Shabbar Zaidi Traders Ki Strike Say Khush Kyun??? - Shabbar Told Everything - video Dailymotion

ARY NEWS

#11thHour #TradersProtest #TradersStrike #Traders #TaxSystemInPakistan #Tax #WaseemBadami #ShabbarZaidi   Follow the ARY News channel on WhatsApp: https://bit.ly/46e5HzY  Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon for latest news updates: http://bit.ly/3e0SwKP  ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.  Official Facebook: https://www.fb.com/arynewsasia  Official Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/arynewsofficial  Official Instagram: https://instagram.com/arynewstv  Website: https://arynews.tv  Watch ARY NEWS LIVE: http://live.arynews.tv    Listen Live: http://live.arynews.tv/audio  Listen Top of the hour Headlines, Bulletins & Programs: https://soundcloud.com/arynewsofficial #ARYNews  ARY News Official YouTube Channel. For more videos, subscribe to our channel and for suggestions please use the comment section.

Transcript

00:00Look, Mr. Badami, the position we are in today is that the government is fundamentally right-wing.

00:09Okay.

00:09But it is absolutely true that this time, there has been a deception with the merchants,

00:17in the sense that the merchant-friendly scheme that was brought,

00:22the merchants were thinking that this is some kind of fixed tax and they have been limited to some liability.

00:31But as I told you earlier, this is not a fixed tax scheme,

00:36this is only a liability of advance tax and the income will be determined based on that.

00:42So when they brought this merchant-friendly scheme,

00:46at that time, the merchants should have understood that what they are understanding is not that.

00:54Now when the return date is approaching, they have understood that this is not that,

01:01that is why they have come to the streets.

01:03So this is the fundamental issue that the government…

01:06Okay, the second thing, Mr. Badami, you people keep saying that the merchant is the guide.

01:13Yes.

01:14Tell me, can these merchant-friendly people who come with you,

01:20if I make an agreement with them or if I do something with them,

01:25can they enforce that thing?

01:28For argument's sake, Mr. Ajmal Chaudhary comes, Mr. Kashif Chaudhary comes, Mr. Naeem Bir comes,

01:36there are other people, they are very reasonable people, they have made a big deal with me.

01:40If I agree with Mr. Naeem Bir today that every merchant will pay Rs. 10, for argument's sake,

01:47only Rs. 10, will Mr. Naeem Bir be able to bring all the merchants of Pakistan in this?

01:55Sir, if there is a representative body of the merchants and they are coming for negotiations,

01:59then they will also be responsible, if something has been agreed, they will get it implemented.

02:03There is no representative body, there is no representative body,

02:09all of them, my question is, Mr. Maseeb, it's a question again,

02:13that the merchants that you see, yes, they are the presidents of some merchants,

02:19but my question is, when I agree with them on something, can they enforce it?

02:25Then at least, Mr. Shabbar, we will not be able to morally oppose it in our primes.

02:31Sir, you must have agreed on one thing, by and large.

02:33No, I will make it easy for you.

02:36At the moment, Mr. Naeem is the chief coordinator of this scheme.

02:40Of the Taj-e-Dos scheme.

02:41Okay?

02:41Yes.

02:43Yes, he is the chief coordinator of the Taj-e-Dos scheme.

02:44Absolutely.

02:45Would I have agreed with Mr. Naeem if I had agreed with Mr. Naeem today

02:50that everyone's liability will be Rs. 5,000, for argument's sake,

02:54would Mr. Naeem Bir be able to get me Rs. 5,000 from all the merchants of Pakistan?

03:01Yes, Mr. Naeem is standing on the other side at the moment.

03:04Okay, I will take my point forward.

03:06Okay.

03:06I understood your point.

03:08The thing is, first of all, I am very happy that the matter has reached this point

03:17and I was waiting for this strike to take place and this place to be deadlocked.

03:23And it will be deadlocked.

03:26And the reason for this deadlock is that there is no mutual trust between the government and the merchants.

03:35Why are you happy about this?

03:36This is wrong.

03:38Yes, I am very happy.

03:39Why?

03:40I am very happy because now things are in the right place.

03:44When your fight is over, then the decision is made.

03:49Okay.

03:50I am happy because I was waiting for the merchants' scheme to come

03:58and then this would be a failure and after this failure, there would be a strike on this

04:05and now we will sit and decide what will happen.

