• 4 months ago
First broadcast 1st August 2010.

Edward Muir and his son Luke,members of the austere Triune Family religious group,are brutally murdered with open bibles by the corpses,referring to the Rapture or promise of eternal life.

Blythe Duff ... DS Jackie Reid
John Michie ... DI Robbie Ross
Alex Norton ... DCI Matt Burke
Colin McCredie ... DC Stuart Fraser
Katrina Bryan ... Pathologist Ellis Sinclair
Alexander Morton ... James Hardie
Fiona Bruce ... Anne Hardie
Edward Corrie ... August Hardie (as Edward M Corrie)
Neil McNulty ... Paul Hardie
Rachel Ogilvy ... Eileen Mulray
Jamie Michie ... Brian Cowie
Sarah Currie ... Donna
Peter Milne ... PC
Christopher Downie ... Camera Man

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00You
00:30I
01:00I
01:30I
01:32I
01:54It's like the young guy who was stabbed by the older one, what do you think murder?
01:59suicide
02:01Must have attacked him in the kitchen dragged him through here cut his own throat and then dropped the knife
02:07Some weird about his house
02:10pictures on the walls
02:12The family photographs
02:16This Bible has been marked in the same place as that one same passage back all the boss
02:24Oh
02:30Monsieur
02:33Where
02:36I'll be right there
02:40Did you know these people
02:44Could you tell me their names
02:47It was you found them
02:51But you don't know
02:55I can't speak to you. I'm sorry, but you're gonna have to we don't speak to moderns
03:04Excuse me
03:05Stewart, could you look after this lady, please?
03:09What have we got two dead males in the house and the woman who found them is refusing to speak
03:24So the same passage has been marked in both Bibles
03:29Hold I show you a mystery. We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed
03:37Mystery exactly
03:42Do you make of this Robbie
03:45Judging by the amount of blood looks like several than artery. I
03:50Mean it could be suicide
03:55You
04:00Victims are Edward Muir and his son Luke
04:02What's the one done quiet kept themselves to themselves seemed like nice folk can't believe this happened in our street pretty much
04:09They were apparently members of the triune family of God as was the woman that found them
04:14Bible bashers, that's all bloody neat
04:16They don't mix with people beyond their church because they believe the world is a wicked place. It is son
04:21So, where's this woman who found them in the car
04:26Is that a bodyguard
04:29If you're looking for my wife I sent her home. Oh you have have you I can speak on her behalf
04:34It's not you. I want to talk to make sure this gentleman and his wife are at the station in 20 minutes
04:41Behold I show you a mystery
04:43We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed any idea why this passage
04:49No, yeah, but it's Corinthians 1551 apparently
04:54I'll never understand how a father can kill a child
04:57never
04:59family that prays together slays together
05:03Gala's humor a coping mechanism
05:05That's Anne Hardy and her husband in the interview room before we talk to them
05:09What's the story of this group they belong to the triune family of God or an evangelical church?
05:15They believe in a triune God God is three people the Father the Son and the Holy Spirit
05:20They don't watch TV or listen to the radio. They won't vote or read newspapers
05:24They don't use computers mobile phones or cameras and they don't allow their kids to go to university
05:29Facial hair is not allowed. Well and the men are the women
05:32They tend to live close to each other because they don't own cars. They rarely speak to people outside the church
05:37They don't touch tea coffee or alcohol
05:40They sound like a right bar laughs right Robin I'll talk to the heart is you to find out what you can about the Muir family
05:50Ds read
05:54Sure, I'll be down in a minute
05:57I
06:03Lean it's so nice to see you. I'm afraid it's not a social call Jack
06:09It's Karen. She didn't come home last night
06:12Mrs. Harvey, why did you leave the scene of crime before DC?
06:16I bark had a chance to speak to you. My wife was simply obeying the rules of our church
06:21We do not associate with moderns who are
06:25Anyone outside our church
06:29And what is your position within the church, mr. Hardy, I'm an elder a
06:34trustee of the elected one
06:36Who is the head of our church?
