" Meri Guzarish Hai Ke Thankhowa Le Len Magar Faislay Durust Karen,
Category
đź—ž
NewsTranscript
00:00In 2019, everyone collected their tax returns from their taxes, sir.
00:05Bilawal Bhutto's tax was Rs. 5,35,243.
00:08Tell me, how much income will he have annually?
00:10Approximately Rs. 3,500,000.
00:12Can an international citizen travel 40 times in his business class,
00:16with a 5-star hotel in his pocket, with this kind of income?
00:19If you consider him to be a respectable father...
00:21Sir, his father gave him a tax of Rs. 23,64,000.
00:25Wow, crores of rupees.
00:27So, his income is Rs. 1,35,000,000.
00:31Because Mr. Shahid said in the press conference yesterday,
00:33that he doesn't pay the tax, the tax payers don't pay the tax.
00:36These are the taxpayers who live in houses worth billions of rupees,
00:39and these are the expenses of billions of rupees.
00:40Sir, if Rs. 2,500,000 is spent on a helicopter, then...
00:42A helicopter worth Rs. 5,500,000.
00:43Huh?
00:43A helicopter worth Rs. 5,500,000.
00:44A helicopter worth Rs. 5,500,000.
00:45It's a domestic flight, sir.
00:47It's a domestic flight, sir.
00:48It's not about international flights.
00:50Mr. Shahbaz Sharif gave a tax of Rs. 8,200,000.
00:52Rs. 8,200,000.
00:55And you imposed a tax of 45% on the taxpayers.
00:58Mr. Mirza, you imposed a tax of 10%, 5%, 10%, 15% when you were the Minister of Treasury,
01:02when you were the Prime Minister.
01:04So, what kind of rocket science did you have,
01:06when you said, reduce the tax on the taxpayers?
01:08What compulsion do they have?
01:10Sir, first of all, I request you to impose a 10% surcharge on a 45% tax.
01:14So, it's a 49.5% tax.
01:16Oh, I didn't know that.
01:17Yes.
01:18It's higher than that?
01:19Yes.
01:20If you have an income above a limit, then it's 49.5% tax on you.
01:23But it won't be applied on them.
01:25It won't be applied on you if you are on the tax-paying side.
01:27It's 38.5% tax on you.
01:29So, that's one thing.
01:31Now, the second thing is,
01:33when Mr. Atta Tarar says that the Prime Minister doesn't take his salary,
01:36then I request him to take his salary,
01:38but correct his decisions.
01:39Because the loss of your decisions is more.
01:41The salary of the Prime Minister is not even Rs. 2,00,000.
01:44So, it doesn't make a difference.
01:45These are all show-offs.
01:47In reality, when you…
01:48They correct the tax too.
01:49With Mr. Shahbaz Sharif…
01:50Look, I only know that
01:52when I was the minister in 2018,
01:55Mr. Shahid Abbasi paid Rs. 25 crores tax.
01:57Something like this.
01:58Is that sales tax or income tax?
01:59Income tax.
02:00Personal income tax.
02:01Okay?
02:02So, the question is…
02:04So, you are saying that if you are the director of a company,
02:06if you have a sugar mill,
02:08whatever personal income you get,
02:09you will have to pay income tax on that, right?
02:11Yes.
02:12Look, there is 15% tax on dividends.
02:14There is more tax on your income.
02:16So, our companies…
02:18Mr. Shahid,
02:19Alhamdulillah,
02:20we have some resources,
02:22but we have money trade resources.
02:25If we don't live in big mansions,
02:28and if we live in a house,
02:29then we can justify that
02:30we have given so much tax here,
02:32and our taxable income is more than our expenses.
02:36Okay?
02:37And the thing is…
02:40Look, I don't know if that tax is right or not,
02:42but there were a couple of loopholes in this.
02:44We eliminated one loophole.
02:46One loophole was that people used to say that
02:48they have got remittance.
02:49That someone has sent you money from abroad.
02:51Which is not taxable.
02:52Which is not taxable.
02:53Okay?
02:54So, it is possible that someone has sent money from abroad
02:56to Mr. Bilawar Bhutto,
02:57his aunt,
02:58or whoever,
02:59I don't know that.
03:00The second…
03:01I tell my aunt to send me money.
03:03Okay.
03:04My aunt has passed away,
03:05so may Allah grant her paradise.
03:06I don't have an aunt,
03:07whom will I tell?
03:08May Allah grant her paradise.
03:09I am giving an example.
03:10Uncle, whatever, okay?
03:11The second thing is that
03:12we have agriculture tax.
03:14That people say,
03:15I had an income from agriculture.
03:16This is also a…
03:17We have kept that.
03:19And the third thing is that
03:20we don't even tax inter-family gifts.
03:23That if you have a husband and a wife,
03:25then okay,
03:26that becomes a unit of children,
03:27but you can also give it to brothers,
03:28you can also give it to sisters.
03:30And then,
03:31you distribute money to the whole family,
03:33and there is no tax on that.
03:34So, it becomes a little difficult to keep this trail.
03:36Maybe, brother…
03:37Has this unemployment been unfair to you?
03:39Absolutely unfair.
03:40You see…
03:41How unfair?
03:42In your opinion,
03:43how unfair was it?
03:44Sir, I…
03:45Because your press conference
03:46repeatedly said that
03:47this is already a tax-paying class.
03:49Sir, my request is this.
03:51On one hand,
03:52the Prime Minister said that
03:53the country is in danger,
03:54the economy is in danger,
03:55we will have to bow our heads.