04:09If a merchant thinks that he will take a fixed tax, limit it to Rs. 10,000 or limit it to Rs. 1,000,

04:18then his dream is void.

04:20Ultimately, he will have to pay tax on his income.

04:25And this should happen, Mr. Shabbar.

04:26This should happen.

04:30What?

04:30I am saying that this should happen, that there should be a tax on income.

04:34This should happen.

04:35Yes, there should be a tax on income.

04:37This is a very clear position from the IWF.

04:40Naeem is also right that there should be a tax on income.

04:45The schemes that we have put in place,

04:47this scheme, that scheme, fixed tax scheme,

04:51all this can happen on very small merchants.

04:53It cannot happen on medium and large merchants.

04:56But Mr. Javed has this objection, Mr. Shabbar,

04:58that on the basis of market value, you are deciding on revenue.

05:02I agree that there should be no market value.

05:07I am agreeing.

05:08What I mean to say is,

05:10please understand what I am saying.

05:12My question is that you can put a fixed scheme on a very small merchant.

05:17But tell me,

05:19will you put a scheme on Bori Bazar, Akbari Mandi, Anarkali, Liberty, Raja Bazar?

05:25What are you saying?

05:27You are saying that my shop is in Raja Bazar,

05:30my shop is in Anarkali,

05:32my shop is on Hall Road,

05:34should I give you a salary tax of Rs. 10,000?

05:37What is wrong with you?

05:38Right.

05:38We are in our senses.

05:40Right.

05:40These are useless things.

05:42And this thing is reaching its logical foundation.

05:48There has been one strike.

05:49There will be more strikes.

05:51And they will deadlock each other.

05:54And after deadlocking,

05:56the government and our establishment will have to decide

06:01whether they want to take tax from the merchants or not.

06:05This thing that there should be a reform in FBR,

06:08this should happen in FBR,

06:09that should happen in FBR,

06:11this is just an attempt to twist things from both sides.

06:16And I want to say the last thing in this,

06:18that no scheme,

06:20no scheme can ever be applied generally on a retailer,

06:26nor should it be.

06:27Every person has to pay tax on their income.

06:31No, Mr. Mir.

06:33You are the coordinator of this scheme.

06:35You tell us.

06:36Mr. Javed and Mr. Shabbar have clearly told us

06:38that this is their opinion,

06:40that this is not a way to decide on the basis of market value.

06:44You have to pay tax on your income.

06:45So, you tell us what you have to say on this, Mr. Naeem.

06:48Look, the thing is that

06:49tax will be taken on income

06:52when someone expresses their income

06:55in their tax return,

06:56then that will be taxed.

06:57If someone is not satisfied with that income,

07:01then the tax authority will audit it.

07:04This is a very simple method.

07:07Now, the real problem is that

07:09when people do not deposit their tax returns,

07:12then who will determine their income?

07:15One way, one indicator has to be made.

07:18Now, this indicator has been made,

07:21there is an objection on it.

07:22Very good.

07:23It is a very good thing.

07:24Mr. Shabbar Jaidi raised that objection.

07:27Mr. Javed Qureshi raised the objection

07:31and said that tax should be imposed on income.

07:33So, the only way to determine income

07:37is the point of sale.

07:38Yes.

07:39There is no other way.

07:40Yes.

07:40This means that when they are demanding

07:43that our traders should impose tax on our income,

07:46then they are demanding

07:49that point of sales should be imposed on our shops.

07:51Yes, absolutely right.

07:52So, they should make their demand clear and loud.

07:57Mr. Javed, the problem is that

07:58if there is a point of sale,

08:00then there will be an objection on that too.

08:01No, no, no.

08:02What Mr. Mir is saying,

08:04the point of sale has already been imposed.

08:06It cannot be imposed on every shop in Pakistan.

08:09Yes, it cannot be imposed on every shop in Pakistan.

08:12One risky shop...

08:14Please give me a chance to talk.

08:17I had to take my time.

08:18I...

08:19Okay, you talk.

08:20The thing is that you have asked me a question,

08:21so let me answer.

08:23When you ask Mr. Mir a question,

08:25he should also give an answer.

08:27He has a right.

08:27He should also get time.

08:28Let him complete.

08:30Let Mr. Naeem complete.

08:31Yes, Mr. Naeem.

Shabbar Zaidi Traders Ki Strike Say Khush Kyun??? - Shabbar Told Everything

Category

Transcript

Recommended