শীর্ষ আদালতে মুখবন্ধ খামে তদন্ত রিপোর্ট জমা তদন্তকারী সংস্থার, কী অভিযোগ জানাল CBI?
~ED.1~
~ED.1~
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00The protest is being held in protest against the Arjikar scandal.
00:03This was the evening when Arjikar's case was heard in the Supreme Court.
00:07On this day, the CBI submitted a report in a closed mouth at the beginning of the hearing.
00:30Maybe they have served, it has not reached me, or they have not served, whatever.
00:34It's not served, it's not served.
00:36Not served, meaning they have not served on me.
00:38Yes.
00:39Sealed envelope.
00:40Put it in a sealed envelope and therefore we...
00:44Take my word for it.
00:46Sir, sorry.
00:47Hmm, that's okay.
00:50The case of Arjikar's young medical student has been heard for a month now.
00:54The Supreme Court has submitted a report on the status of this case, Dr. Rabjo Shastro.
00:59The report states that 23 people have died in the Jnr. medical students' protest.
01:06According to the past hearing, the Supreme Court does not approve of the Jnr. medical students' protest.
01:11But even after that, the Jnr. medical students have protested against the action.
01:16Even if the Jnr. medical students are protesting against the action,
01:19an emergency meeting is going on.
01:21The senior medical students are working.
01:24It is also true that 23 people have died in the protest.
01:28This is what has been claimed in the state's report.
01:31During the presentation of this report by the state health department in the Supreme Court,
01:34Solicitor General Tushar Mehta announced that the report given by the state has not been filed.
01:40His copy has not been confiscated.
01:41But it's filed by Mr. Sibal.
01:44It's not served upon me, that's what he says.
01:45It is not filed.
01:47It's not filed.
01:48It's only given to the court.
01:50If they want to say something, why hide something from the CBI?
01:53You've already hidden many things.
01:55Let's not get lost in...
01:57Let's see what they see.
01:59First and foremost, let us find out what the status of the investigation is.
02:03Yes.
02:04Please have a look at this left-hand side and the right-hand side.
02:08Kindly go through it with some degree of attention.
02:14I have gone through it.
02:18That certificate, yeah.
02:21After this, the investigators have seen the report of the CBI.
02:24The Chief Investigator has asked,
02:27How far is the house of the principal from the hospital?
02:30The CBI says, 15 to 20 minutes.
02:33The CBI's report is published in the Supreme Court on Monday.
02:37The CBI's statement,
02:39The first five hours of this kind of incident are very significant.
02:43But five days later,
02:45Then a lot has changed.
02:47Edulji has also raised the question,
02:49How did it start without the FIR?
02:52There is a question about the FIR.
02:54Maybe that information has been destroyed.
02:57Even during the entry of the General Diary,
02:59Edulji made a mistake.
03:01Just tell us, on the facts, what are you saying?
03:05Mahat, can you take the post-mortem report
03:09and compare it with the duty case which was started?
03:13In the post-mortem report,
03:15the law enforcement will see
03:17whether the clothes of the victim
03:20were produced before the post-mortem doctor.
03:23The entire jeans, the top, the undergarments,
03:29everything was produced or not.
03:31Because as per the notification,
03:34they have to be sealed by the post-mortem doctor
03:37and handed over to the investigating officer.
03:40If the law enforcement sees in the top,
03:43whether the clothes were sent
03:45to the investigating officer of the duty case
03:48by the post-mortem doctor.
03:50I will kindly ask them to just give a copy of it.
03:52Post-mortem.
03:54We have seen the post-mortem report.
03:58Just show us the post-mortem report.
04:00Either the state Bengal or the CBI.
04:04We saw it last time.
04:06Since you are making a point,
04:08let's appreciate what the point is.
04:10They had a list of the men including the parents.
04:15Post-mortem report doesn't even say
04:18at what time it is conducted.
04:20Give it to us.
04:22I am sorry.
04:24It says that at the time everything is there.
04:27I don't know why you are making this statement.
04:29Please tell us what the time of death is.
04:31Condition of the subject,
04:34your law chiefs will find on the left hand side.
04:36Law chiefs will kindly see at the top.
04:38First will be the videograph.
04:40Conducted by whom?
04:42No designation.
04:44Who is he?
04:46From where did he come?
04:48Nothing.
04:50Was it the CD on a re-writable CD
04:52or was it a non-re-writable CD?
04:54It has to be mentioned on the first line of the post-mortem report.
04:58In the case of 17th September,
05:00the proceedings of this case were heard.
05:02The status report of CBI-KF
05:04was submitted to the Supreme Court.
