"Agar Practice and Procedure ka Process High Courts kay andar Hota to Aj... Hafiz Ahsaan's Analysis
#islamabadhighcourt #SupremeCourt #breakingnews #KashifAbbasi #cjp #qazifaizesa #HafizAhsaan
"Agar Practice and Procedure ka Process High Courts kay andar Hota to Aj... Hafiz Ahsaan's Analysis
"Agar Practice and Procedure ka Process High Courts kay andar Hota to Aj... Hafiz Ahsaan's Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Haan Faisal, yeh zyaira ab kisi nukre toh lagega, sawal bahut se uthrein mai jaunga
00:06ke kya high court ke rules bhi banane chahiye, supreme court ko, hukumat ka kirdar kya hai,
00:10leh ke aaj ki proceedings ke baare mein aapka kya khyaal hai, kaafi serious charges lagaye,
00:16baar baar lagaye jaa rahe the.
00:17Lekin Kashif, main aaj ki proceedings hai usko main teen angle se dekhta hu, ek uska
00:22angle yeh hai ke ek institutional response mechanism pe baat ki gayi aur hona chahiye
00:27institutional mechanism jo hai, doosra uske andar baat yeh ki gayi hai, ke baabajood
00:31is cheez ke andar judicial interference hai, uske saath saath jo internal judiciary interference
00:38hai uspe bhi baat aayi hai, aur ek bada important jo lafaz istamaal kiya gaya hai, chief justice
00:43ki taraf se, wo a complicity, ke supreme court ke andar jo log baitha hai, judiciary
00:48ke andar baitha hai, alaqaar bante hain, aur uska izhaar jo hai, wo aapke dharna judgment
00:53ki taraf bhi gaya, wo aapke jo 4, 5, 6, 7 review aaye thi uske upar bhi gaya, review
00:58ko bitha ke rakha, bitha baith gaye uske upar review nahi dekh kiya gaya, phir uske baad
01:02yeh aaya gaya, composition aur benches pe bhi baat ki gayi, phir uske baad aaya gaya
01:06ke liking and disliking wala maamla bhi jo hai, wo aaya aur ek jo discretion ka issue
01:11aaya hua hai, structured kisam ka, uske upar bhi baat ki gayi, ke yeh cheeze agar do saal
01:16pehle practice and procedure aata, to usko strike down ho jana tha.
01:20Practice and procedure high courts mein kyu nahi?
01:23Woh hona chahiye na, yeh hi wo ek cheeze hai.
01:25Arthur Manila sahab ke time, senior puny judge benches banate the, aur sara kuch karte the.
01:30Yeh pehle bhi tha.
01:31Jo ke Justice sahab mein kharu khud the, aap unhone saara maamla aapke haath mein rakha
01:34wo.
01:35Yeh hi wo issue hai, agar yeh practice and procedure ka ek process jo hai, high courts
01:38ke andar hota, to aaj yeh naubat nahi aani thi, jo aayi hui hai, ke jiske andar selective
01:43of benches, fixation of cases ka issue, yeh lagna chahiye, yeh nahi lagna chahiye.
01:48Doosri cheeze ki hai, kuch cheeze exaggeration bhi iske andar aayi hai.
01:51Bas jis tarah ek yeh kaah gaya, ki 76 saal se Pakistan ki judiciary uske andar intervention
01:56hai, jisko Chief Justice ne deny kiya, aapke waha pe 6 Chief Justice baithe hua the aur
02:01Pakistan ka Chief Justice tha, in saaron ke 10-12 saal ka judiciary ke chale ho rahe,
02:06unhone ne kaah ke humari to mudakhalat, koi nahi hai us cheeze ke andar, humne toh kisi
02:10ne nahi kaah, humne toh bada accha kaam kiya hai, aur main as a Chief Justice bhi perform
02:14kiya hai, aur ab bhi kaah hai, koi aisa incident nahi hai.
02:17Ab jo High Courts ke bhi andar aapki cheezein aayi hai, jo cheezein aayi hai, uske andar
02:21ek general baat ki gayi hai, ki pressure hai, external hai, koi facts ko point out hai,
02:27ab iska Kashif hal kya hai?