06:39lives in America
06:41We're worldwide
06:43so as parcel force
06:45If that's the case, can you give your wife permission to talk to us? No, I can't
06:51But I have the authority to speak for any member of our church
06:54We need to know if she saw anything at the house this morning could help with our investigation
06:59Mrs. Hardy must speak for herself. I'm afraid it's not quite as simple as that. Mr. Burke detective chief inspector buck
07:06I've been phoning our mobile, but it just goes to answer the machine. I
07:11Reported are missing at my local station, but they said if she's an adult they can't do anything for 24 hours
07:18Said she was low risk
07:21So
07:23What age is she now? I mean she must be 18 just
07:30Did they allocate you an investigating officer? Yes, they said they'd put her into the system. When did you last see it?
07:37It's about eight o'clock last night
07:39She went out to a pub in the Merchant City
07:42It's got some DJ on there on a Friday. She likes
07:47But I know it's not your department
07:51When she's vulnerable Jackie, she's not streetwise at all
07:59It's okay, I mean, did you have a current photograph? Yes
08:05Brought a few with me. Oh
08:12That Harley I've recognized her
08:15Time flies doesn't it? What was the pub?
08:19the Cali arms the Caledonian arms
08:23Could you call me?
08:24As soon as you hear anything, I promise
08:28No
08:29Off you go
08:32She's probably at home waiting for you now. Thanks Jackie
08:35My
08:39Wife had gone to see Edward. She had been a great comfort to him since his wife died, but
08:46She didn't see anything suspicious. Is that right?
08:53And did Edward Muir have business problems no
08:58If he had we would have known
09:01Her group is very close
09:03How did he caught with his wife's death?
09:06Was devastated
09:08But with God's help he had moved on
09:11So you've no idea why he might have done this terrible thing if he did
09:17if
09:19My friend had hard to believe that Edward would sin against God or plunge a kitchen knife and his son for that matter
09:27The passage from
09:29Corinthians
09:30Behold I show you a mystery
09:33We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed in a moment
09:38The twinkling of an eye at the last trump, but the trumpet shall sound
09:44The dead shall be raised incorruptible
09:48And we shall be changed
09:51What relevance do you think this passage could have to the mortars?
09:54The mystery been spoken of as a truth that had not previously been revealed in the Old Testament, but was revealed in the new
10:02the Rapture
10:04at the end of days
10:07Not all of us will die
10:10See
10:12And it
10:14Edward Muir believe that
10:16It's in the Bible
10:18Plain and simple just answer the question
10:21Did he believe it?
10:24He did
10:27I
10:29See how when you were looking at the trial family you come across anything about the Rapture
10:33Yeah, apparently Jesus will return to earth and all true Christians will be transported to the heavens to meet the Lord
10:39What about the rest of us that was Swanee without a paddle? Yeah, I guess so
10:44Yeah, that's what I thought. So if you believe that why would you risk your eternal salvation?
10:49No
10:51Edward Muir didn't kill himself
10:56I
11:06Speak to someone who was working last night
11:15Karen oh, you know, she comes in on a Friday regular
11:20She likes a DJ. Is that right? Yeah, please a lot of chancy techno
11:25Yeah
11:27Was she with you
11:29Is she okay?
