, Your Honor.
00:30:28- [Bob] And did you see Mr. Marsh
00:30:30the day before he died, Miss Braslow?
00:30:32- Yes.
00:30:33- [Bob] How did he look?
00:30:34- He was pale and sweating.
00:30:36- Did you talk about Miss Carlson?
00:30:39- Yes.
00:30:40- And what did he say?
00:30:42- That he was worried.
00:30:44I was worried.
00:30:46He said that if she kept it
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
583
584
585
about moving back to Chicago?
- Yes
- So
was thinking about leaving.
Couldn't that have caused the stress
and anxiety you observed?
- Objection!
Calls for rank speculation.
- Counsel for the prosecution
has already used this witness
00:31:37to establish the state
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
597
598
599
600
601
that you saw Rebecca
inhaling cocaine in the bathroom.
How do you know it was cocaine?
- It was a white powder.
- Were you ever a patient
at the Mount Hood Substance Abuse Center?
- Objection!
Your Honormedical history is--
00:32:18- Your Honor, the prosecution
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
611
line of questioning.
- I'll allow it.
- Weren't you a patient
at the Mount Hood Substance Abuse Center
from January 5th to
February 5th, two years ago?
00:32:37- Yes.
00:32:38- And what were you being treated for?
00:32:45- Substance and alcohol abuse.
00:32:47- And was that substance cocaine?
00:32:53- Was that substance cocaine?
00:32:58- Yes.
00:33:00- And didn't you supply
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
624
- No!
- Your Honor
a copy of the admissions report.
The square right here
is designated for the signature
of the responsible party,
00:33:20the person who brought
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
to steal strawberries.
I'd sneak into the neighbor's
yard at the end of the street.
00:34:35And I remember they had a big fence.
00:34:39And I'd always scrape my
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
654
655
656
657
658
659
was a huge crowd of people
but we just saw each other and we knew.
- Just like that?
- Yeah.
- Look around.
- You want me to look around the room
and tell you if there's someone here
that has the same taste that I do?
- That's right.
- Okay.
- All right.
Who?
- I'm not gonna tell you.
- You're not gonna tell me?
- [Rebecca] No
- Why not?
- Because he doesn't know it yet.
Yes
- What would?
- You and I making love.
- Is that what you think I was thinking?
- There's nothing wrong with admitting
that you want me
- You take a lot for granted.
- Frank.
Go home.
Thanks for dinner.
- Goodnight.
(gentle music)
- Frank.
(groans)
(loud rip)
(groans)
Uh-uh.
My way.
Are you scared?
- No.
(groans)
(panting)
(Rebecca moans)
(panting)
(Rebecca moaning)
(alarm beeping)
- [Sharon] Would you
see if Michael's up yet?
00:48:43- [Frank] Uh-huh.
00:48:46- The people would like to recall
00:48:48Dr. Alan Paley to the stand.
00:48:50(people murmuring)
00:49:09- Dr. Paley, you're still under oath here.
00:49:11Take it seriously.
00:49:15- Do you know Rebecca Carlson?
00:49:18- [Alan] Yes.
00:49:19- Did you, in fact, date Miss Carlson?
00:49:22(people murmuring)
00:49:25- Yes, we dated.
00:49:26(people murmuring)
00:49:27(gavel bangs)
00:49:28- Keep your rude mouths shut
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
718
719
720
721
722
723
724
725
in particular about him?
- She wanted to know whether
cocaine would kill him
00:50:01if he tried it again.
00:50:03- And what did you say?
00:50:04- I told her it would
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
738
739
740
599
to answer the question.
- No.
- No
- No
- Because she refused
to have sex with you,
00:50:43isn't that correct?
00:50:44- Objection!
00:50:45Your Honor, the counsel
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
750
751
just bottom-feeding
you're going to choke on the mud.
- I'm working toward a
specific point, Your Honor.
00:51:02- Work fast.
00:51:03I'm getting tired of seeing
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
758
759
760
to force yourself on her
in the parking lot?
- Objection!
- Because I can bring
in the parking attendant
00:51:31and two customers to refresh
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
766
time you saw Rebecca
until appearing in court
- I told youthe last time I saw her.
00:51:45- In fact, didn't you
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
775
776
777
where this tape is from
or who made itwhat circumstances.
