How Aston Villa Dominated Manchester City
Aston Villa produced the performance of the season with a stunning 1-0 win over Manchester City. With Unai Emery's team now firmly pushing for Champions League qualification, just how did they make the Premier League champions look so ordinary?
Category
š„
SportTranscript
00:00 Hello everybody, Adam Cleary from 442 here and I don't know if you've heard about this
00:06 yet today or if you've seen it on the news or anything but Aston Villa absolutely monstered
00:12 Manchester City.
00:13 And I know people on YouTube like to exaggerate but that is not an exaggeration.
00:18 Statistically, stylistically, numerically, however you want to measure that game, Aston
00:23 Villa basically bent Man City over and...
00:26 So the question today is, how?
00:32 How does anybody do that to a Pep Guardiola team?
00:36 Well, like this.
00:38 Alright, so just quickly before I start, really big special thank you to Classic Football
00:43 Shirts who sent us this absolutely beautiful Bocas Juniors Christmas jumper but I don't
00:48 think it's going to work with the blue screen, that might be a bit weird so I'm leaving my
00:52 coat on so the video doesn't look bad.
00:54 It is, and I do need to start remembering to take my lanyard off, it is really, really
00:58 nice, they've got a whole range, a big collection of them, we'll leave a link in the description
01:01 below if you want one of your own.
01:03 Anyway though, Aston Villa, this Aston Villa, 11 players who are now immortalised in club
01:08 folklore for probably delivering, maybe this is just my outside opinion, but their best
01:14 win since returning to the Premier League.
01:16 I think that's fair.
01:17 But the main thing you need to know is this, Aston Villa sort of play a 4-4-2, that is
01:23 nominally how they set up, it's normally how they defend but what they do with it is just
01:27 really clever and inventive and a completely, completely wrecked man's day.
01:33 So the key thing here is the two wide players, last night that was John McGinn and Uri Tielemans,
01:37 we will talk about them a little bit more and what tends to happen is that the two central
01:40 midfielders, they sit a little bit deeper and these two players sit a little bit narrower.
01:45 Now as you may be starting to recognise from every single tactics video and every single
01:49 channel for the last 12 months, this looks not unlike a box midfield which some of the
01:53 bigger teams use to get numerical superiority in the middle of the pitch.
01:57 That's not what Villa have.
01:58 It is a box, yes, I can recognise the shape, but it's not a box midfield.
02:04 While other teams will use it to sort of retain possession and hold onto the ball and do things
02:07 nice and slowly, Aston Villa actually use it to break an opposition press and go really
02:12 quickly from back to front.
02:14 The goalkeeper, the defenders and the two central midfielders, they will hold onto the
02:17 ball, they will retain possession, they will knock it around and when an opportunity comes
02:21 out when they spot the pass, one of the two wide midfielders will float into the middle
02:27 to receive a killer ball.
02:29 And when one of these wide players does receive that killer pass, then either the entire team
02:33 can push up and they form this whole different attacking shape or, as will occasionally happen,
02:38 they'll catch them off guard and they've all of a sudden got space to do something really
02:41 quickly.
02:42 And this happened straight away in the game last night.
02:45 Aston Villa's very first chance, Pau Torres, you can see here, he's in no rush whatsoever.
02:50 He's being patient, he's happy to invite the press on, he's got loads of options around
02:53 him, but then John McGinn comes off the wide area into the central space, Torres sees him,
02:59 picks him out and all of a sudden he's got all this room to play in.
03:03 He gets turned away from John Stones and without even looking, just knows where Leon Bailey
03:07 is going to be, fires a ball into that space behind the Manchester City defence and Villa
03:12 get a really good chance of it.
03:14 And how, you might be asking, did he know Leon Bailey, who was supposed to be a centre
03:18 forward in this system, how did he know he was going to be all the way over on the right
03:21 hand channel?
03:22 Well, it's because you don't just have these two central midfielders floating inside so
03:25 they can receive the ball in the middle, it's to pose the full backs and the defenders a
03:29 real problem.
03:30 Do you want to go with them and abandon your flank or do you just want to let them receive
03:35 that in space?
03:36 And what Villa tend to do from there when another team takes the bait is either Diaby
03:39 or Bailey or whoever's playing up front with Watkins, they'll spin off into that area.
03:44 They'll receive the ball wide.