11:32Yeah, as far as I know I just like to find out if she left with anyone in particular
11:36She was talking to one of two guys as I remember. She's had a few she was drunk
11:42Just a bit
11:45Did you recognize any of these guys that she was talking to no, not really
11:48She
11:50Looked like she was having a good time
11:52She's taking a lot of pictures on her mobile. I remember that and she left with someone
11:57Oh, I really don't know. It was stout. I mean she could have left one of the boys. Okay
12:03Could you give me a call if you see Karen again or any of the guys that she was with sure
12:10Thank
12:19Jackie
12:21Where have you been? I've got a murder inquiry here the mirrors. Remember them
12:26I've been checking a missing persons case. Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't know you've been transferred all hands on deck
12:31I want this tied up as soon as possible
12:38They're here you get a tongue-lashing
12:40He did indeed. You know, he's like things again the press
12:44He's the attention
12:46Listen Robbie, can you do me a favor? I need you to cover for me
12:50I'm trying to find the daughter of an old school friend. Her name's caramel Ray. Her mother's worried about her
12:56She's been missing since last night. Hi. Sure. No problem
12:59There are traces of blood and skin under Luke's fingernails. There are no scratches in Edward
13:06So the boys struggle with someone but not his father
13:08I
13:10Was someone else in that room wasn't it possibly I need more time before I give you my full report in the meantime
13:17I'll assume we're looking at a double murder if that's all right with you. Well, let's just say I'm 99% sure
13:31Where's Jackie now, uh, she's away checking near his bank accounts. They have bank accounts
13:38Alright listen up folks
13:40We need to interview every member of this cult pronto
14:08Mr. Hardy
14:16We'd work with your congregation if you don't mind
14:22I'm sorry, but you're not allowed in here
14:24We need to organize a time and a place to speak to them individually. I'll only take a moment. That's impossible
14:30Told you before that we do not associate with people outside our church. Mr. Hardy. This is a criminal inquiry. I know that
14:38You can't force us to cooperate
14:40Not at the moment, but we will you seem to know a lot about police procedure for someone who doesn't
14:47Associate to the outside world. I make it my business to know what I need to know
14:51to protect my people
14:53Don't you understand?
14:55We don't recognize your law
14:57Troublesome it recognizes you
15:01Don't speak to them again
15:04Two members of your congregation have died in suspicious circumstances
15:09Don't you want to know why? You cannot enter our meeting hall
15:14If you don't mind
15:17What is it you've got to hide exactly mr. Hardin?
15:20We have nothing to hide
15:23nothing to parade
15:25We live by the Word of God
15:28And he believes that the secular world is corrupt
15:31And has asked us to shun it
15:34Excuse me
15:38That is gonna go down a bucket of cold sink I
15:43Can't believe I'm here in this who do these people think they are?
15:46Yeah, I know
15:47I'm not too happy with their attitude either boss
15:49But can't force them to help us then we have to get past him to the other members of the church
15:53Find out what's going on with these people. So with religious matters. You should tread carefully show some respect for people's beliefs
15:59They haven't shown much respect to us have they it's give and take in this world Stuart this guy James Hardy thinks is above the law
16:06I don't like that. Yes, sir. I want to talk to somebody else in that church apart for him. Okay?
16:29I
16:46Chalk you've just saved I think he was one of Karen's friends. No, no, I don't think so
16:59I
17:25Said who is this?
17:30I
17:37Seven eight two, three six
17:53Not called on us
17:59I
18:16Robbie I might have lost my marbles. I think I've just found a grave
18:29I
18:34To the just all things are just that's what he said the caller who gave me the coordinates
18:41That's I'm biblical to you. You think this is linked to the trident family. Let's find out
18:48Any ID
18:54Student card
18:57Karen Mulray
19:00All right, you know, yeah, I'm not sure
19:09Jackie hi. Can you talk?
19:12Yeah, what's up? You know that girl? You mentioned your friend's daughter
19:17Was her name Karen Mulray? Yeah
19:21Why what's happened
19:24Listen I'm really sorry to have to tell you this but we've just found a body
19:30I'll
19:32I'll explain a situation to the boss
19:35Okay
19:39If you don't mind I'd like to tell her mother myself sure sure if that's what you want, yeah
19:47Listen I know it's not a good time. But um, is there anything you can tell us?
