Most of us will admit that we'd be lost without our mobile phones - but can we expect better from our children? We took to the streets in a city near you to ask: should phones be disallowed in school because of the distraction they cause? Or do they have their benefits when it comes to safety and even aiding young people's learning?
Category
đź—ž
NewsTranscript
00:00 I understand that in the classrooms, because fair enough, if you're not listening, you're
00:05 on your phone and you're not listening. But I don't agree with them saying no phones in
00:10 the school at all. Our school had tried to do that at one point and it just never worked.
00:14 People need their phone at lunches to do whatever, and then their way home, their way there.
00:18 I think you can look at it two ways. Obviously, kids are on it way too much, because of TikTok
00:24 and whatnot. But at the same time, if you've got a child that might be a bit more nervous,
00:30 they might need their phone. So make sure they can text their parents when they're going
00:34 home. If they're catching the bus home, make sure they've got the bus. But at the same
00:38 time, they need to be learning in school. So yeah, I understand why they would be banned
00:42 if they were distracted.
00:44 A recent survey by U Switch conducted last year found that the average UK adult will
00:48 spend a whopping five hours using various screens, including phones, TVs, laptops and
00:55 tablets. That's in addition to screen time related to work. When it comes to our children,
01:00 screen time can be useful if spent wisely, of course. But do devices distract kids when
01:05 they should be learning? And what do you do to encourage your little ones to put down
01:09 their tech?
01:10 100%. There are a lot, a lot of research about... It's complicated to say in English,
01:19 but it's just not good for the kids. Because if you expose the kids to the screen, then
01:26 in the long term, they are going to struggle to focus on something else. And there are
01:33 so many researches about how unhealthy it is for kids. Actually, for everyone, but especially
01:39 in kids who they are developing the brain and things like that, it's not healthy.
01:43 I think maybe giving them that forced respite will do them good. Actually, I think that's
01:48 probably a very good idea. I never had them at school and it didn't do me any harm. So
01:52 I think it would liberate them a lot more than they think it will damage them.
01:58 Definitely yes.
01:59 And why is that?
02:00 I work in education. I'm a teacher and it's too disruptive. Every time there's a change
02:05 in class, in the lesson from one exercise to the other, they grab their phones and they're
02:10 occupied with that instead of what they should be learning.
02:13 Do you not think it can be quite useful for class?
02:17 Sometimes, but I think that's only 10% of the time.
02:19 I'm doing my master's in education. So this is one of the topics we've been studying a
02:24 lot in class. So I believe that students should have the right to bring their phones to school,
02:31 but with certain kind of guarantee from the teachers. They should limit the students the
02:40 length of the use time of their phones. And I think most of the time nowadays with technology
02:47 development and I think people sometimes teachers want students to use these kind of phones
02:54 to check or Google some stuff. Maybe they can offer students iPads at school and which
03:00 which can bring them opportunity to find the knowledge.