Supreme Court Final Verdict Over Reserved Seats Case | SIC vs ECP | Experts Analysis
#sunniittehadcouncil #breakingnews #cjp #qazifaezisa #supremecourt
#thereporters
Supreme Court Final Verdict Over Reserved Seats Case | SIC vs ECP | Experts Analysis
#thereporters
Supreme Court Final Verdict Over Reserved Seats Case | SIC vs ECP | Experts Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Raja Mousi Nijaz, please tell us how long this decision will be held?
00:06Is this full-court hearing routine? I have not seen it before, but you deal with issues a lot.
00:14So, should we consider it routine?
00:16It is not routine. Usually, it is not like this.
00:20This hearing is also back-to-back.
00:22The last hearing was about an hour and a half.
00:25Today, the hearing was held again.
00:27The decision regarding this particular hearing,
00:30the judges had a discussion about it.
00:33Now, it is said that the decision will be heard tomorrow.
00:38After a while, the cause list for the decision will be issued.
00:45When the decision was secured two days before,
00:48after the arguments of all the parties were completed,
00:50the Chief Justice of Pakistan, in his concluding remarks,
00:55said that the decision will be heard tomorrow.
00:58Nothing can be said in this regard.
01:00The judges will have a discussion about it.
01:02In the same context, there were two rounds of discussion.
01:05You are absolutely right that this is not a regular practice.
01:08It is not seen that the hearing is held in this way.
01:12But this is a very important matter.
01:15There are many things that need to be answered.
01:18There are many technical things that need to be said.
01:26There are many questions that need to be answered.
01:29This is why it is taking a lot of time.
01:31The judges also had two rounds of discussion.
01:35The 13-member full court heard the case.
01:37Now, it is said that the decision will be heard tomorrow morning.
01:45The decision will be heard tomorrow morning.
01:47Is there any detail about the discussion that took place today?
01:58The discussion took place yesterday.
02:01It lasted for about one and a half hours.
02:03All the judges gave their opinions on the arguments of the parties.
02:12The discussion took place today.
02:16All the judges gave their opinions on the arguments of the parties.
02:23It is said that the judges have reached a final decision.
02:29The time has come for the decision to be heard.
02:32This decision is of great importance.
02:35The future functioning of the parliament depends on it.
02:43If the ruling parties get the same ratio, then they will get a two-third majority.
02:53We will see the same in the future.
02:56If the Sunni Atheist Council agrees, then the matter will go to the other side.
03:03This is of great importance.
03:05The decision will be heard tomorrow morning.
03:10This is the last court hearing before the summer court hearings.
03:14The decision will be heard tomorrow morning.
03:24Mr. Chaudhary Gulam, I would like to come to you.
03:26The decision will be heard tomorrow.
03:30There was a full court hearing today.
03:33We are at a legal and historical juncture.
03:36This can be a very important decision politically as well.
03:39In your opinion, how important is it that the decision will be heard tomorrow?
03:45The current National Assembly and the Senate are all governments.
03:51This decision will have a great impact on their functioning.
03:55The majority of the people will be affected.
03:59If this is the status quo, then the Senate and the National Assembly will have a two-third majority.
04:07They will be able to make the changes they want to make.
04:12As of now, no one can comment on the decision until it is heard.
04:21But as of now, the decision of the Election Commission in light of the constitution and the law,
04:31and the hearings of the 13 benches of the Supreme Court,
04:37and the public view,
04:39there is a difference of opinion on a large scale.
04:44Sometimes it seems that 8 is on one side, 5 is on the other side,
04:47sometimes 9 and 4, sometimes 1 and 12, sometimes 13.
04:51So until the decision is heard, it will have a great political impact.
04:58You cannot ignore this.
05:00But what will be the impact and who will benefit?
05:04Politically, those who are traveling first will travel more,
05:10or their suffering will decrease and others will start.
05:13So we will have to wait for the judgment.
05:18Absolutely, we will have to wait for the judgment.
05:21But it will have a great political impact.
05:24Hassan, what would you like to comment on this?
05:27Obviously, the way this is a matter of the entire Senate,
05:32the way the statements were made,
05:34then this matter has gone to the court.
05:36Do you think that the clarity will come to light to some extent after tomorrow's decision?
05:43As of now, I am seeing that tomorrow the Supreme Court will decide according to the law
05:50or the Supreme Court will rewrite the law through its decision.
05:54Now the fundamental question is,
05:56because this is an appeal of 185,
05:58against the decision of the Peshawar High Court,
06:01the Sunni Ithaad Council has come under appeal in the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
06:06Now the Sunni Ithaad Council came under appeal,
06:08their lawyer was Faisal Siddiqui.
06:11Now if you listen to the arguments of Faisal Siddiqui,
06:15and if you listen to the arguments of Kamal Chaudhary's lawyer,
06:20Salman Akram Raja,
06:23then one thing can be corrected.
06:26That is, the arguments of Salman Akram Raja were against Faisal Siddiqui,
06:31and the arguments of Faisal Siddiqui were against Salman Akram Raja.
06:34So I am very confused as to what the Supreme Court will decide in this matter.
06:40And this is probably why the second hearing of the Supreme Court took place,
06:46and all the judges are sitting again.
06:48Because the confusion was not only in Vukla,
06:51because such arguments had come forward.
06:53After that, the judges are also confused as to what to do now.
06:56Are these seats of the Sunni Ithaad?
06:58Or are these seats of Pakistan Tariq-e-Insaf?
07:00Or are these seats, because both are not parliamentary committees,
07:03then they should be distributed among other parliamentary committees.
07:07So one thing is clear that all the judges agree that these seats cannot be left empty.
07:15These seats will be given to someone or the other.
07:18But does the Sunni Ithaad get it?
07:20Does Pakistan Tariq-e-Insaf get it?
07:22Or do other governmental committees get it?
07:24One thing will be this.
07:26The second thing is that always,
07:28any case in which the decision is safe,
07:30the judges consult in it.
07:33But the consultation happens only once.
07:35This is a new thing that we have seen
07:37that all the judges are sitting again for the second time.
07:40And I believe that you have almost reached a conclusion in this.
07:47That is, the decision has already been made on it.
07:51Now tomorrow is its announcement.
07:53Because before this, maybe all these judges…
07:55Of course, if the decision is safe, then this is what it means.
07:58No, the decision has already been safe.
08:00But after that, whether the judges have reached a conclusion or not,
08:03they make the decision because
08:05they have to read all the arguments themselves.
08:07That is, there are many arguments in the writing.
08:09After reading them, they have to reach a conclusion.
08:11No, all this has increased the importance of this case even more.