02:28Hal, abhi aata hu, ek second, pehle zara sense le le na, ki what people think of these proceedings
02:33today?
02:34Aur jo aapne zikr kiya, Catherine Millar sahab ne kaah, 76 saal, Chief Justice sahab ne
02:37kaah, nahi ji yeh, mere daur mein nahi hai.
02:39Aur unhone khud bhi kaah ke, I the Chief Justice bhi mere kaam kiya hai, yeh ab bhi hai,
02:42mere pe toh kabhi kisi ne nahi kaah.
02:45Woh masla yeh ke, bohot saare cases ke faislein aaj, jo abhi kuch har se pehle hua hai, un
02:52saaron ke par tankeer aajsi shuru hogi hai, ammuman log intazaar karte hain, koi jaayega,
02:57koi badlega, phir dekha jaayega, wo idda tak, raat, 12-12 wajah tak proceedings chalayegi,
03:02yeh judges yeh na kahin na kahin, mutaadit cases, Islamabad High Court ke toh aapne saamne
03:09hai, ki kis tarah, chale pichla tenure yeh ho, ya yeh tenure ho.
03:12Kisi ek Islamabad High Court ke andar, in sazaon ko uphold kiya ho, ya kisi High Court
03:17ne kiya ho, pressure kyun hai, pressure kyun ho?
03:21Agar judge aapne banna hai, toh phir aap pressure ko assert karen, aapke par pressure ho kyun
03:26hai?
03:27Sir, yeh kya argument hai, vote pressure dhalenge, aapne agar judge banna hai, pressure dhalenge?
03:30Constitution se nikaal de na, ke main bagayar kisi dar ke kaam karunga, nikaal de uss cheez
03:35ko, main bagayar kisi dar ke kaam karunga.
03:36Sir, Acharya Mianullah sahab ne kaaho, theek ka, ki jab riyasat khadi ho jaye, unke saamne
03:40what do you think, yeh toh pressures ki baat karein, kya yeh judge ko lena chahiye, pressure
03:43hone nahi chahiye?
03:44Constitution mein yeh kya likha hoa hai, ke dara ke kaam karana hai, yeh bhi toh nahi
03:47likha hoa na.
03:48Toh aap kisi se puchhe, yeh toh likha ho na ke darna nahi.
03:51Aaj saare jo the, aaj jo aapke saamne the, unhone toh nahi kaha.
03:55Kaha na sir, masla yeh ke kaha, jab 76 saal kaha, toh unhe kaha, mere pe nahi, kyunki
04:00Athar sahab ne jab Islamabad High Court chalai, toh uska bada confidence hota tha, Saileen
04:05ko bhi, jo humare jaise log jab jaate the, relief lene, yeh arey bata hoa, de dega, tagda
04:10aadmi khada ho jayega.
04:11Lekin, phir aap, humne bohot se adwaar dekhen, sir, hum bhi yehi hai na, jaana padta hai,
04:15idhar hi adalaton mein jaate.
04:17Hal nik, androoni interference bhi hai, bairuni interference bhi hai, but you know, first
04:22time, iske upar baat hui hai, aur kya high court ke rules bhi Supreme Court banaye,
04:29aur is interference ko khatam karna chahiye, androoni mudakhalat hai yeh bairuni.