00:52:04- May I approach?
00:52:05I have reports from two
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
784
and there's been no tampering.
- I'll allow it.
(beeps)
- [Alan] I know you're there.
Pick up the phone
You think I won't do it?
(beeps)
Rebecca?
I can put you awayfor the rest of your life!
00:52:54You better call me or you're fucked
00:52:55either one way or the other.
00:53:00(cassette player beeping)
00:53:04- What did you mean, Dr. Paley?
00:53:10You never told her about
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
814
815
816
817
817
819
820
821
817
823
824
825
826
has never been mentioned
by the prosecution.
- Our investigators
didn't contact Mr. Roston
00:58:18until yesterday afternoon in New York.
00:58:20- What took so long?
00:58:21- [Bob] He just came home
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
833
- That's it
Take a seat.
- Mr. Rostonrelationship with Miss Carlson?
00:58:46- We were lovers.
00:58:48- [Bob] How long were you together?
00:58:49- [Jeffrey] For about a year.
00:58:51- How would you describe
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
844
845
she wanted in my condition.
- What condition is that?
- I had a bad heart.
(people murmuring)
- Frank.
- What happened next?
- [Jeffrey] I had bypass surgery.
- And how are you now?
- I'm fine.
My doctor says I can live
to be a very old man.
00:59:53- How did your relationship
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
864
865
866
intense
- [Jeffrey] Wellif she were trying to push me
01:00:26as far as she could.
01:00:28- Can you give the court an example?
01:00:32- Sex was a game to her.
01:00:35She got off on the control.
01:00:38She always used to tell
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
882
883
884
885
886
(gavel banging)
- Bailiff
everyone except the reporters.
(door thuds)
- After she tied you upRoston, what did she do next?
01:02:07- She started...
01:02:12Masturbating
01:02:14and telling me how much
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
914
915
916
917
918
919
920
921
922
every man I ever had sex with?
- No
who put you in their wills!
- You think I killed Andrew.
- So does everyone in that courtroom!
You made me look like shit in there!
- You are not on trial!
- Oh
I must've been out of my mind
to get involved with you.
01:04:24- To make love to me?
01:04:26- Yes.
01:04:28But I'm not gonna compound my mistakes.
01:04:31You're my client, that's it.
01:04:32I don't want to have anything
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
949
950
951
952
the time to screw your client!
- That's paranoid.
- Oh
(cutlery clattering)
(groans)
01:05:37Fine.
01:05:42- Sharon!
01:05:43Sharon!
01:05:48Sharon.
01:05:49Sharon!
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
968
969
to this bullshit gossip!
- I talked to her!
- What?
- She called here tonight looking for you!
- What did she say?
- She didn't have to say anything.
I could here it in her voice
and the way that she said your name.
- You're making this up.
- What did she do to you
How did you get those marks on your chest?
What are they?
What are they?
Bites?
What happened to your back?
I thought we were happy.
I thought we were a family.
I trusted you.
- It has nothing to do with you.
- You're a son of a bitch.
How dare you stand there
and say that to me?
01:07:06- I love you.
01:07:08You're my wife.
01:07:11- Go pack some things.
01:07:12I don't wanna see you when I get home.
01:07:16- Please, Sharon, I don't wanna lose you.
01:07:19- Then you shouldn't have fucked her.
01:07:35- [Frank] Rebecca!
01:07:39- Frank?
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1003
1004
1005
all the nasty details?
Maybe I gave her some advice.
Or maybe I called to reassure her
that it was over between us.
Maybe that's what I said.
Gets easy
(Rebecca moans)
(Rebecca moans)
(Rebecca breathes heavily)
(rattling)
(Frank grunts)
Frank.
- Let's play another game.
(Rebecca groans)
(Rebecca screams)
(Frank groans)
- [Rebecca] You fuck.
(moans)
(both panting)
- Frank!
(knocking)
01:12:06Frank, get up!
01:12:07Conference room.
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1036
1037
was the end of the show.
Now
It's been erasednot quite all of it.
01:12:47Uh-huh.
01:12:48Uh-huh.
01:12:51This was during his artsy phase,
01:12:53before he went back to using the tripod.