19:53She was she left a Kelly a the Cali arms with a young guy. Okay, that's as far as I got
20:01Oh and and there's one other thing Robbie
20:04She was taking photographs on a mobile phone
20:08Yeah, that could be useful right nice Jackie
20:22You
20:52You
21:06Come to tell me my wee girl's dead
21:12We found her this morning
21:15She's gone
21:23Oh
21:35Where's Billy Eileen, I think he's working
21:42Not sure
21:45We separated last year
21:52I didn't know
21:55Do you want me to speak to him I should do that. I don't mind
22:01He met someone at work
22:04The usual story you could write it yourself
22:09Karen had become a bit withdrawn recently. I'm sure that's why
22:23What happened
22:28I I don't know the details
22:33What did I see
22:36Didn't have half the streets much she thought she did
22:40Now we were the same the nonsense we got up to the drinking and the rest
22:49No
22:53Who would do this to my weak girl Jackie the quote alludes to those who believe in predestination such as the triune family
22:59They see themselves as the just
23:02Justified chosen what they're going to heaven anyway, so they can do whatever they want in this life
23:07Not quite they still have to obey the word of the Lord
23:10So whoever called me either knows who the killer is or is the killer playing at funny buggers
23:15Either way the point in the finger directly at this triune family
23:18Karen's phone I mean according to Jackie she was taking photographs with her before she disappeared
23:23And did she have it on her when she was found no we need to make finding that phone our number one priority
23:47I
24:18I
24:22That's that camera shy, that's the only photo of any member of the trial family
24:26We could find this is James hardly taken 20 years ago when they bought their meeting call
24:30The local paper ran the story on Jackie's found a direct link between caramel ray and the triune family
24:35Yeah, she'd been gathering information on that a mother of any idea. Why she was so interested in them
24:41No, but it sounds to me like she'd been at a bit of a loss after her father left
24:45I mean, maybe she was looking for a new direction in life, but you try to speak to them. It's possible I
24:50Don't think so
24:52She seemed particularly interested in James Hardy sure take a look at a computer. See if you can find anything Jackie might have missed
24:59James Hardy's controlling the other members of the so-called church. You won't let him speak. He knows more than he's letting on
25:07Robbie let's put the pressure on
25:15I
25:38Got to come out at some point
25:40Well, I'm not gonna stand out here on I freeze my ass off climb the fence and open the gate
25:45Hey
25:46This is my best suit Paul Smith
25:49What's the problem? You still paying it up? What you want me to climb it? No
26:01I'm not even gonna ask
26:16Why are you in here?
26:18We'd like to speak to your father
26:21We've no desire to speak to you or any other moderns half it enough of this bollocks. Where's your old man? Excuse me?
26:28But I must ask you to leave this is private property and you're breaking and entering really
26:33Well, you can fill in a complaint form while you're down at the station. Let's go
26:36How
26:42Long do you intend to keep me? Yeah, did you know caramel right?
26:47No, anybody in your cults no caramel right we are not a cult did anyone know Karen Murray I'm aware of
26:56You're hiding something. I haven't begun to piece this little puzzle together yet, but I will
27:03Trust me I will
27:13We clutching at straws here boss, I mean, we've got no witnesses no physical evidence
27:18No motivation no reason for him to have killed the Muir family or the more a girl
27:23I mean, is it possible that you just have a problem with these people with their beliefs?
27:26I don't care what they believe I do care. They think they're above the law
27:30Sir I think I found Colin's phone
27:40Christ that's the dead boy Luke Muir
27:43That's the Cali arms
27:46She was with him the night. She died
27:48That's it. That's the last one
27:51I
27:58Tell me about Luke Muir
28:03What is it to tell
28:05Nice boy good worker
28:07We were very proud of him
28:08How did you feel about his death?
28:11Or his father's for that matter
28:13You haven't really said
28:16No, we keep our feelings within the church
28:18Presumably you were upset
28:21So we're all upset, of course
28:23He was with caramel ray the night. She died
28:26Don't you find that strange? What do you mean?
28:32He was in a pub with her drinking
28:37Well, no he
28:39Should not have been in a place of entertainment. That's true
28:42It was possible. They knew each other
28:45Had a relationship. No
28:47No
28:48No, I don't think that's possible, but you're not sure just how well do you know your flock?
28:55As I said before
28:57We do not associate with anyone outside our church. We do not even eat with moderns
29:03and if he had I would have known and
29:07He would have been shunned
29:09Shunned excluded to cast out we would withdraw from him
29:14He would not be allowed to mix with any member of the church until
29:18We had decided he had been punished enough. How long would that last?