03:45 And if we just rewind it a little bit, John McGinn knew Leon Bailey was going to be there
03:49 because Uri Tielemans was here.
03:51 So that's why it's a really, really effective system.
03:54 And obviously Aston Villa are really good at implementing it.
03:57 But specifically, why was this thing kryptonite to Manchester City?
04:02 Well, the answer, rather unsurprisingly, is this box.
04:06 Like Aston Villa don't play the way Man City do.
04:08 They don't have four players there for the reason Manchester City do.
04:11 But by virtue of the way they do play, it meant they ended up matched up man for man
04:16 in that shape and in that area.
04:19 And this is the truly astonishing thing about it.
04:21 If we look at the four players Villa have occupying this space and then we just sort
04:25 of label up directly who they were playing against for Manchester City, man for man,
04:29 and I'm being deadly serious here, Aston Villa have better players in that situation than
04:35 Manchester City do.
04:37 Now just hang on just a quick second.
04:39 Let me explain.
04:40 Maybe you really, really rate John Stones and Okanji and Rico Lewis and Alvarez.
04:45 Maybe you think they're genuinely better players than Aston Villa have got.
04:49 It's a fair argument.
04:50 They just went and won the treble last season, but none of them, not one of them is a midfielder.
04:55 Now obviously Alvarez had a really good season being deployed from midfield.
05:00 Rico Lewis is one of these fullbacks you can come across into midfield.
05:03 John Stones practically played all last season in midfield, but none of them have what those
05:08 four Aston Villa players have.
05:10 And that is hundreds, hundreds of hours and hundreds of games under their belt in this
05:16 part of the pitch.
05:17 And what you get with that isn't just ability, it's instinct.
05:21 Like you know when to get on the ball and when to find some space, you know when to
05:24 speed it up and when to slow it down, when to take a touch and when to release it early.
05:29 Like being a great footballer who is good on the ball will help, but it does not replicate
05:36 years of experience.
05:37 And that's why Villa just ran them absolutely ragged.
05:40 Like the second really good chance they get, it's exactly the same setup to the first.
05:43 Torres is on the ball, he's being patient, he wants to try and play it through the middle
05:47 like he did last time.
05:48 But City, they're really panicked, they can't let that happen.
05:51 So they flood the centre of the pitch.
05:53 They're outnumbered them 6-4 in that area.
05:55 But that isn't good instinctive decision making.
05:58 It opened up a huge space out on the right hand side.
06:00 And as soon as the ball goes to the fullback, Bailey, who is once again holding a wide position,
06:06 recognises there's now loads of space in the middle because they've all swamped into the
06:09 centre of the pitch.
06:10 He begins a run straight into that space and were his touch better, he'd have been cleaned
06:15 through.
06:16 And pretty much just every single time Villa got the ball in the midfield, they were able
06:19 to do more or less what they wanted with it because the players they were up against in
06:24 that area weren't midfielders.
06:26 They had no idea how to deal with it.
06:29 And this is just a tiny little example, right, but a bounce pass is basically when you want
06:33 to go from player A to player B, but that passing route is blocked.
06:36 So player C recognises that the ball isn't for them, but can effectively form a little
06:42 triangle around the problem, drops really deep, hits the ball first time and you finally
06:46 make that pass via him.
06:48 You tend not to see it in this part of the pitch because even if you are man for man
06:52 in that situation, it's far more congested.
06:53 There's more players around.
06:54 If somebody does get pulled away, chasing somebody down, someone is normally there to
06:59 cover straight away.
07:00 But again, all those words I just said tend to only really apply when the people doing
07:05 this are experienced midfielders.
07:07 Coming up to the end of the first half, Aston Villa want to play the ball from player A,
07:11 who I think is Konca, to player B, who is Uri Tielemans.
07:15 Player C here, which is Kamra, realises this ball is not for him.
07:18 He's being tightly marked, but he has a quick look and he sees that the pass to Tielemans
07:22 is blocked.
07:23 So as any experienced bounce passer would do, he attempts to drop short to give them
07:27 a little indirect way of getting from A to B.
07:29 Now under normal circumstances, this shouldn't work because Alvarez here is easily capable
07:34 of cutting out any B to C pass that happens.
07:37 In fact, so obvious is it what's coming here that Manuel Akanji even shouts at him,
07:41 points at Uri Tielemans and tells him that's where the ball is going.
07:46 Akanji you see, is an experienced bounce passer himself.