04:34Kashif bhai, 76 saalon se is reyasat ka nizam bigda ho hai, is reyasat ko jis tariqah se
04:39hum chalate aa rahe hain, bataur ek security state, ab uski hum limits ko paunch gaye hain,
04:44ab yeh reyasat mazeed istara nahi chal paayegi, yeh 25 crore logon ka mulk hai, iski governance
04:49bohot complex ho chuki hai, hume logon ke masayal ko hal karna hai, agar humne unke
04:53masayal ko hal karna hai, toh phir humari establishment ko, humari intelligence agencies
04:57ko, peeche hatna padega, awam ke numayendon ko mauka dena padega, is mulk ke nizam ko
05:02chalne dena padega, yeh jo judge sahibaan ke jo khatoot hai, in judge sahibaan ke khatoot
05:07ke andar specific allegations hai, unhone afsaraan ka zikar kiya hai, jo afsaraan unke
05:12upar pressure dalte rahe hai, aur aap unke saath jo beeti hai, zara uspe ghaur toh karein
05:17ki yeh high court ke judge sahibaan, Islamabad high court ke, 6 judge sahibaan kah rahe
05:21hain, ek ke brother in law ko utha liya, usko elected shocks lage, uski upar tashaddud
05:25kiya, ek judge sahab jo hai, wo hospital paunch gaye, ek camera nikala hai, camera
05:29nikala hai, yeh kuch maamooli baatein, phir abhi jo iske andar jawabaat ke andar, Peshawar
05:33high court ne, aur attorney general ka aapne sunaya bhi hai, unhone jo ek baat kiye, yeh
05:38Peshawar high court ke judge sahibaan kah rahe hain, ki jee humne jab impartial ho ke
05:43faisle diye, un faisle dene ke nateeje me, humne jab baat nahi suni, toh hume non-state
05:49actors ki jaanib se Afghanistan se dhamkiya aani shuru ho gayi, yeh kya mazaak hai, istara
05:54reyaste chalayi jaate hain, yeh jo judges hain, yeh kahin baayar se hain, yeh humare
05:59pakistani judges hain, yeh koi high court, kisi humare ghair mulki high court hain, yeh
06:04humare apne mulki high court hain, dekhi iska karna kya, aage bhi chalene na zarur, main
06:08aapki baatein sari, main yeh sab suna chukwa, isliye, ki yeh guftagu hui hain, masla yeh
06:13ki maazi mein, humne maazi mein judges ko dekha hai, ralte hue liye, yeh maante hain
06:19bilkul, taarikh bhari padhi hai, taarikh humari bhari padhi hai, ke jisme humari, jo hum
06:24yeh lafz, jisko hum establishment lafz gehte hain na, is establishment lafz ke maini jo
06:29hai, yeh hain, ke uske andar adliya bhi shamil hai, kab adliya istamaal nahi hui, kab adliya
06:35ne apna kanda nahi diya, is mulke andar civilian democratically elected leaders ko fasiyon takpe
06:40chadaya gaya, yeh humare mulki taarikh hai, logon ko kode maare gaye is mulke andar, political
06:46government ko undermine kiya, undermine kiya, logon ki upar jhute cases banaya gaya, naib
06:51ek political engineering ka idara banaya gaya, adalatin khamoshi se baith kar aaj tak dekh
06:55rahi hai, do do saal baad jaakar zamante le leti hain, do saal jis shaks ne andar guzaar
06:59diya, uska kya kasoor tha, uska khandaan walon ko kya kasoor tha, adalat har cheez mein shamil
07:03rahi hai, isme koi shakt nahi hai, yeh humare mulki taarikh hai, lekin, agar yeh high court
07:08ke judge sahibaan ne, yeh jo uthkar saamne aaye hain, aur unhone kaha hai, no more, to
07:13kya us no more ko hum yeh kahka radh kar de, ki peechay ek taarikh hai, isliye humne
07:17inki baat nahi maan bhi, kisi cheez ki iqtadaat, kahiin se to kisi ne naa karni hai, to yeh
07:24jo in 6 judge sahibaan ne Islamabad high court ke kaha, baaki jo 3 high courts se unhone
07:29tajaveez mangai, unhone koi mukhtarif baat ki, sab ek hi baat kar rahe hain, sab ek hi
07:32baat kar rahe hain, aur hum is baat se kaun waqif nahi hain, yeh jo judge sahibaan ka
07:36aapne clip sunaya, jiske andar wo keh rahe hain, ki yeh hum phone idhar rag de, udhar
07:39rag de, hum yeh kaise mulk mein reh rahe hain, hum sab is cheez se guzarte hain, hum aapas
07:43mein guftagu karte hain, hum kehte hain yaar yeh, yeh hum ishaara nahi karte hain, humne
07:46kahaan pauncha diya is mulk mein, aur judge sahibaan phone idhar chhupalo, baayar chhoda
07:50ho, zaroori baat karne hai, yeh to Pakistan ki, yeh hum, yeh taum de nahi karte hain,
07:53aur jiske andar, jo siyasadanon ka amal hai, jo aap ek baat kar rahe the, siyasadan apna
07:58kanda phuram karne ke liye, wo bhi huma waqt tayar rahe the.