We welcome Hassan Ben Imran, legal advisor of the human rights organization law for Palestine, thank you, Hassan, for joining us From the South.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00And to go further into this topic, we now welcome Hassan Benimran, Legal Advisor for
00:05Human Rights Organization Law for Palestine.
00:08Thank you, Hassan, for joining us here in From the South.
00:13Thank you, Van.
00:14It's a pleasure to have you with us.
00:16So let's get right into it.
00:18For the past year, the world has been waiting, demanding for a ceasefire in Gaza, with many
00:23instances of negotiations that have led nowhere.
00:26And finally, on Wednesday, the deal was announced by the Qatari Prime Minister, and it is expected
00:31to come into force on Sunday.
00:34But the attacks have stepped up since that moment.
00:37So I wanted to ask you, just how significant is this deal for the situation in Palestine?
00:43What situation will we have on Sunday?
00:46Of course, allow me to start by saying that this is one of the moments in history where
00:56you stand up and you think, why did this happen only now?
01:01This is a moment that has been being pushed for by human rights organizations, by different
01:06governments, by the International Court of Justice itself.
01:10Many months ago, from the very beginning of the war, everyone was talking about ending
01:14this genocide, stopping the bloodshed.
01:18And as we can see, the deal that has been agreed upon today in the morning or last night
01:24is almost the same that has been discussed many months ago.
01:27Nothing has changed except for losing many lives, many innocent lives.
01:32We're talking about almost 10,000 people that lost their lives ever since almost the very
01:36same deal has been put on the table back in May and June last year.
01:44Just yesterday, after the news of the ceasefire, we lost a very dear colleague of ours, the
01:49head of the Independent Commission for Human Rights, the director actually of the commission,
01:53and a commissioner in the Human Rights Commission, the Palestinian National Commission in Gaza,
01:59Mr. Rifat Salha, who lost his life together with his wife and many of his cousins and
02:06his children as well.
02:07And that was after the news of the deal has been delivered.
02:10This is one of the scariest moments in human history.
02:14It's an actual full-fledged genocide that we're waiting the ICJ to deliberate on and
02:20deliver a decision on.
02:22And yet, it was shocking that what happened yesterday or today in the morning, depending
02:28on the news, which source that we rely on, is something that could have happened more
02:34than a year ago, saving the lives of these innocent people.
02:39So exactly following that line of thought, why now and not then?
02:44Some things have changed.
02:45Of course, in the geopolitical scene, we have President Trump that is about to take office
02:50once again.
02:51Do you think that this comes into place?
02:53What has changed for this to be a scenario now when it could have been this in May or
02:57many months before?
03:01As you can see on the ground, there is almost nothing that has changed in Gaza.
03:06The bloodshed was going on.
03:08The genocide is going on.
03:09The suffering never stopped.
03:11The fighting on the ground never stopped.
03:13Israel claims to hold certain territories, but then it loses control quite fast.
03:20On the ground, I don't see any indication that anything has changed.
03:24It's almost identical.
03:26The only thing that has changed is the death toll, the number of victims killed.
03:31That's the only thing, and the friends and the people that we lost.
03:34Geopolitically, there might have been some changes that pushed Netanyahu to sign the
03:38deal.
03:40We have been looking at the discussions that he's been having with Ben-Gvir and Smotrich,
03:47two ministers of the more radical ministers, actually more radical than Netanyahu himself,
03:52in the Israeli cabinet, and the agreement was that they will step down from the government
03:56apparently as per the latest news, but without causing the government to collapse.
04:04Either way, that doesn't indicate that Israel is showing any intent to stop this genocide.
04:11The ceasefire has been signed.
04:15We need now guarantees that Israel will not go back to continue this genocide.
04:21We can't say that the genocide has stopped because the suffering of the people did not
04:24end yet, and we're not sure about the amount of humanitarian aid that has entered Gaza
04:28yet.
04:29We're not sure about the medical facilities and the capacity to reconstruct the completely
04:34collapsed health system in Gaza.
04:38On the ground, there is not much that has changed since the many months.
04:44Actually, it's the change in American politics that has pushed Netanyahu to take this decision.
04:50Either way, this requires so much further pressure to make sure that Israel does not
04:55go back to deploy its army in Gaza and continue this bloodshed.
05:02And exactly in that way, I wanted to ask you, we know from past experiences that a ceasefire
05:07does not equal the complete end to all aggressions towards Palestinians, of course, in this case.
05:14Also, for the past 15 months, Israel has been completely disregarding all its obligations
05:19to basically any international entity.
05:22So in this scenario, we said some geopolitical aspects have changed, but what can we expect
05:29in terms, can we rely on Israel's word in this case, in terms of the ceasefire?
05:36What do you see coming in the coming months?
05:40The short answer is absolutely not, like, forgive my honesty, but only a fool would
05:47trust Israeli government in its current format.
05:51We have seen this quite lately in Lebanon.
05:54Israel did sign a peace treaty or like a truce, a ceasefire with Lebanon, yet quite little
06:00has changed on the ground.
06:02Israel continued targeting Lebanon, continued actually having foot on the ground in South
06:07Lebanon until this very moment.