29:22As long as we say and if he wanted to leave the church he could leave
29:28But I would never see his family again
29:31So of this kid Luke Muir has been sheltered all his life
29:35Meets a girl outside the cult wants to leave the cult but his old man realizing he'll never see him again
29:41Kills the girl then kills herself and the boy. Aye when the guilt kicks in so who called me who's deep throat?
29:49Now there's something no right about the Hardys. We need to talk to the wife this time, but that our husband being present
29:58Yes, yes wait
30:00I
30:09Thought I didn't associate with people outside the church obviously doesn't apply to taxi drivers
30:17See where she's going
30:21Did she ever mention a boy called Luke
30:25Luke Muir
30:27Is that who took her?
30:31I'm not sure
30:33But I need to know how well she knew
30:37She mentioned him
30:39Said his father was a member of a strict religious group
30:44So he couldn't come over to the house or watch television
30:48Play computer games stuff like that. I
30:51Think she felt sorry for him
30:55Did she meet other members of the group don't know
30:59She
31:02Didn't see that Luke was worried about someone in the group who didn't like the fact that they were free
31:08She mentioned a name
31:14It's ironic I thought they sounded overprotective of their children
31:22But I didn't protect my enough did no no no
31:27This is not your fault Eileen you must never ever think
31:48Is this that
31:56Give them a minute to get a room. Oh, maybe just go for a drink in the chat sure
32:11You're late for Bible class sorry we need a what let them in Brian
32:18Now that you weren't allowed to speak to people outside your faith, so who's this young gentleman I take it
32:24He's not one of the triune family, that's right. I'm not so who is he your lover. He's my brother
32:36I was trying family once
32:38Not anymore
32:40And wants to leave and I'm trying to help her cross back into the secular world
32:44She's not been happy for a long time
32:47Since I left she's afraid she'll never see her boys again
32:52We could you not take your boys with you James would never accept that
32:56This is hardly
32:59Is there anything you can tell me to help me get to the bottom of these killings?
33:02And what way were you a comfort to Edward Muir after his wife died?
33:06Now I'm not going anywhere to look at the truth
33:16Edward Muir and I had an affair
33:21It didn't last long we both knew it was wrong, so it stopped when a
33:29Few weeks before he was killed and who ended it you or him I did did your husband know about this I
33:38Don't believe you did no, so why are you visiting Edward Muir on the day? He was found dead I
33:46Wanted to warn him that his son Luke and my son Paul had been seeing a modern
33:51Saw them with her. I
33:53Didn't want my husband to know I didn't want them shunned and what about August was he saying moderns to?
34:02August no
34:04He'd never do that
34:06He abhors the modern world. We need to speak to Paul in August. No James is at the meeting hall. I
34:13Think the boys are at home. We'll give you a lift. No
34:17Thank you
34:21I'm not sure. I'm going back. I
34:26Need some time to think
34:37I didn't know the girl your mother says different
34:41Says you and Luke Muir were both senior. Were you jealous Paul?
34:47Were you jealous of Luke and Karen I
34:50Wasn't seeing the girl I was trying to stop Luke from seeing her I
34:55Wanted to help him back to the way of the Lord. What were you doing in the Caledonian arms?
35:00Well, you were in the Cali arms
35:02Was that not against the rules of your cult? I?
35:06Saw you Paul dinner you were having a drink weren't you I
35:13Was looking for Karen I
35:15Had to tell her what had happened to Luke
35:18Why there I knew they went there I
35:23Didn't know what I was doing. I was upset
35:26If you know anything you must tell us someone else could get killed. I
35:33Don't think you realize how much
35:37So
35:41What do you think when you discovered your brother was seeing a modern what Paul and Luke
35:47They were both seeing a girl called Karen more a
35:51You didn't know that
35:54Paul wouldn't do that. Apparently he would
35:57Did your father know if he did they would have been shunned?