01:13:09- [Frank] "We had a
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1048
(door creaks)
(people murmuring)
- Miss Braslowdid you stand to inherit
01:13:51before Mr. Marsh modified
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1056
1057
1058
1059
1060
1061
1062
woman and you still--
- You're making it sound--
- Find kind things
01:14:20to say about the man.
01:14:21- Objection!
01:14:22Counsel's arguing with the witness.
01:14:23Move to strike, Your Honor.
01:14:25- I'll sustain it and
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1070
1071
1072
1073
1074
1060
1076
1077
1078
1079
1080
1081
1079
1083
1084
1085
cruel of him to confide in you
about Rebecca after
he'd broken up with you?
01:15:15- Objection!
01:15:16The testimony has no relevance
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1098
1099
him everything she wanted.
- But you didn't?
- Objection!
Counsel's putting the witness on trial.
- I loved him.
I never would've hurt him.
- Even if he asked?!
- Your Honor.
- That's enough
The objection's sustained and
strike Mr. Delaney's question.
01:16:15Now, was that your entire
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1114
1115
1083
1117
1083
him because he had a cold?
You sighed a house charge
for nasal spray on April 8th,
01:16:41the date of Andrew Marshall's death.
01:16:45I'd like to introduce the receipt
01:16:47from Montclair Pharmacy as exhibit H.
01:16:55That was the bottle used to kill him.
01:16:58There was no other nasal
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1129
(gavel banging)
- No!
- You're outta line
Strike his remarks.
- I don't think I wanna
answer any more questions
01:17:20without an attorney.
01:17:29(people murmuring)
01:17:32- She killed him.
01:17:34She set me up to take the fall
01:17:35and she almost got away with it.
01:17:37- You know what bothers me?
01:17:39Why did she charge a three-buck
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1144
1145
1146
1147
1148
1149
supposed to convince the jury?
They can't wait to convict me.
- [Frank] All you need
is a reasonable doubt.
01:18:10- But I know how their minds work.
01:18:12The women hate me, they think I'm a whore.
01:18:15And the men see a cold, heartless bitch
01:18:17they can pay back for every chick
01:18:18that's ever blown them off in a bar.
01:18:20- You have an inflated
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1164
1165
1166
1167
1168
1169
1170
being guilty as charged.
I'm not gonna let you fuck up my case.
- You owe me the chance to explain
(sighs)
(toilet flushing)
- Wish me luck.
(loud slap)
- [Frank] The defense calls
Rebecca Carlson to the stand.
01:20:06(people chattering)
01:20:32- [Bailiff] Solemnly
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1181
1182
to recount
the events on the night of April 8th.
- We came home from dinner early
and Andrew still had a cold
so I thought I'd just put
him to bed and go home.
01:20:59- [Frank] But you didn't go home, did you?
01:21:01- No.
01:21:03He wanted to make love.
01:21:06And that made me want to.
01:21:08He was a very physical man.
01:21:10- [Frank] Would you say you loved him?
01:21:12- Very much.
01:21:13- [Frank] Then why didn't you marry him?
01:21:17- Because his marriages never lasted.
01:21:20I wanted to last.
01:21:23- [Frank] Rebecca, you
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1201
1202
(people murmuring)
For you to use on him while you made love?
- Yes.
He liked that.
He was always in charge
in his life and his work.
01:21:46And in bed, he liked to have
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1212
Andrew indicate to you
that he was having any problems at all
like shortness of breath
while you were making love that night?
- No.
He was fine.
- [Frank] And after you
finished making love,
01:22:11what did you do?
01:22:12- I kissed him goodnight and I went home.
01:22:15- And when did you find out he was dead?
01:22:18(sighs)
01:22:18- Not until the next day.
01:22:21- And when did you find out
01:22:22you were a beneficiary of Andrew's will?
01:22:25- When you told me.
01:22:28- Your witness.
01:22:37- I'm less interested in your relationship
01:22:40with Andrew Marsh,
01:22:41the nature of which you've
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1234
his patient
- [Rebecca] Must've
been about four months.
01:23:00- [Bob] Four months in which
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1241
1242
1243
1244
1245
1246
1247
(people murmuring)
- Is it your sworn testimony
that by coincidence alone
01:23:25you happened to date both Andrew Marsh,
01:23:27who died from a combination
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1252
1253
dated a woman you dated.
