Has the Supreme Court's decision from July 12 really become ineffective??? Sarwar Bari's Analysis
#reservedseatscase #electioncommission #supremecourt #nationalassembly #sunniittehadcouncil #pti #pmlngovt #KanwarDilshad #mariamemon #sawalyehhai #sarwarbari
Has the Supreme Court's decision from July 12 really become ineffective??? Sarwar Bari's Analysis
Has the Supreme Court's decision from July 12 really become ineffective??? Sarwar Bari's Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Do you agree with the Supreme Court's decision on the 12th, that after the amendment to the Election Act, the decision is invalid?
00:10Look, the first thing is that there is a principle all over the world that when the game starts, the rules of the game cannot be changed.
00:22And what has happened in our Parliament is very disappointing.
00:28When the elections have been held and all the proceedings are being carried out, and the rest of the processes are being carried out,
00:37then you cannot go back to the past and make any changes because it is in front of us.
00:45First of all, the Supreme Court has clearly stated that the PTI is present as a party and will remain present.
00:52That is, whoever fought the election, first of all, our election commission, our administration,
01:00first of all, they took away their electoral mark from the PTI, then the candidates who came there were either stopped on the way
01:10or they were picked up and they were forced to fight the election as free candidates.
01:20And when they won the election, then they said, how else can we stop you?
01:25So basically, first they let the election fight in the name of the party.
01:30Now they are saying that the amendment made in the 2017 Election Act is that if a party has not collected the list of reserve seats,
01:41then how can it get the election, how can it get the reserve seats?
01:45So this means that the people who have created all these obstacles, now they are using their own obstacles,
01:54the same party that they had targeted and the whole world said that there was no level playing field for one party.
02:02But brother, if I ask a very precise question, does the Supreme Court's decision become invalid when it has been amended in the Election Act?
02:10Look, the election commission itself is also admitting that it has gone to the Supreme Court.
02:15So if the election commission itself has gone to the Supreme Court, then it should not have gone because the party has become the election commission.
02:23But if you look at its between the lines, then the election commission is also not guaranteed that the amendment of this parliament is final.
02:34For its finality, it is also having to go to the Supreme Court.
02:38And the vast majority of judges of the Supreme Court have decided that the PTI was the party and is, then they should get seats.
02:48This is a very clear decision. Since the decision has come against you, then you say that this decision is wrong.
02:56So this tradition that is being put in Pakistan, the parties of PDM, that the constitution of Pakistan has become a joke,
03:04the foundations of Pakistan have become a joke, and if there are such matches, such Olympics, then who will believe anyone?
03:11You are saying that the rule of the game should not be changed in the middle of the game.
03:14Mr. Kavir Dulshad, there can be an agreement on everything else, on its implementation, on its technicalities, questions can arise.
03:20But on one thing, everyone has an agreement, including Qazi Faiz Issa Sahib, the Chief Justice of Pakistan,
03:25that the interpretation of his decision by the Election Commission of Pakistan was wrong.
03:29There is a party of Tariq-e-Insaaf. So this is against the charge sheet of the election commission itself.
03:36But from there, we are seeing that the election commission is trying to clarify it,
03:41but after such a big charge sheet, we have not seen any accountability or any kind of introspection there.
03:47You are absolutely right that when an election act has been adopted by the parliament,
03:54the government has also presented obstacles so that this decision cannot be reached in any way.
04:00Now the decision has been reached, the decision of majority has been reached,
04:04but because now the act has been made, and they started the act from 2017.
04:09Now they have said from 2017 that all the decisions of the High Court, Supreme Court have come under its jurisdiction.
04:15So now it is the matter of the government, the election commission and the parliament.
04:20Now they have to decide whether the decision of majority is effective or ineffective.
04:27So in our view, the act that has been made, the decision of the Supreme Court of Pakistan has become ineffective.
04:33And what do you think about changing the rule of the game in the middle of the game?
04:40That if a game starts now, you change the rule of the game in the middle of it.
04:44But since they have the power, they can do it. They have done it.
04:48No, even Sajjad Ali Shah fought for the rights of the people.
04:52He also supported the decision of the parliament, in which he said that the President of Pakistan should be allowed to break the constitution.
05:01But the parliament supported it.
05:04There was a very big battle in which Sajjad Ali Shah had to resign,
05:08and the President of Pakistan Sardar Farooq Khan Laghari had to resign.
05:12But this matter went to the extreme of both the parliaments and the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
05:19But I don't see it.
05:21The current Chief Justice is a man of cold-bloodedness, he is a philosopher.
05:25He will never give a speech, he will make a cold decision and Mansoor Ali Shah will become the Chief Justice.
05:30Then he will decide. This matter went to October and November.
05:33Okay, do you also think that this matter will go to October and November, Mr. Bari?
05:38Look, I think that this matter, the kind of election that has been won,
05:45the kind of election that has been won,
05:48this mandate, the theft of such a big mandate,
05:52cannot be digested.
05:54As we have in Bangladesh, that the opposition had boycotted.
05:59Here, the seats of the opposition have been snatched.
06:04We have done a lot of audits.
06:06We have put it in front of the world.
06:08It is on the website of the Election Commission.
06:10It has been audited and re-mattered.
06:14So, I think that if this collation is taken out for 2-3 more months, it will be a big bribe.
06:20Because whether the parliament does it or whatever,
06:23the moral high ground that is there,
06:25the government does not have it.
06:27The Election Commission does not have it.
06:29The people of Pakistan, the media of Pakistan, the civil society, the whole world,
06:33the panel of human rights of the UN,
06:36the whole world is saying that your elections were not right.
06:39So, this kind of illegitimate government,
06:42which does not have a mandate,
06:44cannot run for a long time.
06:46Right. Thank you very much.