36:01shunned
36:02Yeah
36:03Very grown-up way of dealing with things
36:06We have to live the way God tells us or we'll be left behind at the end of days with the fornicators and the adulterers
36:13Paul knows this
36:15He'd never risk his everlasting soul never
36:25Dare you speak to my sons without my permission
36:28Mr. Hardy, they're just helping us with our inquiries. Maybe you could take a leaf out that book. God is our judge
36:35Not you, mr. Hardy
36:39Did you know your wife was having an affair with Edward Muir?
36:41No, I only asked because it does give you motive to kill Edward Muir and his son. There's certainly one way of shunning them
36:55I'm taking my boys home where they belong
37:00If
37:10You don't mind me saying so that was incredibly irresponsible I do mind
37:14You could be putting on Hardy at risk. You've got no idea how her husband might react to that news
37:19Jackie's got a point boss killing three people isn't exactly playing by the rules either. Is it I need results
37:25I don't care what it takes now. I know one of them's a killer and they're hiding behind the religion
37:30That kind of hypocrisy makes my stomach jump
37:49Is it true
37:53It's what you and Edward you were sharing his bed
38:00Oh
38:02Yes, it's true
38:05How could you do that to me
38:07to us
38:10You will be shunned
38:13Do you realize that? You will be shunned
38:17You will never never
38:20See any of us again
38:24Leave her
38:30I
38:32I
38:53Jackie I found something on Karen's computer. Yeah look
38:59Paul Hardy with Karen
39:01Seems he didn't know it after all we should bring him in
39:05She doesn't have to leave
39:08We can forgive her and nobody needs to know anything but God will know
39:12We need to be a family
39:15What's the point of this if we can't be a family the church is our family?
39:21We can't just let our mother disappear from our lives August it's too late for that
39:26She won't be taken by God now. We'll lose her at the rapture. Don't you should pray we don't lose you as well
39:32I
39:54You lied to us Paul
39:57I
39:59You and Karen were seeing each other
40:03Was she playing you off against each other you and Luke
40:09She was making fun of us
40:13I'm sure she didn't mean any harm
40:17That's what girls do sometimes
40:19Using us is that why you killed her? I didn't I loved her
40:25She said she didn't know who she loved me or Luke she was confused
40:31But I would never have hurt her. That's not the way it will seem
40:36You've got a motive
40:38Jealousy and you lie to us
40:41I'll put a bet on it. You'll be convicted, but I'm telling the truth you killed Karen and then Luke
40:48But his father came home and caught you so you had to kill him too. Isn't that right Paul?
40:52Isn't that what happened? No, no, it looks that way to me who else would have done it
41:13Is it possible your father could have found out
41:16But he wanted to protect you
41:19But he could have done this to come
41:21No
41:22My father would never harm anyone not even Edward Muir
41:27He didn't know about my mother and mr. Muir until you told him
41:35We didn't tell him we didn't have the heart we
41:42Your brother knew about your mother's affair
41:45We both did
41:48Luke told us he'd seen them together
41:52August spoke about fornicators and adulterers
42:01Hello August
42:08August what are you doing?
42:12Fallen is Babylon
42:15Please a dwelling for demons August. I'm your mother a haunt for every unclean spirits
42:27I saw heaven wide open
42:30And a white horse appears his rider's name was faithful
42:38To his mouth came a sharpsword to smite the waiting
42:45They must be punished
42:50Unclean God will punish them
42:54Come the end of days. They will be left behind or the Lord shall gather his elect. Now. Give me the knife
43:07Wants me to destroy them
43:10Fornicators. No, he doesn't give me the knife
43:14It's in the scriptures
43:16You killed them
43:19Didn't you?
43:21You killed Edward and look and the girl
43:27They betrayed God
43:33Just listen to me
43:36Only God can decide
43:38Who will travel with them and who will die?
43:41It is his will and his will only now
43:45Please give me the knife
43:47To the just all things are just
44:15I
44:19Was you who made that call wasn't it?
44:22To the just all things are just I don't understand
44:27What did you want to bring attention to yourself?
44:30Not to me
44:32to them
44:33to their crimes
44:35I've nothing to be ashamed of
44:37I
44:43It's not what I told them it's not no, I knew that
45:02We have to
45:05To see Eileen
45:07Try and help her understand why this happened
45:37You