#supremecourt #electiontribunal #cjp #lahorehighcourt #qazifaezisa
Supreme Court suspends LHC and ECP's decision on election tribunals | Meher Bukhari's Analysis
Supreme Court suspends LHC and ECP's decision on election tribunals | Meher Bukhari's Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00The Supreme Court of India has overturned both the Lahore High Court and the Election Commission's decision on the formation of an election tribunal under the leadership of the Chief Justice of Pakistan, Pan Chukni Bench.
00:12The Court of Appeal has said that the Election Commission's notifications are being overturned.
00:16The Lahore High Court's decision and the notification will also be overturned by the Court of Appeal.
00:21The Court of Appeal has also said that the Election Commission is a legal institution and the Chief Justice of the Lahore High Court is also the head of a legal institution.
00:28There was no discussion between the Chief Justice of the Lahore High Court and the Election Commission.
00:31If the Election Commission and the Chief Justice of the Lahore High Court had met, the matter could have been resolved.
00:36At the beginning of the hearing, the Election Commission's lawyer argued that the formation of election tribunals is the right of the Election Commission.
00:42On this occasion, the leadership of the PTI raised objections against the Chief Justice of Pakistan.
00:46The lawyer of the PTI, Niazullah Niazi, said that we want to bring our objection to the record.
00:50The case should be sent to some other bench.
00:52The lawyer said that my client has an objection that the Chief Justice should not sit on the bench.
00:56This case should be sent to some other bench.
00:58On this, the Chief Justice remarked that I have heard your objection. Now, you should be present.
01:02At this time, the lawyer of the Election Commission is giving arguments.
01:05The Chief Justice, Qazi Faizi Sen, while expressing his strong objection, remarked that the court has been scandalized a lot.
01:10Now, it is enough. Why shouldn't Niazullah Niazi's case be sent to the Pakistan Bar for disciplinary action?
01:16The Chief Justice raised the question that at the last hearing, I was also the head of a two-deck bench.
01:21Then, why didn't I object?
01:23Now, I am not alone in the bench. In fact, the entire committee makes the bench.
01:26When one person used to make the bench, no one objected.
01:29The process of humiliation of the court should end.
01:32We will see whether we have to take action against them or not.
01:36They just want to spoil the case.
01:38Niazullah Niazi also got partial relief.
01:40Despite this, they are objecting.
01:42Justice Jamal Mandokhil, while giving his opinion on this point, said that the committee has put us on the bench.
01:47Are we here to be insulted?
01:49We joined the three-deck bench later. Obviously, the objection is on me.
01:53On this, Niazullah Niazi replied that we have no objection on you.
01:57Niazullah Niazi replied that in the first hearing, we were not alone.
02:01The person who is in jail also has an objection.
02:04I am objecting on the request of my client.
02:06On this, the Chief Justice said that the person who is being mentioned has been presented on the video link from the jail.
02:11And he did not object on the bench.
02:13The Chief Justice remarked that he wants to raise objections on the bench and make headlines.
02:18He will terminate the license of the lawyer who scandalized the Supreme Court.
02:21During the hearing, Justice Aqeel Abbasi raised the most important point that you should submit the letter of February 15 of the Election Commission.
02:28It is very important.
02:29You had asked for a panel. What does this mean?
02:32If the judges had a list, they could have taken it from the website.
02:35Is the Chief Justice bound to like or dislike the Election Commission?
02:38Can the Chief Justice be instructed by the Election Commission?
02:41You cannot choose among the judges yourself.
02:43The Chief Justice remarked that only the relevant Chief Justice knows which judges are available.
02:48It is possible that some judges are abroad and some do not want to come to the tribunal for personal reasons.
02:53Justice Jamal Mandokhil said that the Election Commission cannot ask for a panel.
02:57Were panels asked in Islamabad and other provinces?
02:59Justice Jamal Mandokhil remarked that we will not let anyone attack the judicial system.
03:04If the Election Commission does not object, we will also ask for legal authority.
03:09Justice Aqeel Abbasi remarked that the names given by the Chief Justice Sindh High Court were accepted.
03:14Why has the Election Commission created a problem in Punjab?
03:17The Election Commission said that it agrees with you.
03:21Chief Justice Qazi Faizisa remarked that your agreement means that the first opportunity of the Election Commission was not correct.
03:27Justice Jamal Mandokhil remarked that the Chief Justice is told which areas judges are required and he provides them.
03:33Earlier, there was talk of good Taliban and bad Taliban.
03:36Will the judges also be good or bad?
03:38The Supreme Court has notified the establishment of election tribunals.
03:41It said that only after the appointment of the new Chief Justice, the process of negotiation will be possible.
03:45The Supreme Court has postponed the hearing for a long time.