03:56We understand this.
03:57If, God forbid,
03:58the country is in danger,
03:59then you take 40%
04:00tax from the salary-paying class.
04:01Okay?
04:02Listen to this for a second.
04:03But when you are taking 40%
04:04from them,
04:05when you are doubling
04:06the salary-paying tax
04:07of one lakh rupees,
04:09because the country is in danger,
04:10then you will increase
04:11your current expenditure
04:12by 24%.
04:13You will increase your
04:14PSDP by more than 30%.
04:16You will not impose
04:17tax on any agriculture.
04:19It is not fair
04:20that you take tax from
04:21a person whose salary
04:22is one lakh rupees,
04:23but you do not take tax
04:24from someone who has
04:25a thousand-gallon crop
04:26or land.
04:27If the country is in danger,
04:28then the country belongs to all of us, right?
04:29Okay.
04:30Only the salary-paying class
04:31has not taken a loan.
04:32Only the middle class
04:33has not taken a loan
04:34that I should pay tax
04:35on my child's milk,
04:36that I should pay tax
04:37on packaged milk,
04:38but the big properties
04:39in which people live
04:40in the provinces,
04:41they should not pay tax.
04:42Now in Islamabad,
04:43the agricultural land,
04:44they should not pay tax.
04:45And then some parts
04:46of Ashrafia,
04:47they should not pay tax.
04:48So these are two things
04:49that they will have to
04:50investigate.
04:51One is horizontal equity,
04:52that the income
04:53of the people
04:54who have equal income
04:55should be paid
04:56equal tax,
04:57no matter what their profession is.
04:58So I take a salary,
04:59if I have a certain income,
05:00you do business,
05:01your income is equal,
05:02we should pay
05:03equal tax.
05:04Yes,
05:05now my agriculture
05:06is also equal.
05:07Someone has a farm.
05:08Yes,
05:09no matter what profession
05:10you work in.
05:11And you work in ARY,
05:12or you work in a government
05:13court in Pakistan,
05:14the tax should be equal.
05:15On selling land?
05:16What do you think?
05:17In my opinion,
05:18it should be equal.
05:19So this tax exemption
05:20on selling the land
05:21of bureaucrats
05:22and soldiers,
05:23you have also mentioned
05:24this.
05:25I will ask Mr. Shahid.
05:26What is this?
05:27This is a very serious
05:28anomaly.
05:29What will the people
05:30of this country
05:31have to think?
05:32Then you give it
05:33to the judges,
05:34to the politicians,
05:35what are they doing?
05:36What kind of thinking
05:37is this?
05:38Believe me,
05:39everyone asks
05:40what is happening?
05:41All of you
05:42are citizens of this country.
05:43The law
05:44is equal
05:45for all citizens.
05:46It is not possible
05:47that you have
05:48a law
05:49that is different
05:50from yours.
05:51Some are more
05:52than others,
05:53some are less.
05:54No,
05:55no,
05:56no,
05:57no,
05:58no,
05:59no,
06:00no,
06:01no,
06:02no,
06:03no,
06:04no,
06:05no,
06:06no,
06:07no,
06:08no,
06:09no,
06:10no,
06:11no,
06:12no,
06:13no,
06:14no,
06:15no,
06:16no,
06:17no,
06:18no,
06:19no,
06:20no,
06:21no,
06:22no,
06:23no,
06:24no,
06:25no,
06:26no,
06:27no,
06:28no,
06:29no,
06:30no,
06:31no,
06:32no,
06:33no,
06:34no,
06:35no,
06:36no,
06:37no,
06:38no,
06:39no,
06:40no,
06:41no,
06:42no,
06:43no,
06:44no,
06:45no,
06:46no,
06:47no,
06:48no,
06:49no,
06:50no,
06:51no,
06:52no,
06:53no,
06:54no,
06:55no,
06:56no,
06:57no,
06:58no,
06:59no,
07:00no,
07:01no,
07:02no,
07:03no,
07:04no,
07:05no,
07:06no,
07:07no,
07:08no,
07:09no,
07:10no,
07:11no,
07:12no,
07:13no,
07:14no,
07:15no,
07:16no,
07:17no,
07:18no,
07:19no,
07:20no,
07:21no,
07:22no,
07:23no,
07:24no,
07:25no,
07:26no,
07:27no,
07:28no,
07:29no,
07:30no,
07:31no,
07:32no,
07:34no,
07:35no,
07:36no,
07:37no,
07:38no,
07:39no,
07:40no,
07:41no,
07:42no,
07:43no,
07:44no,
07:45no,
07:46no,
07:47no,
07:48no,
07:49no,
07:50no,
07:51no,
07:52no,
07:53no,
07:54no,
07:55no,
07:56no,
07:57no,
07:58no,
07:59no,
08:00no,
08:01no,
08:02no,
08:03no,
08:04no,
08:05no,
08:06no,
08:07no,
08:08no,
08:09no,
08:10no,
08:11no,
08:12no,
08:13no,
08:14no,
08:15no,
08:16no,
08:17no,
08:18no,
08:19no,
08:20no,
08:21no,
08:22no,
08:23no,
08:24no,
08:25no,
08:26no,
08:27no,
08:28no,
08:29no,
08:30no,
08:31no,
08:32no,
08:33no,
08:34no,
08:35no,
08:36no,
08:37no,
08:38no,
08:39no,
08:40no,
08:41no,
08:42no,
08:43no,
08:44no,
08:45no,