PTI aur PTI Nazriati Kay Darmiyan Agreement Haqeeqat Kiya? Expert analysis
#PTI #election2024 #supremecourt
PTI aur PTI Nazriati Kay Darmiyan Agreement Haqeeqat Kiya? Expert analysis
PTI aur PTI Nazriati Kay Darmiyan Agreement Haqeeqat Kiya? Expert analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 The agreement has been presented and the movement for justice has confirmed it.
00:03 But Mr. Dar, who is the founder of this community, says that this is not an agreement.
00:08 Because you meet the founder of PTI, so what is the standard position of the community on this?
00:15 And especially of your clients.
00:17 The more transparency is being done in the election, the more transparency is being seen in this agreement.
00:28 It is just unfolding.
00:30 We have been instructed to get the tickets from the Tariq-e-Insaf Nazriyati.
00:37 And most of the PTI people have got the tickets from Tariq-e-Insaf Nazriyati.
00:45 So this will unfold now.
00:47 Okay, because the agreement that has been presented, the founders of Nazriyati have said that this is not an agreement.
00:55 So in this context, what is the legal value of this agreement?
00:58 That the other signatories are saying that this is not an agreement.
01:01 This is a press conference like this and probably it has happened there too.
01:09 Where most of the PTI people have been present and have expressed their disconnection with PTI.
01:15 So now we will have to see what documents are presented.
01:19 What they have done.
01:21 This is unfolding as we speak. I am not privy to this.
01:24 Okay, Pakistan People's Party Parliamentary and People's Party have a similar agreement.
01:29 And they present it before every election in front of the Election Commission of Pakistan.
01:32 And on the basis of that they fight the elections.
01:34 The Election Commission of Pakistan has taken a plea that this cannot be possible.
01:37 A candidate from another party cannot take the ticket from another party.
01:41 That is why they have instructed the ROs that these papers should not be accepted.
01:46 Yes, Mr. Khosla.
01:51 Yes, this is the first time that the Election Commission has issued such instructions.
01:58 Because in all the previous elections, Pakistan People's Party has fought through the Parliamentarians.
02:08 Okay, fine.
02:10 Mr. Kamran Murtaza, I will ask you this question in legal terms.
02:16 Can such agreements, on the basis of which candidates from one party can fight the elections by adjusting their seats with the other party,
02:24 is it possible, is it legally legit?
02:27 Because the Election Commission of Pakistan has come up with a position that this cannot be done.
02:32 And that is why their documents cannot be accepted.
02:34 Can you guide us on this legally?
02:37 I am asking this question from Kamran Murtaza.
02:43 It is possible that the candidates from one party can fight the elections on the basis of the other party.
02:47 Yes, sir.
02:49 But this is not possible.
02:55 A person can be a member of two parties at the same time.
03:02 I am a member of Jamaitul Islam, but I cannot be a member of any other party.
03:07 This is the same situation in different bars.
03:12 A voter cannot be a member of any other bar.
03:15 If I am a member of Quetta Bar, then I cannot be a member of Islamabad Bar.
03:19 A voter cannot be a member of any other bar.
03:21 If I am a member of an honorary membership, then I can be a member of that bar.
03:24 So, on the same analogy, you cannot fight the elections on the basis of the other party's seat.
03:31 Unless you are a member of that party, and you resign and join another party.
03:36 Sir, if we look at the example of People's Party, both the parties have made a pact.
03:47 I think they had a backup plan because they knew that they should have an alternate party.
03:54 But they did not dissolve the pact.
03:57 So, they manage this.
03:59 Is there any similarity between their case and this case?
04:02 This is a different case. It cannot be compared.
04:07 One thing is that the documents are not in front of us.
04:13 On the basis of which they fight the elections.
04:16 If the documents were in front of us, then we could have given an opinion.
04:20 And the second thing is that if someone is doing something wrong,
04:24 if a party has done something wrong and has not been caught,
04:27 and if another party is caught, then they do not get permission to do this.
04:33 They say that they used to do this, so I have permission to do this.