What are history's most interesting mistakes?
- 6 years ago
The same thinking that led to the Nazi and Communist revolutions also led to the American Revolution.
Question: What are history's most interesting mistakes?
Harvey Mansfield: Well one is that the best regime can be made actual. This has led to world revolutions in the 20th century both on the right and on the left -- the Nazis and the Communists. It also led to the American Revolution. Perhaps even a good thing but a very moderate revolution that substituted the rule of enlightened Americans for the rule of moderate British imperialists. So that was not as ... as nasty and bloody a revolution as the others. We live in our time and in our country, so it makes no sense to condemn everything that we do or the main things I would do as historically mistaken. We need to have a sense of confidence that what we are about is worth it and ... and ... and so I don't think we should be overcome by mistakes. Which I think as a country are fewer than you might find in say France or Britain or Germany, also very intelligent peoples.
Recorded on: 6/13/07
Question: What are history's most interesting mistakes?
Harvey Mansfield: Well one is that the best regime can be made actual. This has led to world revolutions in the 20th century both on the right and on the left -- the Nazis and the Communists. It also led to the American Revolution. Perhaps even a good thing but a very moderate revolution that substituted the rule of enlightened Americans for the rule of moderate British imperialists. So that was not as ... as nasty and bloody a revolution as the others. We live in our time and in our country, so it makes no sense to condemn everything that we do or the main things I would do as historically mistaken. We need to have a sense of confidence that what we are about is worth it and ... and ... and so I don't think we should be overcome by mistakes. Which I think as a country are fewer than you might find in say France or Britain or Germany, also very intelligent peoples.
Recorded on: 6/13/07
Question: What are history's most interesting mistakes?
Harvey Mansfield: Well one is that the best regime can be made actual. This has led to world revolutions in the 20th century both on the right and on the left -- the Nazis and the Communists. It also led to the American Revolution. Perhaps even a good thing but a very moderate revolution that substituted the rule of enlightened Americans for the rule of moderate British imperialists. So that was not as ... as nasty and bloody a revolution as the others. We live in our time and in our country, so it makes no sense to condemn everything that we do or the main things I would do as historically mistaken. We need to have a sense of confidence that what we are about is worth it and ... and ... and so I don't think we should be overcome by mistakes. Which I think as a country are fewer than you might find in say France or Britain or Germany, also very intelligent peoples.
Recorded on: 6/13/07
Question: What are history's most interesting mistakes?
Harvey Mansfield: Well one is that the best regime can be made actual. This has led to world revolutions in the 20th century both on the right and on the left -- the Nazis and the Communists. It also led to the American Revolution. Perhaps even a good thing but a very moderate revolution that substituted the rule of enlightened Americans for the rule of moderate British imperialists. So that was not as ... as nasty and bloody a revolution as the others. We live in our time and in our country, so it makes no sense to condemn everything that we do or the main things I would do as historically mistaken. We need to have a sense of confidence that what we are about is worth it and ... and ... and so I don't think we should be overcome by mistakes. Which I think as a country are fewer than you might find in say France or Britain or Germany, also very intelligent peoples.
Recorded on: 6/13/07