07:49 He's seen this before.
07:50 But Alvarez, being a centre forward boy in a midfield man's body, is thinking only
07:55 about turning that ball over and getting a dangerous chance, so just ignores the instructions
08:01 and goes straight for Kamra.
08:02 Lo and behold, the bounce pass takes him straight out of the equation, forcing the City fullback
08:06 here to push up onto Tielemans to stop him running down the line.
08:10 Again though, not a problem here because City are 4 for 4, there's not really any way
08:14 out.
08:15 He's going to have to go all the way back to his goalkeeper.
08:16 Or rather, he would have to do that, yes, with this inexperienced central midfielder
08:20 here and not a floppy haired Spaniel with the scent of a sausage in its nose.
08:25 He chases the ball down onto Tielemans, leaving this glaring amount of space here and in the
08:29 process turning player C, who was only there to provide the bounce pass, into just a midfielder
08:35 with the ball at his feet and space in front of him.
08:37 And also, goes without saying, because City's backline is pressed so far up while all this
08:41 has been going on, Watkins is clean through and were he not to trot on the ball, would
08:46 almost certainly just get in and score.
08:48 So that is legitimately a goal Aston Villa should have had, purely because Pep Guardiola
08:53 put a forward in midfield and Villa did a little triangle around him.
08:56 But I mean, as for the actual goal, it's pretty much just the greatest hits of all
08:59 the stuff we've already looked at.
09:01 One of Villa's centre backs is just being patient on the ball, inviting the press, waiting
09:05 for one of his wide players to move into the centre so he can play the ball through, which
09:09 inevitably, eventually he does.
09:10 And I still don't know if this is like a really clever touch or if it just kind of
09:14 bounces off him, but either way, it does get there and he gets that straight through to
09:18 Bailey who is now standing on the right hand side, taking up the space he vacated.
09:22 But I'll tell you why, of all the chances Villa had, I'm glad this is the one they score
09:27 because it's not purely about the system.
09:29 They have actually got Bailey quite well marked on this side for once, but what he does is
09:35 he skins him.
09:36 He just, he turns Guardiola with his first touch.
09:39 It's just a good old fashioned doing.
09:41 And once again, he charges from the right hand space into a central area.
09:46 Villa have them 3v2 as they get into the final third and such is just the frantic disorganisation
09:52 of the game.
09:53 What's Ruben Diaz doing here?
09:55 Who is he pointing at and why?
09:58 There is no Villa player coming down the left hand side.
10:01 Who is he telling to watch that space in behind?
10:04 Villa had by this point in the game put the willies up Man City's defenders so much, they're
10:09 screaming for people to go and mark players that aren't even there.
10:13 But anyway, here we are, the actual moment of the shot and just look at the amount of
10:17 space he has with which to pull the trigger.
10:20 City have been pulled this way and that.
10:23 They don't know who's going with the runner, who's going with the man, who's going with
10:26 the space.
10:27 Villa's movement has just confused them so much.
10:30 City have three centre backs in close attendance and none of them can put an effective block
10:36 in against that shot.
10:37 No, in fact, all they can do is just dangle a leg out of it.
10:40 So by the time the ball travels through and hits that, it just simply loops up over the
10:44 goalkeeper and into the back of the net.
10:47 And yeah, of course, they were lucky with the deflection, but Villa could have got their
10:49 goal any number of ways.
10:51 This John McGinn one is my personal favourite.
10:53 You can see here so much, are City struggling to control this game.
10:56 They've even dropped Bernardo Silva from the right wing into sort of a nominal number six
11:01 role just to help them get on the ball.
11:03 This is something else we talked about in the Villa tactics video.
11:05 They don't go this narrow when they press, they try and stay as a proper 4-4-2 and Douglas
11:10 Luiz, his job is to sort of press into that middle area to stop teams playing out.
11:14 They kind of go to a bit of a diamond.
11:16 That's exactly what happens here.
11:17 Like as soon as the ball goes into Silva, he is on him like **** on Velcro and the pressure
11:22 forces him to lose the ball.
11:24 And it would have been nice if McGinn had got that goal, by the way, because I thought
11:27 he was the best player on this pitch by a f****** mile.
11:31 Like every single start I've seen in the last couple of hours, like he had the most dribbles,
11:35 he won the most duels and all this.