05:06The Chief Justice said
05:08that he does not want to comment on the open court.
05:10So that it affects the court.
05:12The status report of the court has to be submitted.
05:14CBI will submit the status report
05:16with the latest information
05:18of the court.
05:20The proceedings of this case will be heard
05:22on 17th September.
05:24My Lords may just see
05:26the highlighted part in the flat portion.
05:28There are two
05:30specimens
05:32or two swabs.
05:34Swabs.
05:36And the result.
05:40Mr. Mehta,
05:42we have seen now the further line
05:44of investigation which is open.
05:46We do not want to comment
05:48in the open court
05:50obviously so that the course of the
05:52investigation should not be affected.
05:54We will give you a week's time
05:56tell us by next Monday
05:58what further leads have emerged
06:00during the course of the further investigation.
06:02We would like a status report
06:04to be submitted to us by next Monday.
06:06Mr. Sibal,
06:08advisedly we should not be
06:10referring to what has emerged
06:12during the course of the investigation.
06:14Let the CBI proceed
06:16on the basis of
06:18what they are now exploring.
06:20The leads which they are pursuing.
06:22We will keep it now on next
06:24Monday.
06:26It's a holiday. It's a Tuesday.
06:28Only a minute.
06:30There is one IA
06:32which we have filed. IA 200162.
06:34Where?
06:36Your law
06:37expert please
06:39not require.
06:41Before my learning friend says that.
06:43Only a minute.
06:45Just hold on.
06:47If you don't mind sir,
06:49let me just show.
06:51It's on the previous matter.
06:53We will just pass a short order on this.
06:55One second.
06:57We will come back to you in a moment.
06:59Just clarify this part.
07:01A status report
07:03has been
07:05dated so and so.
07:07Has been filed by the
07:09Central Bureau of Investigation.
07:11Having produced the report
07:13it appears that
07:15the investigation
07:17is in progress.
07:19We direct the CBI to file
07:21a fresh status report
07:25by the next date of hearing.
07:27List on so and so
07:29for considering the fresh
07:31status report to be filed by the CBI.
07:33Take it up on
07:35Tuesday
07:37for considering
07:39the status report which will be then
07:41filed by the CBI. Let's see what happens
07:43between now and
07:45what has been collected in the past
07:47course of the last 10 days
07:49is subject to further verification.
07:51We will also investigate
07:53who collected the samples.
07:55Abhijukta was seen entering
07:57the CCTV footage of the incident
07:59and going out.
08:01The footage is from 4.30 in the morning.
08:03Was that footage given to the CBI?
08:05The Chief Investigator
08:07Chandrachur wanted to know.
08:09In response, the CBI's
08:11Solicitor General Tushar Mehta
08:13gave four clippings
08:15to the Central Bureau of Investigation.
08:17We have photographs from 12.45pm
08:19onwards of everything that happened.
08:21We have the original with us.
08:25Now,
08:27during the course of the previous hearings
08:29and therefore we, I think though
08:31the investigation is going on, we can share this
08:33because we have all said it openly.
08:35That there is
08:37evidence to, there is a CCTV
08:39footage to indicate
08:41what time the accused
08:43enters the seminar room
08:45and what time he is exiting the seminar room.
08:47This is shared with us.
08:49Now,
08:51obviously therefore there will be CCTV
08:53The CCTV footage
08:55after 4.30 in the morning
08:57throughout the day?
08:59Yes, there will be.
09:01Has the CCTV footage
09:03in its entirety been handed
09:05over to the CBI?
09:07Yes, we have taken.
09:09We have taken the CCTV footage.
09:19We had to reconstruct
09:21the scene
09:23because of the distance.
09:25Mr. Solicitor,
09:27how do you explain this statement
09:29in your affidavit at
09:31small room 3 at page 14?
09:33Just see the last sentence.
09:35My report, Malhotra?
09:37Yes.
09:41Page 14, Malhotra.
09:51Just one para
09:53above 7.
09:55Yes, sir.
09:57The SSC has apparently visited.
10:01Who handed over?
10:03The Calcutta police handed over to the CBI
10:05the entire footage
10:07of the proceedings which were taken
10:09which took place between 8.30 pm
10:11and 10.45 pm?
10:13The CBI
10:15seems to have...
10:17Yes, yes.
10:19It's about 27 minutes.
10:2127 minutes, they said.
10:27The four clippings
10:29totalling duration to 27 minutes.
10:31And the
10:33proceedings conducted
10:35from 17.06, that is 5.6
10:37to 22.45 hours.
10:49We will show you
10:51the CBI's report
10:53after this.
10:57Mirror Report, One India Bangla.