Makhsoos Nashiston Ka Maamla. .. Supreme Court Ka Kya Faisla Ho Ga??
Makhsoos Nashiston Ka Maamla. .. Supreme Court Ka Kya Faisla Ho Ga??
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00184, 187 total justice, complete justice, complete justice, so this argument, there is a difference on the bench that complete justice has to be done or only this prayer has to be done.
00:14Yes, yes, you are absolutely right that this has come to light from the two respected judges of the bench.
00:21One fundamental question is whether the election commission could have declared these hopefuls who were fighting the election with the support of PTI free.
00:29Will it go to the Supreme Court? Can it go to the Supreme Court?
00:31By the way, tell me quickly, I am asking the same thing to Asnath.
00:33Can it go to the Supreme Court that these were Mr. Tariq Khan's, these will be Mr. Tariq Khan's?
00:36Only now, only now, Kashi bhai, this has come to light from the two judges.
00:40With regards to Article 187, with regards to complete justice, there are 13 judges sitting in this bench.
00:47And the decision that has to be taken in this, Kashi bhai, it has to be done on the basis of majority, not on the sayings of one or two judges.
00:54Or on the remarks of Qazi Faisal Sahib, if we take any decision, then the decision will not be taken on the basis of his own decision.
01:01But Kashi bhai, all these things that are happening with regard to the elections,
01:06the remarks given by Atar Manila Sahib that what happened in the elections in the country is a whole history.
01:12But we should also remember, Kashi bhai, that when the elections of the Senate were held in March 2021,
01:19you will remember that 49 votes were cast for Yusuf Raza Gilani, and 48 votes for Sadiq Sanjani.
01:277 votes were cast for him.
01:30And with 7 votes cast, the votes for Yusuf Raza Gilani had become 42.
01:35And for Sadiq Sanjani, it had become 48.
01:38Now here, he did not even have the Mutabadal Forum.
01:41He had gone to the High Court.
01:43Atar Manila Sahib had heard that case.
01:45There too, it was a matter of democracy.
01:47There too, it was a matter of clear elections.
01:50But there, Atar Manila Sahib had told the lawyer of Yusuf Raza Gilani,
01:54that if you have more numbers, then you should go in confidence.
01:59Although it was a matter of 7 votes.
02:01It was a matter of Aiwana-e-Bala.
02:02Those 7 votes were not checked.
02:04They were not seen.
02:05But here you see that the election that took place,
02:09Imran Khan Sahib had said in the case of Naftar Ameen,
02:12that we have a request for Dhandli.
02:15You should apply for it.
02:16You should fix it.
02:17This should have come from the PTI.
02:20What Atar Manila Sahib is doing is fine.
02:22He is a respected judge.
02:23He is sitting on the bench and talking.
02:25But if it had come from the PTI, then it would have been more appropriate.
02:28Now you see that the request for Dhandli has been issued.
02:36Imran, you are right.
02:38I have conceded that the judges have this division.
02:41We keep seeing that something comes from somewhere and something else comes from somewhere.
02:47But do you think that this request will be issued for the election of Dhandli?
02:50Because a lot of decisions, unfortunately,
02:52by looking at the decisions of the Supreme Court,
02:54or by looking at their proceedings,
02:55we already know what is happening.
02:56This will not happen.
02:57This will happen.
02:58This decision will be made.
02:59This will not happen.
03:00No, now this time this is an advantage.
03:02And its credit goes to Chief Justice Qazi Faisal.
03:04According to the Supreme Court Practice and Procedure Act,
03:06they have formed a committee.
03:07Now the majority of the decisions will be made in the committee.
03:09Now Justice Muneeb and Justice Mansoor Ali Shah,
03:12in that majority, if they say that this bench will be there and this case should be filed,
03:16then it will be filed immediately and that bench will be there.
03:18It is not necessary that Justice Qazi Faisal can make this decision.
03:21She can definitely make this decision.
03:22There is no one in this.
03:23And Imran was saying that the demand that complete justice,
03:29look at the entire election,
03:30the decision to take the symbol,
03:32it is quite clear to many people that it has been misinterpreted.
03:35Many people even say that the decision that was given was wrong.
03:38Absolutely.
03:39The one that Qazi Faisal gave.
03:40No, absolutely that is the case.
03:42But it is not the case that the decision of January 13th,
03:44Justice Qazi Faisal himself says that the interpretation of that was not done by the Election Commission.
03:48The PTI made mistakes.
03:50So when the Election Commission, a constitutional body,
03:52did not interpret it correctly,
03:54then 187 can be used.
03:57I think there is a division.
03:59There is a division.
04:00Five judges can go to 184, 3 and 187
04:05and pass such an order and say that PTI should get these reserved seats.
04:09Now PTI has also requested that we should form a party.
04:12By the way, there are many flaws in PTI's legal strategy.
04:16There is no doubt about it.
04:18But who will have the majority?
04:20Because it is very tricky at the moment.
04:225-5, 2-3, swing vote.
04:23We don't know what will happen.
04:26There are many flaws of PTI that have emerged.
04:28They have not done it in many places.
04:30But Pakistani,
04:32I often listen to court cases.
04:34Where there is a will, there is a way.
04:36Where there is no will, there is no way.
04:39But despite the flaws,
04:41what will the Supreme Court do?
04:43What will it do?
04:45If you look at it briefly.
04:47Look, one thing that is obvious is that
04:49if they don't get it, how can they get it?
04:51No League and People's Party get reserved seats.
04:53In this, it seems that
04:55the majority should decide
04:57that these people should not get it.
04:59But no one wants to get it.
05:01Look, there will be a mechanism
05:03that there will be a suggestion
05:05about a constitutional amendment in the parliament.
05:07Or some other solution will be found.
05:09But an amendment should be made for this.
05:11Because when I told Mr. Rana that
05:13these seats do not belong to him,
05:15but you also do not get it.
05:17He said that this will happen with a simple law.
05:19A simple law will be needed.
05:21But they should not get it.
05:23PTI should not get it.
05:25So the real thing in this case
05:27is the constitutional amendment.