11:38 There isn't a metric that sort of measures how good you are at sticking your big arse
11:43 out to shield the ball.
11:44 But if there was, he'd have topped that as well.
11:46 And just while we're on the stats, some of the numbers coming out of this game are absolutely
11:50 incredible, given it was only 1-0.
11:53 That is the most amount of chances a Pep Guardiola team has ever faced, ever, like 22 across
12:00 the course of the game or something.
12:01 It's the most any team has won the ball back from them in the final third.
12:07 That's just mind blowing.
12:08 City's entire xG from that game, which I think is like 0.8 or something, comes from a double
12:13 chance they had in the 11th minute.
12:16 After that chance, their xG for the rest of the game is 0.00.
12:23 They didn't have one go a goal.
12:26 And one final thing I want to illustrate here, okay, this is Aston Villa's average pass map,
12:31 their average positions.
12:32 That looks to me like nothing particularly exciting or spectacular.
12:36 You can see here they were spread all over the pitch, they were getting in quite advanced
12:39 areas and as we've discussed, both their wide players play quite narrow and their other
12:43 striker plays quite wide.
12:44 Nothing there you didn't know.
12:45 And I show you it to highlight what a normal pass map should probably look like.
12:50 Okay, so you're looking at it, you're looking at it, retain that information.
12:54 This is City's.
12:55 You could legitimately throw an admittedly quite large blanket over their entire team
13:01 just sat in the middle of the pitch.
13:03 They could barely get out of their own half.
13:06 Now just to really want to hammer this point home, because I do these videos a lot and
13:09 I like to use these pass maps quite a lot.
13:11 You do quite often see teams that can't get past the halfway line, but when that happens,
13:16 their defenders are on the edge of their own box.
13:20 City's are only 10 yards behind them.
13:22 And what that shows you, what that really neatly illustrates is that last night Manchester
13:26 City were a team that were building out from the back, that liked to have controlled possession,
13:30 that would get the ball and try and move it through the middle of the pitch, but simply
13:34 couldn't.
13:35 Like that legitimately looks like a normal pass map that has gone head first into a brick
13:40 wall and is now squashed.
13:43 That is what Aston Villa did to them.
13:45 And I could go on and on and on and on like Watkins wasn't really in the chances, but
13:49 his movement was brilliant.
13:50 I think Martinez might probably be the best goalkeeper in the world.
13:54 I definitely think Douglas Luiz is the best number six in the Premier League right now.
13:59 Just this individual performances all over the pitch were great, but the system, how
14:03 it worked, how it absolutely beasted Man City.
14:06 I could not believe what I was watching.
14:09 Now I will say if you are a Man City fan, you've got all the way to this point in the
14:12 video.
14:13 This is not me saying you're certainly crap and you're not going to win anything.
14:15 You've got loads of key injuries.
14:16 I thought the selection was bad.
14:18 You look tired.
14:19 There's loads of reasons why your performance sucked.
14:22 And I think when you get some players back, you're not going to ever suck that much again.
14:26 But just this video, I just want to praise Villa because it's so easy when a really big
14:31 team gets beat by literally anybody else to just look at the problems they had rather
14:36 than giving the due credit to a team that did so, so, so much right.
14:41 So Villa, that's your win.
14:44 That's not Man City's loss.
14:45 Anyway, that is it for me.
14:46 If you have enjoyed this video and people seem to bizarrely, then please do consider
14:50 subscribing to us here at 442 on YouTube.
14:53 They're every single day, this stuff.
14:55 And my mom says they're good.
14:57 Thanks once again to the folks at Classic Football Shirts.
14:59 I'll just take the coat off at this point.
15:01 If the blue screen goes mad, then who really cares?
15:03 You can get your own beautiful football Christmas jumper from the link in the description.
15:07 Honestly, the range is absolutely mind-blowing.
15:09 You can get me on whatever your favorite social network is.
15:12 That's not really any of my business.
15:13 @AdamCleary, C-L-E-R-Y, 442Socials in the corner of the video.
15:18 That's incredibly uncomfortable.
15:19 But until next time, I've been Adam Cleary.
15:21 This has been 442.
15:22 Well done Villa!
15:23 That was fun.
15:24 And I'll see you soon.
15:25 Bye!
15:26 Bye, bye, bye, bye, bye.
15:26 Bye!
15:27 Bye, bye, bye, bye.
15:28 Bye! Bye!