• 2 months ago
#supremecourt #constitutionalamendments #pmlngovt #pti #senate #nationalassembly #supremecourt #supremecourtjudges #chaudhryghulamhussain #khawarghumman #hassanayub

"Bill Lakar ye Hasil Kiya Karna Chahte Hain...? Masla Sirf Aik Hi Hai inko..." Chaudhry Ghulam Hussain's Blunt Analysis
Transcript
00:00Let's move on to the second story.
00:02Yesterday, the bill was presented in the Senate
00:06to increase the number of judges in the Supreme Court in Pakistan.
00:11Today, the bill of the same nature is in the National Assembly.
00:15Daniyal Chaudhry, an M.A. in the Pakistan Muslim League,
00:18presented the bill and gave some explanations
00:22as to why we need more judges in the Supreme Court in Pakistan.
00:28I wish to move, leave to introduce a bill further to amend the Supreme Court
00:32Number of Judges Act 1997.
00:35Supreme Court Number of Judges Amendment Bill 2024.
00:38When this last bill was introduced, our population was around 16 crores.
00:43And today, as we speak, the number has increased from 25 crores to 25 crores.
00:49The pending cases in the Supreme Court, more than 54,000 cases,
00:53as we speak, are pending in the Supreme Court.
00:56There is a very big backlog of judges.
00:59As time goes on, we need more specialized judges.
01:04And this bill is coming as needed, at this time, when it is needed.
01:10Barrister Gohar, Chairman of the National Assembly for Justice in Pakistan,
01:16as an M.A.
01:17He presented some counter-arguments,
01:19that he referred to different countries of the world,
01:23that how much population is there, how many judges are there.
01:26The issue of penancy, especially in India,
01:29how serious is the issue of penancy.
01:31Is it necessary to increase the number of judges because of this?
01:35The bill that is being introduced,
01:37it can be a private member bill,
01:39it can be allowed.
01:41Increasing the number of judges,
01:42only and only rewards the government,
01:44to the extent of the Supreme Court and Islamabad High Court.
01:47Now, I will give an example of India, Mr. Speaker.
01:49He is saying that our population has increased.
01:51The number of judges that we have at the moment,
01:53compare it with India.
01:54The population of India at the moment is 1.45 crore.
01:57In India, the judges of the High Court,
01:59are 1114.
02:01The Supreme Court sitting on 1114 judges,
02:03consists of only 23 judges.
02:06In the Supreme Court, their cases will be pending for 80,221.
02:10Increasing the number of judges will not reduce the case.
02:13There will be a big burden on this issue.
02:15But Mr. Speaker, I say, if you will move this bill,
02:18Article 74, Article 81, Article 90, Rule 118,
02:22the judgement of the Supreme Court,
02:24and the violation of the Mustafa Imtiaz Court,
02:26therefore, it is not allowed to be moved.
02:30Hassan, one of the questions that is being raised,
02:33the need for agreed judges,
02:35the issue of agreed penalty,
02:37agreed, in Pakistan,
02:39to get cheap and immediate justice,
02:41there is a need for measures.
02:43So, why is this a private member bill?
02:46Hassan, why not,
02:48in the middle of the day,
02:50this is a genuine issue.
02:52Let's move ahead with this concern.
02:54Let's talk to him.
02:56He is a brilliant brainwave.
02:58At night, Danyal Aziz,
03:00our young barrister,
03:02Danyal Chaudhary,
03:04he came to his senses,
03:06he made the bill,
03:08and presented it.
03:10It is a one-pager amendment.
03:12Sir, I am trying to understand you.
03:14He is a government member.
03:16He is the MNA of Pakistan Muslim League Noon.
03:18So, why a private member bill?
03:20Why not a government bill?
03:22A private member bill cannot be brought by
03:24an independent parliamentarian.
03:26He has to play his role.
03:28Look, we should appreciate this,
03:30that such an independent,
03:32such a private member,
03:34such a private member,
03:36who is doing this work,
03:38this is the work of the government,
03:40which he is doing,
03:42we should appreciate him,
03:44and not say, why didn't the government do it?
03:46If the government doesn't do it,
03:48the government is afraid of the Supreme Court,
03:50the government is afraid of some more pressure.
03:52So, if an individual has taken this bold step,
03:54and he is a young man,
03:56and he is becoming a parliamentarian for the first time,
03:58then you and I should sit and praise him.
04:00This is my opinion.
04:04Okay.
04:06Chaudhary Ghulam Sahib,
04:08Chaudhary Sahib,
04:10Now, if a young man is sitting with me,
04:12he will laugh at me.
04:14Okay, there is another bill
04:16that has come today.
04:18He is a member of the National Assembly
04:20of the JUIF,
04:22from Peshawar, Noor Alam Khan Sahib,
04:24he was a member of the People's Party,
04:26then from our dear Pakistan Tehreek-e-Nasab,
04:28he represented
04:30the Peshawar National Assembly.
04:32Nowadays, he is a member of the JUIF.
04:36He has presented 2-3 bills there.
04:38One bill is that
04:40there should be no
04:42civilian bureaucracy
04:44or dual nationality
04:46in Pakistan.
04:48Along with that,
04:50he has also proposed
04:52some amendments
04:54in 184.3,
04:56according to which
04:58a notice
05:00related to the common people,
05:02which is taken,
05:04should be heard by at least 9 members.
05:06A review petition within 30 days
05:08and if a review petition is applied,
05:10then it should be made by 9 members,
05:12then 10 members, 11 members,
05:14whatever the bench is made.
05:16And the case of Tohin-e-Adalat
05:18has also been said to be terminated.
05:20It is not necessary that
05:22the law of Tohin-e-Adalat should be terminated.
05:24So, this bill
05:26was also presented there today.
05:28On this,
05:30the columns of the newspapers
05:32are all across,
05:34you can read the columns
05:36of any newspaper,
05:38read the opinions of the columnists,
05:40it is being said that
05:42the purpose is good,
05:44the intention is good,
05:46but the intention behind it
05:48has some dark clouds.
05:50What is the reason
05:52why all people think like this?
05:54Hassan thinks it is not like that.
05:56Your comments on this,
05:58what is the reason
06:00that the private member bill,
06:02this consensus,
06:04this bill can come, why not?
06:06No, the bill can come,
06:08it cannot come,
06:10what does Hassan want to do?
06:12Actually, the problem
06:14is that he is seeing
06:16his own personal death.
06:18Because the people have not
06:20voted for him,
06:22now he is sitting
06:24under the leadership of Taka Shahi,
06:26sometimes he does something,
06:28sometimes Supreme Court,
06:30he will be stuck in this,
06:32he cannot get out of this.
06:34Why?
06:36When Fazl-ur-Rehman,
06:38whom your colleagues also praise a lot,
06:40did he ever have
06:42the honourable way
06:44that you sit in the opposition?
06:46No, you have to stay in this country
06:48with a strong chest.
06:50When this is your way,
06:52then he will suffer the consequences.

Recommended