06:09And we're talking about almost more, we're talking about more than a month, like a month
06:14and 10 days probably, since the agreement has been signed or has been agreed upon.
06:21And yet Israel is violating its responsibility towards the ceasefire agreement with Lebanon
06:28or with the fighting paramilitary in Lebanon.
06:32The same applies to Syria.
06:35Israel is advancing within the Syrian territory without clearly stating its own military goals.
06:43There are now the Israeli troops are almost 20 kilometers away from Damascus, the capital
06:49of Syria.
06:50And Syria, at least the current formula that is governing Syria, has not posed any threats
06:56to Israel, yet Israel is acting, treating them as a foe and as an enemy.
07:01So we have little, actually we have quite much evidence to indicate the opposite, which
07:08means that this is a moment for us, for people concerned about international law, people
07:14working on the rule of law internationally, to keep pushing for a further action to prevent
07:22the Israeli cabinet and the Israeli government from redeploying its forces into Gaza.
07:28The levels of trust is close to non-existent.
07:31We have sufficient evidence to indicate that Israel will not abide by its obligations.
07:39In order to suggest otherwise, we need quite an argument to be able to argue that we can
07:46be secure about Israel not re-invading Gaza or redeploying its troops and inflicting serious
07:53life conditions on the people of Gaza.
07:56What needs to be done is further pressure.
07:59Unfortunately, the streets have got used to the massacres happening in Gaza.
08:05Less pressure has been expressed or exerted from activists, from academics who were quite
08:13active in the beginning of the war, from people and NGOs organizing different protests in
08:19London and other capitals to pressure the governments to exert actual pressure on Israel.
08:25What needs to be done, in my opinion and in the opinion of many people that have been
08:29working on this for the past 15 months, is that Israel will stop only when they face
08:38a sufficient pressure that makes them realize that they're going to lose more if they continue
08:43in this line of action.
08:44What does that mean?
08:45That means military embargo.
08:47That means economic boycott.
08:49That means also unseating Israel from the United Nations.
08:52Israel is disrespecting publicly the United Nations, shutting down the UN agency, publicly
08:58disrespecting the UN Secretary General, disrespecting the UN and actually banning many of the UN
09:03officials from coming into its territory.
09:07Perhaps this is a moment where we remember what happened to South Africa, apartheid regime
09:12in South Africa, when the Bouteflika rule was activated at that time with Algeria and
09:18other countries pushing for dismissing Israeli diplomats from the United Nations facilities.
09:24And that happened.
09:25South Africa, the apartheid regime of South Africa, was unseated from the UN.
09:28That isolated the apartheid regime in South Africa further, which created further pressure
09:33on them to realize that the only way to end this is to respect their obligations according
09:40to international law and to respect the bare minimum of human morality of dismantling the
09:49apartheid regime that has been constructed in South Africa back then.
09:53The same is applicable to Israel, in my opinion.
09:56And in terms of stepping up that international pressure, you were mentioning before the case
10:01at the ICJ that is at the moment continuing to investigate the ongoing genocide in Palestine.
10:11So in terms of this ceasefire agreement from an international law perspective, if the agreement
10:17was not followed, if what it's agreed upon in terms of the entry of humanitarian aid,
10:24for example, of the assistance to the Palestinians in Gaza, if this is not kept, as we imagine
10:32could very well happen, as you were just saying, could that just add some arguments into
10:40that international pressure to be able to be stepped up and enforced on behalf of different,
10:47either other countries or the mediators themselves?
10:50Does the ceasefire agreement bind them in some way in that sense?
10:57The ceasefire agreement is meant to be binding.
11:01Binding on the warring parties, binding on third parties as well, third states.
11:08Binding on the UN, on the third states that are financing the Israeli genocide.
11:17The Israeli ammunition is coming from the US, Germany and other states, 70% is coming
11:21from the US, which means that it is binding on these states.
11:25The very idea that an agreement has been signed reinforces the calls and the demands and the
11:31action, the line of action that's being taken.
11:33Any Israeli action against the ceasefire further reinforces the South African case in the ICJ.
11:39So absolutely, the ceasefire is binding.
11:42It does end much of the unnecessary disputes, like intellectual conversations or intellectual
11:51exercises that are being practiced by some people here and there.
11:56This is an agreement that has been signed by the directly involved parties, that has
12:02been directly co-sponsored by the other parties that have been contributing to the situation,
12:08mainly the United States.
12:10So yes, it's binding, it should be upheld and there has to be a step forward to reconstruct
12:16Gaza and allow the people of Gaza to be able to resume a sense of normal life, which I
12:24can't imagine how that is possible after what they've been through.
12:27But at least in the sense of reconstructing the completely destroyed health system, the
12:33hospitals, the access to aid, access to humanitarian aid, to medical aid, so on and so forth.
12:40So of course, we hope that this binding quality is upheld and is enforced by the mediators
12:47along which are some very important nations, as you were mentioning.
12:51So we'll have to see what happens, of course, in the coming days.
12:56Thank you, Hassan, so much for joining us in From the South with such a clear perspective
13:00that allows us to further understand this topic.
13:03Advisor at Law for Palestine and also PhD scholar at the University of Galway.
13:11We now go for a short break, but stay with us.