(people chattering)
(sighs)
- Do you think you're
capable of just answering
01:23:47the questions put to you?
01:23:51- I'm just trying to explain myself.
01:23:57- The night of Mr. Marsh's death,
01:23:59were you watching a pornographic videotape
01:24:02you'd made of yourselves?
01:24:03- Objection as to the characterization.
01:24:07- An explicit videotape?
01:24:10- Well, Andrew used to say,
01:24:11"Why watch strangers when
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1271
turn it off before I left.
- Because Andrew Marsh was already dead
and you were in a hurry to make your exit?
- Objection!
Argumentative isn't the word
for counsel's approach to cross!
- Sustained.
Watch yourself
- Miss Carlsonyou handcuffed Andrew Marsh
01:24:48before having sex with him
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1287
1288
1289
777
1291
defendant have no bearing
on the charges against her.
- The state has an obvious
interest in a pattern of abuse
01:25:18that ended with the death of the victim.
01:25:21- Answer the question, Miss Carlson.
01:25:23Succinctly, please.
01:25:27- I never hurt him.
01:25:29- Did you humiliate him?
01:25:31- I never humiliated him either.
01:25:33He picked the games.
01:25:36- You have a weakness for rich,
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1304
1305
1306
1307
profit-and-loss statements.
- Are we supposed to believe
that Jeffrey Roston and Andrew
Marsh are both coincidences?
01:26:02- They had nothing to do with each other.
01:26:04- Well, they both had
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1315
1316
1083
induce a heart attack
before he had surgery to
repair it, you bailed out!
01:26:30He wasn't any good to
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1321
1322
1323
1324
1325
1326
1327
1328
1329
1330
1331
1079
1333
1334
him to think that I left
because of the moneyleft because I couldn't stay.
01:27:44- Mr. Roston isn't here to defend himself.
01:27:46You could say anything you want about him.
01:27:47- Yes, he is.
01:27:54Ask him yourself.
01:28:12(people murmuring)
01:28:34- [Bob] No further questions.
01:28:38- [Mabel] Redirect, Mr. Dulaney?
01:28:42- [Frank] Your Honor, the defense rests.
01:28:51(people chattering)
01:28:59(gentle music)
01:30:00- Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,
01:30:02in the case of the People
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
(gavel banging)
1357
1358
1359
1360
1361
1362
1363
1364
1365
1366
1367
ever after
If you stick around me
you're gonna to get yourself indicted
for perjury and murder.
I'm home free.
They can't try me twiceyou are a different story.
01:32:18(sighs)
01:32:22Shit.
01:32:25Frank.
01:32:27- He heard us.
01:32:28- He's my lawyer.
01:32:29It's privileged.
01:32:30- I'd have given you the
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1381
1382
1383
1384
slept
Don't look so hurt
I fucked youAndrew, I fucked Frank.
01:32:50That's what I do.
01:32:51I fuck.
01:32:53And it made me $8 million.
01:32:54- So you're fucking Dr. Paley here
01:32:56and he mentions a rich patient,
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1393
1394
1395
1396
1397
1398
1399
1400
makes you look guilty as hell.
Then you set me up to destroy him
so I can make you look innocent.
Sort of a reverse character witness
You're a real genius.
- Sorry I can't say the
same thing about you.
01:33:31I always thought the message
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1408
1409
1410
1411
1412
1413
1414
1415
1416
1417
1418
1419
1420
1421
1422
1423
(groans)
(groans)
(loud crash)
01:34:11- [Frank] Stop it!
01:34:14Paley!
01:34:17(groans)
01:34:22(Rebecca groans)
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1430
1431
1432
(Rebecca yelps)
(grunts)
(gun fires)
(gun fires)
(loud crash)
01:35:02(Alan yelps)
01:35:04(loud thud)
01:35:11- Oh, God.
01:35:25You're gonna be all right.
01:35:28- Get me out of here, Frank.
01:35:38Okay.
01:35:48(gun fires)
19
00:03:06,435 --> 00:03:10,147
1444
1423
1446
1447
1448
1449
1450
1451
1452
1060
1454
1455
1456
1457
1458
1459
1459